DOE PAGES title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Electron Heating in 2D Particle-in-cell Simulations of Quasi-perpendicular Low-beta Shocks

Journal Article · · The Astrophysical Journal

Abstract We measure the thermal electron energization in 1D and 2D particle-in-cell simulations of quasi-perpendicular, low-beta ( β p = 0.25) collisionless ion–electron shocks with mass ratio m i / m e = 200, fast Mach number M ms = 1 –4, and upstream magnetic field angle θ Bn = 55°–85° from the shock normal n ˆ . It is known that shock electron heating is described by an ambipolar, B -parallel electric potential jump, Δ ϕ , that scales roughly linearly with the electron temperature jump. Our simulations have Δ ϕ / ( 0.5 m i u sh 2 ) 0.1 –0.2 in units of the pre-shock ions’ bulk kinetic energy, in agreement with prior measurements and simulations. Different ways to measure ϕ , including the use of de Hoffmann–Teller frame fields, agree to tens-of-percent accuracy. Neglecting off-diagonal electron pressure tensor terms can lead to a systematic underestimate of ϕ in our low- β p shocks. We further focus on two θ Bn = 65° shocks: a M s = 4 ( M A = 1.8 ) case with a long, 30 d i precursor of whistler waves along n ˆ , and a M s = 7 ( M A = 3.2 ) case with a shorter, 5 d i precursor of whistlers oblique to both n ˆ and B ; d i is the ion skin depth. Within the precursors, ϕ has a secular rise toward the shock along multiple whistler wavelengths and also has localized spikes within magnetic troughs. In a 1D simulation of the M s = 4 , θ Bn = 65° case, ϕ shows a weak dependence on the electron plasma-to-cyclotron frequency ratio ω pece , and ϕ decreases by a factor of 2 as m i / m e is raised to the true proton–electron value of 1836.

Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE
Grant/Contract Number:
SC0023015
OSTI ID:
2332919
Journal Information:
The Astrophysical Journal, Journal Name: The Astrophysical Journal Journal Issue: 1 Vol. 965; ISSN 0004-637X
Publisher:
American Astronomical SocietyCopyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English

References (125)

Numerical simulation of electron distributions upstream and downstream of high Mach number quasi‐perpendicular collisionless shocks journal August 2008
Electron Resonant Interaction With Whistler Waves Around Foreshock Transients and the Bow Shock Behind the Terminator journal February 2022
Preacceleration in the Electron Foreshock. I. Electron Acoustic Waves journal June 2022
Observational Evidence for Stochastic Shock Drift Acceleration of Electrons at the Earth’s Bow Shock journal February 2020
Intense Whistler-mode Waves at Foreshock Transients: Characteristics and Regimes of Wave−Particle Resonant Interaction journal February 2023
Magnetic pumping model for energizing superthermal particles applied to observations of the Earth's bow shock journal June 2020
Dependence of kinetic plasma waves on ion-to-electron mass ratio and light-to-Alfvén speed ratio journal April 2020
Non adiabatic electron behavior through a supercritical perpendicular collisionless shock: Impact of the shock front turbulence journal November 2010
Mach number dependence of electron heating in high Mach number quasiperpendicular shocks journal April 2010
Spacecraft Observations and Theoretical Understanding of Slow Electron Holes journal October 2021
The structure of magneto-hydrodynamic shock waves journal December 1955
Electron Injection by Whistler Waves in Non-Relativistic Shocks journal May 2011
Plasma heating through a supercritical oblique collisionless shock journal April 1987
Observations of electromagnetic whistler precursors at supercritical interplanetary shocks: WHISTLER PRECURSORS-PARTICLES journal April 2012
Relativistic Electrons Produced by Foreshock Disturbances Observed Upstream of Earth’s Bow Shock journal November 2016
Upstream whistlers generated by protons reflected from a quasi‐perpendicular shock journal May 1997
Isothermal magnetosheath electrons due to nonlocal electron cross talk journal February 2014
An introduction to the theory of diffusive shock acceleration of energetic particles in tenuous plasmas journal August 1983
Revisiting the structure of low-Mach number, low-beta, quasi-perpendicular shocks: SHOCK STRUCTURE journal September 2017
Electron velocity distributions near interplantary shocks journal January 1983
Unified View of Nonlinear Wave Structures Associated with Whistler-Mode Chorus journal January 2019
Standing waves at low Mach number laminar bow shocks journal February 1975
Nonlocal electron heating at the Earth's bow shock and the role of the magnetically tangent point journal December 2013
Electron Scattering by Low-frequency Whistler Waves at Earth’s Bow Shock journal November 2019
The Discrepancy Between Simulation and Observation of Electric Fields in Collisionless Shocks journal January 2021
Electron Heating Scales in Collisionless Shocks Measured by MMS journal March 2023
Generation of High-frequency Whistler Waves in the Earth’s Quasi-perpendicular Bow Shock journal September 2021
Electron velocity distributions near the Earth's bow shock journal January 1983
Multiscale whistler waves within Earth's perpendicular bow shock journal December 2012
Electrostatic Solitary Waves in the Earth's Bow Shock: Nature, Properties, Lifetimes, and Origin journal July 2021
A Quarter Century of Collisionless Shock Research book March 2013
Electron ‐ whistler interaction at the Earth's bow shock: 2. Electron pitch angle diffusion journal August 1993
Subcritcal dispersive shock waves upstream of planetary bow shocks and at comet Giacobini‐Zinner journal October 1988
Emission of plasma waves by the Earth's bow shock journal March 1968
Electron heating in quasi‐perpendicular shocks: A Monte Carlo Simulation journal September 1990
Observations of Energized Electrons in the Martian Magnetosheath journal April 2021
Collisionless Electron Dynamics in the Magnetosheath of Mars journal November 2019
Modified two-stream instability at perpendicular collisionless shocks: Full particle simulations journal March 2012
Electron acceleration at quasi-perpendicular shocks in sub- and supercritical regimes: 2D and 3D simulations journal October 2018
Whistler waves, core ion heating, and nonstationarity in oblique collisionless shocks journal July 2007
Evaluating the deHoffmann‐Teller Cross‐Shock Potential at Real Collisionless Shocks journal August 2021
Structure of perpendicular shocks in collisionless plasma journal January 1983
The electron foreshock at high-Mach-number non-relativistic oblique shocks journal May 2022
Instability of the Whistler Structure of Oblique Hydromagnetic Shocks journal October 1972
Noncoplanar magnetic field in the collisionless shock front journal May 1996
Strong reconnection electric fields in shock-driven turbulence journal April 2022
Realistic Electron Diffusion Rates and Lifetimes Due to Scattering by Electron Holes journal August 2021
Non-adiabatic electron behaviour due to short-scale electric field structures at collisionless shock waves journal January 2013
ARTEMIS Observations of Plasma Waves in Laminar and Perturbed Interplanetary Shocks journal June 2021
MMS Observations of Intense Whistler Waves Within Earth's Supercritical Bow Shock: Source Mechanism and Impact on Shock Structure and Plasma Transport journal July 2020
Nonstationarity of strong collisionless quasiperpendicular shocks: Theory and full particle numerical simulations journal April 2002
A parametric survey of the first critical Mach number for a fast MHD shock journal December 1984
Magnetic structure of the low beta, quasi‐perpendicular shock journal September 1993
Transition scale at quasiperpendicular collisionless shocks: Full particle electromagnetic simulations journal June 2006
Electron ‐ whistler interaction at the Earth's bow shock: 1. Whistler instability journal August 1993
Whistler Waves in the Foot of Quasi‐Perpendicular Supercritical Shocks journal May 2022
Adaptation of the de Hoffmann–Teller frame for quasi-perpendicular collisionless shocks journal March 2015
Quasi-adiabatic and Stochastic Heating and Particle Acceleration at Quasi-perpendicular Shocks journal November 2020
Cross‐Shock Electrostatic Potentials at Mars Inferred From MAVEN Measurements journal March 2021
Double Layers in the Earth's Bow Shock journal December 2022
Low Frequency Waves at and Upstream of Collisionless Shocks book February 2016
Electron Bulk Acceleration and Thermalization at Earth’s Quasiperpendicular Bow Shock journal May 2018
MMS Observations of Electrostatic Waves in an Oblique Shock Crossing journal November 2018
Comment on “Electron demagnetization and heating in quasi-perpendicular shocks” by Mozer and Sundkvist journal March 2014
A review of the physics of electron heating at collisionless shocks journal January 1995
Non-Thermal Electron Acceleration in low mach Number Collisionless Shocks. i. Particle Energy Spectra and Acceleration Mechanism journal October 2014
On the nonstationarity of collisionless shocks and its impact on deriving the cross‐shock potential journal July 2017
Microinstabilities associated with a high Mach number, perpendicular bow shock journal January 1984
High-Resolution Measurements of the Cross-Shock Potential, Ion Reflection, and Electron Heating at an Interplanetary Shock by MMS journal June 2019
Electron heating and phase space signatures at supercritical, fast mode shocks journal August 2001
Electron acceleration and heating influenced by whistler wave packets at quasi‐parallel shock waves journal July 2002
Electron heating and the potential jump across fast mode shocks journal January 1988
Particle acceleration at oblique shock fronts journal August 1989
Model for the partition of temperature between electrons and ions across collisionless, fast mode shocks journal December 2000
Electron Heating in Perpendicular Low-beta Shocks journal September 2020
Theory of Stochastic Shock Drift Acceleration for Electrons in the Shock Transition Region journal March 2019
Structure of the quasi-perpendicular laminar bow shock journal February 1975
Two-stream instabilities from the lower-hybrid frequency to the electron cyclotron frequency: application to the front of quasi-perpendicular shocks journal January 2017
Effect of strong thermalization on shock dynamical behavior journal January 2005
Electron Heating in Low-Mach-number Perpendicular Shocks. I. Heating Mechanism journal December 2017
Electron Scattering by High-frequency Whistler Waves at Earth’s Bow Shock journal June 2017
On the noncoplanarity of the magnetic field within a fast collisionless shock journal March 1987
Whistler waves associated with weak interplanetary shocks journal November 2012
Discontinuous Galerkin algorithms for fully kinetic plasmas journal January 2018
Electron temperature and de Hoffmann-Teller potential change across the Earth's bow shock: New results from ISEE 1 journal September 2000
Electron cross talk and asymmetric electron distributions near the Earth's bowshock journal March 2012
Particle Acceleration in Relativistic Magnetized Collisionless pair Shocks: Dependence of Shock Acceleration on Magnetic Obliquity journal June 2009
The structure of oblique subcritical bow shocks: ISEE 1 and 2 observations journal January 1984
Microturbulence in the electron cyclotron frequency range at perpendicular supercritical shocks: ELECTRON CYCLOTRON DRIFT INSTABILITY journal May 2013
The resolved layer of a collisionless, high β, supercritical, quasi-perpendicular shock wave: 1. Rankine-Hugoniot geometry, currents, and stationarity journal January 1986
Solitary Waves Across Supercritical Quasi‐Perpendicular Shocks journal June 2018
Magnetic reconnection and kinetic waves generated in the Earth's quasi-parallel bow shock journal September 2020
On microinstabilities in the foot of high Mach number perpendicular shocks journal January 2006
The field‐aligned flow approximation for electrons within layers possessing a normal mass flux: A corollary to the deHoffmann‐Teller Theorem journal December 1987
Collisionless dissipation in quasi‐perpendicular shocks journal April 1984
Impact of Shock Front Rippling and Self-reformation on the Electron Dynamics at Low-Mach-number Shocks journal April 2018
Electromagnetic ion beam instabilities: Oblique pulsations journal March 1999
Ion heating in oblique low-Mach number shocks journal October 1997
Theory and Simulation of Turbulent Heating by the Modified Two-Stream Instability journal January 1972
Heating and acceleration of electrons through the whistler precursor in 1-D and 2-D oblique shocks journal January 1995
Electrostatic Steepening of Whistler Waves journal May 2018
Simulations of high Mach number perpendicular shocks with resistive electrons journal August 1986
Shock-drift particle acceleration in superluminal shocks - A model for hot spots in extragalactic radio sources journal April 1990
The resolved layer of a collisionless, high β, supercritical, quasi-perpendicular shock wave: 3. Vlasov electrodynamics journal January 1986
Whistler critical Mach number and electron acceleration at the bow shock: Geotail observation journal December 2006
Dynamics of energetic electrons in nonstationary quasi-perpendicular shocks: ENERGETIC ELECTRONS IN NONSTATIONARY SHOCKS journal November 2012
Direct evidence of nonstationary collisionless shocks in space plasmas journal February 2019
Electron‐Scale Reconnection in Three‐Dimensional Shock Turbulence journal August 2022
Electron dynamics and whistler waves at quasi‐perpendicular shocks journal August 1995
The structure of perpendicular bow shocks journal July 1982
Electron dynamics and cross-shock potential at the quasi-perpendicular Earth's bow shock: ELECTRON DYNAMICS AND SHOCK POTENTIAL journal September 2007
Electron heating and phase space signatures at strong and weak quasi-perpendicular shocks journal February 1998
The structure of hydromagnetic shock waves journal March 1971
Quasi-perpendicular shocks: Length scale of the cross-shock potential, shock reformation, and implication for shock surfing journal January 2003
Low-Frequency Instabilities in Magnetic Pulses journal November 1971
Plasma heating at collisionless shocks due to the kinetic cross‐field streaming instability journal January 1985
Numerical studies of electron dynamics in oblique quasi‐perpendicular collisionless shock waves journal June 1991
Steepening of kinetic magnetosonic waves into shocklets: Simulations and consequences for planetary shocks and comets journal January 1990
The adiabatic energy change of plasma electrons and the frame dependence of the cross-shock potential at collisionless magnetosonic shock waves journal January 1984
Whistler waves in 3D hybrid simulations of quasiperpendicular shocks journal March 1996
The plasma physics of shock acceleration journal December 1991
Modified two-stream instability in the foot of high Mach number quasi-perpendicular shocks journal January 2003
Dispersive Nature of High Mach Number Collisionless Plasma Shocks: Poynting Flux of Oblique Whistler Waves journal January 2012
Adiabatic charged-particle motion journal January 1963
Electron dynamics in two‐ and one‐dimensional oblique supercritical collisionless magnetosonic shocks journal April 1994