Purification of Zirconium Tetrachloride from UNF Cladding
- Univ. of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN (United States)
The overarching objective of this project was to design and demonstrate (laboratory scale) a sublimation-based purification protocol to obtain pure zirconium chloride (ZrCl4) from impure feeds derived from the direct chlorination of Zircaloy cladding materials. To achieve this objective the following goals were identified. (1) Design, construct and test an apparatus capable of subliming and purifying ZrCl4 at room pressure and temperatures between 600 and 700K (sublimation point of ZrCl4 606 K). (2) Investigate reactions that may be used to chemically alter the makeup of the impure ZrCl4 feed materials to enhance their removal from ZrCl4 in the sublimation-purification process. (3) Computationally model the reactions of metal chlorides in the gas phase under sublimation conditions (1 atm, 600 K) to determine if oligomers are formed and, if formed, how they would influence sublimation-based purification strategies. All experimental investigations performed as part of this project used stable (non-radioactive) compounds and materials as surrogates for the impure ZrCl4 feedstocks that would be derived from the direct chlorination of Zircaloy claddings from spent nuclear fuel rods. No radiologically active materials were used at any time in this project. The impure ZrCl4 feedstocks used in this study were derived from the direct chlorination of virgin Zircaloy claddings (Zirc-2, -4 and high Nb). The main goals of the project have been achieved during the three year period of this NEUP sponsored project. The impurities of greatest concern in the feedstocks were identified as the chloride salts of the alloying metals originally found in Zircaloy (Fe, Nb) and radiological contaminants (Cs, Sr, and Sb). A series of prototype sublimation apparatuses and heating arrangements were designed, constructed and tested. A general batch-sublimator design was identified and a 1.0 kg batch sublimator/oven system was fabricated from glass. Purification protocols developed on small scale runs were found to scale to 1.0 kg batches without problem. Purification factor ranges (PFs: wt% final / wt% initial) for the impurity chlorides identified above have been measured: Fe (40 – 500); Nb (10 – 70); Cs (520 – 5000); Sr (250 – 1900); Sb (220 – 2300). Removal of iron is sensitive to the partial pressure of hydrogen (in nitrogen) flowing through the system. Lower PFs are obtained when the hydrogen partial pressure is lower. Lower flows are required to raise the iron PF. Removal of niobium is very sensitive to the endpoint determination of the forerun. When judged properly (color change yellow to white in sublimate) reasonable PFs (500) can be achieved. However, as discussed in the conclusions section, endpoint determination can be difficult and significantly lower PFs may be obtained when the endpoint is not correctly identified. Several methods of obtaining quantitative cesium, strontium and antimony PFs were investigated, the best being ICP-MS. The results reported here reflect very limited access to and ICP-MS instrument during the course of this project. It should be noted that, while significantly reduced amounts of antimony are observed in the product, antimony is also found in the exhaust trap after the condenser. Quantum chemical computational modeling studies of the reactions of metal chlorides in the gas phase provided important information about a chemical transport mechanism that could defeat sublimation-based purification strategies. Many metal chlorides are known to oligomerize in the gas phase to reduce their coordinative unsaturation. Dimerization of ZrCl4 with iron or niobium chlorides would provide a mechanism by which both metal impurities could be carried over with the product during sublimation of the bulk material. Computational modeling conclusively showed that under sublimation conditions in the gas phase, dimerization reactions are not favored thermodynamically due to a significant entropic penalty for the reaction. Therefore, consistent with experimental observations, sublimation-based purification strategies remain viable. The experimental part of the report concludes with a short discussion of the issues that still remain in developing a technologically relevant Zircaloy recycling strategy. The final section of the report is a summary of the quantum chemical investigation of the reactions of metal chlorides in the gas phase under sublimation conditions.
- Research Organization:
- Univ. of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN (United States)
- Sponsoring Organization:
- USDOE Office of Nuclear Energy (NE)
- DOE Contract Number:
- NE0008421
- OSTI ID:
- 1492793
- Report Number(s):
- 15-8323; 15-8323
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
Similar Records
Investigations into the Gas Phase Reactions of Zirconium Tetrachloride (ZrCl) from UNF Cladding
Purification of Zirconium Cladding Using a Chloride Volatility Process