Interobserver variability in the interpretation of myocardial images with Tc-99m-labeled diphosphonate and pyrophosphate
Without prior knowledge of the significant clinical data, six observers have independently evaluated a consecutive series of 250 myocardial scans made with Tc-99m-labeled phosphates: 127 with MDP and 123 with PPi. Of the 226 patients, all having acute precordial chest pain, 169 were shown to have acute myocardial infarction while 57 suffered acute distress from other causes. The six observers, varying in their experience with nuclear medicine, compared the intensity of uptake in the heart with that in bone, and rated their impression of a positive image by a six-category scale - that is, one with five criterion levels. Results were expressed as receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves, from which the optimal individual criterion level for each observer was determined. We found very high interobserver variability in the perception of the shades of myocardial concentration, although they were based on strict and apparently objective criteria. This variability has a direct influence on the overall performance of each observer. In every instance, PPi was demonstrated to be a better tracer than MDP for myocardial imaging. The bias of the experience, visual perception, and psychology of the observer at the time of the reading of the images seems to be significant, as is the presence of uncorrected visual defects. These results justify the setting of special programs to evaluateperiodically the performance of every physician who interprets studies, to establish his optimal individual criterion level instead of using a fixed criterion level to decide whether an image is positive.
- Research Organization:
- Instituto Nacional de Cardiologia Dr. Ignacio Chavez, Mexico City, Mexico
- OSTI ID:
- 5437107
- Journal Information:
- J. Nucl. Med.; (United States), Vol. 21:1
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
Similar Records
Technetium-99m-pyrophosphate scintigraphy in patients with suspected acute myocardial infarction: impact of interobserver variability
Evaluation of /sup 99m/Tc stannous pyrophosphate as an imaging agent in acute myocardial infarction
Related Subjects
59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES
MYOCARDIUM
SCINTISCANNING
TECHNETIUM 99
DIAGNOSTIC USES
COMPARATIVE EVALUATIONS
EVALUATION
HEART
ISOMERIC NUCLEI
MEDICAL PERSONNEL
MYOCARDIAL INFARCTION
PATIENTS
PHOSPHONATES
PSYCHOLOGY
PYROPHOSPHATES
UPTAKE
BETA DECAY RADIOISOTOPES
BETA-MINUS DECAY RADIOISOTOPES
BODY
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES
CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
COUNTING TECHNIQUES
DIAGNOSTIC TECHNIQUES
DISEASES
HOURS LIVING RADIOISOTOPES
INTERMEDIATE MASS NUCLEI
ISOMERIC TRANSITION ISOTOPES
ISOTOPES
MUSCLES
NUCLEI
ODD-EVEN NUCLEI
ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
ORGANIC PHOSPHORUS COMPOUNDS
ORGANS
OXYGEN COMPOUNDS
PERSONNEL
PHOSPHORUS COMPOUNDS
PROFESSIONAL PERSONNEL
RADIOISOTOPE SCANNING
RADIOISOTOPES
TECHNETIUM ISOTOPES
USES
YEARS LIVING RADIOISOTOPES
550601* - Medicine- Unsealed Radionuclides in Diagnostics
551001 - Physiological Systems- Tracer Techniques