Incorporating psychological influences in probabilistic cost analysis

Journal Article · Thu Jan 08 04:00:00 EST 2004 · Journal of Systems Engineering

DOI:https://doi.org/10.1002/sys.20004· OSTI ID:841313

Kujawski, Edouard ^[1]; Alvaro, Mariana; Edwards, William

---

1. LBNL Library

Today's typical probabilistic cost analysis assumes an ''ideal'' project that is devoid of the human and organizational considerations that heavily influence the success and cost of real-world projects. In the real world ''Money Allocated Is Money Spent'' (MAIMS principle); cost underruns are rarely available to protect against cost overruns while task overruns are passed on to the total project cost. Realistic cost estimates therefore require a modified probabilistic cost analysis that simultaneously models the cost management strategy including budget allocation. Psychological influences such as overconfidence in assessing uncertainties and dependencies among cost elements and risks are other important considerations that are generally not addressed. It should then be no surprise that actual project costs often exceed the initial estimates and are delivered late and/or with a reduced scope. This paper presents a practical probabilistic cost analysis model that incorporates recent findings in human behavior and judgment under uncertainty, dependencies among cost elements, the MAIMS principle, and project management practices. Uncertain cost elements are elicited from experts using the direct fractile assessment method and fitted with three-parameter Weibull distributions. The full correlation matrix is specified in terms of two parameters that characterize correlations among cost elements in the same and in different subsystems. The analysis is readily implemented using standard Monte Carlo simulation tools such as {at}Risk and Crystal Ball{reg_sign}. The analysis of a representative design and engineering project substantiates that today's typical probabilistic cost analysis is likely to severely underestimate project cost for probability of success values of importance to contractors and procuring activities. The proposed approach provides a framework for developing a viable cost management strategy for allocating baseline budgets and contingencies. Given the scope and magnitude of the cost-overrun problem, the benefits are likely to be significant.

• Research Organization: Ernest Orlando Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA (US)
• Sponsoring Organization: USDOE Director, Office of Science (US)
• DOE Contract Number: AC03-76SF00098
• OSTI ID: 841313
• Report Number(s): LBNL--54276
• Journal Information: Journal of Systems Engineering, Journal Name: Journal of Systems Engineering Journal Issue: 3 Vol. 7
• Country of Publication: United States
• Language: English

Related Subjects

42 ENGINEERING
CONTRACTORS
COST OVERRUNS
DESIGN
MANAGEMENT
PROBABILITY
PROGRAM MANAGEMENT
SIMULATION
SYSTEMS:COST ANALYSIS