Power pools & ISOs: Monitoring market power in a restructured industry
- Cameron McKenna, Washington, DC (United States)
The California debate over electric restructuring is now nearly four years old. And though it is nearing its final stages, some of the most important questions as to how this will work in practice are just emerging. With transmission access apparently resolved, one might have thought that most concerns over abuses of market power would dissipate. That assumption proved to be a dangerous illusion, however. Instead, there emerged a whole new set of regulatory concerns over `horizontal` market power. These concerns related to utility concentrations in generation, generation units strategically located to take advantage of or needed to relieve transmission constraints (`must-run` units in California`s jargon). Concerns even arose that individual units could exercise market power in setting market clearing prices in auction markets by virtue of their typical placement on the supply curve. Similar concerns have been expressed in the ISO New England restructuring and surely will be raised in others. Hence, even after agreement from the investor-owned utilities on the basics of vesting control of transmission in the ISO (effected through `transmission control agreement`), the California debate over IOU market power in generation continued unabated. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission devoted a lengthy separate order to the issue in its late 1996 rulings on the basic concepts of the California restructuring proposal; and its only technical conference on the proposal (in January 1997) was devoted solely to these market power concerns. In its December 1996 order, with very little discussion, the Commission imposed a requirement that has enormous implications of how market power concerns will be addressed in restructuring situations. The ISO was ordered to file a `detailed monitoring plan,` which includes how market power will be identified and mitigated and what information will be collected and submitted to the FERC.
- OSTI ID:
- 585217
- Journal Information:
- Fortnightly, Journal Name: Fortnightly Journal Issue: 5 Vol. 136; ISSN FRTNE8
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
Similar Records
Promoting emerging energy-efficiency technologies and practices by utilities in a restructured energy industry: A report from California
A framework for operations in the competitive open access environment