skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Analysis of sheltering and evacuation strategies for a Chicago nuclear detonation scenario.

Abstract

Development of an effective strategy for shelter and evacuation is among the most important planning tasks in preparation for response to a low yield, nuclear detonation in an urban area. Extensive studies have been performed and guidance published that highlight the key principles for saving lives following such an event. However, region-specific data are important in the planning process as well. This study examines some of the unique regional factors that impact planning for a 10 kt detonation in Chicago. The work utilizes a single scenario to examine regional impacts as well as the shelter-evacuate decision alternatives at selected exemplary points. For many Chicago neighborhoods, the excellent assessed shelter quality available make shelter-in-place or selective transit to a nearby shelter a compelling post-detonation strategy.

Authors:
;
Publication Date:
Research Org.:
Sandia National Laboratories
Sponsoring Org.:
USDOE
OSTI Identifier:
1029774
Report Number(s):
SAND2011-6720
TRN: US201201%%184
DOE Contract Number:
AC04-94AL85000
Resource Type:
Technical Report
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Subject:
99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS//MATHEMATICS, COMPUTING, AND INFORMATION SCIENCE; CHICAGO; EXPLOSIONS; PLANNING; SHELTERS; URBAN AREAS

Citation Formats

Yoshimura, Ann S., and Brandt, Larry D. Analysis of sheltering and evacuation strategies for a Chicago nuclear detonation scenario.. United States: N. p., 2011. Web. doi:10.2172/1029774.
Yoshimura, Ann S., & Brandt, Larry D. Analysis of sheltering and evacuation strategies for a Chicago nuclear detonation scenario.. United States. doi:10.2172/1029774.
Yoshimura, Ann S., and Brandt, Larry D. 2011. "Analysis of sheltering and evacuation strategies for a Chicago nuclear detonation scenario.". United States. doi:10.2172/1029774. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1029774.
@article{osti_1029774,
title = {Analysis of sheltering and evacuation strategies for a Chicago nuclear detonation scenario.},
author = {Yoshimura, Ann S. and Brandt, Larry D.},
abstractNote = {Development of an effective strategy for shelter and evacuation is among the most important planning tasks in preparation for response to a low yield, nuclear detonation in an urban area. Extensive studies have been performed and guidance published that highlight the key principles for saving lives following such an event. However, region-specific data are important in the planning process as well. This study examines some of the unique regional factors that impact planning for a 10 kt detonation in Chicago. The work utilizes a single scenario to examine regional impacts as well as the shelter-evacuate decision alternatives at selected exemplary points. For many Chicago neighborhoods, the excellent assessed shelter quality available make shelter-in-place or selective transit to a nearby shelter a compelling post-detonation strategy.},
doi = {10.2172/1029774},
journal = {},
number = ,
volume = ,
place = {United States},
year = 2011,
month = 9
}

Technical Report:

Save / Share:
  • Development of an effective strategy for shelter and evacuation is among the most important planning tasks in preparation for response to a low yield, nuclear detonation in an urban area. This study examines shelter-evacuate policies and effectiveness focusing on a 10 kt scenario in Los Angeles. The goal is to provide technical insights that can support development of urban response plans. Results indicate that extended shelter-in-place can offer the most robust protection when high quality shelter exists. Where less effective shelter is available and the fallout radiation intensity level is high, informed evacuation at the appropriate time can substantially reducemore » the overall dose to personnel. However, uncertainties in the characteristics of the fallout region and in the exit route can make evacuation a risky strategy. Analyses indicate that only a relatively small fraction of the total urban population may experience significant dose reduction benefits from even a well-informed evacuation plan.« less
  • Development of an effective strategy for shelter and evacuation is among the most important planning tasks in preparation for response to a low yield, nuclear detonation in an urban area. Extensive studies have been performed and guidance published that highlight the key principles for saving lives following such an event. However, region-specific data are important in the planning process as well. This study examines some of the unique regional factors that impact planning for a 10 kT detonation in the National Capital Region. The work utilizes a single scenario to examine regional impacts as well as the shelter-evacuate decision alternativesmore » at one exemplary point. For most Washington, DC neighborhoods, the excellent assessed shelter quality available make shelter-in-place or selective transit to a nearby shelter a compelling post-detonation strategy.« less
  • The NUclear EVacuation Analysis Code (NUEVAC) has been developed by Sandia National Laboratories to support the analysis of shelter-evacuate (S-E) strategies following an urban nuclear detonation. This tool can model a range of behaviors, including complex evacuation timing and path selection, as well as various sheltering or mixed evacuation and sheltering strategies. The calculations are based on externally generated, high resolution fallout deposition and plume data. Scenario setup and calculation outputs make extensive use of graphics and interactive features. This software is designed primarily to produce quantitative evaluations of nuclear detonation response options. However, the outputs have also proven usefulmore » in the communication of technical insights concerning shelter-evacuate tradeoffs to urban planning or response personnel.« less
  • This report reviews the major planning concepts and decision criteria that should be considered in preparing for and selecting appropriate protective actions in the event of a nuclear power plant accident. The document can serve as an aid to all emergency planners, since it provides concepts and criteria to be considered in both radiological and nonradiological emergencies. The report is divided into two parts, the first of which consists of a two chapter overview of protective action decisionmaking. The introductory chapter begins with an analysis of the decision environment surrounding the selection of appropriate protective actions for offsite residents inmore » the event of a nuclear power plant emergency. The second chapter presents decision aids that describe the major planning concepts and decision criteria for sheltering and evacuation.« less
  • This report reviews the major planning concepts and decision criteria that should be considered in preparing for and selecting appropriate protective actions in the event of a nuclear power plant accident. The document can serve as an aid to all emergency planners, since it provides concepts and criteria to be considered in both radiological and nonradiological emergencies. It is designed to give basic information that every planner, implementer and decisionmaker should have at his or her grasp. The principal planning concept is the prior analysis of the decision environment surrounding the selection of protective actions. The major decision criteria inmore » a nuclear power plant accident would include the radiological risks, nonradiological risks, economic costs and extent of compliance by the public with recommended protective actions. In a nonradiological emergency, only the radiological risk criterion would be eliminated. 6 refs., 17 tabs.« less