DOE PAGES title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Nuclear-level effective theory of μ→e conversion: Formalism and applications

Journal Article · · Physical Review. C
ORCiD logo [1]; ORCiD logo [2];  [2];  [3]
  1. Univ. of California, Berkeley, CA (United States); Lawrence Berkeley National Lab. (LBNL), Berkeley, CA (United States); University of California, Berkeley
  2. Univ. of California, Berkeley, CA (United States)
  3. Shanghai Jiao Tong Univ. (China); Univ. of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA (United States)

Over the next decade new μ→e conversion searches at Fermilab (Mu2e) and J-PARC (COMET, DeeMe) are expected to advance limits on charged lepton flavor violation (CLFV) by more than four orders of magnitude. By considering the consequence of P and CP on elastic μ→e conversion and the structure of possible charge and current densities, we show that rates are governed by six nuclear responses and a single scale, q/mN, where q is the momentum transferred from the leptons to the nucleus. To relate this result to microscopic formulations of CLFV, we construct in nonrelativistic effective theory (NRET) the CLFV nucleon-level interaction, pointing out the relevance of the dimensionless scales y = ($$\frac{qb}{2}$$)2 > |N| > |μ| > |T|, where b is the nuclear size, N and μ are the nucleon and muon intrinsic velocities, and T is the target recoil variety. Here, we discuss previous work, noting the lack of a systematic treatment of the various small parameters. A proper calculation of the mu-to-e conversion rate requires a full multipole expansion of the nuclear response functions, an apparently daunting task with Coulomb-distorted electron partial waves. We demonstrate that the multipole expansion can be carried out to high precision by introducing a simplifying local effective momentum for the electron. Previous work has been limited to simple charge or spin interactions, thereby treating the nucleus effectively as a point particle. We show that such formulations are not compatible with the general form of the μ→e conversion rate, failing to generate three of the six allowed nuclear response functions. The inclusion of the nucleon velocity operator N yields an NRET with 16 operators and a rate of the general form. Consequently, in the current discovery era for CLFV, it provides the most sensible starting point for experimental analysis, defining what can and cannot be determined about CLFV from the highly exclusive process of elastic μ→e conversion. Finally, we expand the NRET operator basis to account for the effects μ, associated with the muon's lower component, generating corrections to the CLFV coefficients of the point-nucleus response functions. Using advanced shell-model methods, we compute mu-to-e conversion rates for a series of experimental targets, deriving bounds on the coefficients of the CLFV operators. These calculations are the first to include a general basis of CLFV operators, full evaluation of the associated nuclear response functions, and an accurate treatment of electron and muon Coulomb effects. We discuss target selection as an experimental "knob" that can be turned to probe the microscopic origins of CLFV. We describe two types of coherence that enhance certain CLFV operators and selection rules that blind elastic μ→e conversion to others. We discuss the matching of the NRET onto higher level effective field theories, such as those constructed at the light quark level, noting opportunities to build on existing work in direct detection of dark matter. We discuss the relation of μ→e conversion to μ→e+γ and μ→3e, showing how MEG II and Mu3e results will complement those of Mu2e and COMET. Finally we describe a accompanying script—in Mathematica and Python versions—that can be used to compute μ→e conversion rates in various nuclear targets for the full set of NRET operators.

Research Organization:
Univ. of California, Berkeley, CA (United States)
Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE; National Science Foundation (NSF); Heising-Simons Foundation
Grant/Contract Number:
SC0004658; AC02-05CH11231
OSTI ID:
1968545
Journal Information:
Physical Review. C, Journal Name: Physical Review. C Journal Issue: 3 Vol. 107; ISSN 2469-9985
Publisher:
American Physical Society (APS)Copyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English

References (83)

Renormalisation-group improved analysis of μ → e processes in a systematic effective-field-theory approach journal May 2017
Effective field theory for dark matter direct detection up to dimension seven journal October 2018
Effective interactions for the 1p shell journal November 1965
Multipole operators in semileptonic weak and electromagnetic interactions with nuclei journal February 1979
Nuclear charge-density-distribution parameters from elastic electron scattering journal May 1987
Chiral dynamics and heavy-fermion formalism in nuclei: exchange axial currents journal October 1993
Nuclear form factors for the scattering of weakly interacting massive particles journal July 1991
Test of lepton-flavour conservation in μ → e conversion on titanium journal November 1993
Signals for supersymmetric unification journal October 1994
Nuclear radii in the high-energy limit of elastic electron scattering journal December 1971
An analytic description of inelastic electron scattering on nuclei journal May 1974
Semileptonic weak and electromagnetic interactions with nuclei: Nuclear current operators through order (v/c)nucleon2 journal October 1978
A search for muon-electron and muon-positron conversion in sulfur journal March 1982
Study of the flavour violating (μ−,e−) conversion in nuclei journal April 1990
Coherent and incoherent (μ−, e−) conversion in nuclei journal July 1993
Study of the muon number violating (μ−, e− conversion in a nucleus by using quasi-particle RPA journal April 1994
Search for the decay μ+ → e+e+e− journal March 1988
On the nuclear dependence of the μ−→e− conversion branching ratio journal May 2003
μ–e conversion in nuclei versus : an effective field theory point of view journal March 1998
Exotic μ→e conversion in nuclei: energy moments of the transition strength and average energy of the outgoing e journal February 2001
Shell model study of the isobaric chains A=50, A=51 and A=52 journal November 2001
SevenOperators, a Mathematica script for harmonic oscillator nuclear matrix elements arising in semileptonic electroweak interactions journal September 2008
Factorization in large-scale many-body calculations journal December 2013
Isotope dependence of muon-to-electron conversion journal July 2022
Spin-dependent μ→e conversion journal August 2017
PandaX-II constraints on spin-dependent WIMP-nucleon effective interactions journal May 2019
Charged lepton flavor violation: An experimenter’s guide journal November 2013
Lepton flavor and number conservation, and physics beyond the standard model journal July 2013
Towards grounding nuclear physics in QCD journal November 2021
Electron scattering and nuclear structure journal January 1966
In-medium similarity renormalization group for closed and open-shell nuclei journal December 2016
Non-relativistic effective theory of dark matter direct detection journal November 2010
The effective field theory of dark matter direct detection journal February 2013
Tools for model-independent bounds in direct dark matter searches journal October 2013
Chiral effective theory of dark matter direct detection journal February 2017
A search for muon-to-electron conversion at J-PARC: the COMET experiment journal January 2013
COMET Phase-I technical design report journal March 2020
Selection Rules for the β -Disintegration journal June 1936
The Capture of Negative Mesotrons in Matter journal September 1947
Next-to-leading order scalar contributions to μ→e conversion journal May 2022
Shell-Model Structure ofCa42−50 journal July 1970
Total nuclear capture rates for negative muons journal June 1987
Realistic nuclear matrix elements for the lepton-flavor violatingμ−→e−conversion in27Aland48Ti journal August 2000
Effective interaction for pf -shell nuclei journal May 2002
New effective interaction for p f -shell nuclei and its implications for the stability of the N = Z = 28 closed core journal March 2004
New “USD” Hamiltonians for the sd shell journal September 2006
New effective interaction for f 5 pg 9 -shell nuclei journal December 2009
Weakly interacting massive particle-nucleus elastic scattering response journal June 2014
Nuclear axial currents in chiral effective field theory journal January 2016
Coherent μ − e conversion at next-to-leading order journal July 2018
Multipole decomposition of the rate of muon-to-electron ( μ − ⟶ e − ) conversion in Pb 208 journal June 2019
Effective field theory analysis of the first LUX dark matter search journal June 2021
Z dependence of coherent μ e conversion rate in anomalous neutrinoless muon capture journal October 1979
Search for muon-electron and muon-positron conversion journal October 1988
Lepton-flavor violation via right-handed neutrino Yukawa couplings in the supersymmetric standard model journal March 1996
Detailed calculation of lepton flavor violating muon-electron conversion rate for various nuclei journal November 2002
Lepton flavor violation without supersymmetry journal October 2004
Model discriminating power of μ → e conversion in nuclei journal July 2009
A model independent approach to inelastic dark matter scattering journal November 2014
Standard Model anatomy of WIMP dark matter direct detection. II. QCD analysis and hadronic matrix elements journal February 2015
Dark matter effective field theory scattering in direct detection experiments journal May 2015
Nuclear structure factors for general spin-independent WIMP-nucleus scattering journal March 2019
Nuclear Spins and Moments of Ga Isotopes Reveal Sudden Structural Changes between N = 40 and N = 50 journal June 2010
Nuclear-Level Effective Theory of μ→e Conversion journal March 2023
Improved Limits on Lepton-Flavor-Violating Decays of Light Pseudoscalars via Spin-Dependent μ→e Conversion in Nuclei journal March 2023
Search for the Reaction μ − + Cu → e + + Co journal May 1972
Electromagnetic Transitions Between μ Meson and Electron journal July 1959
Reaction μ − + Nucleus → e − + Nucleus in Gauge Theories journal June 1977
Empirical Renormalization of the One-Body Gamow-Teller β -Decay Matrix Elements in the 1 s − 0 d Shell journal June 1978
Parity Nonconservation in F 18 and Meson-Exchange Contributions to the Axial Charge Operator journal March 1981
Search forμ-econversion in Ti journal July 1985
Weak-interaction rates in ^{16}O journal September 1990
Improved Limit on the Branching Ratio of μ → e Conversion on Lead journal January 1996
Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay and Lepton Flavor Violation journal December 2004
Muon decay and physics beyond the standard model journal January 2001
Coulomb distortion of relativistic electrons in the nuclear electrostatic field journal November 2005
“Spin-dependent” $$\varvec{\mu \rightarrow e}$$ μ → e conversion on light nuclei journal February 2018
The design of the MEG II experiment: MEG II Collaboration journal May 2018
A search for μ-e conversion in muonic gold journal May 2006
Status of the Nuclear Shell Model journal December 1988
Charged Lepton Flavor Violation Experiments journal November 2008
Charged lepton flavour violation: An experimental and theoretical introduction journal January 2018
The Mu3e experiment journal September 2021

Similar Records

Distinguishing Charged Lepton Flavor Violation Scenarios with Inelastic μ e Conversion
Journal Article · Sun Dec 22 23:00:00 EST 2024 · Physical Review Letters · OSTI ID:2483622

Nuclear-level effective theory of μ e conversion: Inelastic process
Journal Article · Thu Feb 06 23:00:00 EST 2025 · Physical Review. C · OSTI ID:2512410

Isotope dependence of muon-to-electron conversion
Journal Article · Fri May 13 00:00:00 EDT 2022 · Nuclear Physics. B · OSTI ID:1869250