Relaxing environmental standards during oil-supply disruptions: past, present and future
During past oil supply disruptions pollution control regulations have been temporarily relaxed. In addition, the Clean Air Act was amended in 1977 to permit temporary variances from air pollution control regulations in the event of a national or regional energy emergency. However, neither actions taken in the past nor the present provisions of the Clean Air Act regarding the temporary relaxation of environmental standards have received much scrutiny. This paper attempts to fill this void by addressing the following two policy questions: (1) should environmental standards such as sulfur emissions limitations be relaxed during oil supply disruptions; and (2) if relaxing a particular standard appears desirable, when, where and how should it be relaxed. In answer to these questions, the argument is made that disruptions could suddenly result in marginal pollution abatement costs much greater than the benefits from, or demand for, the marginal improvement in air quality from such abatement - thereby justifying temporary variances. As a result, a set of criteria for evaluating variance policies are developed on the basis of both the theoretical rationale for variances and institutional or implementation considerations. After describing present federal variance policy, the developed criteria are used to evaluate current policy. Current federal variance policy is found to be inattentive to both the theoretical rationale for granting variances during oil supply disruptions and the salient characteristics of disruptions.
- Research Organization:
- Harvard Univ., Cambridge, MA (USA). John Fitzgerald Kennedy School of Government
- DOE Contract Number:
- AC01-80PE70278
- OSTI ID:
- 6514827
- Report Number(s):
- DOE/PE/70278-T15; ON: DE81024250
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
Similar Records
An evaluation of air pollution abatement relaxation strategies for Tennessee during periods of pending or actual energy emergencies. (Tennessee State science, engineering, and technology project). Final report
The A&WMA 2007 Critical Review. Will the circle be unbroken: a history of the U.S. national ambient air quality standards
Related Subjects
02 PETROLEUM
29 ENERGY PLANNING
POLICY AND ECONOMY
ENERGY SHORTAGES
GOVERNMENT POLICIES
POLLUTION REGULATIONS
ENFORCEMENT
CLEAN AIR ACT
COMPLIANCE
EVALUATION
FOSSIL-FUEL POWER PLANTS
FUEL OILS
GASOLINE
PETROLEUM REFINERIES
POLLUTION CONTROL
RECOMMENDATIONS
STANDARDS
CONTROL
FUELS
INDUSTRIAL PLANTS
LAWS
LIQUID FUELS
OILS
ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
OTHER ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
PETROLEUM PRODUCTS
POLLUTION LAWS
POWER PLANTS
REGULATIONS
SHORTAGES
THERMAL POWER PLANTS
500600* - Environment
Atmospheric- Regulations- (-1989)
021000 - Petroleum- Legislation & Regulations
294002 - Energy Planning & Policy- Petroleum
293000 - Energy Planning & Policy- Policy
Legislation
& Regulation