Case study of the propagation of a small flaw under PWR loading conditions and comparison with the ASME code design life: comparison of ASME Code sections III and XI

Technical Report · Thu Nov 01 04:00:00 EST 1984

OSTI ID:6289657

Yahr, G T; Richardson, A K; Gwaltney, R C; Server, W L

A cooperative study was performed to investigate the degree of conservatism and consistency in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Sect. III fatigue evaluation procedure and Sect. XI flaw acceptance standards. A single, realistic, sample problem was analyzed to determine the significance of certain points of criticism made of an earlier parametric study by staff members of the Division of Engineering Standards of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. The problem was based on a semielliptical flaw located on the inside surface of the hot-leg piping at the reactor vessel safe-end weld for the Zion 1 pressurized-water reactor (PWR). Two main criteria were used in selecting the problem; first, it should be a straight pipe to minimize the computational expense; second, it should exhibit as high a cumulative usage factor as possible. Although the problem selected has one of the highest cumulative usage factors of any straight pipe in the primary system of PWRs, it is still very low. The Code Sect. III fatigue usage factor was only 0.00046, assuming it was in the as-welded condition, and fatigue crack-growth analyses predicted negligible crack growth during the 40-year design life. When the analyses were extended past the design life, the usage factor was less than 1.0 when the flaw had propagated to failure. The current study shows that the criticism of the earlier report should not detract from the conclusion that if a component experiences a high level of cyclic stress corresponding to a fatigue usage factor near 1.0, very small cracks can propagate to unacceptable sizes.

• Research Organization: Oak Ridge National Lab., TN (USA)
• DOE Contract Number: AC05-84OR21400
• OSTI ID: 6289657
• Report Number(s): NUREG/CR-3982; ORNL-6099; ON: TI85002387
• Country of Publication: United States
• Language: English

Related Subjects

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS
210200 -- Power Reactors
Nonbreeding
Light-Water Moderated
Nonboiling Water Cooled
22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS
220900* -- Nuclear Reactor Technology-- Reactor Safety
COOLING SYSTEMS
CRACK PROPAGATION
DEFECTS
ENERGY SYSTEMS
ENRICHED URANIUM REACTORS
FATIGUE
MECHANICAL PROPERTIES
PIPES
POWER REACTORS
PRIMARY COOLANT CIRCUITS
PWR TYPE REACTORS
REACTOR COMPONENTS
REACTOR COOLING SYSTEMS
REACTORS
THERMAL REACTORS
WATER COOLED REACTORS
WATER MODERATED REACTORS
ZION-1 REACTOR