Alternative diagnostic strategies for coronary artery disease in women: demonstration of the usefulness and efficiency of probability analysis
Alternative strategies using conditional probability analysis for the diagnosis of coronary artery disease (CAD) were examined in 93 infarct-free women presenting with chest pain. Another group of 42 consecutive female patients was prospectively analyzed. For this latter group, the physician had access to the pretest and posttest probability of CAD before coronary angiography. These 135 women all underwent stress electrocardiographic, thallium scintigraphic, and coronary angiographic examination. The pretest and posttest probabilities of coronary disease were derived from a computerized Bayesian algorithm. Probability estimates were calculated by the four following hypothetical strategies: SO, in which history, including risk factors, was considered; S1, in which history and stress electrocardiographic results were considered; S2, in which history and stress electrocardiographic and stress thallium scintigraphic results were considered; and S3, in which history and stress electrocardiographic results were used, but in which stress scintigraphic results were considered only if the poststress probability of CAD was between 10% and 90%, i.e., if a sufficient level of diagnostic certainty could not be obtained with the electrocardiographic results alone. The strategies were compared with respect to accuracy with the coronary angiogram as the standard. For both groups of women, S2 and S3 were found to be the most accurate in predicting the presence or absence of coronary disease (p less than .05). However, it was found with use of S3 that more than one-third of the thallium scintigrams could have been avoided without loss of accuracy. It was also found that diagnostic catheterization performed to exclude CAD as a diagnosis could have been avoided in half of the patients without loss of accuracy.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
- Research Organization:
- Univ. of Louvain Medical School, Brussels, Belgium
- OSTI ID:
- 5482973
- Journal Information:
- Circulation; (United States), Journal Name: Circulation; (United States) Vol. 71:3; ISSN CIRCA
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
Similar Records
Critical analysis of the application of Bayes theorem to sequential testing in the noninvasive diagnosis of coronary artery disease
Comparison of three Bayesian methods to estimate posttest probability in patients undergoing exercise stress testing
Related Subjects
62 RADIOLOGY AND NUCLEAR MEDICINE
ANIMALS
ARTERIES
BIOMEDICAL RADIOGRAPHY
BLOOD VESSELS
BODY
CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
COMPARATIVE EVALUATIONS
CORONARIES
COUNTING TECHNIQUES
DIAGNOSTIC TECHNIQUES
DIAGRAMS
DISEASES
ELECTROCARDIOGRAMS
EXERCISE
FEMALES
ISOTOPES
MALES
MAMMALS
MAN
MEDICINE
MEN
NUCLEAR MEDICINE
ORGANS
PRIMATES
RADIOISOTOPE SCANNING
RADIOLOGY
SCINTISCANNING
THALLIUM ISOTOPES
VASCULAR DISEASES
VERTEBRATES