Skip to main content
U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Assessing the behavioral realism of energy system models in light of the consumer adoption literature

Journal Article · · Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews
Effective policymaking to achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions demands an understanding of the complex drivers of, and barriers to, consumer adoption behavior via behaviorally realistic energy system models. Existing models tend to oversimplify by focusing on homogenized financial factors while neglecting consumer heterogeneity and non-monetary influences. This study develops and applies a comprehensive framework for evaluating the behavioral realism of consumer adoption models, informed by the adoption literature. It introduces a typology for factors influencing low-carbon technology adoption decisions: monetary and non-monetary factors relating to household characteristics, psychology, technological attributes, and contextual conditions. Next, reviews of the consumer adoption and decision-making literature identify the most influential adoption factor categories for distributed solar photovoltaics, electric vehicles, and air-source heat pumps. Finally, the extent to which a selection of energy system models accounts for these adoption factors is assessed. Existing models predominantly emphasize the economic aspects of technology, which are generally identified as the most important factors. Where the models fall short — in considering moderately important factor categories — sector-specific and agent-based models can offer more behaviorally realistic insights. This study sheds light on which types of factors are most important for consumer adoption decisions and investigates how well current models rise to the challenge of behavioral realism. The end-to-end analysis presented enables internally consistent comparisons across models and energy technologies. This research advances timely conversations on consumer adoption. It could inform more behaviorally realistic energy system modeling, and thereby more effective decarbonization policymaking.
Research Organization:
Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), Oak Ridge, TN (United States)
Sponsoring Organization:
National Science Foundation (NSF); USDOE Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE)
Grant/Contract Number:
AC02-05CH11231; AC05-00OR22725
OSTI ID:
2483719
Alternate ID(s):
OSTI ID: 2491451
Journal Information:
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Journal Name: Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews Vol. 211; ISSN 1364-0321
Publisher:
ElsevierCopyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English

References (90)

Mass deployment of sustainable transportation: evaluation of factors that influence electric vehicle adoption journal June 2017
Integrated assessment modelling as a positive science: private passenger road transport policies to meet a climate target well below 2 ∘C journal September 2018
The Effect of Rebate and Loan Incentives on Residential Heat Pump Adoption: Evidence from North Carolina journal May 2022
Heterogeneity in preferences for renewable home heating systems among Irish households journal February 2022
Exploring the willingness of consumers to electrify their homes journal May 2023
Integrated Economic Adoption Model for residential grid-connected photovoltaic systems: An Australian case study journal November 2019
China's building energy demand: Long-term implications from a detailed assessment journal October 2012
Improving policy instruments to better tap into homeowner refurbishment potential: Lessons learned from a case study in Germany journal May 2012
Barriers to widespread adoption of electric vehicles: An analysis of consumer attitudes and perceptions journal September 2012
The influence of financial incentives and other socio-economic factors on electric vehicle adoption journal May 2014
Market-driven automotive industry compliance with fuel economy and greenhouse gas standards: Analysis based on consumer choice journal September 2017
Heating system upgrades: The role of knowledge, socio-demographics, building attributes and energy infrastructure journal September 2018
The dual-credit policy: Quantifying the policy impact on plug-in electric vehicle sales and industry profits in China journal October 2018
Predictors of electric vehicle adoption: An analysis of potential electric vehicle drivers in Austria journal November 2018
Information dissemination and residential solar PV adoption rates: The effect of an information campaign in Sweden journal July 2020
Energy transition at local level: Analyzing the role of peer effects and socio-economic factors on UK solar photovoltaic deployment journal January 2021
Transitioning to energy efficient housing: Drivers and barriers of intermediaries in heat pump technology journal February 2022
Socioeconomic and demographic disparities in residential battery storage adoption: Evidence from California journal May 2022
How to support EV adoption: Tradeoffs between charging infrastructure investments and vehicle subsidies in California journal June 2022
Current status and future potential of rooftop solar adoption in the United States journal June 2023
Agent-based modeling of energy technology adoption: Empirical integration of social, behavioral, economic, and environmental factors journal August 2015
Examining the decision-making processes behind household energy investments: A review journal November 2015
Explaining interest in adopting residential solar photovoltaic systems in the United States: Toward an integration of behavioral theories journal March 2017
Peer effects in the adoption of solar energy technologies in the United States: An urban case study journal February 2019
Fear and loathing of electric vehicles: The reactionary rhetoric of range anxiety journal February 2019
Agent-based modelling and socio-technical energy transitions: A systematic literature review journal March 2019
Who is buying electric vehicles in California? Characterising early adopter heterogeneity and forecasting market diffusion journal September 2019
What drives home solar PV uptake? Subsidies, peer effects and visibility in Sweden journal February 2020
A meta-analysis of residential PV adoption: the important role of perceived benefits, intentions and antecedents in solar energy acceptance journal February 2022
The role of human influences on adoption and rejection of energy technology: A systematised critical review of the literature on household energy transitions journal July 2022
Behavior matters: A systematic review of representing consumer mobility choices in energy models journal August 2022
Falling short in 2030: Simulating battery-electric vehicle adoption behaviour in the Netherlands journal March 2023
Social and contextual determinants of heat pump adoption in the US: Implications for subsidy policy design journal October 2023
Rooftop solar, electric vehicle, and heat pump adoption in rural areas in the United States journal November 2023
Quantifying the impacts of micro- and mild- hybrid vehicle technologies on fleetwide fuel economy and electrification journal May 2020
Modelling social influence and cultural variation in global low-carbon vehicle transitions journal November 2017
Forecasting distributed energy resources adoption for power systems journal June 2022
Exploratory policy analysis for electric vehicle adoption in European countries: A multi-agent-based modelling approach journal August 2023
How does the presence of HOV lanes affect plug-in electric vehicle adoption in California? A generalized propensity score approach journal September 2017
Assessing the Potential to Reduce U.S. Building CO2 Emissions 80% by 2050 journal October 2019
The impact of range anxiety and home, workplace, and public charging infrastructure on simulated battery electric vehicle lifetime utility journal July 2014
Societal Transformations in Models for Energy and Climate Policy: The Ambitious Next Step journal December 2019
Overcoming barriers and uncertainties in the adoption of residential solar PV journal April 2016
Residential solar photovoltaic adoption behaviour: End-to-end review of theories, methods and approaches journal June 2021
Exploring residential solar PV and battery energy storage adoption motivations and barriers in a mature PV market journal May 2022
Comparison of plug-in electric vehicle adoption in the United States: A state by state approach journal October 2015
Energy systems modeling for twenty-first century energy challenges journal May 2014
The adoption of PV in the Netherlands: A statistical analysis of adoption factors journal January 2015
Influence of demographic variables on uptake of domestic solar photovoltaic technology journal January 2017
A review of factors influencing consumer intentions to adopt battery electric vehicles journal October 2017
Factors influencing early battery electric vehicle adoption in Ireland journal February 2020
Future integrated mobility-energy systems: A modeling perspective journal March 2020
Assessing the socio-demographic, technical, economic and behavioral factors of Nordic electric vehicle adoption and the influence of vehicle-to-grid preferences journal April 2020
Predictors, taxonomy of predictors, and correlations of predictors with the decision behaviour of residential solar photovoltaics adoption: A review journal May 2020
A systemic approach to analyze integrated energy system modeling tools: A review of national models journal November 2020
Political, economic, social, technological, legal and environmental dimensions of electric vehicle adoption in the United States: A social-media interaction analysis journal December 2021
Next frontiers in energy system modelling: A review on challenges and the state of the art journal May 2022
Adoption of renewable home heating systems: An agent-based model of heat pumps in Ireland journal November 2022
Cross-country diffusion of photovoltaic systems: Modelling choices and forecasts for national adoption patterns journal February 2010
A review of socio-technical energy transition (STET) models journal November 2015
Forecasting residential solar photovoltaic deployment in California journal April 2017
What do adoption patterns of solar panels observed so far tell about governments’ incentive? Insights from diffusion models journal November 2020
A comprehensive model of regional electric vehicle adoption and penetration journal February 2017
Consumer preferences for business models in electric vehicle adoption journal January 2019
An early look at plug-in electric vehicle adoption in disadvantaged communities in California journal June 2019
Can you ever be certain? Reducing hypothetical bias in stated choice experiments via respondent reported choice certainty journal July 2016
Improving the behavioral realism of global integrated assessment models: An application to consumers’ vehicle choices journal August 2017
A review and simple meta-analysis of factors influencing adoption of electric vehicles journal September 2020
The role of infrastructure to enable and support electric drive vehicles: A Transportation Research Part D Special Issue journal December 2020
Battery Electric Vehicle adoption in regions without strong policies journal January 2021
Is EV experience related to EV acceptance? Results from a German field study journal July 2014
Scaling Deep Decarbonization Technologies journal October 2021
Personal and contextual influences on househould energy adaptations. journal February 1985
Agent-based modelling of consumer energy choices journal May 2016
Why significant variables aren’t automatically good predictors journal October 2015
Improvements in the representation of behavior in integrated energy and transport models journal July 2018
Adoption of electric vehicles: Which factors are really important? journal September 2020
Patterns and predictors of early electric vehicle adoption in Massachusetts journal April 2021
Evolution of consumer information preferences with market maturity in solar PV adoption journal July 2017
Characterizing local rooftop solar adoption inequity in the US journal February 2022
Policy complementarity and the paradox of carbon pricing journal November 2023
Understanding the determinants of rooftop solar installation: evidence from household surveys in Australia journal July 2019
Models of Decision Making and Residential Energy Use journal November 2007
Bounded Rationality journal June 1999
Creating Agent-Based Energy Transition Management Models That Can Uncover Profitable Pathways to Climate Change Mitigation journal January 2017
What Matters for Electrification? Evidence from 70 Years of U.S. Home Heating Choices journal February 2023
Free Charging: Exploratory Study of Its Impact on Electric Vehicle Sales and Energy journal May 2019
Why is renewable heat in the UK underperforming? A socio-technical perspective journal February 2013
Peer Effects in the Diffusion of Solar Photovoltaic Panels journal November 2012
GCAM v5.1: representing the linkages between energy, water, land, climate, and economic systems journal January 2019