Skip to main content
U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Modeling separation of lanthanides via heterogeneous ligand binding

Journal Article · · Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics. PCCP
DOI:https://doi.org/10.1039/d4cp00880d· OSTI ID:2430012

Individual lanthanide elements have physical/electronic/magnetic properties that make each useful for specific applications. Several of the lanthanides cations (Ln3+) naturally occur together in the same ores. They are notoriously difficult to separate from each other due to their chemical similarity. Predicting the Ln3+ differential binding energies (ΔΔE) or free energies (ΔΔG) at different binding sites, which are key figures of merit for separation applications, will help design of materials with lanthanide selectivity. We apply ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations and density functional theory (DFT) to calculate ΔΔG for Ln3+ coordinated to ligands in water and embedded in metal–organic frameworks (MOFs), and ΔΔE for Ln3+ bonded to functionalized silica surfaces, thus circumventing the need for the computational costly absolute binding (free) energies ΔG and ΔE. Perturbative AIMD simulations of water-inundated simulation cells are applied to examine the selectivity of ligands towards adjacent Ln3+ in the periodic table. Static DFT calculations with a full Ln3+ first coordination shell, while less rigorous, show that all ligands examined with net negative charges are more selective towards the heavier lanthanides than a charge-neutral coordination shell made up of water molecules. Amine groups are predicted to be poor ligands for lanthanide-binding. Finally, we also address cooperative ion binding, i.e., using different ligands in concert to enhance lanthanide selectivity.

Research Organization:
Sandia National Laboratories (SNL-NM), Albuquerque, NM (United States)
Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA); USDOE Laboratory Directed Research and Development (LDRD) Program
Grant/Contract Number:
NA0003525
OSTI ID:
2430012
Report Number(s):
SAND--2024-10564J
Journal Information:
Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics. PCCP, Journal Name: Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics. PCCP Journal Issue: 30 Vol. 26; ISSN 1463-9076
Publisher:
Royal Society of ChemistryCopyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English

References (92)

The Energetic and Structural Effects of Steric Crowding in Phosphate and Dithiophosphinate Complexes of Lanthanide Cations M3+: A Computational Study journal April 2001
Elucidation of the Structure of Organic Solutions in Solvent Extraction by Combining Molecular Dynamics and X-ray Scattering journal April 2014
Specific Ion Effects on an Oligopeptide: Bidentate Binding Matters for the Guanidinium Cation journal November 2018
Hydration of Lanthanoid(III) Ions in Aqueous Solution and Crystalline Hydrates Studied by EXAFS Spectroscopy and Crystallography: The Myth of the “Gadolinium Break” journal March 2008
Hydration of Lanthanoids(III) and Actinoids(III): An Experimental/Theoretical Saga journal August 2012
Periodic Behavior of Lanthanide Coordination within Reverse Micelles journal January 2013
Efficient Separation of Light Lanthanides(III) by Using Bis‐Lactam Phenanthroline Ligands journal March 2019
Metal Recognition Driven by Weak Interactions: A Case Study in Solvent Extraction journal May 2016
A Computational Approach to Predicting Ligand Selectivity for the Size-Based Separation of Trivalent Lanthanides: A Computational Approach to Predicting Ligand Selectivity for the Size-Based Separation of Trivalent Lanthanides journal June 2016
Semiempirical GGA-type density functional constructed with a long-range dispersion correction journal January 2006
Predictive Models for HOMO and LUMO Energies of N-Donor Heterocycles as Ligands for Lanthanides Separation journal July 2018
Understanding the Stability Trend Along Light Lanthanide Complexes with an Ehtylenediamine‐Type Ligand: A Quantum Chemical Study journal November 2019
Rare earth element complexation by PO43− ions in aqueous solution journal October 1991
Efficiency of ab-initio total energy calculations for metals and semiconductors using a plane-wave basis set journal July 1996
Role of the intramolecular hydrogen bond and ligand rigidity in the complexation of trifluoroacetylcycloalkanones with lanthanides: novel strategy for the design of organic ligands of high selectivity journal January 1998
Complexation of Ln3+ lanthanide cations with phosphoryl-containing OPR3 ligands: a quantum-mechanics study journal April 1998
A Monte Carlo simulation study of solvent effect on Eu3+ to Nd3+ ion mutation journal July 2001
Thermodynamic data provided through the FUNMIG project: Analyses and prospective journal February 2012
Recent advances in computational modeling and simulations on the An(III)/Ln(III) separation process journal July 2012
The chemical consequences of the gradual decrease of the ionic radius along the Ln-series journal March 2020
New reversed phase-high performance liquid chromatographic method for selective separation of yttrium from all rare earth elements employing nitrilotriacetate complexes in anion exchange mode journal March 2015
Rare earth elements recovery using staged precipitation from a leachate generated from coarse coal refuse journal July 2018
Combined supramolecular and mesoscale modelling of liquid–liquid extraction of rare earth salts journal October 2018
Sorption of Eu(III) on quartz at high salt concentrations journal October 2019
Industrial property prediction using Towhee and LAMMPS journal March 2004
A DFT study of the affinity of lanthanide and actinide ions for sulfur-donor and nitrogen-donor ligands in aqueous solution journal February 2013
A Molecular-Scale Approach to Rare-Earth Beneficiation: Thinking Small to Avoid Large Losses journal September 2020
Complexation of trivalent lanthanides and actinides with diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid: Theoretical unraveling of bond covalency journal February 2020
Designing Metal-Chelator-like Traps by Encoding Amino Acids in Zirconium-Based Metal–Organic Frameworks journal October 2022
Coordination Sphere of Lanthanide Aqua Ions Resolved with Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics and X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy journal February 2021
Ionic Contraction across the Lanthanide Series Decreases the Temperature-Induced Disorder of the Water Coordination Sphere journal December 2021
Topological Study of Bonding in Aquo and Bis(triazinyl)pyridine Complexes of Trivalent Lanthanides and Actinides: Does Covalency Imply Stability? journal August 2016
“Straining” to Separate the Rare Earths: How the Lanthanide Contraction Impacts Chelation by Diglycolamide Ligands journal November 2016
Development of Lennard-Jones and Buckingham Potentials for Lanthanoid Ions in Water journal May 2017
Influence of a Heterocyclic Nitrogen-Donor Group on the Coordination of Trivalent Actinides and Lanthanides by Aminopolycarboxylate Complexants journal January 2018
In Situ 27 Al NMR Spectroscopy of Aluminate in Sodium Hydroxide Solutions above and below Saturation with Respect to Gibbsite journal July 2018
Highly Selective Separation of Actinides from Lanthanides by Dithiophosphinic Acids: An in-Depth Investigation on Extraction, Complexation, and DFT Calculations journal October 2018
Enhancing Actinide(III) over Lanthanide(III) Selectivity through Hard-by-Soft Donor Substitution: Exploitation and Implication of Near-Degeneracy-Driven Covalency journal July 2019
Implementing f-Block Metal Ions in Medicine: Tuning the Size Selectivity of Expanded Macrocycles journal June 2019
Theoretical Study of p K a Values for Trivalent Rare-Earth Metal Cations in Aqueous Solution journal January 2018
Insight into the Extraction Mechanism of Americium(III) over Europium(III) with Pyridylpyrazole: A Relativistic Quantum Chemistry Study journal April 2018
Influence of Counterions on the Hydration Structure of Lanthanide Ions in Dilute Aqueous Solutions journal February 2018
Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics Reveal Spectroscopic Siblings and Ion Pairing as New Challenges for Elucidating Prenucleation Aluminum Speciation journal June 2018
Cation-Induced Disruption of the Local Structure of Water in Faujasite journal February 2023
Common Cations Are Not Polarizable: Effects of Dispersion Correction on Hydration Structures from Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics journal May 2023
Concerted Metal Cation Desorption and Proton Transfer on Deprotonated Silica Surfaces journal August 2018
Improving Rare-Earth Mineral Separation with Insights from Molecular Recognition: Functionalized Hydroxamic Acid Adsorption onto Bastnäsite and Calcite journal April 2022
Mussel-Inspired Nanocellulose Coating for Selective Neodymium Recovery journal July 2023
Selective Extraction of Heavy and Light Lanthanides from Aqueous Solution by Advanced Magnetic Nanosorbents journal April 2016
Highly Efficient and Selective Recovery of Rare Earth Elements Using Mesoporous Silica Functionalized by Preorganized Chelating Ligands journal October 2017
Selective Separation and Preconcentration of Scandium with Mesoporous Silica journal December 2017
Molecular Recognition at Mineral Interfaces: Implications for the Beneficiation of Rare Earth Ores journal March 2020
The Chemistry of Lanthanides in Biology: Recent Discoveries, Emerging Principles, and Technological Applications journal August 2019
Cooperative Binding and Multiple Recognition by Bridged Bis(β-cyclodextrin)s with Functional Linkers journal July 2006
First Principles Calculations of Atomic Nickel Redox Potentials and Dimerization Free Energies: A Study of Metal Nanoparticle Growth journal December 2010
Interactions of Al(III), La(III), Gd(III), and Lu(III) with the Fused Silica/Water Interface Studied by Second Harmonic Generation journal August 2010
Sulfate Complexation of Trivalent Lanthanides Probed by Nanoelectrospray Mass Spectrometry and Time-Resolved Laser-Induced Luminescence journal September 2005
Trends in Aqueous Hydration Across the 4f Period Assessed by Reliable Computational Methods journal September 2010
Revised Ionic Radii of Lanthanoid(III) Ions in Aqueous Solution journal May 2011
Molecular Recognition of Sialic Acid by Lanthanide(III) Complexes through Cooperative Two-Site Binding journal April 2010
The missing term in effective pair potentials journal November 1987
Elucidating the Bimodal Acid−Base Behavior of the Water−Silica Interface from First Principles journal December 2009
Macrocyclic Ligands with an Unprecedented Size-Selectivity Pattern for the Lanthanide Ions journal July 2020
Advancing Rare-Earth Separation by Machine Learning journal June 2022
Protonation Constants of Ethylenediamine, Diethylenetriamine, and Spermine in NaCl(aq), NaI(aq), (CH 3 ) 4 NCl(aq) , and (C 2 H 5 ) 4 NI(aq) at Different Ionic Strengths and t = 25 °C journal November 2005
Molecular Models of Hydroxide, Oxyhydroxide, and Clay Phases and the Development of a General Force Field journal January 2004
Trends in Ln(III) Sorption to Quartz Assessed by Molecular Dynamics Simulations and Laser-Induced Fluorescence Studies journal October 2011
Exponential Sensitivity and Speciation of Al(III), Sc(III), Y(III), La(III), and Gd(III) at Fused Silica/Water Interfaces journal December 2011
Importance of Counteranions on the Hydration Structure of the Curium Ion journal June 2013
A versatile MOF-based trap for heavy metal ion capture and dispersion journal January 2018
Multicoordinate ligands for actinide/lanthanide separations journal January 2007
Hydrophilic sulfonated bis-1,2,4-triazine ligands are highly effective reagents for separating actinides( iii ) from lanthanides( iii ) via selective formation of aqueous actinide complexes journal January 2015
Capture of actinides (Th 4+ , [UO 2 ] 2+ ) and surrogating lanthanide (Nd 3+ ) in porous metal–organic framework MIL-100(Al) from water: selectivity and imaging of embedded nanoparticles journal January 2017
Soft-donor dipicolinamide derivatives for selective actinide( iii )/lanthanide( iii ) separation: the role of S- vs. O-donor sites journal January 2019
Structure and electronic properties of rare earth DOBDC metal–organic-frameworks journal January 2019
Tuning the anion binding properties of lanthanide receptors to discriminate nucleoside phosphates in a sensing array journal January 2020
Interplay of physically different properties leading to challenges in separating lanthanide cations – an ab initio molecular dynamics and experimental study journal January 2021
N-oxide ligands for selective separations of lanthanides: insights from computation journal January 2023
Tuning the pore chemistry of Zr-MOFs for efficient metal ion capture from complex streams journal January 2024
Computational study of lanthanide(iii) hydration journal January 2010
Why does the B3LYP hybrid functional fail for metals? journal July 2007
Ab initio molecular dynamics calculations of ion hydration free energies journal May 2009
Ion sizes and finite-size corrections for ionic-solvation free energies journal December 1997
Quantum chemical modelling of extraction separation of minor actinides and lanthanides: the state of the art journal September 2016
Lanthanide complexes as fluorescent indicators for neutral sugars and cancer biomarkers journal June 2006
Efficient iterative schemes for ab initio total-energy calculations using a plane-wave basis set journal October 1996
From ultrasoft pseudopotentials to the projector augmented-wave method journal January 1999
Generalized Gradient Approximation Made Simple journal October 1996
Stability constants of tervalent actinide and lanthanide sulfate complexes in aqueous solutions journal May 2012
Extractive Metallurgy of Rare Earths book December 2015
Practical Applications of Supramolecular Extraction with Macrocycles journal October 2020
Formation of metal complexes with ethylenediamine: a critical survey of equilibrium constants, enthalpy and entropy values journal January 1984

Similar Records

Coordination Sphere of Lanthanide Aqua Ions Resolved with Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics and X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy
Journal Article · Thu Feb 04 23:00:00 EST 2021 · Inorganic Chemistry · OSTI ID:1769883

Changes in nitrate binding with lanthanides in BLPhen complexes
Journal Article · Tue Jul 11 00:00:00 EDT 2023 · Journal of Molecular Liquids · OSTI ID:1995657