Skip to main content
U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Helfrich-Hurault elastic instabilities driven by geometrical frustration

Journal Article · · Reviews of Modern Physics
 [1];  [2];  [3];  [4];  [5];  [6]
  1. Université Montpellier (France)
  2. Brown University, Providence, RI (United States); Université PSL, Paris (France)
  3. University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA (United States)
  4. Université PSL, Paris (France)
  5. University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN (United States)
  6. Utrecht University (Netherlands)

Here, the Helfrich-Hurault (HH) elastic instability is a well-known mechanism behind patterns that form as a result of strain upon liquid crystal systems with periodic ground states. In the HH model, layered structures undulate and buckle in response to local, geometric incompatibilities in order to maintain the preferred layer spacing. Classic HH systems include cholesteric liquid crystals under electromagnetic field distortions and smectic liquid crystals under mechanical strains, where both materials are confined between rigid substrates. However, richer phenomena are observed when undulation instabilities occur in the presence of deformable interfaces and variable boundary conditions. Understanding how the HH instability is affected by deformable surfaces is imperative for applying the instability to a broader range of materials. In this review, the HH mechanism is reexamined and special focus is given to how the boundary conditions influence the response of lamellar systems to geometrical frustration. Lamellar liquid crystals confined within a spherical shell geometry are used as the model system. Made possible by the relatively recent advances in microfluidics within the past 15 years, liquid crystal shells are composed entirely of fluid interfaces and have boundary conditions that can be dynamically controlled at will. Past and recent work that exemplifies how topological constraints, molecular anchoring conditions, and boundary curvature can trigger the HH mechanism in liquid crystals with periodic ground states is examined. The review ends by identifying similar phenomena across a wide variety of materials, both biological and synthetic. The fact that the HH mechanism is a generic and often overlooked response of periodic materials to geometrical frustration is highlighted.

Research Organization:
US Department of Energy (USDOE), Washington, DC (United States). Office of Science, Basic Energy Sciences (BES)
Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE Office of Science (SC), Basic Energy Sciences (BES); French National Research Agency; National Science Foundation (NSF); Simons Foundation; European Commission
OSTI ID:
2424899
Alternate ID(s):
OSTI ID: 1968914
Journal Information:
Reviews of Modern Physics, Journal Name: Reviews of Modern Physics Journal Issue: 1 Vol. 95; ISSN 0034-6861
Publisher:
American Physical Society (APS)Copyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English

References (232)

Control of Periodic Zigzag Structures of DNA by a Simple Shearing Method journal November 2016
Controlling the Photonic Properties of Cholesteric Cellulose Nanocrystal Films with Magnets journal June 2017
The Self-Assembly of Cellulose Nanocrystals: Hierarchical Design of Visual Appearance journal December 2017
Visual Appearance of Chiral Nematic Cellulose‐Based Photonic Films: Angular and Polarization Independent Color Response with a Twist journal November 2019
Electroinduced Diffraction Gratings in Cholesteric Polymer with Phototunable Helix Pitch journal July 2015
Cholesteric Liquid Crystal Materials for Tunable Diffractive Optics journal June 2018
Reversible Switching of Block Copolymer Nanopatterns by Orthogonal Electric Fields journal October 2015
La structure fibrillaire et l'orientation des chromosomes chez les Dinoflagell�s journal January 1968
Vektorfelder inn-dimensionalen Mannigfaltigkeiten journal December 1927
�ber Abbildung von Mannigfaltigkeiten journal March 1911
Drops and shells of liquid crystal journal January 2011
Magnetic field induced instabilities of a doped lyotropic hexagonal phase journal March 1999
Curvature walls and focal conic domains in a lyotropic lamellar phase journal July 1999
Undulation instability of lamellar phases under shear: A mechanism for onion formation? journal October 1999
The confinement of smectics with a strong anchoring journal January 2001
Distorsions of a planar cholesteric structure induced by a magnetic field journal June 1972
Surface polarity induced domains in liquid crystals journal October 1973
Liquid crystal order and turbulence in the planar twist of the growing plant cell walls journal January 1992
Periodic perturbations in the cholesteric plane texture journal October 1971
Buckling instability of the layers in a smectic-A liquid crystal journal May 1973
Twisted fibrous arrangements in biological materials and cholesteric mesophases journal January 1972
Condensed phases of DNA: Structures and phase transitions journal January 1996
Magnetic field-induced instabilities and irreversible evolution in modulated ferromagnetic phases of cobalt films journal June 2002
Plywood structures in nature journal June 1998
Geometrical frustration and defects in condensed matter systems journal March 2008
Thick smectic shells journal October 2015
Thin nematic films: Anchoring effects and stripe instability revisited journal May 2013
Self-assembly of amphiphiles, polymers and proteins at interfaces between thermotropic liquid crystals and aqueous phases journal June 2008
Geometrical Frustration book January 2010
Principles of Condensed Matter Physics book January 1995
Structure Evolution and Drying Dynamics in Sliding Cholesteric Cellulose Nanocrystals journal March 2018
Temperature-Driven Anchoring Transitions at Liquid Crystal/Water Interfaces journal July 2020
Elastocapillary Driven Assembly of Particles at Free-Standing Smectic-A Films journal January 2018
Realignment of Liquid Crystal Shells Driven by Temperature-Dependent Surfactant Solubility journal July 2019
Light-Fueled Nanoscale Surface Waving in Chiral Liquid Crystal Networks journal January 2021
Amphiphile-Induced Phase Transition of Liquid Crystals at Aqueous Interfaces journal October 2018
Dynamic Diffractive Patterns in Helix-Inverting Cholesteric Liquid Crystals journal February 2019
Hierarchical Self-Assembly of Cellulose Nanocrystals in a Confined Geometry journal August 2016
Swelling Cholesteric Liquid Crystal Shells to Direct the Assembly of Particles at the Interface journal April 2020
Modulated Phases: Review and Recent Results journal December 2008
An Experimental System for Imaging the Reversible Adsorption of Amphiphiles at Aqueous−Liquid Crystal Interfaces journal August 2002
Effect of Surfactant Structure on the Orientation of Liquid Crystals at Aqueous−Liquid Crystal Interfaces journal August 2003
Active Control of the Anchoring of 4‘-Pentyl-4-cyanobiphenyl (5CB) at an Aqueous−Liquid Crystal Interface By Using a Redox-Active Ferrocenyl Surfactant journal October 2003
Contribution of Water Droplets to Defect Array Formation in Water-in-Cholesteric Liquid Crystal Emulsions journal October 2003
Parabolic Focal Conics in Self-Assembled Solid Films of Cellulose Nanocrystals journal April 2005
Interfacial Tension of a Nematic Liquid Crystal/Water Interface with Homeotropic Surface Alignment journal September 2004
Controlling the Stability and Size of Double-Emulsion-Templated Poly(lactic- co -glycolic) Acid Microcapsules journal June 2012
Influence of Specific Anions on the Orientational Ordering of Thermotropic Liquid Crystals at Aqueous Interfaces journal August 2012
Nematic Pancakes Revisited journal April 2008
Freeze−Fracture Electron Microscopy of Sheared Lamellar Phase journal January 1996
Deformation of Oriented Lamellar Block Copolymer Films journal August 2000
Electric Field Effects and Form Birefringence in Diblock Copolymers journal December 1995
Equilibrium morphology of block copolymer melts. 3 journal August 1990
Electric Field Alignment of Asymmetric Diblock Copolymer Thin Films journal December 2005
Thin Film Diblock Copolymers in Electric Field: Transition from Perpendicular to Parallel Lamellae journal March 2008
Shear-Induced Instability of the Lamellar Phase of a Block Copolymer journal January 1996
The highly concentrated liquid-crystalline phase of DNA is columnar hexagonal journal June 1989
Twenty years of drying droplets journal October 2017
Cellulose nanocrystal-based materials: from liquid crystal self-assembly and glass formation to multifunctional thin films journal January 2014
Deposition and drying dynamics of liquid crystal droplets journal May 2017
The smectic order of wrinkles journal July 2017
Nematic twist-bend phase with nanoscale modulation of molecular orientation journal November 2013
Topological zoo of free-standing knots in confined chiral nematic fluids journal January 2014
Frustrated nematic order in spherical geometries journal February 2011
A generalized density-modulated twist-splay-bend phase of banana-shaped particles journal April 2021
Cellulose photonic pigments journal June 2022
Dynamics of topological defects and structural synchronization in a forming periodic tissue journal January 2021
Nano-scale surface wrinkling in chiral liquid crystals and plant-based plywoods journal January 2015
Influence of interface stabilisers and surrounding aqueous phases on nematic liquid crystal shells journal January 2016
pH-Responsive liquid crystal double emulsion droplets prepared using microfluidics journal January 2016
Second harmonic light scattering induced by defects in the twist-bend nematic phase of liquid crystal dimers journal January 2016
Mesoscale structure of chiral nematic shells journal January 2016
Topological defects in cholesteric liquid crystal shells journal January 2016
The dependency of twist-bend nematic liquid crystals on molecular structure: a progression from dimers to trimers, oligomers and polymers journal January 2016
Structures in the meniscus of smectic membranes: the role of dislocations? journal January 2017
Cholesteric liquid crystals in living matter journal January 2017
Stabilized electrically induced Helfrich deformation and enhanced color tuning in cholesteric liquid crystals journal January 2017
Optically induced motion of liquid crystalline droplets journal January 2018
Correction: Shedding light on the structural properties of lipid bilayers using molecular dynamics simulation: a review study journal January 2019
Optical motion control of liquid crystalline droplets by host–guest molecular interaction journal January 2019
Topological solitons, cholesteric fingers and singular defect lines in Janus liquid crystal shells journal January 2020
Undulation instability in block-copolymer lamellae subjected to a perpendicular electric field journal January 2006
Liquid crystal models of biological materials and processes journal January 2010
Chromonic review journal January 2010
Color selectivity lent to a cholesteric liquid crystal by monitoring interface-induced deformations journal January 2011
Self-assembly of block copolymers journal January 2012
Towards tunable defect arrangements in smectic liquid crystal shells utilizing the nematic–smectic transition in hybrid-aligned geometries journal January 2012
Geometrical frustration of chiral ordering in cholesteric droplets journal January 2012
Bivalent defect configurations in inhomogeneous nematic shells journal January 2013
Dynamic flow behaviour of surfactant vesicles under shear flow: role of a multilamellar microstructure journal January 2013
I. Liquid crystals. On the theory of liquid crystals journal January 1958
Les états mésomorphes de la matière journal January 1922
Focal conic faceting in smectic-A liquid crystals journal July 1991
Ginzburg-Landau theory of aqueous surfactant solutions journal September 1992
Saddle-splay and periodic instability in a hybrid aligned nematic layer subjected to a normal magnetic field journal October 1992
Effect of shear on a lyotropic lamellar phase journal September 1993
Dynamics of Undulation Instability in Lamellar Systems journal August 1995
Nonlinear Analysis of Stripe Textures in Hexagonal Lyotropic Mesophases journal February 1996
The Anchoring of a Cholesteric Liquid Crystal at the Free Surface journal June 1996
Recherches sur les textures des états mésomorphes - 1. Les arrangements focaux dans les smectiques : rappels et considérations théoriques journal January 1972
Statistical properties of focal conic textures in smectic liquid crystals journal January 1973
Covariant elasticity for smectics A journal January 1975
Instabilities under mechanical tension in a smectic cylinder journal January 1976
Mechanical instabilities of smectic-A liquid crystals under dilative or compressive stresses journal January 1977
The parabolic focal conic : a new smectic a defect journal January 1977
Quasicrystalline behaviour and phase transition in cholesteric « blue » phase journal January 1981
Elastic light scattering by smectic A focal conic defects journal January 1982
Undulation instability under shear in smectic A liquid crystals journal January 1982
The organization of cholesteric spherulites journal January 1984
The Frank constants of some nematic liquid crystals journal January 1985
Liquid crystalline phases given by helical biological polymers (DNA, PBLG and xanthan). Columnar textures journal January 1986
Undulation instability in stripe domain structures of « bubble » material journal January 1987
Distorsion D'Une Lamelle NÉMatique sous Champ MagnÉTique Conditions D'Ancrage aux Parois journal November 1969
Ferroelectric liquid crystals journal January 1975
A tentative description of the crystallography of amorphous solids journal January 1979
Hydrodynamics of cholesteric liquid crystals with impurities journal January 1981
Column undulation instability in a discotic liquid crystal journal January 1985
Undulational instabilities of the columnar phase of diblock copolymers journal July 2002
Deformation of Cholesteric Liquid Crystals with low Threshold Voltage journal December 1970
Strain‐induced instability of monodomain smectic A and cholesteric liquid crystals journal May 1973
Conduction‐Induced Alignment of Nematic Liquid Crystals: Basic Model and Stability Considerations journal November 1969
Electrohydrodynamic and Dielectric Instabilities of Cholesteric Liquid Crystals journal July 1971
Static distortions of a cholesteric planar structure induced by magnetic or ac electric fields journal August 1973
Comparison between square, triangular, or one dimensional lattice of distortions in smectic A and cholesteric crystals for superposed strain and magnetic field of any directions journal February 1974
Nematic ordering and defects on the surface of a sphere: A Monte Carlo simulation study journal March 2008
Fluctuation effects in the theory of microphase separation in block copolymers journal July 1987
Response and instabilities of the lamellar phase of diblock copolymers under uniaxial stress journal February 1994
Chiral symmetry breaking by spatial confinement in tactoidal droplets of lyotropic chromonic liquid crystals journal March 2011
Elastic sheet on a liquid drop reveals wrinkling and crumpling as distinct symmetry-breaking instabilities journal June 2012
Wrinkles and splay conspire to give positive disclinations negative curvature journal September 2015
Curvature-induced stiffness and the spatial variation of wavelength in wrinkled sheets journal January 2016
Waltzing route toward double-helix formation in cholesteric shells journal August 2016
Mesoscale structure of wrinkle patterns and defect-proliferated liquid crystalline phases journal February 2020
Curved crystals, defects and disorder journal January 1989
Structure and dynamics of biological liquid crystals journal October 2013
Anchoring transitions and periodic deformations in nematic slabs journal June 2015
Influence of head group and chain length of surfactants used for stabilising liquid crystal shells journal September 2018
Topological defects in dispersed words and worlds around liquid crystals, or liquid crystal drops journal January 1998
On the existence of even indexed disclinations in nematic liquid crystals journal February 1973
On Molecular Structure and Physical Properties of Thermotropic Liquid Crystals journal June 1969
Electric-Field-Induced Texture Transformation and Pitch Contraction in a Cholesteric Liquid Crystal journal December 1971
Dislocation Effects on the Viscoelastic Properties of a Smectic A Liquid Crystal journal January 1977
Chemical and biological sensing using liquid crystals journal June 2013
Smectic shells journal June 2012
Liquid crystals in micron-scale droplets, shells and fibers journal February 2017
Contact topology and the structure and dynamics of cholesterics journal November 2017
The Physics of Liquid Crystals book December 1993
Tuning the defect configurations in nematic and smectic liquid crystalline shells
  • Liang, Hsin-Ling; Noh, JungHyun; Zentel, Rudolf
  • Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences, Vol. 371, Issue 1988 https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2012.0258
journal April 2013
Nematic-isotropic interface of some members of the homologous series of 4-cyano-4′-( n -alkyl)biphenyl liquid crystals journal December 1984
Evolution of disorder in magnetic stripe domains. I. Transverse instabilities and disclination unbinding in lamellar patterns journal December 1992
Static One-Dimensional Distortions in Cholesteric Liquid Crystals journal December 1973
Layer buckling in smectic-Aliquid crystals and two-dimensional stripe phases journal October 1993
Periodic stripe domains and hybrid-alignment regime in nematic liquid crystals: Threshold analysis journal February 1994
Strain-induced instabilities in hexagonal columnar phases journal October 1994
Mixed fluid bilayers: Effects of confinement journal October 1994
Structure of the cholesteric focal conic domains at the free surface journal October 1996
Inverted and multiple nematic emulsions journal January 1998
Buckling induced by dilative strain in two- and three-dimensional layered materials journal September 2000
Undulations in a confined lamellar system with surface anchoring journal February 2001
Measurement of the anisotropy of the energy of an isotropic-smectic interface in a smectic cylinder: Application to theL3−Lαinterface journal June 2001
Coiling instabilities of multilamellar tubes journal December 2002
Smectic blue phases: Layered systems with high intrinsic curvature journal October 2003
Defect dynamics in a smectic Grandjean-Cano wedge journal January 2004
Self-assembled patterns and strain-induced instabilities for modulated systems journal August 2005
Reexamination of the Helfrich-Hurault effect in smectic-Aliquid crystals journal October 2005
Undulations of lamellar liquid crystals in cells with finite surface anchoring near and well above the threshold journal July 2006
Nematic textures in spherical shells journal August 2006
X-ray microscopy study of chromonic liquid crystal dry film texture journal December 2007
Topological transformations in bipolar shells of nematic liquid crystals journal February 2009
Mechanically induced Helfrich-Hurault effect in lamellar systems journal September 2009
Extrinsic curvature, geometric optics, and lamellar order on curved substrates journal November 2009
Phase behavior and properties of the liquid-crystal dimer 1′′,7′′-bis(4-cyanobiphenyl-4′-yl) heptane: A twist-bend nematic liquid crystal journal September 2011
Formation and ordering of topological defect arrays produced by dilatational strain and shear flow in smectic- A liquid crystals journal January 2012
Defect trajectories in nematic shells: Role of elastic anisotropy and thickness heterogeneity journal August 2012
Defect coalescence in spherical nematic shells journal September 2012
Chemically induced twist-bend nematic liquid crystals, liquid crystal dimers, and negative elastic constants journal August 2013
Twist-bend nematic liquid crystals in high magnetic fields journal June 2014
Instability and reorientation of block copolymer microstructure by imposed electric fields journal May 2016
Spherical nematic shells with a threefold valence journal July 2016
Elastic interactions between topological defects in chiral nematic shells journal December 2016
Topological Defects in Spherical Nematics journal July 2008
Undulation Instabilities in the Meniscus of Smectic Membranes journal March 2011
Nematic-Smectic Transition under Confinement in Liquid Crystalline Colloidal Shells journal June 2011
Nematic-Smectic Transition in Spherical Shells journal June 2011
Weirdest Martensite: Smectic Liquid Crystal Microstructure and Weyl-Poincaré Invariance journal April 2016
Layered Chiral Active Matter: Beyond Odd Elasticity journal June 2021
Electric and Magnetic Field Investigations of the Periodic Gridlike Deformation of a Cholesteric Liquid Crystal journal March 1972
Electrohydrodynamic Effects in Cholesteric Liquid Crystals under ac Electric Fields journal March 1972
Light Scattering by Deformation of the Plane Texture of Smectic and Cholesteric Liquid Crystals journal January 1973
Plasticity in a Smectic-ALiquid Crystal journal November 1977
Relieving Cholesteric Frustration: The Blue Phase in a Curved Space journal August 1983
Column Buckling Instability in a Discotic Liquid Crystal journal August 1984
Corrugational Instabilities of Thin Copolymer Films journal July 1995
Structure of a Lyotropic Lamellar Phase under Shear journal February 1997
Minimal Surfaces, Screw Dislocations, and Twist Grain Boundaries journal April 1999
Geometry and Physics of Wrinkling journal February 2003
Stability of a Block-Copolymer Lamella in a Strong Electric Field journal December 2005
Structure and Dynamics of Liquid Crystalline Pattern Formation in Drying Droplets of DNA journal May 2006
Geometric Theory of Columnar Phases on Curved Substrates journal July 2007
Novel Defect Structures in Nematic Liquid Crystal Shells journal October 2007
Undulation instabilities in cholesteric liquid crystals induced by anchoring transitions journal May 2020
Dynamic tuning of the director field in liquid crystal shells using block copolymers journal July 2020
Geometry of the Cholesteric Phase journal September 2014
Change in Stripes for Cholesteric Shells via Anchoring in Moderation journal November 2017
Defect-Driven Shape Instabilities of Bundles journal August 2018
The topological theory of defects in ordered media journal July 1979
Crystalline liquids: the blue phases journal April 1989
The geometry of soft materials: a primer journal September 2002
Physics of liquid crystals of bent-shaped molecules journal November 2018
Complex alloy structures regarded as sphere packings. I. Definitions and basic principles journal March 1958
Shaping nanoparticle fingerprints at the interface of cholesteric droplets journal October 2018
Biaxiality-driven twist-bend to splay-bend nematic phase transition induced by an electric field journal September 2020
Monodisperse Double Emulsions Generated from a Microcapillary Device journal April 2005
Structural Origin of Circularly Polarized Iridescence in Jeweled Beetles journal July 2009
Domain Shapes and Patterns: The Phenomenology of Modulated Phases journal January 1995
Design of Surfaces for Patterned Alignment of Liquid Crystals on Planar and Curved Substrates journal June 1997
Alignment of Liquid Crystals with Patterned Isotropic Surfaces journal March 2001
Shaping colloidal bananas to reveal biaxial, splay-bend nematic, and smectic phases journal August 2020
The effect of shear flow on the Helfrich interaction in lyotropic lamellar systems journal August 2002
Colloids on free-standing smectic films journal June 2006
Corona patterns around inclusions in freely suspended smectic films journal January 2009
Wetting of cholesteric liquid crystals journal February 2016
Hydrodynamic instabilities in active cholesteric liquid crystals journal April 2017
Design of Responsive and Active (Soft) Materials Using Liquid Crystals journal June 2016
Soft Lithography journal August 1998
Block Copolymer Thermodynamics: Theory and Experiment journal October 1990
Instability patterns in ultrathin nematic films: Comparison between theory and experiment journal October 2010
Cylindrical intermediates in a shear-induced lamellar-to-vesicle transition journal February 2001
Switchable two-dimensional gratings based on field-induced layer undulations in cholesteric liquid crystals journal January 2005
Polymer-Dispersed Liquid Crystals: Boojums at Work journal January 1991
Liquid Crystal Dispersions journal January 1997
Observations géométriques sur les liquides à coniques focales journal January 1910

Figures / Tables (40)