skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Computational analysis of metal–metal bonded dimetal tetrabenzoate redox potentials in the context of ammonia oxidation electrocatalysis

Journal Article · · Dalton Transactions
DOI:https://doi.org/10.1039/d3dt00552f· OSTI ID:1992368

Metal–metal bonded complexes are promising candidates for catalyzing redox transformations. Of particular interest is the oxidation of ammonia to dinitrogen, an important half reaction for the potential utilization of ammonia as a fuel or hydrogen carrier. This work computationally explores 30 different metal–metal bonded dimers (5 different metal centers and 6 different benzoate ligand derivatives) to explore the tunability of the redox potential when ammonia is bound to the complexes as an axial ligand, modeling the first step in ammonia oxidation electrocatalysis. We calculate the redox potentials of these compounds, making reference to experimental data when appropriate, identifying two degrees of tunability: a coarse adjustment, changing the metal center, allows for a wide range of redox potentials to be accessed (from +1.0 to –2.0 V vs. ferrocene/ferrocenium in acetonitrile solution) and a fine adjustment, the para-substituent of the benzoate derivative, which affects the redox potential in a smaller range based on the electron donating/withdrawing effects of the substituent. Ruthenium and osmium tetrabenzoate catalysts are prime candidates for next generation ammonia oxidation catalysts because their redox potentials fall within the direct ammonia fuel cell “viability zone” bracketed by the thermodynamic potentials of oxygen reduction (ORR) and nitrogen reduction (NRR). Rhodium tetrabenzoate species fall above the ORR potential, suggesting ammonia oxidation promoted by Rh2 catalysts could instead be used to facilitate hydrogen production through coupling to hydrogen evolution at a cathode. The redox potentials of rhenium and iridium tetrabenzoate catalysts fall below the NRR potential suggesting that these compounds could be further investigated in the context of electrochemical ammonia synthesis. Each redox event studied involves electron transfer from the M–M δ* orbital regardless of choice of metal or benzoate ligand derivative; this leads us to believe that the chemical reactivity of the various studied compounds will be similar in the context of ammonia oxidation.

Research Organization:
Univ. of Wisconsin, Madison, WI (United States)
Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE Office of Science (SC), Basic Energy Sciences (BES). Chemical Sciences, Geosciences & Biosciences Division (CSGB); USDOE
Grant/Contract Number:
SC0021021
OSTI ID:
1992368
Alternate ID(s):
OSTI ID: 1973295
Journal Information:
Dalton Transactions, Vol. 52, Issue 21; ISSN 1477-9226
Publisher:
Royal Society of ChemistryCopyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English

References (118)

Chemistry, structure and bonding in diruthenium(II) tetracarboxylates journal August 1989
A Roadmap to the Ammonia Economy journal June 2020
Enhanced Ammonia Oxidation Catalysis by a Low-Spin Iron Complex Featuring Cis Coordination Sites journal May 2021
Synthesis of atomically precise single-crystalline Ru 2 -based coordination polymers journal January 2020
Magnetic Sponge Behavior via Electronic State Modulations journal April 2018
Arene–perfluoroarene interactions for crystal engineering of metal complexes: Controlled self-assembly of paddle-wheel dimers journal January 2013
A Reliable Method of Preparation of Diiridium Paddlewheel Complexes:  Structures of the First Compounds with Ir25+ Cores journal September 2000
Electrochemistry of metal-metal bonded diruthenium complexes journal May 2021
Metamagnetism with TN = 97 K in a layered assembly of paddlewheel [Ru2] units and TCNQ: an empirical rule for interlayer distances determining the magnetic ground state journal January 2018
Paddlewheel Complexes with Azulenes: Electronic Interaction between Metal Centers and Equatorial Ligands journal January 2019
The effect of chlorine and fluorine substitutions on tuning the ionization potential of benzoate-bridged paddlewheel diruthenium(ii, ii) complexes journal January 2015
Magnetic and liquid-crystalline properties of chlorido- and cyanato-bridged chain complexes of mixed-valent dinuclear ruthenium(ii,iii) 3,4,5-trialkoxybenzoates journal January 2019
Diruthenium(II,III) tetracarboxylates catalyzed H2O2 oxygenation of organic sulfides journal January 2015
New Dirhenium(III) Compounds Bridged by Carboxylate Ligands:  N(C4H9)4[Re2(OOCCF3)Cl6] and Re2(OOCCCHCo2(CO)6)4Cl2 journal September 2002
Regulation of NO Uptake in Flexible Ru Dimer Chain Compounds with Highly Electron Donating Dopants journal November 2016
Synthesis and molecular structure of the first inorganic quadruply-bridged Ir(II) dimer (Ir-Ir) journal January 1987
Hammett-law Correlation in the Electron-donation Ability oftrans-Heteroleptic Benzoate-bridged Paddlewheel-type Diruthenium(II,II) Complexes journal May 2018
Electrocatalytic Ammonia Oxidation by a Low-Coordinate Copper Complex journal November 2022
Redox chemistry of multiply bonded diosmium complexes: preparation and characterization of complexes containing osmium-osmium bonds of order 2.5 journal December 1984
A three-dimensional network of two-electron-transferred [Ru2]2TCNQ exhibiting anomalous conductance due to charge fluctuations journal January 2011
Inverting Steric Effects: Using “Attractive” Noncovalent Interactions To Direct Silver-Catalyzed Nitrene Transfer journal November 2017
Manganese‐Catalyzed Ammonia Oxidation into Dinitrogen under Chemical or Electrochemical Conditions** journal September 2021
Heteronuclear Dirhodium-Gold Anionic Complexes: Polymeric Chains and Discrete Units journal August 2020
An Electron-Transfer Ferromagnet with T c =107 K Based on a Three-Dimensional [Ru 2 ] 2 /TCNQ System journal September 2008
Crystallographic study and ligand substitution reactions of dirhodium(II) tris- and tetrakis(tritolylbenzoate) journal September 1989
New dirhodium(II,II) carboxylates with 2,6-bis(N′-1,2,4-triazolyl)pyridinato ligand (btp) journal December 2001
Substituent effects in dinuclear paddlewheel compounds: electrochemical and spectroscopic investigations journal August 1998
Geometries of Third-Row Transition-Metal Complexes from Density-Functional Theory journal July 2008
Calculation of One-Electron Redox Potentials Revisited. Is It Possible to Calculate Accurate Potentials with Density Functional Methods? journal June 2009
Magnetic Behavior of a 1D Molecular-Oxygen System Included within a Transformable Single-Crystal Adsorbent journal March 2006
All-Electron Scalar Relativistic Basis Sets for Third-Row Transition Metal Atoms journal May 2008
Gas-responsive porous magnet distinguishes the electron spin of molecular oxygen journal December 2018
Porous frameworks constructed by non-covalent linking of substitution-inert metal complexes journal January 2015
CO2superabsorption in a paddlewheel-type Ru dimer chain compound: gate-open performance dependent on inter-chain interactions journal January 2013
Neutral Paddlewheel Diruthenium Complexes with Tetracarboxylates of Large π-Conjugated Substituents:  Facile One-Pot Synthesis, Crystal Structures, and Electrochemical Studies journal September 2004
Selective NO Trapping in the Pores of Chain-Type Complex Assemblies Based on Electronically Activated Paddlewheel-Type [Ru2II,II]/[Rh2II,II] Dimers journal November 2013
Homogeneous electrocatalytic oxidation of ammonia to N 2 under mild conditions journal January 2019
The Effect of Structure upon the Reactions of Organic Compounds. Benzene Derivatives journal January 1937
Oxidation of Ammonia with Molecular Complexes journal September 2020
Dirhodium Paddlewheel with Functionalized Carboxylate Bridges: New Building Block for Self-Assembly and Immobilization on Solid Support journal April 2012
Host–Guest Hydrogen Bonding Varies the Charge‐State Behavior of Magnetic Sponges journal May 2019
Crystal Transformation and Host Molecular Motions in CO2 Adsorption Process of a Metal Benzoate Pyrazine (MII = Rh, Cu) journal February 2010
Preparation, structure, and magnetic properties of a tetrakis(carboxylato)diosmium(III) dichloride. Comparison with Os2(hp)4Cl2 journal March 1993
Honeycomb frameworks with a very large mesh of 39 × 29 Å diameters stabilized by π-stacked coronene molecules journal January 2012
Stepwise Neutral−Ionic Phase Transitions in a Covalently Bonded Donor/Acceptor Chain Compound journal March 2011
Synthesis, Properties, and Structural Characterization of Bromo‐ and Iodotetracarboxylatodiruthenium( II , III ) Compounds journal November 2004
Discrete and Monodimensional Heteropolynuclear Structures Formed by Tetracarboxylatodiruthenium(II,III) and Perrhenato Fragments journal July 2005
Synthesis, crystal structure, and gas adsorption property of microporous solid by assembly of 1-D coordination polymer with a zigzag skeleton journal January 2004
A Smooth Solvation Potential Based on the Conductor-Like Screening Model journal December 1999
Bottom-Up Synthesis of Acrylic and Styrylic RhII Carboxylate Polymer Beads: Solid-Supported Analogs of Rh2 (OAc)4 journal November 2018
Magnetic Sponge with Neutral-Ionic Phase Transitions journal December 2017
The structure of oxo-bridged trinuclear ruthenium and iridium hexacarboxylates journal November 1993
Tuning of the ionization potential of paddlewheel diruthenium(ii,ii) complexes with fluorine atoms on the benzoate ligands journal January 2011
The first examples of triply bonded dirhenium(II,II) complexes that contain bis(diphenylphosphino)methane and dithiocarbamato ligands: spectroscopic, structural, cytotoxicity and computational studies journal January 2020
Relativistic regular two‐component Hamiltonians journal September 1993
Ionic Donor-Acceptor Chain Derived from an Electron-Transfer Reaction of a Paddlewheel-Type Diruthenium(II, II) Complex and N ,N′ -Dicyanoquinonediimine journal August 2018
Layered ferrimagnets constructed from charge-transferred paddlewheel [Ru2] units and TCNQ derivatives: the importance of interlayer translational distance in determining magnetic ground state journal January 2018
Aerobic Ruthenium-Catalyzed Oxidative Transformation of Secondary Amines to Imines journal July 2007
Role of intramolecular hydrogen bonding in the redox chemistry of hydroxybenzoate-bridged paddlewheel diruthenium(ii,ii) complexes journal January 2022
Carbon Dioxide Inclusion Phases of a Transformable 1D Coordination Polymer Host [Rh2(O2CPh)4(pyz)]n journal September 2003
Gate-open-type Sorption in a Zigzag Paddlewheel Ru Dimer Chain Compound with a Phenylenediamine Linker Instructed by a Preliminary Structural Change of Desolvation journal September 2017
A metal–organic framework that exhibits CO2-induced transitions between paramagnetism and ferrimagnetism journal November 2020
Dirhodium-Based Supramolecular Framework Catalyst for Visible-Light-Driven Hydrogen Evolution journal July 2021
X-Ray Structure, Ligand Substitution, and Other Properties of Trinuclear Ruthenium Complex, [Ru 33 -O)(μ-C 6 H 5 COO) 6 (py) 3 ](PF 6 ) (py = pyridine), and X-Ray Structure of Dinuclear Ruthenium Complex, [Ru 2 (μ-C 6 H 5 COO) 4 Cl] journal June 1992
Structural and Magnetic Study of O2 Molecules Arranged along a Channel in a Flexible Single-Crystal Host Family journal December 2008
Density-functional exchange-energy approximation with correct asymptotic behavior journal September 1988
Molecular orbital and spectroscopic studies of triple bonds between transition-metal atoms. 2. The d5-d5 Re2Cl4(PR3)4 compounds journal May 1983
Functionalized Paddle Wheel Complexes from BODIPY Carboxylic Acids journal November 2015
Synthesis, Characterization, Absorption Properties, and Electronic Structures of Paddlewheel-Type Dirhodium(II) Tetra-μ-(n-naphthoate) Complexes: An Experimental and Theoretical Study journal January 2019
Fully Electron-Transferred Donor/Acceptor Layered Frameworks with TCNQ 2– journal January 2015
Crystal and molecular structure of tetrakis(benzoato)bis(dimethylsulfoxide)dirhodium(II)·toluene journal November 1986
Rh 2 (II,III) Catalysts with Chelating Carboxylate and Carboxamidate Supports: Electronic Structure and Nitrene Transfer Reactivity journal February 2016
Scrutinizing ligand exchange reactions in the formation of the precious group metal–organic framework RuII,II-HKUST-1: the impact of diruthenium tetracarboxylate precursor and modulator choice journal January 2021
Structural, spectroscopic and theoretical studies of diosmium(iii,iii) tetracarboxylates journal January 2013
Charge-transfer two-dimensional layers constructed from a 2 : 1 assembly of paddlewheel diruthenium(II,II) complexes and bis[1,2,5]thiadizolotetracyanoquinodimethane: bulk magnetic behavior as a function of inter-layer interactions journal January 2009
Heading to Distributed Electrocatalytic Conversion of Small Abundant Molecules into Fuels, Chemicals, and Fertilizers journal November 2019
Gas inclusion crystal between 1-D coordination polymer and nitrous oxide: occurrence of crystal phase transition induced by a slight amount of fluid guests inside host journal December 2003
Geometrical Difference and Electron Configuration of Lantern-Type Rh24+ and Rh25+ Complexes:  X-ray Structural and DFT Study journal August 1998
Catalytic Ammonia Oxidation to Dinitrogen by Hydrogen Atom Abstraction journal June 2019
Bis(dimethyl sulfoxide-S)tetrakis(μ-p-hydroxybenzoato-O:O′)dirhodium(II)–tetrakis(μ-butyrato-O:O′)bis(dimethyl sulfoxide-S)dirhodium(II) cocrystal ethanol disolvate journal October 2000
Water-soluble diruthenium complexes bearing acetate and carbonate bridges: highly efficient catalysts for aerobic oxidation of alcohols in water journal January 2006
Diruthenium and diosmium tetracarboxylates: synthesis, physical properties and applications journal March 1998
Donor/acceptor neutral aggregation of a paddlewheel-type [Ru2II,II] complex and TCNQ journal March 2013
Magnetic and Electronic Properties of Three New Hetero-Bimetallic Coordination Frameworks [Ru2(O2CR)4][Au(CN)2] (R = Benzoic Acid, Furan-2-carboxylate, or Thiophen-2-carboxylate) journal January 2014
Alcohol Production from Carbon Dioxide: Methanol as a Fuel and Chemical Feedstock journal January 2021
Preparation and structural characterization of three tetracarboxylato dirhodium (RhRh) compounds with bulky ligands journal January 1984
Beyond fossil fuel–driven nitrogen transformations journal May 2018
Reactions of the octahalodirhenate(III) ions. VII. Structural characterization of dichlorotetrabenzoatodirhenium(III) journal August 1968
Electrocatalytic, Homogeneous Ammonia Oxidation in Water to Nitrate and Nitrite with a Copper Complex journal May 2022
Theoretical Studies on the Redox Potentials of Fe Dinuclear Complexes as Models for Hydrogenase journal October 2008
Synthesis and Characterisation of Diruthenium Paddlewheel Compounds Bearing 2,6-Di(p-tolyl)benzoate Ligands journal April 2010
Balanced basis sets of split valence, triple zeta valence and quadruple zeta valence quality for H to Rn: Design and assessment of accuracy journal January 2005
Construction of an Artificial Ferrimagnetic Lattice by Lithium Ion Insertion into a Neutral Donor/Acceptor Metal-Organic Framework journal March 2016
Ruthenium-catalysed oxidative conversion of ammonia into dinitrogen journal July 2019
Reversible Magnetism between an Antiferromagnet and a Ferromagnet Related to Solvation/Desolvation in a Robust Layered [Ru 2 ] 2 TCNQ Charge-Transfer System journal August 2010
Magneto-ionic phase control in a quasi-layered donor/acceptor metal–organic framework by means of a Li-ion battery system journal May 2017
The First Dirhodium Tetracarboxylate Molecule without Axial Ligation:  New Insight into the Electronic Structures of Molecules with Importance in Catalysis and Other Reactions journal April 2002
The crystal and molecular structures of dichromium tetraacetate dihydrate and dirhodium tetraacetate dihydrate journal August 1971
In Situ Tracking of Dynamic NO Capture through a Crystal-to-Crystal Transformation from a Gate-Open-Type Chain Porous Coordination Polymer to a NO-Adducted Discrete Isomer journal February 2019
Designing for a green chemistry future journal January 2020
Magnetic Sponge Phenomena Associated with Interchain Dipole–Dipole Interactions in a Series of Ferrimagnetic Chain Compounds Doped with Minor Diamagnetic Species journal April 2014
Acetonitrile vapour inclusion in single-crystal adsorbents [MII2(bza)4(pyz)]n (MII = Rh, Cu) journal January 2010
Density-functional approximation for the correlation energy of the inhomogeneous electron gas journal June 1986
Reduction of diruthenium(II,III) carboxylate compounds with hydroquinone: a facile preparation of diruthenium(II) complexes journal January 2005
Structure of tetra-n-butyratodiruthenium chloride, a compound with a strong metal-metal bond journal January 1969
Tuning of Stepwise Neutral–Ionic Transitions by Acceptor Site Doping in Alternating Donor/Acceptor Chains journal February 2016
Magnetic Correlation Engineering in Spin‐Sandwiched Layered Magnetic Frameworks journal November 2020
Ionicity Diagrams for Electron-Donor and -Acceptor Metal–Organic Frameworks: DA Chains and D2A Layers Obtained from Paddlewheel-Type Diruthenium(II,II) Complexes and Polycyano-Organic Acceptors journal January 2021
The influence of remote substituent in tetrakis(μ-N,N′-diarylformamidinato)–dirhodium(II) compounds. Part 7. Linear free energy relationships in dinuclear compounds journal January 2000
Structure and bonding in dirhodium(II) tetrasalicylate journal August 1984
A pyrazine bis-adduct of a binuclear rhodium(II) carboxylate containing 3,4,5-triethoxybenzoate as the equatorial ligand journal June 2002
Magnet Creation by Guest Insertion into a Paramagnetic Charge-Flexible Layered Metal–Organic Framework journal April 2021
A charge-disproportionate ordered state with δ = 0.75 in a chemically sensitive donor/acceptor D δ+ 2 A 2δ− layered framework journal January 2015
Solution Studies of Ru2(O2CR)4n+ Complexes (n = 0, 1; O2CR = Octanoate, Crotonate, Dimethylacrylate, Benzoate, p-Toluate) and Solid-State Structures of Ru2(O2C-p-tolyl)4(THF)2, [Ru2(O2C-p-tolyl)4(THF)2]+[BF4]-, and Ru2(O2C-p-tolyl)4(CH3CN)2:  Investigations of the Axial Ligation of the Ru2 Core journal January 1996
A Parent Iron Amido Complex in Catalysis of Ammonia Oxidation journal March 2022
Spontaneous N2 formation by a diruthenium complex enables electrocatalytic and aerobic oxidation of ammonia journal November 2021
Systematic Tuning and Switching of Neutral and Ionic Phases in a Donor-Acceptor Chain Compound by Doping with Less-Active Donors and by Pressure Application journal March 2014
A Dimer-of-dimers Composed of Paddlewheel Diruthenium(II, III) Complexes and a Bridge of Tetrachlorohydroquinonate(2−) Derived by Intramolecular Charge Transfers journal January 2012