Skip to main content
U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Critical review of functionalized silica sorbent strategies for selective extraction of rare earth elements from acid mine drainage

Journal Article · · Journal of Hazardous Materials

We report the ubiquitous and growing global reliance on rare earth elements (REEs) for modern technology and the need for reliable domestic sources underscore the rising trend in REE-related research. Adsorption-based methods for REE recovery from liquid waste sources are well-positioned to compete with those of solvent extraction, both because of their expected lower negative environmental impact and simpler process operations. Functionalized silica represents a rising category of low cost and stable sorbents for heavy metal and REE recovery. These materials have collectively achieved high capacity and/or high selective removal of REEs from ideal solutions and synthetic or real coal wastewater and other leachate source. These sorbents are competitive with conventional materials, such as ion exchange resins, activated carbon; and novel polymeric materials like ion-imprinted particles and metal organic frameworks (MOFs). This critical review first presents a data mining analysis for rare earth element recovery publications indexed in Web of science, highlighting changes in REE recovery research foci and confirming the sharply growing interest in functionalized silica sorbents. A detailed examination of sorbent formulation and operation strategies to selectively separate heavy (HREE), middle (MREE), and light (LREE) REEs from the aqueous sources is presented. Selectivity values for sorbents were largely calculated from available figure data and gauged the success of the associated strategies, primarily: (1) silane-grafted ligands, (2) impregnated ligands, and (3) bottom-up ligand/silica hybrids. These were often accompanied by successful co-strategies, especially bite angle control, site saturation, and selective REE elution. Recognizing the need to remove competing fouling metals to achieve purified REE “baskets,” we highlight techniques for eliminating these species from acid mine drainage (AMD) and suggest a novel adsorption-based process for purified REE extraction that could be adapted to different water systems.

Research Organization:
National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL), Pittsburgh, PA, Morgantown, WV, and Albany, OR (United States)
Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE Office of Fossil Energy (FE)
Grant/Contract Number:
89243318CFE000003
OSTI ID:
1868079
Alternate ID(s):
OSTI ID: 1834972
Journal Information:
Journal of Hazardous Materials, Journal Name: Journal of Hazardous Materials Journal Issue: Part C Vol. 424; ISSN 0304-3894
Publisher:
ElsevierCopyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English

References (162)

Synthesis, structure, and morphology of polymer-silica hybrid nanocomposites based on hydroxyethyl methacrylate journal November 1999
Nanostructured Hybrid Materials for the Selective Recovery and Enrichment of Rare Earth Elements journal January 2014
Synthesis and characterization of a surface imprinting silica gel polymer functionalized with phosphonic acid groups for selective adsorption of Fe(III) from aqueous solution: ARTICLE journal April 2017
Formation of Supramolecular Clusters at the Interface of Zeolite X Following the Adsorption of Rare-Earth Cations and Their Impact on the Macroscopic Properties of the Zeolite journal June 2018
Amine Sorbents for Selective Recovery of Heavy Rare‐Earth Elements (Dysprosium, Ytterbium) from Aqueous Solution journal January 2020
Novel Rapid Screening of Basic Immobilized Amine Sorbent/Catalyst Water Stability by a UV/Vis/Cu 2+ Technique journal October 2018
Recent Advances in the Separation of Rare Earth Elements Using Mesoporous Hybrid Materials journal May 2018
Ein neues Verfahren zur Trennung der seltenen Erden journal May 1937
Impact of AMD on water quality in critical watershed in the Hudson River drainage basin: Phillips Mine, Hudson Highlands, New York journal April 2008
Synthesis of ion-selective imprinted polymer for manganese removal from environmental water journal October 2010
Selective adsorption and separation of gadolinium with three-dimensionally interconnected macroporous imprinted chitosan films journal November 2016
The study of rare earth elements in farmer's well waters of the Podwiśniówka acid mine drainage area (south-central Poland) journal October 2013
Azo resorcin[4]calixpyrrole grafted Amberlite XAD-2 polymer: an efficient solid phase extractant for separation and preconcentration of La(III) and Ce(III) from natural geological samples journal December 2014
Synthesis of Ion-Imprinted Bioadsorbents Based on Chitosan and its Usage in Al(III) Removal journal April 2017
Characterization of Silicate Complexes in Aqueous Sodium Sulfate Solutions by FAB-MS journal June 2005
Synthesis of imprinted amino-functionalized mesoporous silica and their selective adsorption performance of Pb2+, Cu2+, and Zn2+ journal April 2019
The Recovery of Rare Earth Elements (REEs) from Aqueous Solutions Using Natural Zeolite and Bentonite journal July 2019
Geochemical characteristics of dissolved rare earth elements in acid mine drainage from abandoned high-As coal mining area, southwestern China journal July 2017
Trend of the research on rare earth elements in environmental science journal February 2020
A solution chemistry approach to the study of rare earth element precipitation by oxalic acid journal April 1999
Recovery of Rare-Earth Elements from Neodymium Magnet Waste Using Glycolic, Maleic, and Ascorbic Acids Followed by Solvent Extraction journal December 2018
Ion imprinted polymer particles: synthesis, characterization and dysprosium ion uptake properties suitable for analytical applications journal February 2003
The dissolution kinetics of amorphous silica into sodium chloride solutions: effects of temperature and ionic strength journal December 2000
Acid mine drainage composition and the implications for its impact on lotic systems journal July 1998
Extraction of rare earth elements with 2-ethylhexyl hydrogen 2-ethylhexyl phosphonate impregnated resins having different morphology and reagent content journal October 2001
Dissolved metals and associated constituents in abandoned coal-mine discharges, Pennsylvania, USA. Part 1: Constituent quantities and correlations journal February 2008
Attenuation and diel cycling of coal-mine drainage constituents in a passive treatment wetland: A case study from Lambert Run, West Virginia, USA journal June 2010
The role of Al13-polymers in the recovery of rare earth elements from acid mine drainage through pH neutralization journal February 2020
Sorption of europium on diatom biosilica as model of a “green” sorbent for f-elements journal March 2021
Diglycolic amic acid-modified E. coli as a biosorbent for the recovery of rare earth elements journal September 2016
Evaluation of lanthanide sorption and their coordination mechanism by EXAFS measurement using novel hybrid adsorbent journal June 2013
Ultrafast and high-capacity adsorption of Gd(III) onto inorganic phosphorous acid modified mesoporous SBA-15 journal April 2017
Coordination and silica surface chemistry of lanthanides (III), scandium (III) and yttrium (III) sorption on 1-(2-pyridylazo)-2-napththol (PAN) and acetylacetone (acac) immobilized gels journal September 2017
Studies on toluene adsorption performance and hydrophobic property in phenyl functionalized KIT-6 journal February 2018
Ligand immobilized novel hybrid adsorbents for rare earth elements (REE) removal from waste water: Assessing the feasibility of using APTES functionalized silica in the hybridization process with chitosan journal December 2017
Two-stage selective recovery process of scandium from the group of rare earth elements in aqueous systems using activated carbon and silica composites: Dual applications by tailoring the ligand grafting approach journal June 2018
Sorption and fractionation of rare earth element ions onto nanoscale zerovalent iron particles journal August 2018
Poly(amidoamine) dendrimer immobilized on mesoporous silica foam (MSF) and fibrous nano-silica KCC-1 for Gd3+ adsorption in water journal December 2019
Simultaneous recovery of rare earth elements from waste permanent magnets (WPMs) leach liquor by solvent extraction and hollow fiber supported liquid membrane journal February 2020
Rare earth elements in a historical mining district (south-west Spain): Hydrogeochemical behaviour and seasonal variability journal August 2020
Effective removal of Fe(II) impurity from rare earth solution using surface imprinted polymer journal December 2013
The geochemistry of rare earth elements (REE) in acid mine drainage from the Sitai coal mine, Shanxi Province, North China journal April 2007
Rare earth element resources in coal mine drainage and treatment precipitates in the Appalachian Basin, USA journal January 2017
Rare earth elements recovery using staged precipitation from a leachate generated from coarse coal refuse journal July 2018
The evaluation of critical rare earth element (REE) enriched treatment solids from coal mine drainage passive treatment systems journal May 2019
Rare Earth Elements and Yttrium (REY) in coal mine drainage from the Illinois Basin, USA journal January 2020
Synthesis of mesoporous silica containing group 2-metal cations and their performance behavior in rare earth cation adsorption journal February 2021
Sorption of lanthanum and erbium from aqueous solution by activated carbon prepared from rice husk journal December 2010
Geochemical characteristics of coal mine discharge vis-à-vis behavior of rare earth elements at Jaintia Hills coalfield, northeastern India journal January 2012
Study on recognition and separation of rare earth ions at picometre scale by using efficient ion-surface imprinted polymer materials journal December 2014
Rapid and selective recovery of heavy rare earths by using an adsorbent with diglycol amic acid group journal May 2015
Comparative study of the application of chelating resins for rare earth recovery journal May 2017
Recovery of light and heavy rare earth elements from apatite ore using sulphuric acid leaching, solvent extraction and precipitation journal August 2018
Extraction and separation studies of rare earth elements using Cyanex 272 impregnated Amberlite XAD-7 resin journal November 2018
Separation of rare earths using solvent extraction consisting of three phases journal September 2019
Solvent extraction of tungsten and rare earth with tertiary amine N235 from H2SO4–H3PO4 mixed acid leaching liquor of scheelite journal September 2020
Design and synthesis of chelating diamide sorbents for the separation of lanthanides journal June 2011
Separation of rare earths in nitric acid medium by a novel silica-based pyridinium anion exchange resin journal February 2006
Acceleration effect of sulfate ion on the dissolution of amorphous silica journal March 2009
Preparation and CO2 adsorption properties of aminopropyl-functionalized mesoporous silica microspheres journal November 2009
An EDTA-β-cyclodextrin material for the adsorption of rare earth elements and its application in preconcentration of rare earth elements in seawater journal March 2016
Recognition performance and mechanism of the activated carbon based UF resin towards traces of Fe(III) in rare earth solutions journal April 2017
Adsorptive recovery of neodymium and dysprosium in phosphorous functionalized nanoporous carbon journal October 2017
Optimization of carboxyl-functionalized mesoporous silica for the selective adsorption of dysprosium journal October 2018
Influence of competitive eluting agents on REEs recovery from silica gel adsorbent with immobilized aminodiphosphonic acid journal August 2020
Polyacrylamide–clinoptilolite/Y-zeolite composites: Characterization and adsorptive features for terbium journal March 2011
N- and O- ligand doped mesoporous silica-chitosan hybrid beads for the efficient, sustainable and selective recovery of rare earth elements (REE) from acid mine drainage (AMD): Understanding the significance of physical modification and conditioning of the polymer journal April 2018
MnFe2O4-graphene oxide magnetic nanoparticles as a high-performance adsorbent for rare earth elements: Synthesis, isotherms, kinetics, thermodynamics and desorption journal June 2018
Adsorption of rare earth metals from wastewater by nanomaterials: A review journal March 2020
Mesoporous silica adsorbents modified with amino polycarboxylate ligands – functional characteristics, health and environmental effects journal March 2021
Rationally designed dipicolinate-functionalized silica for highly efficient recovery of rare-earth elements from e-waste journal April 2021
Mass transfer and selective separation of neodymium ions via a hollow fiber supported liquid membrane using PC88A as extractant journal January 2015
EDTA-functionalized KCC-1 and KIT-6 mesoporous silicas for Nd3+ ion recovery from aqueous solutions journal November 2018
Recovery of rare-earth metals from aqueous solutions by bio/adsorption using non-conventional materials: a review with recent studies and promising approaches in column applications journal April 2020
Synthesis of metal ion loaded silica gel/chitosan biocomposite and its fluoride uptake studies from water journal September 2014
Sorption properties of porous spray-dried microspheres functionalized by phosphonic acid groups journal May 2012
Benzene triamido-tetraphosphonic acid immobilized on mesoporous silica for adsorption of Nd 3+ ions in aqueous solution journal March 2018
Hierarchical porous zeolitic imidazolate frameworks nanoparticles for efficient adsorption of rare-earth elements journal April 2019
Facile strategies for synthesis of functionalized mesoporous silicas for the removal of rare-earth elements and heavy metals from aqueous systems journal February 2021
A critical review on solvent extraction of rare earths from aqueous solutions journal February 2014
The evolution of mineral processing in extraction of rare earth elements using solid-liquid extraction over liquid-liquid extraction: A review journal October 2017
Adsorption of rare earth metals: A review of recent literature journal September 2016
Biosorption-a green method for the preconcentration of rare earth elements (REEs) from waste solutions: A review journal January 2019
The story of rare earth elements (REEs): Occurrences, global distribution, genesis, geology, mineralogy and global production journal July 2020
Application of physical–chemical and biological–chemical methods for heavy metals removal from acid mine drainage journal November 2012
Solvent-impregnated resins (SIRs) – Methods of preparation and their applications journal August 2010
Selective solid-phase extraction of rare earth elements by the chemically modified Amberlite XAD-4 resin with azacrown ether journal September 2010
Selectively removal of Al(III) from Pr(III) and Nd(III) rare earth solution using surface imprinted polymer journal January 2013
Review and new life cycle assessment for rare earth production from bastnäsite, ion adsorption clays and lateritic monazite journal April 2020
Determination of trace rare earth elements by inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectrometry after preconcentration with multiwalled carbon nanotubes journal January 2005
Non-aqueous solvent extraction of rare-earth nitrates from ethylene glycol to n-dodecane by Cyanex 923 journal March 2017
An overview on membrane strategies for rare earths extraction and separation journal May 2018
Study on the extraction of lanthanides by a mesoporous MCM-41 silica impregnated with Cyanex 272 journal January 2019
Reusable hydroxamate immobilized silica adsorbent for dispersive solid phase extraction and separation of rare earth metal ions journal January 2020
Sorption of rare-earth elements onto a ligand-associated media for pH-dependent extraction and recovery of critical materials journal March 2021
Use of natural clays as sorbent materials for rare earth ions: Materials characterization and set up of the operative parameters journal December 2015
Synergistic Effect of Doped Functionalized Ionic Liquids in Silica Hybrid Material for Rare Earth Adsorption journal February 2016
Branched 1,6-Diaminohexane-Derived Aliphatic Polyamine as Curing Agent for Epoxy: Isothermal Cure, Network Structure, and Mechanical Properties journal April 2017
Ethylenediaminetriacetic Acid-Functionalized Activated Carbon for the Adsorption of Rare Earths from Aqueous Solutions journal January 2018
Gd 3+ Adsorption over Carboxylic- and Amino-Group Dual-Functionalized UiO-66 journal January 2019
Ultrafast and Stable Adsorption–Desorption Performance for Recovery of Valuable Rare-Earth Ions using High-Density Polyacrylic Acid Brush-Grafted Polypropylene Fibers Optimized by RSM Models journal April 2020
Effect of Counteranions on the Extraction and Complexation of Trivalent Lanthanides with Tetradentate Phenanthroline-Derived Phosphonate Ligands journal November 2020
Preparation of Phosphoric Acid-Functionalized SBA-15 and Its High Efficient Selective Adsorption Separation of Lanthanum Ions journal January 2020
Theoretical Study of p K a Values for Trivalent Rare-Earth Metal Cations in Aqueous Solution journal January 2018
Nitrogen-Enriched Porous Benzimidazole-Linked Polymeric Network for the Adsorption of La (III), Ce (III), and Nd (III) journal February 2020
Understanding Selectivity of Mesoporous Silica-Grafted Diglycolamide-Type Ligands in the Solid-Phase Extraction of Rare Earths journal December 2020
Selective Extraction of Heavy and Light Lanthanides from Aqueous Solution by Advanced Magnetic Nanosorbents journal April 2016
Functionalization of Mesoporous Carbon Materials for Selective Separation of Lanthanides under Acidic Conditions journal March 2017
Recovering Rare Earth Elements from Aqueous Solution with Porous Amine–Epoxy Networks journal May 2017
Highly Efficient and Selective Recovery of Rare Earth Elements Using Mesoporous Silica Functionalized by Preorganized Chelating Ligands journal October 2017
Selective Separation and Preconcentration of Scandium with Mesoporous Silica journal December 2017
Selective Adsorption of Rare Earth Elements over Functionalized Cr-MIL-101 journal June 2018
Porous Covalent Organic Polymers Comprising a Phosphite Skeleton for Aqueous Nd(III) Capture journal March 2019
Size-Selective Separation of Rare Earth Elements Using Functionalized Mesoporous Silica Materials journal May 2019
On the Mechanism of the Dissolution of Quartz and Silica in Aqueous Solutions journal March 2017
Techno-Economic and Life Cycle Assessments for Sustainable Rare Earth Recovery from Coal Byproducts using Biosorption journal December 2020
Selective Adsorption of La 3+ Using a Tough Alginate-Clay-Poly( n -isopropylacrylamide) Hydrogel with Hierarchical Pores and Reversible Re-Deswelling/Swelling Cycles journal September 2016
Novel Polyethylenimine–Acrylamide/SiO 2 Hybrid Hydrogel Sorbent for Rare-Earth-Element Recycling from Aqueous Sources journal September 2017
Behind the Scenes of Clean Energy: The Environmental Footprint of Rare Earth Products journal January 2018
DTPA-Functionalized Silica Nano- and Microparticles for Adsorption and Chromatographic Separation of Rare Earth Elements journal April 2018
Organic Functionalization and Morphology Control of Mesoporous Silicas via a Co-Condensation Synthesis Method journal November 2003
Ionic radii in aqueous solutions journal December 1988
Reappraisal of thermochemical radii for complex ions journal September 1979
Rare Earth Element Distributions and Trends in Natural Waters with a Focus on Groundwater journal March 2014
Revised Ionic Radii of Lanthanoid(III) Ions in Aqueous Solution journal May 2011
Rare earths. LXXIX. Syntheses and properties of ethylenediamine chelates of the tripositive lanthanide ions journal April 1969
The Solubility of Amorphous Silica in Water journal June 1954
Fractional Partition of the rare Earths journal July 1941
Reaction Rates and Dissolution Mechanisms of Quartz as a Function of pH journal March 2008
Influence of Tetrahydrofuran on Epoxy−Amine Polymerization journal July 2005
Adsorption and chromatographic separation of rare earths with EDTA- and DTPA-functionalized chitosan biopolymers journal January 2014
Synthesis and characterization of lysine-modified SBA-15 and its selective adsorption of scandium from a solution of rare earth elements journal January 2014
Adsorption performance of functionalized chitosan–silica hybrid materials toward rare earths journal January 2014
Design of mesoporous silica hybrid materials as sorbents for the selective recovery of rare earth metals journal January 2015
Support effects in rare earth element separation using diglycolamide-functionalized mesoporous silica journal January 2016
Selective recovery of rare earth elements using chelating ligands grafted on mesoporous surfaces journal January 2015
Efficient adsorption and separation of dysprosium from NdFeB magnets in an acidic system by ion imprinted mesoporous silica sealed in a dialysis bag journal January 2016
Polyethylenimine-cross-linked cellulose nanocrystals for highly efficient recovery of rare earth elements from water and a mechanism study journal January 2017
Selective adsorption of rare earth elements onto functionalized silica particles journal January 2018
Stable immobilized amine sorbents for heavy metal and REE removal from industrial wastewaters journal January 2020
Biosilica layer-by-layer modified with polyamines and carboxyarsenazo for REE preconcentration prior to ICP-MS determination in lignites and volcanic fumarole sediment journal January 2020
Lanthanide selective sorbents: self-assembled monolayers on mesoporous supports (SAMMS) journal January 2004
Silica-based solvent impregnated adsorbents for separation of rare earth metals journal May 2017
Flame-Retardant Properties of PP/Al(OH) 3 /Mg(OH) 2 /POE/ZB Nanocomposites journal March 2012
Recovery of rare earth elements from acid mine drainage by ion exchange journal January 2020
Preparation of diglycolamide polymer modified silica and its application as adsorbent for rare earth ions journal January 2019
Efficient sorption of light rare-earth elements using resorcinol-formaldehyde polymeric resin journal August 2011
Sorption in the chemistry of rare earth elements journal June 2017
Kinetics and Mechanisms of Dissolution of Silica at Room Temperature and Pressure journal January 1994
Immobilization of Diglycol Amic Acid on Silica Gel for Selective Recovery of Rare Earth Elements journal September 2014
Preparation of a Novel Macroporous Silica-based Diglycolamide Derivative-impregnated Polymeric Composite and its Adsorption Mechanism for Rare Earth Metal Ions journal June 2007
Influence of Guanidine, Imidazole, and Some Heterocyclic Compounds on Dissolution Rates of Amorphous Silica journal December 2010
GEOCHEMISTRY AND HYDROGEOLOGY OF ACID MINE DRAINAGE IN THE GREAT FALLS-LEWISTOWN COAL FIELD, MONTAN [English] journal June 2006
Synthesis of mesoporous silica-phosphate hybrids and their adsorption competency for rare earth metal cations journal January 2017
Phosphomethylated Polyethyleneimine-immobilized Chelating Resin: Role of Phosphomethylation Rate on Solid-Phase Extraction of Trace Elements journal January 2019
Pilot test of pollution control and metal resource recovery for acid mine drainage journal September 2015
Mineral commodity summaries 2021 report February 2021
Selective Extraction of REEs Thanks to One-Pot Silica Hybrid Materials journal October 2020
Selective Extraction of Rare Earth Elements from Phosphoric Acid by Ion Exchange Resins journal August 2018
Recovery of Rare Earth Elements by Carbon-Based Nanomaterials—A Review journal May 2019
Tailoring bifunctional hybrid organic–inorganic nanoadsorbents by the choice of functional layer composition probed by adsorption of Cu 2+ ions journal January 2017
Dissolution of biogenic silica from land to ocean: Role of salinity and pH journal July 2008