skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Utilizing Environmental Tracers to Reduce Groundwater Flow and Transport Model Parameter Uncertainties

Journal Article · · Water Resources Research
DOI:https://doi.org/10.1029/2020WR028235· OSTI ID:1808335

Abstract Non‐uniqueness in groundwater model calibration is a primary source of uncertainty in groundwater flow and transport predictions. In this study, we investigate the ability of environmental tracer information to constrain groundwater model parameters. We utilize a pilot point calibration procedure conditioned to subsets of observed data including: liquid pressures, tritium ( 3 H), chlorofluorocarbon‐12 (CFC‐12), and sulfur hexafluoride (SF 6 ) concentrations; and groundwater apparent ages inferred from these environmental tracers, to quantify uncertainties in the heterogeneous permeability fields and infiltration rates of a steady‐state 2‐D synthetic aquifer and a transient 3‐D model of a field site located near Riverton, Wyoming (USA). To identify the relative data worth of each observation data type, the post‐calibration uncertainties of the optimal parameters for a given observation subset are compared to that from the full observation data set. Our results suggest that the calibration‐constrained permeability field uncertainties are largest when liquid pressures are used as the sole calibration data set. We find significant reduction in permeability uncertainty and increased predictive accuracy when the environmental tracer concentrations, rather than apparent groundwater ages, are used as calibration targets in the synthetic model. Calibration of the Riverton field site model using environmental tracer concentrations directly produces infiltration rate estimates with the lowest uncertainties, however; permeability field uncertainties remain similar between the environmental tracer concentration and apparent groundwater age calibration scenarios. This work provides insight on the data worth of environmental tracer information to calibrate groundwater models and highlights potential benefits of directly assimilating environmental tracer concentrations into model parameter estimation procedures.

Research Organization:
Sandia National Lab. (SNL-NM), Albuquerque, NM (United States); Sandia National Laboratories, WIPP Site
Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE; USDOE Office of Nuclear Energy (NE), Fuel Cycle Technologies
Grant/Contract Number:
DE‐NA0003525; AC04-94AL85000; NU-18-MT-UM-040102-04; DGE-1633831; NA0003525
OSTI ID:
1808335
Alternate ID(s):
OSTI ID: 1808339; OSTI ID: 1810349
Report Number(s):
SAND-2021-7550J; e2020WR028235
Journal Information:
Water Resources Research, Journal Name: Water Resources Research Vol. 57 Journal Issue: 7; ISSN 0043-1397
Publisher:
American Geophysical Union (AGU)Copyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English

References (77)

Parameter estimation using groundwater age and head data, Cape Cod, Massachusetts journal April 1998
3H/3He age data in assessing the susceptibility of wells to contamination journal May 2005
Estimability of recharge through groundwater model calibration: Insights from a field-scale steady-state example journal September 2016
Inverse Problem Theory and Methods for Model Parameter Estimation book January 2005
Capturing the influence of groundwater dynamics on land surface processes using an integrated, distributed watershed model: INFLUENCE OF GROUNDWATER DYNAMICS ON LAND journal February 2008
Pilot points method incorporating prior information for solving the groundwater flow inverse problem journal November 2006
Investigating the age distribution of fracture discharge using multiple environmental tracers, Bedrichov Tunnel, Czech Republic journal October 2016
Notes on Groundwater Age in Forward and Inverse Modeling journal July 2009
Correcting artifacts in transition to a wound optic fiber: Example from high-resolution temperature profiling in the Dead Sea journal June 2014
Testing mixing models of old and young groundwater in a tropical lowland rain forest with environmental tracers: TESTING MIXING MODELS WITH ENVIRONMENTAL TRACERS journal April 2010
Groundwater Age and Groundwater Age Dating journal May 2008
A comparison of particle-tracking and solute transport methods for simulation of tritium concentrations and groundwater transit times in river water journal January 2014
Calibration of models using groundwater age journal September 2010
Random-Walk Simulation of Transport in Heterogeneous Porous Media: Local Mass-Conservation Problem and Implementation Methods journal March 1996
Bias of Apparent Tracer Ages in Heterogeneous Environments: Ground Water xx, no. x: x-x journal April 2013
The sensitivity of the PDSI to the Thornthwaite and Penman-Monteith parameterizations for potential evapotranspiration journal January 2011
Mixing effects on apparent reaction rates and isotope fractionation during denitrification in a heterogeneous aquifer: MIXING EFFECTS ON APPARENT REACTION RATES journal August 2010
The effects of numerical-model complexity and observation type on estimated porosity values journal July 2015
On the assimilation of environmental tracer observations for model-based decision support journal January 2020
Expanding the role of reactive transport models in critical zone processes journal February 2017
Direct Simulation of Groundwater Age journal February 1996
A short exploration of structural noise: A SHORT EXPLORATION OF STRUCTURAL NOISE journal May 2010
Simulation of reactive transport of uranium(VI) in groundwater with variable chemical conditions: SIMULATION OF REACTIVE TRANSPORT OF URANIUM(VI) journal April 2006
Effective Groundwater Model Calibration book January 2007
Transient age distributions in subsurface hydrologic systems journal December 2016
A review of methods for modelling environmental tracers in groundwater: Advantages of tracer concentration simulation journal November 2014
The age of groundwater – Definitions, models and why we do not need this term journal November 2014
Calibration-constrained Monte Carlo analysis of highly parameterized models using subspace techniques: CALIBRATION-CONSTRAINED SSMC ANALYSIS journal January 2009
Accuracy of travel time distribution (TTD) models as affected by TTD complexity, observation errors, and model and tracer selection journal July 2014
Advancing Physically-Based Flow Simulations of Alluvial Systems Through Atmospheric Noble Gases and the Novel 37 Ar Tracer Method: INTEGRATING TRACERS WITH MODELS journal December 2017
Identifying key controls on the behavior of an acidic-U(VI) plume in the Savannah River Site using reactive transport modeling journal August 2013
The use of simulation and multiple environmental tracers to quantify groundwater flow in a shallow aquifer journal February 1994
Contribution of age data to the characterization of complex aquifers journal September 2012
Bayesian evaluation of groundwater age distribution using radioactive tracers and anthropogenic chemicals: UNCERTAINTIES IN GROUNDWATER DATING journal September 2012
Comparison of particle-tracking and lumped-parameter age-distribution models for evaluating vulnerability of production wells to contamination journal January 2012
Regularized pilot points method for reproducing the effect of small scale variability: Application to simulations of contaminant transport journal June 2008
Transport modeling applied to the interpretation of groundwater 36 Cl age: TRANSPORT MODELING journal May 2002
A manifesto for the equifinality thesis journal March 2006
A multitracer approach for characterizing interactions between shallow groundwater and the hydrothermal system in the Norris Geyser Basin area, Yellowstone National Park: GROUNDWATER FLOW AROUND NORRIS journal August 2011
On Constraining Pilot Point Calibration with Regularization in PEST journal November 2009
Prediction uncertainty and data worth assessment for groundwater transport times in an agricultural catchment journal June 2018
Transport and speciation of uranium in groundwater-surface water systems impacted by legacy milling operations journal March 2021
Calculation of ground water ages-A comparative analysis journal May 2005
The cost of uniqueness in groundwater model calibration journal April 2006
Refining the site conceptual model at a former uranium mill site in Riverton, Wyoming, USA journal July 2015
Pilot Point Methodology for Automated Calibration of an Ensemble of conditionally Simulated Transmissivity Fields: 1. Theory and Computational Experiments journal March 1995
Simulating Water‐Quality Trends in Public‐Supply Wells in Transient Flow Systems journal July 2014
Groundwater age distributions at a public drinking water supply well field derived from multiple age tracers ( 85 Kr, 3 H/ 3 He, and 39 Ar) : Groundwater Age Distributions at a Drinking Water Well Field journal November 2013
Modelling pesticide transport in a shallow groundwater catchment using tritium and helium-3 data journal November 2014
Hydrochemical tracers in the middle Rio Grande Basin, USA: 2. Calibration of a groundwater-flow model journal April 2004
On the distribution of multicomponent mixtures over generalized exposure time in subsurface flow and reactive transport: Foundations, and formulations for groundwater age, chemical heterogeneity, and biodegradation journal May 1999
Inferring transit time distributions from atmospheric tracer data: Assessment of the predictive capacities of Lumped Parameter Models on a 3D crystalline aquifer model journal June 2015
Limitations of the Use of Environmental Tracers to Infer Groundwater Age journal July 2014
Determining the turnover time of groundwater systems with the aid of environmental tracers journal June 1982
Krypton-81 in groundwater of the Culebra Dolomite near the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant, New Mexico journal May 2014
Using Environmental Tracers in Modeling Flow in a Complex Shallow Aquifer System journal November 2008
Coupling 3D groundwater modeling with CFC-based age dating to classify local groundwater circulation in an unconfined crystalline aquifer journal December 2016
PFLOTRAN: Reactive Flow & Transport Code for Use on Laptops to Leadership-Class Supercomputers book March 2012
On uncertainty quantification in hydrogeology and hydrogeophysics journal December 2017
A comparison of recharge rates in aquifers of the United States based on groundwater-age data journal April 2011
A review of radioactive isotopes and other residence time tracers in understanding groundwater recharge: Possibilities, challenges, and limitations journal December 2017
An Approach toward a Rational Classification of Climate journal January 1948
Critical review of the impact of tortuosity on diffusion journal July 2007
Assessment of the value of groundwater age time-series for characterizing complex steady-state flow systems using a Bayesian approach journal November 2014
A new model for predicting the hydraulic conductivity of unsaturated porous media journal June 1976
Environmental tracer evidence for connection between shallow and bedrock aquifers and high intrinsic susceptibility to contamination of the conterminous U.S. glacial aquifer journal April 2020
Insights into controls on hexavalent chromium in groundwater provided by environmental tracers, Sacramento Valley, California, USA journal November 2015
Evolution of groundwater age in a mountain watershed over a period of thirteen years journal August 2012
Uncertainty in hydrologic modeling: Toward an integrated data assimilation framework: HYDROLOGIC DATA ASSIMILATION journal July 2007
Beyond Classical Observations in Hydrogeology: The Advantages of Including Exchange Flux, Temperature, Tracer Concentration, Residence Time, and Soil Moisture Observations in Groundwater Model Calibration journal January 2019
Noble gases as natural tracers of water circulation in the Paris Basin: 2. Calibration of a groundwater flow model using noble gas isotope data journal October 1998
A Closed-form Equation for Predicting the Hydraulic Conductivity of Unsaturated Soils1 journal January 1980
Ground Water Model Calibration Using Pilot Points and Regularization journal March 2003
Estimating Flow Using Tracers and Hydraulics in Synthetic Heterogeneous Aquifers journal November 2009
Age Dating of Shallow Groundwater with Chlorofluorocarbons, Tritium/Helium: 3, and Flow Path Analysis, Southern New Jersey Coastal Plain journal April 1996
High Performance Simulation of Environmental Tracers in Heterogeneous Domains journal December 2013
Approximating groundwater age distributions using simple streamtube models and multiple tracers journal April 2014