Integration of Omics into a New Comprehensive Rate Law for Competitive Terminal Electron-Accepting Processes in Reactive Transport Models: Application to N, Fe, S, and Contaminant Transformations in Stream and Wetland Sediments
- Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA (United States)
- Argonne National Laboratory (ANL), Argonne, IL (United States)
- Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), Oak Ridge, TN (United States)
- USDOE Joint Genome Institute (JGI), Berkeley, CA (United States)
- Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), Richland, WA (United States). Environmental Molecular Sciences Laboratory (EMSL)
Surface waters represent important sources of alternate energy and drinking water in the United States, and characterizing the biogeochemical processes that affect surface water quality is relevant to the DOE-BER mission. Sediment biogeochemical processes regulate the release of carbon (C), nutrients, and contaminants to surface waters and thus influence water quality. Sediment biogeochemical processes are dynamic and affected by the deposition and remobilization of solid material and changes in environmental conditions driven by water discharge variations. Wetlands are important natural filters of surface waters which may either trap, metabolize, or mobilize nutrients and contaminants. Despite their importance, biogeochemical processes regulating nutrient and contaminant release and C transformation in stream and wetland sediments cannot be predicted accurately by current mathematical models. These reactive transport models largely rely on detectable changes in geochemical conditions to activate metabolic processes, do not accurately account for the competition between microbial processes, and poorly constrain effects of hydrological perturbations on biogeochemical processes. In this BER-SBR exploratory project, metagenomic and geochemical signatures were combined to identify microbially-mediated redox processes in anaerobic stream and wetland sediments from the Savannah River Site (SRS, ANL SFA) and East Fork Poplar Creek (EFPC, ORNL SFA) that play important roles in C, uranium (U), and mercury (Hg) transformations. In addition, sediment incubations were conducted to examine the competition between anaerobic respiration processes Finally, new rate laws were developed for reactive transport models that rely on complementary metagenomic and geochemical signatures to identify the underlying anaerobic microbial processes in stream and wetland sediments, describe the competition between the dominant metabolic processes involved in nutrient release and U and Hg mobilization, and more accurately quantify carbon transformation and the response of microbial processes to changes in redox conditions associated with hydrological forcing. These rate laws were optimized in batch reactors with SRS wetland sediments, where iron and sulfate reduction dominate. Anaerobic carbon remineralization processes followed the expected thermodynamic sequence of microbial respiration with depth in both sediments, except that geochemical signals indicated that sulfate reduction was inactive in EFPC sediments and moderate in SRS wetland sediments. Estimates indicated that microbial iron reduction contributed to at least half of the production of reduced iron in these sediments. Incubations demonstrated that nitrate reduction, denitrification, and dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium were active in the natural EFPC sediment and activated upon nitrate amendment in these nitrate-rich sediments. In turn, these processes were outcompeted by the addition of either iron oxides or sulfate as alternative terminal electron acceptors. Although geochemical products of sulfate reduction were not detected in the incubations, the abundance of sulfate reduction genes increased with depth in the sediment and was equally more pronounced in treatments amended with either iron oxides or sulfate. Simultaneously, anaerobic sulfide oxidizing bacteria coupling sulfide oxidation to DNRA (and not conventional denitrification) were apparently enriched over time, regardless of the treatments. These findings indicate that sulfate reduction is important in freshwater stream sediments and probably catalyzed by a cryptic sulfur cycle involving nitrogen species, in which the sulfur products from sulfate reduction are immediately removed by side reactions and not detectable by geochemical measurements alone. Similar experiments in SRS sediments, however, demonstrated little interaction between nitrogen and sulfur cycling microorganisms. Sulfate reduction was impacted by the addition of more thermodynamically favorable electron acceptors, suggesting either that iron-reducing microorganisms outcompeted sulfate-reducing microorganisms for organic substrate, depleting the stock of electron donor available for sulfate reduction, or that the cryptic sulfur cycle was shunted by the precipitation of FeS generated as a result of the abiotic reduction of iron oxides by dissolved sulfide. A diagnostic modeling exercise was conducted to further investigate the competition between terminal electron accepting processes. As conventional kinetic models typically do not account for cryptic cycles and used inaccurate formulations to describe competition between microbial communities, new metabolic rate laws were developed that explicitly express the electron acceptor-specific enzyme of each energetically favorable metabolic process based on gene abundance detected in the incubations. The model was tested with the sediment slurry incubation data to determine whether substrate competition could explain the decrease in sulfate reduction observed in the presence of iron oxide competitor. The model was able to reproduce geochemical concentrations really well in each treatment once the model was calibrated with the unamended control, suggesting that microbial competition was indeed driven by thermodynamic considerations. Overall, carbon remineralization processes and rates will be reproduced much more realistically with the new metabolic rate laws.
- Research Organization:
- Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA (United States)
- Sponsoring Organization:
- USDOE Office of Science (SC), Biological and Environmental Research (BER). Earth & Environmental Systems Science (EESS)
- DOE Contract Number:
- SC0019416
- OSTI ID:
- 1839282
- Report Number(s):
- DOE-GT-MT002
- Resource Relation:
- Related Information: M. Taillefert, E. M. Eitel, T.J. DiChristina, H. D. Shin, F. Stewart, A. D. Bertagnolli, N. V. Patin, K. Kemner, S. Brooks, D. I. Kaplan, C. Pennacchio, S. J. Callister. 2020. Development of Gene-Centric Model for Competitive Terminal Electron-Accepting Processes in Freshwater Sediments. 260th ACS National Meeting, virtual.A. Moran, M. Taillefert, E. M. Eitel. 2019. Competitive Dynamics of Redox Processes in Wetland Sediments. 258th ACS National Meeting, San Diego, CA.E. M. Eitel, A. Moran, H. D. Shin, N. V. Patin, A. Bertagnolli, K. Kemner, S. Brooks. D. Kaplan, C. Pennacchio, F. Stewart, T. J. DiChristina, M. Taillefert. 2019. Combining Geochemical Measurements and Omics to Investigate Competitive Anaerobic Redox Dynamics in Sediments. Goldschmidt Conference, Barcelona (Spain).M. Taillefert, E. M. Eitel, T. J. DiChristina, H. D. Shin, F. Stewart, A. D. Bertagnolli, N. V. Patin, K. Kemner, S. Brooks, D. I. Kaplan, C. Pennacchio, S. J. Callister. 2019. Integration of omics into a new comprehensive rate law for competitive terminal electron-accepting processes in freshwater sediments. 258th ACS National Meeting, San Diego, CA.K. Belli, P. Van Cappellen, M. Taillefert. 2019. Effects of ferrihydrite impurities on the microbially-mediated redox cycling of uranium and iron. 257th ACS National Meeting, Orlando, FL.
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
Similar Records
Biogeochemistry simulations for the Salt Marsh Accretion Response to Temperature eXperiment (SMARTX)
Effect of fluctuating redox conditions on trace metal release from wetland soils from South Carolina and stream sediments from Tennessee