Development of a LOCA Experimental Benchmark for BISON - Milestone L2:FMC.P15.08
- Idaho National Lab. (INL), Idaho Falls, ID (United States)
- Structural Integrity Assoc., San Jose, CA (United States)
Since 2013 CASL has been planning and working towards a PWR LOCA Challenge Problem. Since BISON is the CASL fuel rod simulation platform, it plays a central role in that activity. The goal of the FY-17 CASL milestone reported here was to develop an Experimental Benchmark for LOCA analysis using BISON. Activities encompassed both code development and validation. This report provides a current snapshot of BISON’s capability for LOCA behavior including: 1) a summary of code extensions to facilitate accident analysis, 2) a series of separate effects tests, and 3) initial code validation to complex integral rod LOCA behavior. Conclusions from each of these main activities are summarized below. The key material and behavior models required to address transient high-temperature phenomena occurring during LOCAs in a standard PWR have now been implemented in BISON. These apply specifically to UO2 fuel, Zircaloy cladding and water coolant. During FY-17 important new capability to address axial UO2 fuel relocation (for 1.5D geometry) and account for oxidation energy deposition in cladding, were included. Planned future development efforts include extending the axial fuel relocation model from 1.5D to 2D/3D and improving BISON’s fission gas release model to include transient gas release associated with the high burnup structure (HBS) in high burnup fuel. Additionally, investigation of potential anisotropic creep behavior in Zircaloy cladding is planned, assuming sufficient experimental data are available to support this effort. A substantial number of separate effects validation cases (42 tests from 3 experimental series) have been completed to compare BISON predictions to measured ballooning and burst behavior for Zircaloy cladding. Such experiments include a wide variety of pressures, temperatures and loading rates. In general, BISON predictions of burst temperature, pressure and burst time are very reasonable. For one experimental series, however, involving both very high temperatures and strain rates, BISON systematically over-predicts the cladding hoop strain. Investigation of this discrepancy is an important and planned activity. With another experiment an effort was made to investigate 3D cladding response due to an azimuthal temperature variation. Results indicated 3D effects are potentially important in fuel rod analysis during LOCAs and will be further investigated in the future. BISON validation to a series of integral fuel rod experiments has also been completed. These experiments involve all fuel and cladding phenomena relevant to LOCA conditions, and can include complexities associated with irradiated fuel relative to fresh fuel. Such experiments also generally include complex thermal-hydraulic boundary conditions. Four experiments (6 rods) have been considered to date including simulated fuel (ZrO2) and both fresh and high-burnup UO2. Test rods ranged from rodlets to full length commercial PWR fuel rods. As with the separate effects experiments, BISON predictions of burst temperature, pressure and burst time are generally very reasonable. Comparisons to cladding peak strain and rod outer diameter axial profiles are less satisfactory, and identify material models and possibly modeling approximations (e.g., 2D-RZ vs 3D geometries) requiring additional investigation. Validation of BISON for integral rod LOCA behavior is by no means complete, with additional cases planned.
- Research Organization:
- Idaho National Lab. (INL), Idaho Falls, ID (United States)
- Sponsoring Organization:
- USDOE Office of Nuclear Energy (NE)
- DOE Contract Number:
- AC07-05ID14517
- OSTI ID:
- 1472114
- Report Number(s):
- INL/EXT-17-43309-Rev000
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
Similar Records
Determination of Experimental Fuel Rod Parameters using 3D Modelling of PCMI with MPS Defect
Analysis of Experimental Fuel Rod Parameters using 3D Modelling of PCMI with MPS Defect