DOE PAGES title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Modeling the Effects of Artificial Drainage on Agriculture-Dominated Watersheds Using a Fully Distributed Integrated Hydrology Model

Journal Article · · Water Resources Research

In agriculture-dominated watersheds where natural drainage is poor, agricultural ditches (narrow engineered channels) and tile drains (perforated pipes) are widely employed to enhance surface and subsurface drainage, respectively. Despite their relatively small scale, these features exert substantial control over the hydro-biogeochemical function of watersheds and their effects need to be represented in the models. We introduce a novel strategy to incorporate the effects of artificial agricultural drainage into a fully distributed basin-scale integrated surface-subsurface hydrology models. In our approach, narrow agriculture ditches for surface drainage are resolved efficiently using ditch-aligned computational meshes that are hydrologically conditioned to ensure connectivity in the stream/ditch network. For tile drainage in the subsurface, we use the physically based Hooghoudt's drainage equation as a subgrid model and route the water drained through tiles to the nearest ditch. Without site-specific calibration, this model reproduced observed streamflow in the Portage River Watershed (>1,000 km2) as recorded by a USGS gauge with good accuracy (normalized KGE = 0.81) and outperformed a calibrated SWAT model (normalized KGE = 0.68). Numerical experiments confirm that artificial drainage reduces surface inundations and effectively controls the water table. At the watershed scale, artificial drainage increases baseflow but has little effect on watershed discharges above the 90th percentile. The strong physical underpinnings and reduced need for calibration allow us to study the impacts of artificial drainage on distributed hydrological response in terms of fluxes and states and provide a platform for investigating watershed-scale nutrient transport.

Research Organization:
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), Richland, WA (United States)
Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE Office of Science (SC), Biological and Environmental Research (BER)
Grant/Contract Number:
AC05-76RL01830; AC05-00OR22725
OSTI ID:
2371865
Alternate ID(s):
OSTI ID: 2373006
Report Number(s):
PNNL-SA-198315
Journal Information:
Water Resources Research, Journal Name: Water Resources Research Journal Issue: 6 Vol. 60; ISSN 0043-1397
Publisher:
American Geophysical Union (AGU)Copyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English

References (88)

Surface-subsurface model intercomparison: A first set of benchmark results to diagnose integrated hydrology and feedbacks journal February 2014
Changing Rainfall Patterns Over the Western Lake Erie Basin (1975–2017): Effects on Tributary Discharge and Phosphorus Load journal February 2020
Daymet: Daily Surface Weather Data on a 1-km Grid for North America, Version 4 R1 collection January 2022
Evaluating Hydrologic Response in Tile‐Drained Landscapes: Implications for Phosphorus Transport journal August 2019
Integrated surface/subsurface permafrost thermal hydrology: Model formulation and proof-of-concept simulations: INTEGRATED PERMAFROST THERMAL HYDROLOGY journal August 2016
Building confidence in climate model projections: an analysis of inferences from fit: Building confidence in climate model projections
  • Baumberger, Christoph; Knutti, Reto; Hirsch Hadorn, Gertrude
  • Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, Vol. 8, Issue 3 https://doi.org/10.1002/wcc.454
journal January 2017
Best Management Practices for Diffuse Nutrient Pollution: Wicked Problems Across Urban and Agricultural Watersheds journal July 2020
Incorporating landscape depressions and tile drainages of a northern German lowland catchment into a semi‐distributed model journal February 2010
Development and Applications of the HYDRUS and STANMOD Software Packages and Related Codes journal January 2008
Importance of including small‐scale tile drain discharge in the calibration of a coupled groundwater‐surface water catchment model journal January 2013
Catchment hydrologic response with a fully distributed triangulated irregular network model: CATCHMENT HYDROLOGIC RESPONSE WITH A TIN journal November 2004
Real-world hydrologic assessment of a fully-distributed hydrological model in a parallel computing environment journal October 2011
Impact of model development, calibration and validation decisions on hydrological simulations in West Lake Erie Basin: Impact of Model Development Decisions on Streamflow Simulations journal July 2015
A stream-aligned mixed polyhedral meshing strategy for integrated surface-subsurface hydrological models journal June 2024
Assessing uncertainty in best management practice effectiveness under future climate scenarios journal April 2013
Satellite Psychrometric Formulation of the Operational Simplified Surface Energy Balance (SSEBop) Model for Quantifying and Mapping Evapotranspiration journal January 2018
Quantifying the contribution of tile drainage to basin-scale water yield using analytical and numerical models journal March 2019
Simulating coupled surface and subsurface water flow in a tile-drained agricultural catchment journal February 2015
Tile drainage causes flashy streamflow response in Ohio watersheds journal August 2021
Combining hyper-resolution land surface modeling with SMAP brightness temperatures to obtain 30-m soil moisture estimates journal June 2020
Toward more mechanistic representations of biogeochemical processes in river networks: Implementation and demonstration of a multiscale model journal November 2021
Multiscale Framework for Modeling Multicomponent Reactive Transport in Stream Corridors journal October 2018
GEOtop 2.0: simulating the combined energy and water balance at and below the land surface accounting for soil freezing, snow cover and terrain effects journal January 2014
DRAINMOD: Model Use, Calibration, and Validation journal January 2012
Hydrologic Evaluation of the soil and Water Assessment tool for a Large Tile-Drained Watershed in iowa journal January 2006
Integrated modeling of groundwater-surface water interactions in a tile-drained agricultural field: The importance of directly measured flow route contributions: GROUNDWATER-SURFACE WATER INTERACTIONS journal November 2010
Managing the food, water, and energy nexus for achieving the Sustainable Development Goals in South Asia journal April 2016
The integrated hydrologic model intercomparison project, IH-MIP2: A second set of benchmark results to diagnose integrated hydrology and feedbacks: INTEGRATED HYDROLOGIC MODEL INTERCOMPARISON, IH-MIP2 journal January 2017
Dynamically dimensioned search algorithm for computationally efficient watershed model calibration: DYNAMICALLY DIMENSIONED SEARCH ALGORITHM journal January 2007
Watershed Workflow: A toolset for parameterizing data-intensive, integrated hydrologic models journal November 2022
A sensitivity analysis of Hortonian flow journal September 2009
What Are the Key Catchment Characteristics Affecting Spatial Differences in Riverine Water Quality? journal October 2018
Regional interpretation of water-quality monitoring data journal December 1997
The Impact of Drainage on Streamflow book October 2015
A Second-Order Accurate, Finite Volume-Based, Integrated Hydrologic Modeling (FIHM) Framework for Simulation of Surface and Subsurface Flow journal November 2009
Comparing alternative conceptual models for tile drains and soil heterogeneity for the simulation of tile drainage in agricultural catchments journal September 2022
A generalized Richards equation for surface/subsurface flow modelling journal March 2009
Development and Testing of Watershed-Scale Models for Poorly Drained Soils journal January 2005
Fill and Spill Hillslope Runoff Representation With a Richards Equation‐Based Model journal November 2019
On the testing of fully integrated surface-subsurface hydrological models: SCIENTIFIC BRIEFING journal November 2012
Homogenization of spatial patterns of hydrologic response in artificially drained agricultural catchments journal August 2013
Hydrologic impacts of subsurface drainage at the field scale: Climate, landscape and anthropogenic controls journal February 2016
A review of the efficacy of contemporary agricultural stewardship measures for ameliorating water pollution problems of key concern to the UK water industry journal February 2009
Physically based modeling in catchment hydrology at 50: Survey and outlook: SURVEY OF PHYSICALLY BASED MODELING IN CATCHMENT HYDROLOGY journal September 2015
Managing complexity in simulations of land surface and near-surface processes journal April 2016
Runoff conditions in the upper Danube basin under an ensemble of climate change scenarios journal March 2012
Hydrologic impacts of subsurface drainage from the field to watershed scale journal June 2017
Stationarity Is Dead: Whither Water Management? journal February 2008
Model Evaluation Guidelines for Systematic Quantification of Accuracy in Watershed Simulations journal January 2007
Assessment of Agricultural Best Management Practices Using Models: Current Issues and Future Perspectives journal March 2015
Effects of Agricultural Drainage on Aquatic Ecosystems: A Review journal November 2009
Scalable deep learning for watershed model calibration journal November 2022
Modeling the Hydrologic Influence of Subsurface Tile Drainage Using the National Water Model journal April 2022
Modeling water balance and effects of different subsurface drainage methods on water outflow components in a clayey agricultural field in boreal conditions journal April 2013
Integrated surface–groundwater flow modeling: A free-surface overland flow boundary condition in a parallel groundwater flow model journal July 2006
Decomposition of the mean squared error and NSE performance criteria: Implications for improving hydrological modelling journal October 2009
Numerical investigation of the spatial scale and time dependency of tile drainage contribution to stream flow journal July 2016
Mapping subsurface tile drainage systems with thermal images journal June 2019
Effective and efficient agricultural drainage pipe mapping with UAS thermal infrared imagery: A case study journal January 2018
Hydrologic-Response simulations for the R-5 catchment with a comprehensive physics-based model journal April 2001
Simulation of water balance in a clayey, subsurface drained agricultural field with three-dimensional FLUSH model journal January 2013
Field-scale modeling of subsurface tile-drained soils using an equivalent-medium approach journal July 2007
Scenario-testing of agricultural best management practices in Lake Erie watersheds journal September 2013
Impact of subsurface drainage on streamflows in the Red River of the North basin journal April 2014
Agricultural Phosphorus and Eutrophication: A Symposium Overview journal March 1998
A process-based, distributed hydrologic model based on a large-scale method for surface–subsurface coupling journal December 2010
GEOtop: A Distributed Hydrological Model with Coupled Water and Energy Budgets journal June 2006
A semidiscrete finite volume formulation for multiprocess watershed simulation: MULTIPROCESS WATERSHED SIMULATION journal August 2007
Effect of subsurface drainage on streamflow in an agricultural headwater watershed journal November 2014
Evaluating the contribution of subsurface drainage to watershed water yield using SWAT+ with groundwater modeling journal January 2022
Global Barriers To Improving Water Quality: A Critical Review report January 2017
A Multicomponent Reactive Transport Model for Integrated Surface‐Subsurface Hydrology Problems journal August 2022
Modeling of subsurface agricultural drainage using two hydrological models with different conceptual approaches as well as dimensions and spatial scales journal October 2016
Landscape changes and their hydrologic effects: Interactions and feedbacks across scales journal January 2021
Phosphorus Transport in Agricultural Subsurface Drainage: A Review journal January 2015
A distributed hydrology-vegetation model for complex terrain journal June 1994
An evaluation of the impact of model structure on hydrological modelling uncertainty for streamflow simulation journal October 2004
Development and assessment of the SMAP enhanced passive soil moisture product journal January 2018
Hydrologic and water quality impacts of agricultural drainage∗ journal January 1994
Proof of concept of regional scale hydrologic simulations at hydrologic resolution utilizing massively parallel computer resources: RAPID COMMUNICATION journal April 2010
Present and future Köppen-Geiger climate classification maps at 1-km resolution journal October 2018
Hydro-conditioning: Advanced approaches for cost-effective water quality management in agricultural watersheds journal July 2022
Evaluating controls on coupled hydrologic and vegetation dynamics in a humid continental climate watershed using a subsurface-land surface processes model: EVALUATING CONTROLS ON HYDROLOGIC AND VEGETATION DYNAMICS journal May 2013
Simulating seasonal variations of tile drainage discharge in an agricultural catchment journal May 2017
Analyzing subsurface drain network performance in an agricultural monitoring site with a three-dimensional hydrological model journal October 2015
New framework for natural-artificial transport paths and hydrological connectivity analysis in an agriculture-intensive catchment journal May 2021
Evaluation of distributed process-based hydrologic model performance using only a priori information to define model inputs journal March 2023
Phosphorus Loss in Agricultural Drainage: Historical Perspective and Current Research journal January 1998