DOE PAGES title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Glass formulation and composition optimization with property models: A review

Journal Article · · Journal of the American Ceramic Society
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jace.19333 · OSTI ID:1993108

Abstract Glass is a versatile material with a remarkable history and many practical applications. It plays a critical role in our everyday lives, the advancement of science, and the development of many technologies. The Edisonian type trial‐and‐error method was commonly used for conventional design of glass compositions, which was time‐consuming and costly. With the urgent need to develop new glass compositions for technology applications rapidly, it has become necessary to develop precise property models with predictive powers using large databases and efficient formulation approaches. This paper reviews the design of glass compositions using these analytical and numerical models of composition–structure–property relations of glasses, some based on large databases and machine learning approaches. Aspects of data collection, model fitting, feature extraction, model evaluation, and uncertainty quantification will be covered. Furthermore, advances in the glass optimization framework and available tools are summarized with examples. The outlook and perspective for further glass property model development and formulation approaches are discussed.

Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE
Grant/Contract Number:
AR0001613
OSTI ID:
1993108
Journal Information:
Journal of the American Ceramic Society, Journal Name: Journal of the American Ceramic Society Journal Issue: 3 Vol. 107; ISSN 0002-7820
Publisher:
Wiley-BlackwellCopyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English

References (171)

Atomistic Simulations of Glasses: Fundamentals and Applications book April 2022
Die Abhängigkeit der Viscosität von der Temperatur bie unterkühlten Flüssigkeiten journal October 1926
Pyomo — Optimization Modeling in Python book January 2021
Computational Modeling of Silicate Glasses: A Quantitative Structure-Property Relationship Perspective book January 2015
CasADi: A Symbolic Package for Automatic Differentiation and Optimal Control book January 2012
Effects of boron oxide substitution on the structure and bioactivity of SrO-containing bioactive glasses journal February 2017
Al and Si coordination in SiO2-Al2O3 glasses and liquids: A study by NMR and IR spectroscopy and MD simulations journal April 1992
Nuclear magnetic resonance studies of the glasses in the system Na2OB2O3SiO2 journal March 1978
Topology of covalent non-crystalline solids I: Short-range order in chalcogenide alloys journal October 1979
Statistical mechanical model of boron coordination journal October 1980
11B NMR studies and structural modeling of Na2OB2O3SiO2 glasses of high soda content journal October 1983
Effect of disorder on diffusion and viscosity in condensed systems journal September 1988
Liquidus temperature–composition model for multi-component glasses in the Fe, Cr, Ni, and Mn spinel primary phase field journal November 2001
A neutron diffraction study of yttrium- and lanthanum-aluminate glasses journal February 2002
X-ray absorption studies of vanadium valence and local environment in borosilicate waste glasses using vanadium sulfide, silicate, and oxide standards journal March 2002
Structure and magnetic properties of vanadium–sodium silicate glasses journal April 2003
Vanadium incorporation in silica glasses journal July 1987
Fracture toughness anomalies: Viewpoint of topological constraint theory journal December 2016
Predicting glass transition temperatures using neural networks journal October 2018
Explainable Machine Learning Algorithms For Predicting Glass Transition Temperatures journal April 2020
Machine learning unveils composition-property relationships in chalcogenide glasses journal November 2022
Machine learning as a tool to design glasses with controlled dissolution for healthcare applications journal April 2020
Effect of solution condition on hydroxyapatite formation in evaluating bioactivity of B2O3 containing 45S5 bioactive glasses journal December 2019
GlassNet: A multitask deep neural network for predicting many glass properties journal November 2023
Linear and nonlinear QSPR models to predict refractive indices of polymers from cyclic dimer structures journal July 2008
QSPR studies on refractive indices of structurally heterogeneous polymers journal January 2015
Correlation between the glass transition temperatures and multipole moments for polymers journal January 2007
QSPR analysis for intrinsic viscosity of polymer solutions by means of GA-MLR and RBFNN journal July 2007
Deciphering the atomic genome of glasses by topological constraint theory and molecular dynamics: A review journal March 2019
Decoding the glass genome journal April 2018
Calculation of thermal expansion coefficient of glasses based on topological constraint theory journal October 2016
Vanadium K edge XANES of synthetic and natural basaltic glasses and application to microscale oxygen barometry journal May 2005
Using machine learning for improving knowledge on antibacterial effect of bioactive glass journal September 2013
A review of uncertainty quantification in deep learning: Techniques, applications and challenges journal December 2021
Optical properties of 3d transition metal ion-doped sodium borosilicate glass journal March 2015
Modelling the sulfate capacity of simulated radioactive waste borosilicate glasses journal February 2017
Statistical approach to modeling relationships of composition – structure – property I: Alkaline earth phosphate glasses journal February 2018
Density of multicomponent silica-based potential bioglasses: Quantitative structure-property relationships (QSPR) analysis journal January 2007
The medium range structure of sodium silicate glasses: a molecular dynamics simulation journal December 2004
Network connectivity in aluminoborosilicate glasses: A high-resolution 11B, 27Al and 17O NMR study journal November 2005
Chromium phase behavior in a multi-component borosilicate glass melt journal July 2006
Solubility of glasses in the system P2O5–CaO–MgO–Na2O–TiO2: Experimental and modeling using artificial neural networks journal March 2007
Arrhenius model for high-temperature glass-viscosity with a constant pre-exponential factor journal April 2008
Glass viscosity as a function of temperature and composition: A model based on Adam–Gibbs equation journal July 2008
Viscosity of many-component glasses journal June 2009
Composition and structure dependence of the properties of lithium borophosphate glasses showing boron anomaly journal December 2009
Effect of thermal history and chemical composition on hardness of silicate glasses journal April 2010
The split network analysis for exploring composition–structure correlations in multi-component glasses: I. Rationalizing bioactivity-composition trends of bioglasses journal March 2011
Rare earth ion clustering behavior in europium doped silicate glasses: Simulation size and glass structure effect journal December 2012
Effect of glass composition on activation energy of viscosity in glass-melting-temperature range journal August 2012
The effect of high-level waste glass composition on spinel liquidus temperature journal January 2014
Short- and medium-range structures of cerium aluminophosphate glasses: A molecular dynamics study journal November 2014
High-temperature viscosity of many-component glass melts journal April 2016
Development of effective empirical potentials for molecular dynamics simulations of the structures and properties of boroaluminosilicate glasses journal December 2016
Boron and pentavalent vanadium local environments in binary vanadium borate glasses journal December 2016
On the 90th birthday of Oleg V. Mazurin, scholar and teacher journal September 2017
Liquidus temperature in the spinel primary phase field: A comparison between optical and crystal fraction methods journal March 2018
Predicting the dissolution kinetics of silicate glasses using machine learning journal May 2018
A new transferable interatomic potential for molecular dynamics simulations of borosilicate glasses journal October 2018
Iron phosphate glass waste forms for vitrifying Hanford AZ102 Low Activity Waste (LAW), part II: Property-composition model journal September 2018
Prediction of the Young's modulus of silicate glasses by topological constraint theory journal June 2019
Balance between accuracy and simplicity in empirical forcefields for glass modeling: Insights from machine learning journal July 2019
Quantitative structure-property relationship (QSPR) analysis of calcium aluminosilicate glasses based on molecular dynamics simulations journal February 2020
Predicting radioactive waste glass dissolution with machine learning journal April 2020
Cooling rate effects on the structure of 45S5 bioglass: Insights from experiments and simulations journal April 2020
Predicting boron coordination in multicomponent borate and borosilicate glasses using analytical models and machine learning journal February 2021
Structures of Vanadium-Containing Silicate and Borosilicate Glasses: Vanadium Potential Development and MD Simulations journal January 2022
Glass length: Workability and meltability of glass as a function of glass melt fragility journal December 2022
X-ray absorption and Raman spectroscopy studies of molybdenum environments in borosilicate waste glasses journal May 2017
Non-linear effects of alumina concentration on Product Consistency Test response of waste glasses journal December 2018
Structural features of ISG borosilicate nuclear waste glasses revealed from high-energy X-ray diffraction and molecular dynamics simulations journal March 2019
A review on Machine learning aspect in physics and mechanics of glasses journal October 2022
Compositional Models of Glass/Melt Properties and their Use for Glass Formulation journal January 2014
Development of an Experimental Design to Investigate the Effects of R7T7 Glass Composition on the Residual Rate of Alteration journal January 2014
Machine learning for glass science and engineering: A review journal December 2019
Effects of boron oxide on the structure, properties and bioactivities of bioactive glasses: A review journal December 2022
Impacts of constraints and uncertainties on projected amount of Hanford low-activity waste glasses journal December 2021
Prediction of refractive indices of linear polymers by a four-descriptor QSPR model journal December 2004
Prediction of intrinsic viscosity in polymer–solvent combinations using a QSPR model journal April 2006
Prediction of high weight polymers glass transition temperature using RBF neural networks journal March 2005
Accelerating the Design of Functional Glasses through Modeling journal June 2016
Vanadium Oxidation States and Structural Role in Aluminoborosilicate Glasses: An Integrated Experimental and Molecular Dynamics Simulation Study journal November 2021
Medium-Range Structural Organization of Phosphorus-Bearing Borosilicate Glasses Revealed by Advanced Solid-State NMR Experiments and MD Simulations: Consequences of B/Si Substitutions journal October 2017
Mixed Network Former Effect on Structure, Physical Properties, and Bioactivity of 45S5 Bioactive Glasses: An Integrated Experimental and Molecular Dynamics Simulation Study journal February 2018
Molecular Dynamics Investigation of Halide-Containing Phospho-Silicate Bioactive Glasses journal March 2018
Quantitative Structure–Property Relationship (QSPR) Analysis of ZrO 2 -Containing Soda-Lime Borosilicate Glasses journal January 2019
Statistical Mechanical Modeling of Borate Glass Structure and Topology: Prediction of Superstructural Units and Glass Transition Temperature journal January 2019
Structural Role of Sodium in Borosilicate, Phosphosilicate, and Borophosphosilicate Glasses Unveiled by Solid-State NMR and MD Simulations journal September 2019
Direct Experimental Evidence for Abundant BO 4 –BO 4 Motifs in Borosilicate Glasses From Double-Quantum 11 B NMR Spectroscopy journal October 2018
Correlation and Prediction of the Refractive Indices of Polymers by QSPR journal November 1998
Effect of Strontium Substitution on the Structure of 45S5 Bioglasses journal June 2011
87 Sr Solid-State NMR as a Structurally Sensitive Tool for the Investigation of Materials: Antiosteoporotic Pharmaceuticals and Bioactive Glasses journal July 2012
Topological Principles of Borosilicate Glass Chemistry journal November 2011
Molecular Dynamics Simulations and Structural Descriptors of Radioisotope Glass Vectors for In Situ Radiotherapy journal October 2012
Quantitative Structure−Property Relationships of Potentially Bioactive Fluoro Phospho-silicate Glasses journal July 2009
Predicting densities and elastic moduli of SiO2-based glasses by machine learning journal March 2020
Structure of International Simple Glass and properties of passivating layer formed in circumneutral pH conditions journal February 2018
Structural role of ZrO2 and its impact on properties of boroaluminosilicate nuclear waste glasses journal June 2018
Impacts of glass composition, pH, and temperature on glass forward dissolution rate journal August 2018
Can a simple topological-constraints-based model predict the initial dissolution rate of borosilicate and aluminosilicate glasses? journal March 2020
Forty years of durability assessment of nuclear waste glass by standard methods journal December 2021
Structure--property relationship and chemical durability of magnesium-containing borosilicate glasses with insight from topological constraints journal July 2022
Explainable machine-learning predictions for the prevention of hypoxaemia during surgery journal October 2018
SciPy 1.0: fundamental algorithms for scientific computing in Python journal February 2020
Predicting the Young’s Modulus of Silicate Glasses using High-Throughput Molecular Dynamics Simulations and Machine Learning journal June 2019
Chemical synthesis and materials discovery journal June 2022
A review of the structures of oxide glasses by Raman spectroscopy journal January 2015
B 2 O 3 /SiO 2 substitution effect on structure and properties of Na 2 O–CaO–SrO–P 2 O 5 –SiO 2 bioactive glasses from molecular dynamics simulations journal January 2018
NMR studies of oxide-based glasses journal January 2012
Structure and diffusion of ZnO–SrO–CaO–Na2O–SiO2 bioactive glasses: a combined high energy X-ray diffraction and molecular dynamics simulations study journal January 2013
Structure, dynamics, and electronic properties of lithium disilicate melt and glass journal September 2006
Structure and properties of sodium aluminosilicate glasses from molecular dynamics simulations journal July 2013
Cooling rate and size effects on the medium-range structure of multicomponent oxide glasses simulated by molecular dynamics journal September 2013
Structural and topological aspects of borophosphate glasses and their relation to physical properties journal May 2015
Effects of system size and cooling rate on the structure and properties of sodium borosilicate glasses from molecular dynamics simulations journal January 2018
Viscosity of glass-forming liquids journal November 2009
Mixture Experiment Approaches: Examples, Discussion, and Recommendations journal July 1994
Uniform Designs for Highly Constrained Mixture Experiments journal January 2009
Towards a quantitative rationalization of multicomponent glass properties by means of molecular dynamics simulations journal October 2006
Construction of a 21-Component Layered Mixture Experiment Design Using a New Mixture Coordinate-Exchange Algorithm journal October 2005
Developing a space-filling mixture experiment design when the components are subject to linear and nonlinear constraints journal December 2018
Model-driven design of bioactive glasses: from molecular dynamics through machine learning journal December 2019
Structure and properties of amorphous V 2 O 5 journal April 1991
Parsimonious viscosity–composition relationships for high-temperature multicomponent glass melts journal January 2022
Augmenting a Waste Glass Mixture Experiment Study with Additional Glass Components and Experimental Runs journal September 2002
Neutron and x-ray diffraction studies of liquids and glasses journal November 2005
A molecular dynamics simulation interpretation of neutron and x-ray diffraction measurements on single phase Y 2 O 3 –Al 2 O 3 glasses journal April 2009
Permutation importance: a corrected feature importance measure journal April 2010
Cation clustering in lithium silicate glasses: Quantitative description by solid-state NMR and molecular dynamics simulations journal August 2005
Prediction of Glass Hardness Using Temperature-Dependent Constraint Theory journal September 2010
Boron anomaly in the thermal conductivity of lithium borate glasses journal July 2019
Two Centuries of Glass Research: Historical Trends, Current Status, and Grand Challenges for the Future journal July 2014
Submixture model to predict nepheline precipitation in waste glasses journal May 2016
“Gene” modeling approach to new glass design journal November 2019
Nepheline crystallization and the residual glass composition: Understanding waste glass durability journal April 2020
A Corning perspective on the future of technical glass in our evolving world journal March 2022
Heat capacity of complex aluminoborosilicate glasses journal March 2022
Hanford low‐activity waste glass composition‐temperature‐melt viscosity relationships journal April 2022
Analysis of Recent Measurements of the Viscosity of Glasses journal June 1925
Mixture Experiment Techniques for Reducing the Number of Components Applied for Modeling Waste Glass Sodium Release journal January 2005
Global Model for Calculating Room-Temperature Glass Density from the Composition journal August 2007
XANES Determination of Chromium Oxidation States in Glasses: Comparison With Optical Absorption Spectroscopy journal November 2007
Property-Composition-Temperature Modeling of Waste Glass Melt Data Subject to a Randomization Restriction journal October 2008
Effects of the Iron Content and Redox State on the Structure of Sodium Borosilicate Glasses: A Raman, Mössbauer and Boron K-Edge XANES Spectroscopy Study journal January 2012
DWPF Startup Frit Viscosity Measurement Round Robin Results journal May 2012
Nepheline Crystallization in Nuclear Waste Glasses: Progress Toward Acceptance of High-Alumina Formulations journal August 2011
Vanadium in Borosilicate Glass journal October 2014
Development of boron oxide potentials for computer simulations of multicomponent oxide glasses journal October 2018
Data‐driven glass/ceramic science research: Insights from the glass and ceramic and data science/informatics communities journal May 2019
A data‐driven approach for predicting nepheline crystallization in high‐level waste glasses journal May 2020
Effects of Al:Si and (Al + Na):Si ratios on the properties of the international simple glass, part II: Structure journal September 2020
Predicting the dissolution rate of borosilicate glasses using QSPR analysis based on molecular dynamics simulations journal May 2021
Predicting nepheline precipitation in waste glasses using ternary submixture model and machine learning journal July 2021
Effect of iron redox ratio on the structures of boroaluminosilicate glasses journal August 2022
Predicting initial dissolution rates using structural features from molecular dynamics simulations journal October 2022
Viscosity and Glass Transition in Amorphous Oxides journal January 2008
Structural behaviour of vanadium ions in alkali borosilicate glass for nuclear waste storage journal August 2018
Nepheline Precipitation in High-Level Waste Glasses : Compositional Effects and Impact on the Waste Form Acceptability journal January 1996
Liquidus Temperature of Spinel Precipitating High-Level Waste Glasses journal January 1996
Structure of Glasses and Melts journal January 2006
Expanded High-Level Waste Glass Property Data Development: Phase I report January 2011
Glass Property Models and Constraints for Estimating the Glass to be Produced at Hanford by Implementing Current Advanced Glass Formulation Efforts report July 2013
Database and Interim Glass Property Models for Hanford HLW and LAW Glasses report September 2002
2016 Update of Hanford Glass Property Models and Constraints for Use in Estimating the Glass Mass to be Produced at Hanford by Implementing Current Enhanced Glass Formulation Efforts report September 2016
Glass Property-Composition Models for Support of Hanford WTP LAW Facility Operation report March 2022
Preliminary Enhanced LAW Glass Formulation Algorithm report February 2022
Preliminary Enhanced LAW Glass Formulation Algorithm report January 2023
NMR Spectroscopy in Glass Science: A Review of the Elements journal March 2018
Machine Learning with Gradient-Based Optimization of Nuclear Waste Vitrification with Uncertainties and Constraints journal November 2022
GEKKO Optimization Suite journal July 2018
Calibration of Machine Learning Models book January 2010