DOE PAGES title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: How does uncertainty of soil organic carbon stock affect the calculation of carbon budgets and soil carbon credits for croplands in the U.S. Midwest?

Journal Article · · Geoderma
 [1];  [1];  [1];  [1];  [1];  [2];  [3];  [4];  [1];  [1];  [1];  [1]
  1. Univ. of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, IL (United States)
  2. Lawrence Berkeley National Lab. (LBNL), Berkeley, CA (United States)
  3. Univ. of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN (United States)
  4. Univ. of Alberta, Edmonton, AB (Canada)

Cropland carbon budget depicts the amount of carbon flowing in and out of agroecosystems and the changes in carbon stocks of soil and living biomass during the same period. Soil carbon credit is the additional change in soil carbon stock under certain farming practices compared with the business-as-usual practices. Accurately calculating cropland carbon budget and soil carbon credit is critical to assessing climate change mitigation potential in agroecosystems. The calculation of cropland carbon budget and soil carbon credit is sensitive to local soil and climatic conditions, especially initial soil organic carbon (SOC) stock, which is determined by both SOC concentration (SOC%) and bulk density (Bulk_Density). SOC stock data are either from soil sampling or gridded public survey data. In agroecosystem models, SOC stock data are a key model input for quantifying cropland carbon budget and soil carbon credit. However, various types and degrees of uncertainties exist in SOC stock datasets, which propagate to the quantification of SOC stock change. In particular, a large discrepancy is found in two widely used SOC stock datasets — Rapid Carbon Assessment dataset (RaCA) and Gridded Soil Survey Geographic Database (gSSURGO) — in the U.S. Midwest, with a relative difference (quantified using Normalized Root Mean Square Error, NRMSE) of 48.0% for 0–30 cm SOC stock between the two datasets. It remains largely unclear how uncertainty in SOC stocks affects the calculation of cropland carbon budget and soil carbon credit. To address this question, we used a well-validated process-based agroecosystem model, ecosys, to assess the impacts of SOC stock uncertainty on carbon budget and soil carbon credit calculation in the U.S. Midwestern corn-soybean rotation systems. Our results reveal the following findings: (1) A sizable discrepancy exists in simulated cropland carbon budget between using gSSURGO and using RaCA for their SOC% and Bulk_Density as model inputs, with a Pearson correlation coefficient (r) of only 0.4 for simulated change of SOC stock (ΔSOC) using these two different soil datasets. (2) Simulated cropland carbon budget components were more sensitive to initial SOC% than to Bulk_Density. For example, the upper and lower quartiles of multi-year averaged ΔSOC were –29.8 and 4.8 gC/m2/year for the selected counties respectively, with an uncertainty of 13.7 and 0.7 gC/m2/year induced by uncertainties in initial SOC% and Bulk_Density, respectively. (3) Both simulated ΔSOC and its uncertainty were negatively correlated with initial SOC%, whereas ΔSOC was negatively correlated with air temperature, and ΔSOC uncertainty was positively correlated with air temperature. (4) The uncertainty of calculated soil carbon credits was much smaller compared with the uncertainty of calculated absolute carbon budgets assuming the same SOC stock uncertainty level in the inputs. Specifically, in our assessment comparing planting cover crops vs no cover crop, the uncertainty of calculated soil carbon credits induced by initial SOC% uncertainty was less than 4% (relative to the quantified value of the soil carbon credits) for 90% of the cases. Our analysis highlights that high accuracy measurement of SOC% as inputs is needed for the calculation of cropland carbon budgets; however, soil carbon credit quantification is much less sensitive to the initial SOC% inputs, and the current publicly available soil datasets (e.g., gSSURGO) are largely suitable for the calculation of soil

Research Organization:
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL), Berkeley, CA (United States)
Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE Office of Science (SC), Biological and Environmental Research (BER); National Science Foundation (NSF); National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA); Foundation for Food and Agriculture Research (FFAR)
Grant/Contract Number:
AC02-05CH11231; AR0001227; FOA-0002250; 1847334; 80NSSC18K0170; 602757
OSTI ID:
1974559
Journal Information:
Geoderma, Vol. 429; ISSN 0016-7061
Publisher:
ElsevierCopyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English

References (79)

Global Carbon Budget 2020 journal January 2020
Multiple models and experiments underscore large uncertainty in soil carbon dynamics journal October 2018
Improving the monitoring of crop productivity using spaceborne solar-induced fluorescence journal November 2015
The role of soil carbon in natural climate solutions journal March 2020
Agro-C: A biogeophysical model for simulating the carbon budget of agroecosystems journal January 2009
Magnitude and sources of uncertainties in soil organic carbon (SOC) stock assessments at various scales journal October 2009
Assessing Different Plant‐Centric Water Stress Metrics for Irrigation Efficacy Using Soil‐Plant‐Atmosphere‐Continuum Simulation journal August 2021
Simulation of Carbon Assimilation and Partitioning in Maize journal July 1989
Nitrogen mineralization drives the response of forest productivity to soil warming: Modelling in ecosys vs. measurements from the Harvard soil heating experiment journal September 2014
The shared and unique values of optical, fluorescence, thermal and microwave satellite data for estimating large-scale crop yields journal September 2017
Improved methodology to quantify the temperature sensitivity of the soil heterotrophic respiration in croplands journal June 2017
Modelling soil attribute depth functions with equal-area quadratic smoothing splines journal August 1999
Changes in Soil Organic Matter under Different Tillage and Rotation: Mathematical Modeling in ecosys journal July 1997
Modeling stomatal and nonstomatal effects of water deficits on CO 2 fixation in a semiarid grassland : MODELING WATER DEFICIT EFFECTS ON CO journal August 2007
Benefits of Seasonal Climate Prediction and Satellite Data for Forecasting U.S. Maize Yield journal September 2018
Soil organic carbon estimation using VNIR–SWIR spectroscopy: The effect of multiple sensors and scanning conditions journal July 2021
Soil Organic Carbon Sequestration Rates by Tillage and Crop Rotation journal January 2002
Using soil library hyperspectral reflectance and machine learning to predict soil organic carbon: Assessing potential of airborne and spaceborne optical soil sensing journal March 2022
Soil Property and Class Maps of the Conterminous United States at 100‐Meter Spatial Resolution journal January 2018
Soil Carbon Sequestration Impacts on Global Climate Change and Food Security journal June 2004
Modeling the effects of hydrology on ecosystem respiration at Mer Bleue bog journal January 2010
Soil Profile Transformation after 50 Years of Agricultural Land Use journal July 2015
Regional scale cropland carbon budgets: Evaluating a geospatial agricultural modeling system using inventory data journal January 2015
Natural climate solutions for the United States journal November 2018
Long-term effects of tillage and straw management on soil organic carbon, crop yield, and yield stability in a wheat-maize system journal March 2019
Informing Nature‐based Climate Solutions for the United States with the best‐available science journal April 2022
Soil carbon 4 per mille journal April 2017
The Microbial Efficiency-Matrix Stabilization (MEMS) framework integrates plant litter decomposition with soil organic matter stabilization: do labile plant inputs form stable soil organic matter? journal February 2013
Net Biome Productivity of Irrigated and Rainfed Maize–Soybean Rotations: Modeling vs. Measurements journal January 2007
Spatial representation of organic carbon and active-layer thickness of high latitude soils in CMIP5 earth system models journal August 2017
Determining soil organic carbon for agricultural soils: a comparison between the Walkley & Black and the dry combustion methods (north Belgium) journal December 2009
Estimating the water retention curve from soil properties: comparison of linear, nonlinear and concomitant variable methods journal December 2004
SoilGrids250m: Global gridded soil information based on machine learning journal February 2017
Modeling Climate Change Impacts on an Arctic Polygonal Tundra: 1. Rates of Permafrost Thaw Depend on Changes in Vegetation and Drainage journal May 2019
Test of a simple biochemical model for photosynthesis of maize and soybean leaves journal October 1989
Climate and Soil Characteristics Determine Where No-Till Management Can Store Carbon in Soils and Mitigate Greenhouse Gas Emissions journal August 2019
How much will precision nitrogen management pay off? An evaluation based on simulating thousands of corn fields over the US Corn-Belt journal July 2019
Historical nitrogen fertilizer use in agricultural ecosystems of the contiguous United States during 1850–2015: application rate, timing, and fertilizer types journal January 2018
Simulation of Maize Phenology journal May 1989
Oxygen availability determines key regulators in soil organic carbon mineralisation in paddy soils journal February 2021
Modelling the dynamic physical protection of soil organic carbon: Insights into carbon predictions and explanation of the priming effect journal July 2017
Controlled Warming Effects on Wheat Growth and Yield: Field Measurements and Modeling journal January 2011
Long-Term Changes in Soil Carbon under Different Fertilizer, Manure, and Rotation: Testing the Mathematical Model ecosys with Data from the Breton Plots journal January 2001
Modelling carbon balances of coastal arctic tundra under changing climate journal January 2003
Global meta-analysis of the relationship between soil organic matter and crop yields journal January 2019
Reconciling the temperature dependence of respiration across timescales and ecosystem types journal June 2012
Natural climate solutions journal October 2017
Soil carbon dynamics in cropland and rangeland journal March 2002
More replenishment than priming loss of soil organic carbon with additional carbon input journal August 2018
Carbon sources and sinks of North America as affected by major drought events during the past 30 years journal October 2017
Predicting soil bulk density for incomplete databases journal January 2014
Simulating long-term impacts of cover crops and climate change on crop production and environmental outcomes in the Midwestern United States journal February 2016
Model structures amplify uncertainty in predicted soil carbon responses to climate change journal June 2018
Soil carbon storage informed by particulate and mineral-associated organic matter journal November 2019
Carbon budget of mature no-till ecosystem in North Central Region of the United States journal May 2005
Quantification of organic carbon pools for Austria’s agricultural soils using a soil information system journal September 2005
Formation of soil organic matter via biochemical and physical pathways of litter mass loss journal September 2015
Simulating measurable ecosystem carbon and nitrogen dynamics with the mechanistically defined MEMS 2.0 model journal May 2021
Nitrogen and phosphorus control carbon sequestration in agricultural ecosystems: modelling carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus balances at the Breton Plots with ecosys under historical and future climates journal December 2020
Current status, uncertainty and future needs in soil organic carbon monitoring journal January 2014
Microbes drive global soil nitrogen mineralization and availability journal January 2019
A critical review of the conventional SOC to SOM conversion factor journal May 2010
Measurements necessary for assessing the net ecosystem carbon budget of croplands journal November 2010
Soil organic carbon fractions in the Great Plains of the United States: an application of mid-infrared spectroscopy journal February 2021
Impact of soil organic matter on soil properties—a review with emphasis on Australian soils journal January 2015
Assessing the impacts of cover crops on maize and soybean yield in the U.S. Midwestern agroecosystems journal November 2021
Modeling carbon biogeochemistry in agricultural soils journal September 1994
Scale Effects of Geographical Soil Datasets on Soil Carbon Estimation in Louisiana, USA: A Comparison of STATSGO and SSURGO journal August 2011
Simulation of canopy photosynthesis in maize and soybean journal October 1989
Uncertainties of modeling gross primary productivity over Europe: A systematic study on the effects of using different drivers and terrestrial biosphere models: EFFECTS ON SIMULATED GPP journal December 2007
Measurements and Modeling of Carbon and Nitrogen Cycling in Agroecosystems of Southern Wisconsin: Potential for SOC Sequestration during the Next 50 Years journal April 2001
Simulation of carbon and nitrogen transformations in soil: Mineralization journal October 1993
Salinity, water use and yield of maize: Testing of the mathematical model ecosys journal January 1995
Quantifying carbon budget, crop yields and their responses to environmental variability using the ecosys model for U.S. Midwestern agroecosystems journal September 2021
A daily, 250 m and real-time gross primary productivity product (2000–present) covering the contiguous United States journal January 2021
Examining strategies to improve the carbon balance of corn/soybean agriculture using eddy covariance and mass balance techniques journal February 2005
Modelling changes in nitrogen cycling to sustain increases in forest productivity under elevated atmospheric CO 2 and contrasting site conditions journal January 2013
Crop Rotation and Tillage Effects on Soil Organic Carbon and Nitrogen journal March 1990
Dynamics of C, N, P and S in grassland soils: a model journal February 1988