DOE PAGES title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Optimal Gas-Electric Energy System Decarbonization Planning

Journal Article · · Advances in Applied Energy

As energy utilities implement climate change mitigation policies, system planners require strategies for achieving affordable emissions reductions. Coordinated planning of electric power and natural gas systems will allow synergistic investments to address cross-sector operational constraints, competing uses for net-zero emissions fuels, and shifts in energy demands across energy carriers. In this study, we develop a novel optimization program that finds the cost-minimizing mix of infrastructure expansion or reduction across gas and electric systems to satisfy sector-specific emissions constraints. Alongside energy supply resources, our framework allows for central-planning of end-use equipment stocks to allow switching between gas and electric appliances upon failure or premature replacement. The proposed model is used to simulate case study scenarios for a benchmark 24-pipe gas network coupled to a 24-node power system test network. We find that electrification of greater than 80% of core gas demands is a component of the least-cost solution for modeled energy systems. Despite this substitution, the gas system is maintained to service difficult-to-electrify customers and to deliver net-zero emissions gas to electricity generators in times of peak electricity demand. Restricting electrification of gas appliances increases reliance on power- to-gas technologies and increases annual costs by 15% in 2040. Neglecting constraints on pipeline blending of hydrogen can produce a misleading result that relies on hydrogen blend fractions of greater than 50%. In all cases, we find the average costs of delivered gas increase nearly 5-fold across the decarbonization transition, highlighting the importance of future work investigating cost-allocation strategies for ensuring an equitable energy transition.

Research Organization:
Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL), Los Alamos, NM (United States)
Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE Office of Electricity (OE)
Grant/Contract Number:
89233218CNA000001
OSTI ID:
1845259
Report Number(s):
LA-UR-21-25254
Journal Information:
Advances in Applied Energy, Journal Name: Advances in Applied Energy Vol. 6; ISSN 2666-7924
Publisher:
ElsevierCopyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English

References (83)

Coordination of Interdependent Electricity Grid and Natural Gas Network—a Review journal February 2018
Robust coordination of interdependent electricity and natural gas systems in day-ahead scheduling for facilitating volatile renewable generations via power-to-gas technology journal April 2017
Coordinated optimal dispatch and market equilibrium of integrated electric power and natural gas networks with P2G embedded journal December 2017
Optimal power flows journal April 1979
Emissions and efficiency of a domestic gas stove burning natural gases with various compositions journal November 2003
Accounting for sequestered carbon: the question of permanence journal December 2001
Multi-objective optimization for the operation of distributed energy systems considering economic and environmental aspects journal December 2010
Carbon constrained design of energy infrastructure for new build schemes journal January 2014
Combined gas and electricity network expansion planning journal January 2014
A bi-level programming for multistage co-expansion planning of the integrated gas and electricity system journal August 2017
Time series aggregation for energy system design: Modeling seasonal storage journal March 2018
Clustering methods to find representative periods for the optimization of energy systems: An initial framework and comparison journal April 2019
Biomethane addition to California transmission pipelines: Regional simulation of the impact of regulations journal September 2019
Cost benefits of optimizing hydrogen storage and methanation capacities for Power-to-Gas plants in dynamic operation journal January 2020
Planning multiple energy systems for low-carbon districts with high penetration of renewable energy: An empirical study in China journal March 2020
Energy systems planning: A survey on models for integrated power and natural gas networks coordination journal March 2020
Facilitating renewables and power-to-gas via integrated electrical power-gas system scheduling journal October 2020
Extreme events in time series aggregation: A case study for optimal residential energy supply systems journal October 2020
Extended convex hull-based distributed optimal energy flow of integrated electricity-gas systems journal April 2021
Quantifying the impact of residential space heating electrification on the Texas electric grid journal September 2021
RiSES3: Rigorous Synthesis of Energy Supply and Storage Systems via time-series relaxation and aggregation journal August 2019
Coordinated Operation of the Electricity and Natural Gas Systems with Bi-directional Energy Conversion journal May 2017
Review of energy efficiency and system performance of residential heat pump water heaters journal May 2017
A detailed MILP optimization model for combined cooling, heat and power system operation planning journal September 2014
Energy efficiency improvement opportunities and associated greenhouse gas abatement costs for the residential sector journal January 2017
A rolling-horizon optimization algorithm for the long term operational scheduling of cogeneration systems journal October 2019
Multi-stage contingency-constrained co-planning for electricity-gas systems interconnected with gas-fired units and power-to-gas plants using iterative Benders decomposition journal August 2019
Renewable portfolio standards and cost-effective energy-efficiency investment journal March 2009
Cost-effectiveness of high-efficiency appliances in the U.S. residential sector: A case study journal June 2012
Trends in transmission, distribution, and administration costs for U.S. investor-owned electric utilities journal June 2017
Renewable natural gas in California: An assessment of the technical and economic potential journal December 2017
Valuing intra-day coordination of electric power and natural gas system operations journal June 2020
Stochastic PSO-based heat and power dispatch under environmental constraints incorporating CHP and wind power units journal January 2011
The role of power-to-gas and carbon capture technologies in cross-sector decarbonisation strategies journal March 2020
Future cost and performance of water electrolysis: An expert elicitation study journal December 2017
Coordinated operation of electricity and natural gas systems from day-ahead to real-time markets journal January 2021
Additionality and permanence standards in California's Forest Offset Protocol: A review of project and program level implications journal August 2017
The Role of Firm Low-Carbon Electricity Resources in Deep Decarbonization of Power Generation journal November 2018
Electricity Load Implications of Space Heating Decarbonization Pathways journal February 2020
Role of Long-Duration Energy Storage in Variable Renewable Electricity Systems journal September 2020
The Value of Inter-Regional Coordination and Transmission in Decarbonizing the US Electricity System journal January 2021
Electrofuels for the transport sector: A review of production costs journal January 2018
Optimal planning and operation of multi-vector energy networks: A systematic review journal November 2020
Electrofuel Synthesis from Variable Renewable Electricity: An Optimization-Based Techno-Economic Analysis journal May 2021
Accounting for the Greenhouse Gas Emission Intensity of Regional Electricity Transfers journal May 2021
Quantifying Methane Emissions from Natural Gas Water Heaters journal April 2020
Carbon‐Neutral Pathways for the United States journal January 2021
Biophysical and economic limits to negative CO2 emissions journal December 2015
Economics of converting renewable power to hydrogen journal February 2019
Developing reliable hourly electricity demand data through screening and imputation journal May 2020
Accuracy of HAZUS General Building Stock Data journal November 2017
Negative emissions—Part 2: Costs, potentials and side effects journal May 2018
At scale, renewable natural gas systems could be climate intensive: the influence of methane feedstock and leakage rates journal August 2020
Optimal Planning of Integrated Electricity-Gas System With Demand Side Management journal January 2019
Impact of Natural Gas Infrastructure on Electric Power Systems journal May 2005
Multicarrier Energy Systems: Shaping Our Energy Future journal September 2020
Multienergy Networks Analytics: Standardized Modeling, Optimization, and Low Carbon Analysis journal September 2020
An Uncertainty Management Framework for Integrated Gas-Electric Energy Systems journal September 2020
A Novel Hybrid Framework for Co-Optimization of Power and Natural Gas Networks Integrated With Emerging Technologies journal September 2020
Energy hubs for the future journal January 2007
Optimization of natural-gas pipeline systems via dynamic programming journal October 1968
Operation of Natural Gas Pipeline Networks With Storage Under Transient Flow Conditions journal March 2022
Optimal Power Flow of Multiple Energy Carriers journal February 2007
A Model to Long-Term, Multiarea, Multistage, and Integrated Expansion Planning of Electricity and Natural Gas Systems journal May 2010
Adaptive Robust Optimization for the Security Constrained Unit Commitment Problem journal February 2013
Multi-Period Integrated Framework of Generation, Transmission, and Natural Gas Grid Expansion Planning for Large-Scale Systems journal September 2015
Low Carbon Oriented Expansion Planning of Integrated Gas and Power Systems journal March 2015
Integrated Power and Natural Gas Model for Energy Adequacy in Short-Term Operation journal November 2015
A Linear Programming Approach to Expansion Co-Planning in Gas and Electricity Markets journal September 2016
Coordinated Scheduling for Interdependent Electric Power and Natural Gas Infrastructures journal January 2017
Enhanced Representative Days and System States Modeling for Energy Storage Investment Analysis journal November 2018
Joint Electricity and Natural Gas Transmission Planning With Endogenous Market Feedbacks journal November 2018
Coordinated Operation of Electricity and Natural Gas Systems: A Convex Relaxation Approach journal May 2019
Planning Multiple Energy Systems Toward Low-Carbon Society: A Decentralized Approach journal September 2019
Coordinated Planning Strategy for Integrated Energy Systems in a District Energy Sector journal July 2020
Methane Leaks from North American Natural Gas Systems journal February 2014
Net-zero emissions energy systems journal June 2018
JuMP: A Modeling Language for Mathematical Optimization journal January 2017
Creating the Future: Integrated Resource Planning for Electric Utilities journal November 1991
Computing in Operations Research Using Julia journal April 2015
Convex Relaxations for Gas Expansion Planning journal November 2016
Preparation of Synthesis Gas from CO2 for Fischer–Tropsch Synthesis—Comparison of Alternative Process Configurations journal September 2020
Multistage Expansion Co-Planning of Integrated Natural Gas and Electricity Distribution Systems journal March 2019