Assessment of four strain energy decomposition methods for phase field fracture models using quasi-static and dynamic benchmark cases

Journal Article · 12 January 2022 · Materials Theory

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s41313-021-00037-1 · OSTI ID:1839497

Zhang, Shuaifang; Jiang, Wen; Tonks, Michael R.

Abstract Strain energy decomposition methods in phase field fracture models separate strain energy that contributes to fracture from that which does not. However, various decomposition methods have been proposed in the literature, and it can be difficult to determine an appropriate method for a given problem. The goal of this work is to facilitate the choice of strain decomposition method by assessing the performance of three existing methods (spectral decomposition of the stress or the strain and deviatoric decomposition of the strain) and one new method (deviatoric decomposition of the stress) with several benchmark problems. In each benchmark problem, we compare the performance of the four methods using both qualitative and quantitative metrics. In the first benchmark, we compare the predicted mechanical behavior of cracked material. We then use four quasi-static benchmark cases: a single edge notched tension test, a single edge notched shear test, a three-point bending test, and a L-shaped panel test. Finally, we use two dynamic benchmark cases: a dynamic tensile fracture test and a dynamic shear fracture test. All four methods perform well in tension, the two spectral methods perform better in compression and with mixed mode (though the stress spectral method performs the best), and all the methods show minor issues in at least one of the shear cases. In general, whether the strain or the stress is decomposed does not have a significant impact on the predicted behavior.

• Sponsoring Organization: USDOE
• OSTI ID: 1839497
• Journal Information: Materials Theory, Journal Name: Materials Theory Journal Issue: 1 Vol. 6; ISSN 2509-8012
• Publisher: Springer Science + Business MediaCopyright Statement
• Country of Publication: Switzerland
• Language: English