Title: Comparing Genome-Wide Association Study Results from Different Measurements of an Underlying Phenotype

Journal Article · · G3

Increasing popularity of high-throughput phenotyping technologies, such as image-based phenotyping, offer novel ways for quantifying plant growth and morphology. These new methods can be more or less accurate and precise than traditional, manual measurements. Many large-scale phenotyping efforts are conducted to enable genome-wide association studies (GWAS), but it is unclear exactly how alternative methods of phenotyping will affect GWAS results. In this study we simulate phenotypes that are controlled by the same set of causal loci but have differing heritability, similar to two different measurements of the same morphological character. We then perform GWAS with the simulated traits and create receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves from the results. The areas under the ROC curves (AUCs) provide a metric that allows direct comparisons of GWAS results from different simulated traits. We use this framework to evaluate the effects of heritability and the number of causative loci on the AUCs of simulated traits; we also test the differences between AUCs of traits with differing heritability. We find that both increasing the number of causative loci and decreasing the heritability reduce a trait's AUC. We also find that when two traits are controlled by a greater number of causative loci, they are more likely to have significantly different AUCs as the difference between their heritabilities increases. When simulation results are applied to measures of tassel morphology, we find no significant difference between AUCs from GWAS using manual and image-based measurements of typical maize tassel characters. This finding indicates that both measurement methods have similar ability to identify genetic associations. These results provide a framework for deciding between competing phenotyping strategies when the ultimate goal is to generate and use phenotype-genotype associations from GWAS.

Research Organization:
Univ. of California, Oakland, CA (United States); Univ. of Wisconsin, Madison, WI (United States)
Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE Office of Science (SC)
Grant/Contract Number:
AC02-05CH11231; FC02-07ER64494
OSTI ID:
1609248
Journal Information:
G3, Journal Name: G3 Journal Issue: 11 Vol. 8; ISSN 2160-1836
Publisher:
Genetics Society of AmericaCopyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English

References (48)

A PRM approach for early prediction of breast cancer response to chemotherapy based on registered MR images journal May 2018
XV.—The Correlation between Relatives on the Supposition of Mendelian Inheritance. journal January 1919
Hundreds of variants clustered in genomic loci and biological pathways affect human height journal September 2010
Sizing up human height variation journal May 2008
A high-throughput imaging system to quantitatively analyze the growth dynamics of plant seedlings journal January 2012
Plant Disease Severity Estimated Visually, by Digital Photography and Image Analysis, and by Hyperspectral Imaging journal March 2010
A Fast and Flexible Statistical Model for Large-Scale Population Genotype Data: Applications to Inferring Missing Genotypes and Haplotypic Phase journal April 2006
GAPIT: genome association and prediction integrated tool journal July 2012
Construction of the third-generation Zea mays haplotype map journal December 2017
Plasticity of Arabidopsis Root Gravitropism throughout a Multidimensional Condition Space Quantified by Automated Image Analysis journal November 2009
A robust, high-throughput method for computing maize ear, cob, and kernel attributes automatically from images journal November 2016
Iterative Usage of Fixed and Random Effect Models for Powerful and Efficient Genome-Wide Association Studies journal February 2016
A SUPER Powerful Method for Genome Wide Association Study journal September 2014
Selection Signatures Underlying Dramatic Male Inflorescence Transformation During Modern Hybrid Maize Breeding journal September 2018
Efficient Methods to Compute Genomic Predictions journal November 2008
Persistent homology and the branching topologies of plants journal March 2017
A New Approach for Testing the Significance of Differences Between ROC Curves Measured from Correlated Data book January 1984
The area above the ordinal dominance graph and the area below the receiver operating characteristic graph journal November 1975
The use of near infrared reflectance spectroscopy (NIRS) on undried samples of grass silage to predict chemical composition and digestibility parameters journal May 1998
An Expanded View of Complex Traits: From Polygenic to Omnigenic journal June 2017
XV.—The Correlation between Relatives on the Supposition of Mendelian Inheritance. journal January 1919
Hundreds of variants clustered in genomic loci and biological pathways affect human height journal September 2010
Sizing up human height variation journal May 2008
Automated abnormality classification of chest radiographs using deep convolutional neural networks journal May 2020
A high-throughput imaging system to quantitatively analyze the growth dynamics of plant seedlings journal January 2012
The distribution of the effects of genes affecting quantitative traits in livestock journal May 2001
Plant Disease Severity Estimated Visually, by Digital Photography and Image Analysis, and by Hyperspectral Imaging journal March 2010
A Fast and Flexible Statistical Model for Large-Scale Population Genotype Data: Applications to Inferring Missing Genotypes and Haplotypic Phase journal April 2006
GAPIT: genome association and prediction integrated tool journal July 2012
Construction of the third-generation Zea mays haplotype map journal December 2017
Plasticity of Arabidopsis Root Gravitropism throughout a Multidimensional Condition Space Quantified by Automated Image Analysis journal November 2009
A Modern Ampelography: A Genetic Basis for Leaf Shape and Venation Patterning in Grape journal November 2013
Insights into the Maize Pan-Genome and Pan-Transcriptome journal January 2014
A robust, high-throughput method for computing maize ear, cob, and kernel attributes automatically from images journal November 2016
The distribution of the effects of genes affecting quantitative traits in livestock journal May 2001
TIPS: a system for automated image-based phenotyping of maize tassels journal March 2017
Iterative Usage of Fixed and Random Effect Models for Powerful and Efficient Genome-Wide Association Studies journal February 2016
Glucocerebrosidase Deficiency in Drosophila Results in α-Synuclein-Independent Protein Aggregation and Neurodegeneration journal March 2016
A SUPER Powerful Method for Genome Wide Association Study journal September 2014
Selection Signatures Underlying Dramatic Male Inflorescence Transformation During Modern Hybrid Maize Breeding journal September 2018
Reference-based QUantification Of gene Dispensability (QUOD) text January 2021
Comparing the Areas under Two or More Correlated Receiver Operating Characteristic Curves: A Nonparametric Approach journal September 1988
Efficient Methods to Compute Genomic Predictions journal November 2008
Persistent homology and the branching topologies of plants journal March 2017
Data from: Selection signatures underlying dramatic male inflorescence transformation during modern hybrid maize breeding dataset January 2018
Data from: Genome-wide association analysis of stalk biomass and anatomical traits in maize dataset January 2019
Hundreds of variants clustered in genomic loci and biological pathways affect human height text January 2010
TIPS: a system for automated image-based phenotyping of maize tassels dataset March 2017

Cited By (1)