Greenhouse gas emissions and crop yield in no-tillage systems: A meta-analysis
Abstract
We report that no-tillage (NT) has been touted as one of several climate-smart agriculture (CSA) management practices that improve food security and enhance agroecosystem resilience to climate change. However, the sustainable effectiveness of NT greatly depends on trade-offs between NT-induced changes in crop yield and greenhouse gas (GHG, i.e. CH4, CO2, and N2O) emissions. Such trade-offs are regulated by climate fluctuations and heterogeneous soil conditions and have not been well addressed. Supporting CSA management decisions requires advancing our understanding of how NT affects crop yield and GHG emissions in different agroecological regions. In this study, a meta-analysis was conducted using 740 paired measurements from 90 peer-reviewed articles to assess the effects of NT on crop yield, GHG emissions, and the global warming potential (GWP) of major cereal cropping systems. Compared to conventional tillage (CT), NT reduced in GHG emissions and increased crop yield in dry, but not humid, climates, and reduced in the GWP at sites with acidic soils. Across different cropping systems, NT enhanced barley yield by 49%, particularly in dry climates, and it decreased the GWP of rice fields through a 22% reduction in both CO2 and CH4 emissions. Our synthesis suggests that NT is an effective CSAmore »
- Authors:
-
- Univ. of Kentucky, Lexington, KY (United States)
- Indiana Univ., Indianapolis, IN (United States); Purdue Univ., Indianapolis, IN (United States)
- Tennessee State Univ., Nashville, TN (United States)
- Oak Ridge National Lab. (ORNL), Oak Ridge, TN (United States)
- West Virginia University Extension Service, Point Pleasant, WV (United States)
- Publication Date:
- Research Org.:
- Oak Ridge National Lab. (ORNL), Oak Ridge, TN (United States)
- Sponsoring Org.:
- USDOE Office of Science (SC), Biological and Environmental Research (BER)
- OSTI Identifier:
- 1607275
- Grant/Contract Number:
- AC05-00OR22725
- Resource Type:
- Accepted Manuscript
- Journal Name:
- Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment
- Additional Journal Information:
- Journal Volume: 268; Journal Issue: C; Journal ID: ISSN 0167-8809
- Publisher:
- Elsevier
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
- Subject:
- 54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES; Climate change mitigation; Crop yield; Greenhouse gas emissions; No-tillage
Citation Formats
Huang, Yawen, Ren, Wei, Wang, Lixin, Hui, Dafeng, Grove, John H., Yang, Xiaojuan, Tao, Bo, and Goff, Ben. Greenhouse gas emissions and crop yield in no-tillage systems: A meta-analysis. United States: N. p., 2018.
Web. doi:10.1016/j.agee.2018.09.002.
Huang, Yawen, Ren, Wei, Wang, Lixin, Hui, Dafeng, Grove, John H., Yang, Xiaojuan, Tao, Bo, & Goff, Ben. Greenhouse gas emissions and crop yield in no-tillage systems: A meta-analysis. United States. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2018.09.002
Huang, Yawen, Ren, Wei, Wang, Lixin, Hui, Dafeng, Grove, John H., Yang, Xiaojuan, Tao, Bo, and Goff, Ben. Thu .
"Greenhouse gas emissions and crop yield in no-tillage systems: A meta-analysis". United States. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2018.09.002. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1607275.
@article{osti_1607275,
title = {Greenhouse gas emissions and crop yield in no-tillage systems: A meta-analysis},
author = {Huang, Yawen and Ren, Wei and Wang, Lixin and Hui, Dafeng and Grove, John H. and Yang, Xiaojuan and Tao, Bo and Goff, Ben},
abstractNote = {We report that no-tillage (NT) has been touted as one of several climate-smart agriculture (CSA) management practices that improve food security and enhance agroecosystem resilience to climate change. However, the sustainable effectiveness of NT greatly depends on trade-offs between NT-induced changes in crop yield and greenhouse gas (GHG, i.e. CH4, CO2, and N2O) emissions. Such trade-offs are regulated by climate fluctuations and heterogeneous soil conditions and have not been well addressed. Supporting CSA management decisions requires advancing our understanding of how NT affects crop yield and GHG emissions in different agroecological regions. In this study, a meta-analysis was conducted using 740 paired measurements from 90 peer-reviewed articles to assess the effects of NT on crop yield, GHG emissions, and the global warming potential (GWP) of major cereal cropping systems. Compared to conventional tillage (CT), NT reduced in GHG emissions and increased crop yield in dry, but not humid, climates, and reduced in the GWP at sites with acidic soils. Across different cropping systems, NT enhanced barley yield by 49%, particularly in dry climates, and it decreased the GWP of rice fields through a 22% reduction in both CO2 and CH4 emissions. Our synthesis suggests that NT is an effective CSA management practice because of its potential for climate change mitigation and crop yield improvement. However, the net effect of NT (relative to CT) was influenced by several environmental and agronomic factors (climatic conditions, tillage duration, soil texture, pH, crop species). Therefore, agroecological setting must be taken into consideration when conducting a comparative evaluation of different tillage practices.},
doi = {10.1016/j.agee.2018.09.002},
journal = {Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment},
number = C,
volume = 268,
place = {United States},
year = {Thu Sep 20 00:00:00 EDT 2018},
month = {Thu Sep 20 00:00:00 EDT 2018}
}
Web of Science
Works referenced in this record:
Aerobic and Anaerobic Microbial Populations in No-till and Plowed Soils
journal, July 1984
- Linn, D. M.; Doran, J. W.
- Soil Science Society of America Journal, Vol. 48, Issue 4
Conservation tillage systems: a review of its consequences for greenhouse gas emissions
journal, February 2013
- Abdalla, M.; Osborne, B.; Lanigan, G.
- Soil Use and Management, Vol. 29, Issue 2
No-tillage lessens soil CO2 emissions the most under arid and sandy soil conditions: results from a meta-analysis
journal, January 2016
- Abdalla, Khatab; Chivenge, Pauline; Ciais, Philippe
- Biogeosciences, Vol. 13, Issue 12
Greenhouse gas emission from direct seeding paddy field under different rice tillage systems in central China
journal, December 2009
- Ahmad, Shahrear; Li, Chengfang; Dai, Guangzhao
- Soil and Tillage Research, Vol. 106, Issue 1
Carbon Dioxide and Nitrous Oxide Fluxes in Corn Grown under Two Tillage Systems in Southwestern Quebec
journal, January 2009
- Almaraz, Juan J.; Mabood, Fazli; Zhou, Xiaomin
- Soil Science Society of America Journal, Vol. 73, Issue 1
Management Effects on Soil Carbon Dioxide Fluxes under Semiarid Mediterranean Conditions
journal, January 2008
- Álvaro-Fuentes, J.; López, M. V.; Arrúe, J. L.
- Soil Science Society of America Journal, Vol. 72, Issue 1
Changing pH shifts the microbial sourceas well as the magnitude of N2O emission from soil
journal, July 2010
- Baggs, Elizabeth M.; Smales, Claire L.; Bateman, Emma J.
- Biology and Fertility of Soils, Vol. 46, Issue 8
The influence of gas transport and porosity on methane oxidation in soils
journal, October 1997
- Ball, B. C.; Dobbie, K. E.; Parker, J. P.
- Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, Vol. 102, Issue D19
Field N2O, CO2 and CH4 fluxes in relation to tillage, compaction and soil quality in Scotland
journal, November 1999
- Ball, Bruce C.; Scott, Albert; Parker, John P.
- Soil and Tillage Research, Vol. 53, Issue 1
Operating Characteristics of a Rank Correlation Test for Publication Bias
journal, December 1994
- Begg, Colin B.; Mazumdar, Madhuchhanda
- Biometrics, Vol. 50, Issue 4
Soil tillage enhanced CO2 and N2O emissions from loamy sand soil under spring barley
journal, November 2007
- Chatskikh, Dmitri; Olesen, Jørgen E.
- Soil and Tillage Research, Vol. 97, Issue 1
Impacts of no-tillage management on nitrate loss from corn, soybean and wheat cultivation: A meta-analysis
journal, September 2017
- Daryanto, Stefani; Wang, Lixin; Jacinthe, Pierre-André
- Scientific Reports, Vol. 7, Issue 1
Global synthesis of drought effects on cereal, legume, tuber and root crops production: A review
journal, January 2017
- Daryanto, Stefani; Wang, Lixin; Jacinthe, Pierre-André
- Agricultural Water Management, Vol. 179
Responses of terrestrial ecosystem phosphorus cycling to nitrogen addition: A meta-analysis: DENG et al.
journal, March 2017
- Deng, Qi; Hui, Dafeng; Dennis, Sam
- Global Ecology and Biogeography, Vol. 26, Issue 6
Organic Carbon, Nitrogen, and Phosphorus Concentrations and pH in Soil Profiles as Affected by Tillage Intensity
journal, January 1983
- Dick, W. A.
- Soil Science Society of America Journal, Vol. 47, Issue 1
Emissions of Nitrous Oxide and Carbon Dioxide: Influence of Tillage Type and Nitrogen Placement Depth
journal, March 2006
- Drury, C. F.; Reynolds, W. D.; Tan, C. S.
- Soil Science Society of America Journal, Vol. 70, Issue 2
Nitrogen Source, Application Time, and Tillage Effects on Soil Nitrous Oxide Emissions and Corn Grain Yields
journal, January 2012
- Drury, C. F.; Reynolds, W. D.; Yang, X. M.
- Soil Science Society of America Journal, Vol. 76, Issue 4
Effect of tillage and water management on GHG emissions from Mediterranean rice growing ecosystems
journal, February 2017
- Fangueiro, David; Becerra, Daniel; Albarrán, Ángel
- Atmospheric Environment, Vol. 150
Crop yield and weed management in rainfed conservation agriculture
journal, December 2011
- Farooq, M.; Flower, K. C.; Jabran, K.
- Soil and Tillage Research, Vol. 117
Tillage-induced short-term soil organic matter turnover and respiration
journal, January 2016
- Fiedler, Sebastian Rainer; Leinweber, Peter; Jurasinski, Gerald
- SOIL, Vol. 2, Issue 3
The contribution of maize cropping in the Midwest USA to global warming: A regional estimate
journal, March 2011
- Grace, Peter R.; Philip Robertson, G.; Millar, Neville
- Agricultural Systems, Vol. 104, Issue 3
Long-Term Trends in Nitrous Oxide Emissions, Soil Nitrogen, and Crop Yields of Till and No-Till Cropping Systems
journal, January 2006
- Grandy, A. Stuart; Loecke, Terrance D.; Parr, Sara
- Journal of Environment Quality, Vol. 35, Issue 4
Tillage effects on N 2 O emission from soils under corn and soybeans in Eastern Canada
journal, May 2008
- Gregorich, E. G.; Rochette, P.; St-Georges, P.
- Canadian Journal of Soil Science, Vol. 88, Issue 2
Nitrification and Denitrification in Conventional and No‐Tillage Soils
journal, March 1985
- Groffman, Peter M.
- Soil Science Society of America Journal, Vol. 49, Issue 2
Nitrogen, Tillage, and Crop Rotation Effects on Nitrous Oxide Emissions from Irrigated Cropping Systems
journal, January 2008
- Halvorson, Ardell D.; Del Grosso, Stephen J.; Reule, Curtis A.
- Journal of Environment Quality, Vol. 37, Issue 4
Soil properties and crop yields after 11 years of no tillage farming in wheat–maize cropping system in North China Plain
journal, May 2011
- He, Jin; Li, Hongwen; Rasaily, Rabi G.
- Soil and Tillage Research, Vol. 113, Issue 1
The Meta-Analysis of Response Ratios in Experimental Ecology
journal, June 1999
- Hedges, Larry V.; Gurevitch, Jessica; Curtis, Peter S.
- Ecology, Vol. 80, Issue 4
Very high resolution interpolated climate surfaces for global land areas
journal, January 2005
- Hijmans, Robert J.; Cameron, Susan E.; Parra, Juan L.
- International Journal of Climatology, Vol. 25, Issue 15
Effect of polymer-coated urea on nitrous oxide emission in zero-till and conventionally tilled silage corn
journal, March 2016
- Hunt, Derek E.; Bittman, Shabtai; Zhang, Hongjie
- Canadian Journal of Soil Science, Vol. 96, Issue 1
Fluxes of Carbon Dioxide, Nitrous Oxide, and Methane in Grass Sod and Winter Wheat‐Fallow Tillage Management
journal, September 1998
- Kessavalou, Anabayan; Mosier, Arvin R.; Doran, John W.
- Journal of Environmental Quality, Vol. 27, Issue 5
Unexpected stimulation of CH4 emissions under continuous no-tillage system in mono-rice paddy soils during cultivation
journal, April 2016
- Kim, Sang Yoon; Gutierrez, Jessie; Kim, Pil Joo
- Geoderma, Vol. 267
Sequestering carbon and increasing productivity by conservation agriculture
journal, May 2015
- Lal, R.
- Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, Vol. 70, Issue 3
Soil Carbon Sequestration to Mitigate Climate Change and Advance food Security
journal, January 2007
- Lal, R.; Follett, R. F.; Stewart, B. A.
- Soil Science, Vol. 172, Issue 12
Methane emissions from double-rice cropping system under conventional and no tillage in southeast China
journal, June 2011
- Li, Daming; Liu, Manqiang; Cheng, Yanhong
- Soil and Tillage Research, Vol. 113, Issue 2
Emissions of CH4 and CO2 from double rice cropping systems under varying tillage and seeding methods
journal, December 2013
- Li, Chengfang; Zhang, Zhisheng; Guo, Lijin
- Atmospheric Environment, Vol. 80
Effect of Water-Filled Pore Space on Carbon Dioxide and Nitrous Oxide Production in Tilled and Nontilled Soils1
journal, January 1984
- Linn, D. M.; Doran, J. W.
- Soil Science Society of America Journal, Vol. 48, Issue 6
Climate-smart agriculture for food security
journal, November 2014
- Lipper, Leslie; Thornton, Philip; Campbell, Bruce M.
- Nature Climate Change, Vol. 4, Issue 12
Mitigation of nitrous oxide emissions from paddy soil under conventional and no-till practices using nitrification inhibitors during the winter wheat-growing season
journal, November 2012
- Ma, Yuchun; Sun, Liying; Zhang, Xiaoxu
- Biology and Fertility of Soils, Vol. 49, Issue 6
Methane and nitrous oxide emissions from laboratory measurements of rice soil suspension: Effect of soil oxidation-reduction status
journal, January 1993
- Masscheleyn, Patrick H.; DeLaune, Ronald D.; Patrick, William H.
- Chemosphere, Vol. 26, Issue 1-4
No-till management impacts on crop productivity, carbon input and soil carbon sequestration
journal, March 2012
- Ogle, Stephen M.; Swan, Amy; Paustian, Keith
- Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, Vol. 149
Determinants of annual fluxes of CO2 and N2O in long-term no-tillage and conventional tillage systems in northern France
journal, September 2007
- Oorts, Katrien; Merckx, Roel; Gréhan, Eric
- Soil and Tillage Research, Vol. 95, Issue 1-2
When does no-till yield more? A global meta-analysis
journal, November 2015
- Pittelkow, Cameron M.; Linquist, Bruce A.; Lundy, Mark E.
- Field Crops Research, Vol. 183
Tillage and nitrogen fertilization effects on nitrous oxide yield-scaled emissions in a rainfed Mediterranean area
journal, May 2014
- Plaza-Bonilla, Daniel; Álvaro-Fuentes, Jorge; Arrúe, José Luis
- Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, Vol. 189
Soil carbon dioxide and methane fluxes as affected by tillage and N fertilization in dryland conditions
journal, April 2014
- Plaza-Bonilla, Daniel; Cantero-Martínez, Carlos; Bareche, Javier
- Plant and Soil, Vol. 381, Issue 1-2
Methane oxidation kinetics and diffusivity in soils under conventional tillage and long-term no-till
journal, October 2014
- Prajapati, P.; Jacinthe, P. A.
- Geoderma, Vol. 230-231
Greenhouse gas fluxes in varying soils types under conventional and no-tillage practices
journal, August 2010
- Regina, K.; Alakukku, L.
- Soil and Tillage Research, Vol. 109, Issue 2
No-till only increases N2O emissions in poorly-aerated soils
journal, September 2008
- Rochette, P.
- Soil and Tillage Research, Vol. 101, Issue 1-2
The File-Drawer Problem Revisited: a General Weighted Method for Calculating Fail-Safe Numbers in Meta-Analysis
journal, February 2005
- Rosenberg, Michael S.
- Evolution, Vol. 59, Issue 2
Initial nitrous oxide, carbon dioxide, and methane costs of converting conservation reserve program grassland to row crops under no-till vs. conventional tillage
journal, May 2013
- Ruan, Leilei; Philip Robertson, G.
- Global Change Biology, Vol. 19, Issue 8
A meta-analysis of long-term effects of conservation agriculture on maize grain yield under rain-fed conditions
journal, July 2011
- Rusinamhodzi, Leonard; Corbeels, Marc; van Wijk, Mark T.
- Agronomy for Sustainable Development, Vol. 31, Issue 4
Tillage, residue and nitrogen management effects on methane and nitrous oxide emission from rice–wheat system of Indian Northwest Indo-Gangetic Plains
journal, November 2015
- Sapkota, Tek B.; Jat, M. L.; Shankar, Vivek
- Journal of Integrative Environmental Sciences, Vol. 12, Issue sup1
Fluxes of nitrous oxide in tilled and no-tilled boreal arable soils
journal, January 2013
- Sheehy, Jatta; Six, Johan; Alakukku, Laura
- Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, Vol. 164
Review of greenhouse gas emissions from crop production systems and fertilizer management effects
journal, October 2009
- Snyder, C. S.; Bruulsema, T. W.; Jensen, T. L.
- Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, Vol. 133, Issue 3-4
Mass Spectrometric Studies of the Effect of pH on the Accumulation of Intermediates in Denitrification by Paracoccus denitrificans
journal, February 1994
- Thomsen, Jens K.; Geest, Torben; Cox, Raymond P.
- Applied and Environmental Microbiology, Vol. 60, Issue 2
Soils as sources and sinks for atmospheric methane
journal, May 1997
- Topp, Edward; Pattey, Elizabeth
- Canadian Journal of Soil Science, Vol. 77, Issue 2
Climate, duration, and N placement determine N 2 O emissions in reduced tillage systems: a meta-analysis
journal, August 2012
- van Kessel, Chris; Venterea, Rodney; Six, Johan
- Global Change Biology, Vol. 19, Issue 1
Nitrogen Oxide and Methane Emissions under Varying Tillage and Fertilizer Management
journal, January 2005
- Venterea, Rodney T.; Burger, Martin; Spokas, Kurt A.
- Journal of Environment Quality, Vol. 34, Issue 5
Soil Redox and pH Effects on Methane Production in a Flooded Rice Soil
journal, January 1993
- Wang, Z. P.; DeLaune, R. D.; Patrick, W. H.
- Soil Science Society of America Journal, Vol. 57, Issue 2
Crop Species and Tillage Effects on Carbon Sequestration in Subsurface soil
journal, January 2007
- Wright, Alan L.; Dou, Fugen; Hons, Frank M.
- Soil Science, Vol. 172, Issue 2
Nitrous oxide and methane fluxes from a rice–wheat crop rotation under wheat residue incorporation and no-tillage practices
journal, November 2013
- Yao, Zhisheng; Zheng, Xunhua; Wang, Rui
- Atmospheric Environment, Vol. 79
Nitrous oxide and methane emissions from a Chinese wheat–rice cropping system under different tillage practices during the wheat-growing season
journal, March 2015
- Zhang, Yuefang; Sheng, Jing; Wang, Zichen
- Soil and Tillage Research, Vol. 146
Effects of nitrogen fertilizer sources and tillage practices on greenhouse gas emissions in paddy fields of central China
journal, November 2016
- Zhang, Z. S.; Chen, J.; Liu, T. Q.
- Atmospheric Environment, Vol. 144
Methane and nitrous oxide emissions under no-till farming in China: a meta-analysis
journal, February 2016
- Zhao, Xin; Liu, Sheng-Li; Pu, Chao
- Global Change Biology, Vol. 22, Issue 4
Long-term tillage and synthetic fertilization affect soil functioning and crop yields in a corn–soybean rotation in eastern Canada
journal, August 2014
- Ziadi, Noura; Angers, Denis A.; Gagnon, Bernard
- Canadian Journal of Soil Science, Vol. 94, Issue 3
Works referencing / citing this record:
Responses of soil carbon sequestration to climate‐smart agriculture practices: A meta‐analysis
journal, May 2019
- Bai, Xiongxiong; Huang, Yawen; Ren, Wei
- Global Change Biology, Vol. 25, Issue 8
Estimation and mitigation of greenhouse gases in typical paddy‐upland rotation systems in the middle and lower reaches of the Yangtze River, China
journal, November 2019
- Shi, Yifan; Lou, Yunsheng; Wang, Ying
- Greenhouse Gases: Science and Technology, Vol. 10, Issue 1