Search Menu
DOE PAGES title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information
Search Scholarly Publications

Title: Hydrogeological Model Selection Among Complex Spatial Priors

Journal Article · · Water Resources Research
ORCiD logo [1]; ORCiD logo [2]; ORCiD logo [1]; ORCiD logo [1]
  1. Univ. of Lausanne, Lausanne (Switzerland). Applied and Environmental Geophysics Group, Inst. of Earth Sciences
  2. British Geological Survey, Environmental Science Centre, Nottingham (United Kingdom)
+ Show Author Affiliations

Hydrogeological field studies rely often on a single conceptual representation of the subsurface. This is problematic since the impact of a poorly chosen conceptual model on predictions might be significantly larger than the one caused by parameter uncertainty. Furthermore, conceptual models often need to incorporate geological concepts and patterns in order to provide meaningful uncertainty quantification and predictions. Consequently, several geologically realistic conceptual models should ideally be considered and evaluated in terms of their relative merits. Here, we propose a full Bayesian methodology based on Markov chain Monte Carlo to enable model selection among 2-D conceptual models that are sampled using training images and concepts from multiple-point statistics. More precisely, power posteriors for the different conceptual subsurface models are sampled using sequential geostatistical resampling and Graph Cuts. To demonstrate the methodology, we compare and rank five alternative conceptual geological models that have been proposed in the literature to describe aquifer heterogeneity at the MAcroDispersion Experiment site in Mississippi, USA. We consider a small-scale tracer test for which the spatial distribution of hydraulic conductivity impacts multilevel solute concentration data observed along a 2-D transect. The thermodynamic integration and the stepping-stone sampling methods were used to compute the evidence and associated Bayes factors using the computed power posteriors. We find that both methods are compatible with multiple-point statistics-based inversions and provide a consistent ranking of the competing conceptual models considered.

Research Organization:
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL), Berkeley, CA (United States)
Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE Office of Science (SC)
Grant/Contract Number:
AC02-05CH11231
OSTI ID:
1572041
Journal Information:
Water Resources Research, Vol. 55, Issue 8; ISSN 0043-1397
Publisher:
American Geophysical Union (AGU)Copyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Citation Metrics:
Cited by: 12 works
Citation information provided by
Web of Science

References (93)

Some Tests of Significance, Treated by the Theory of Probability journal April 1935
Bayes Factors journal June 1995
An experimental comparison of min-cut/max- flow algorithms for energy minimization in vision journal September 2004
Posterior population expansion for solving inverse problems: POSTERIOR POPULATION EXP. journal April 2017
Nested Sampling
  • Skilling, John
  • BAYESIAN INFERENCE AND MAXIMUM ENTROPY METHODS IN SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING: 24th International Workshop on Bayesian Inference and Maximum Entropy Methods in Science and Engineering, AIP Conference Proceedings https://doi.org/10.1063/1.1835238
conference January 2004
Inference from Iterative Simulation Using Multiple Sequences journal November 1992
Targeting Bayes factors with direct-path non-equilibrium thermodynamic integration journal March 2017
Interpretative modelling of a geological cross section from boreholes: sources of uncertainty and their quantification journal January 2014
Marginal likelihood estimation via power posteriors journal July 2008
Training‐Image Based Geostatistical Inversion Using a Spatial Generative Adversarial Neural Network journal January 2018
Simulating normalizing constants: from importance sampling to bridge sampling to path sampling journal May 1998
Geological realism in hydrogeological and geophysical inverse modeling: A review journal December 2015
When good statistical models of aquifer heterogeneity go bad: A comparison of flow, dispersion, and mass transfer in connected and multivariate Gaussian hydraulic conductivity fields: FLOW, DISPERSION, AND MASS TRANSFER journal March 2003
On the efficient sampling of pathways in the transition path ensemble journal January 2001
Influence of conceptual model uncertainty on contaminant transport forecasting in braided river aquifers journal December 2015
Conceptual model uncertainty in groundwater modeling: Combining generalized likelihood uncertainty estimation and Bayesian model averaging: EVALUATING CONCEPTUAL MODEL journal December 2008
Bayesian evidence computation for model selection in non-linear geoacoustic inference problems journal December 2010
Probabilistic inversion with graph cuts: Application to the Boise Hydrogeophysical Research Site: INVERSION WITH GRAPH CUTS AT THE BHRS journal February 2017
Analysis of Solute Transport in Flow Fields Influenced by Preferential Flowpaths at the Decimeter Scale journal March 2003
Three-dimensional high resolution fluvio-glacial aquifer analog: Part 1: Field study journal July 2011
Bayesian model selection for complex geological structures using polynomial chaos proxy journal March 2017
Three-dimensional high resolution fluvio-glacial aquifer analog – Part 2: Geostatistical modeling journal July 2011
Improving power posterior estimation of statistical evidence journal May 2013
Tomogram-based comparison of geostatistical models: Application to the Macrodispersion Experiment (MADE) site journal December 2015
Summary statistics from training images as prior information in probabilistic inversion journal February 2015
Integrating MT-DREAMzs and nested sampling algorithms to estimate marginal likelihood and comparison with several other methods journal August 2018
Quantifying Uncertainty in Subsurface Systems book May 2018
The Direct Sampling method to perform multiple-point geostatistical simulations: PERFORMING MULTIPLE-POINTS SIMULATIONS journal November 2010
The Controlled Thermodynamic Integral for Bayesian Model Evidence Evaluation journal April 2016
Conditioning of Multiple-Point Statistics Facies Simulations to Tomographic Images journal September 2013
Geological modeling of submeter scale heterogeneity and its influence on tracer transport in a fluvial aquifer journal October 2010
Choosing among Partition Models in Bayesian Phylogenetics journal August 2010
Evaluating marginal likelihood with thermodynamic integration method and comparison with several other numerical methods: THERMODYNAMIC INTEGRATION FOR EVALUATING MARGINAL LIKELIHOOD journal February 2016
Parallel tempering: Theory, applications, and new perspectives journal January 2005
Calibration of channelized subsurface flow models using nested sampling and soft probabilities journal January 2015
Bayesian inverse problem and optimization with iterative spatial resampling: ITERATIVE SPATIAL RESAMPLING journal November 2010
Monte Carlo sampling of solutions to inverse problems journal July 1995
Inverse problems with non-trivial priors: efficient solution through sequential Gibbs sampling journal January 2012
Can uncertainty in geological cross-section interpretations be quantified and predicted? journal April 2018
Dealing with spatial heterogeneity journal February 2005
Issues in characterizing heterogeneity and connectivity in non-multiGaussian media journal January 2008
Bayesian evolutionary model testing in the phylogenomics era: matching model complexity with computational efficiency journal June 2013
Bayesian model selection in hydrogeophysics: Application to conceptual subsurface models of the South Oyster Bacterial Transport Site, Virginia, USA journal April 2017
To be or not to be multi-Gaussian? A reflection on stochastic hydrogeology journal February 1998
Model selection on solid ground: Rigorous comparison of nine ways to evaluate Bayesian model evidence journal December 2014
An adaptive multiscale method for density-driven instabilities journal July 2012
Modelling guidelines––terminology and guiding principles journal January 2004
Improved Nested Sampling and Surrogate-Enabled Comparison With Other Marginal Likelihood Estimators journal February 2018
Investigation of Small-Scale Preferential Flow with a Forced-Gradient Tracer Test journal August 2010
Image synthesis with graph cuts: a fast model proposal mechanism in probabilistic inversion journal December 2015
Connectivity metrics for subsurface flow and transport journal January 2013
A lithofacies approach for modeling non‐ F ickian solute transport in a heterogeneous alluvial aquifer journal January 2016
High-dimensional posterior exploration of hydrologic models using multiple-try DREAM (ZS) and high-performance computing : EFFICIENT MCMC FOR HIGH-DIMENSIONAL PROBLEMS journal January 2012
Bayesian Interpolation journal May 1992
Computing Bayes Factors Using Thermodynamic Integration journal April 2006
A dual-domain mass transfer approach for modeling solute transport in heterogeneous aquifers: Application to the Macrodispersion Experiment (MADE) site journal September 2000
Spatial connectivity in a highly heterogeneous aquifer: From cores to preferential flow paths: SPATIAL CONNECTIVITY IN A HETEROGENEOUS AQUIFER journal May 2011
Nested sampling for general Bayesian computation journal December 2006
Review of strategies for handling geological uncertainty in groundwater flow and transport modeling journal February 2012
Applied Geostatistics with SGeMS book January 2009
Relative importance of dispersion and rate-limited mass transfer in highly heterogeneous porous media: Analysis of a new tracer test at the Macrodispersion Experiment (MADE) site: NEW SWIW TRACER TEST AT THE MADE SITE journal March 2010
Patch-based iterative conditional geostatistical simulation using graph cuts: GEOSTATISTICAL SIMULATION USING GRAPH CUTS journal August 2016
On uncertainty quantification in hydrogeology and hydrogeophysics journal December 2017
Make the most of your samples: Bayes factor estimators for high-dimensional models of sequence evolution journal March 2013
Reversible jump Markov chain Monte Carlo computation and Bayesian model determination journal January 1995
Improving Marginal Likelihood Estimation for Bayesian Phylogenetic Model Selection journal December 2010
Multiple-point geostatistics for modeling subsurface heterogeneity: A comprehensive review: REVIEW OF MULTIPLE POI journal November 2008
Lessons Learned from 25 Years of Research at the MADE Site journal September 2010
Bayesian calibration of a large-scale geothermal reservoir model by a new adaptive delayed acceptance Metropolis Hastings algorithm: ADAPTIVE DELAYED ACCEPTANCE METROPOLIS-HASTINGS ALGORITHM journal October 2011
Falsification and corroboration of conceptual hydrological models using geophysical data: Falsification of hydrological models using geophysics journal January 2014
Estimating Bayes factors via thermodynamic integration and population MCMC journal October 2009
Field study of dispersion in a heterogeneous aquifer: 1. Overview and site description journal December 1992
The Necessity of a Multiple-Point Prior Model journal December 2006
Merging parallel tempering with sequential geostatistical resampling for improved posterior exploration of high-dimensional subsurface categorical fields journal April 2016
Field study of dispersion in a heterogeneous aquifer: 3. Geostatistical analysis of hydraulic conductivity journal December 1992
Rate-limited mass transfer or macrodispersion: Which dominates plume evolution at the macrodispersion experiment (MADE) site? journal March 2000
Heterogeneity in Sedimentary Deposits: A Review of Structure-Imitating, Process-Imitating, and Descriptive Approaches journal April 1996
What do you think this is? “Conceptual uncertainty” in geoscience interpretation journal January 2007
Measuring the impact of COVID-19 vaccine misinformation on vaccination intent in the UK and USA journal February 2021
Abdominal multi-organ auto-segmentation using 3D-patch-based deep convolutional neural network journal April 2020
The Controlled Thermodynamic Integral for Bayesian Model Evidence Evaluation text January 2016
Geostatistics for environmental applications journal August 2013
Bayes factors journal November 2006
On uncertainty quantification in hydrogeology and hydrogeophysics text January 2017
Monte Carlo methods null January 1970
The controlled thermodynamic integral for Bayesian model evidence evaluation text January 2015
Parallel power posterior analyses for fast computation of marginal likelihoods in phylogenetics journal January 2021
Improving power posterior estimation of statistical evidence text January 2012
Summary statistics from training images as prior information in probabilistic inversion text January 2017
Image synthesis with graph cuts: a fast model proposal mechanism in probabilistic inversion text January 2017
Training-image based geostatistical inversion using a spatial generative adversarial neural network text January 2017
The Controlled Thermodynamic Integral for Bayesian Model Evidence Evaluation text January 2016
Training images for the MADE site dataset January 2019

Figures / Tables (15)

Algorithm 1(p. 12)figure Algorithm 1
Figure 1(p. 13)figure Figure 1
Figure 2(p. 16)figure Figure 2
Table 1(p. 17)table Table 1
Table 2(p. 17)table Table 2
Table 3(p. 18)table Table 3
Figure 3(p. 20)figure Figure 3
Table 4(p. 21)table Table 4
Figure 4(p. 22)figure Figure 4
Figure 5(p. 23)figure Figure 5
Table 5(p. 25)table Table 5
Figure 8(p. 26)figure Figure 8
Figure 9(p. 27)figure Figure 9
Figure A1(p. 31)figure Figure A1
Figure A2(p. 33)figure Figure A2

Similar Records

Related Subjects

58 GEOSCIENCES