Moderate Disturbance Has Similar Effects on Production Regardless of Site Quality and Composition
Abstract
Moderate severity disturbances, which only kill a subset of canopy trees (e.g., via insects, pathogens, and windthrow), are increasingly widespread in North America, and can alter forest structure and production. Whether the net primary production (NPP) of forest stands differing in pre-disturbance site quality and composition respond similarly to moderate severity disturbance, however, is unknown, but critical to understanding the disturbance response dynamics of patchy landscapes. We experimentally disturbed three, 2-ha stands varying in pre-disturbance primary production and community composition, temporarily reducing live stand basal area by 38% to 66%through the stem girdling of all mature early successional aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx. and Populus grandidentata Michx.) and birch (Betula papyrifera Marshall). Disturbance significantly altered stand-scale physical and biological structure and prompted a similar decade-long pattern of wood NPP decline and recovery. All stands exhibited an initial reduction in wood NPP, followed by a recovery period and eventual return to pre-disturbance levels within eight years, with the most productive stand exhibiting an increase in primary production following recovery. Following wood NPP recovery, more biologically diverse forest canopies with higher leaf area indexes intercepted more light, and, consequently, had higher rates of wood NPP. We conclude that, despite substantial pre-disturbance differences inmore »
- Authors:
-
- Virginia Commonwealth Univ., Richmond, VA (United States)
- Univ. of Connecticut, Storrs, CT (United States)
- Univ. of Michigan Biological Station, Pellston, MI (United States)
- The Ohio State Univ., Columbus, OH (United States)
- Publication Date:
- Research Org.:
- The Ohio State Univ., Columbus, OH (United States)
- Sponsoring Org.:
- USDOE Office of Science (SC)
- OSTI Identifier:
- 1510300
- Grant/Contract Number:
- SC0006708
- Resource Type:
- Accepted Manuscript
- Journal Name:
- Forests
- Additional Journal Information:
- Journal Volume: 9; Journal Issue: 2; Journal ID: ISSN 1999-4907
- Publisher:
- MDPI
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
- Subject:
- 54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES; temperate forest; carbon cycling; net primary production; disturbance; resilience; canopy structure; leaf area index; diversity; lidar; hemispherical imaging
Citation Formats
Sagara, Benjamin, Fahey, Robert, Vogel, Christoph, Fotis, Alexander, Curtis, Peter, and Gough, Christopher. Moderate Disturbance Has Similar Effects on Production Regardless of Site Quality and Composition. United States: N. p., 2018.
Web. doi:10.3390/f9020070.
Sagara, Benjamin, Fahey, Robert, Vogel, Christoph, Fotis, Alexander, Curtis, Peter, & Gough, Christopher. Moderate Disturbance Has Similar Effects on Production Regardless of Site Quality and Composition. United States. https://doi.org/10.3390/f9020070
Sagara, Benjamin, Fahey, Robert, Vogel, Christoph, Fotis, Alexander, Curtis, Peter, and Gough, Christopher. Tue .
"Moderate Disturbance Has Similar Effects on Production Regardless of Site Quality and Composition". United States. https://doi.org/10.3390/f9020070. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1510300.
@article{osti_1510300,
title = {Moderate Disturbance Has Similar Effects on Production Regardless of Site Quality and Composition},
author = {Sagara, Benjamin and Fahey, Robert and Vogel, Christoph and Fotis, Alexander and Curtis, Peter and Gough, Christopher},
abstractNote = {Moderate severity disturbances, which only kill a subset of canopy trees (e.g., via insects, pathogens, and windthrow), are increasingly widespread in North America, and can alter forest structure and production. Whether the net primary production (NPP) of forest stands differing in pre-disturbance site quality and composition respond similarly to moderate severity disturbance, however, is unknown, but critical to understanding the disturbance response dynamics of patchy landscapes. We experimentally disturbed three, 2-ha stands varying in pre-disturbance primary production and community composition, temporarily reducing live stand basal area by 38% to 66%through the stem girdling of all mature early successional aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx. and Populus grandidentata Michx.) and birch (Betula papyrifera Marshall). Disturbance significantly altered stand-scale physical and biological structure and prompted a similar decade-long pattern of wood NPP decline and recovery. All stands exhibited an initial reduction in wood NPP, followed by a recovery period and eventual return to pre-disturbance levels within eight years, with the most productive stand exhibiting an increase in primary production following recovery. Following wood NPP recovery, more biologically diverse forest canopies with higher leaf area indexes intercepted more light, and, consequently, had higher rates of wood NPP. We conclude that, despite substantial pre-disturbance differences in productivity and community composition, relative wood NPP recovery patterns can be similar, though long-term post-recovery primary production may trend higher in more productive and compositionally diverse stands. We suggest that improved mechanistic understanding of different forest ecosystems’ responses to disturbances remains critical to informing management decisions across diverse landscape mosaics.},
doi = {10.3390/f9020070},
journal = {Forests},
number = 2,
volume = 9,
place = {United States},
year = {Tue Jan 30 00:00:00 EST 2018},
month = {Tue Jan 30 00:00:00 EST 2018}
}
Web of Science
Works referenced in this record:
Influence of Disturbance on Temperate Forest Productivity
journal, September 2012
- Peters, Emily B.; Wythers, Kirk R.; Bradford, John B.
- Ecosystems, Vol. 16, Issue 1
Multi-decade biomass dynamics in an old-growth hemlock-northern hardwood forest, Michigan, USA
journal, January 2014
- Woods, Kerry D.
- PeerJ, Vol. 2
Tree species diversity mitigates disturbance impacts on the forest carbon cycle
journal, December 2014
- Silva Pedro, Mariana; Rammer, Werner; Seidl, Rupert
- Oecologia, Vol. 177, Issue 3
Influence of stocking, site quality, stand age, low-severity canopy disturbance, and forest composition on sub-boreal aspen mixedwood carbon stocks
journal, March 2014
- Reinikainen, Michael; D’Amato, Anthony W.; Bradford, John B.
- Canadian Journal of Forest Research, Vol. 44, Issue 3
Quantifying canopy complexity and effects on productivity and resilience in late-successional hemlock–hardwood forests
journal, April 2015
- Fahey, Robert T.; Fotis, Alexander T.; Woods, Kerry D.
- Ecological Applications, Vol. 25, Issue 3
Key canopy traits drive forest productivity
journal, January 2012
- Reich, Peter B.
- Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, Vol. 279, Issue 1736
The role of species mixtures in plantation forestry
journal, September 2006
- Kelty, Matthew J.
- Forest Ecology and Management, Vol. 233, Issue 2-3
A niche for neutrality
journal, February 2007
- Adler, Peter B.; HilleRisLambers, Janneke; Levine, Jonathan M.
- Ecology Letters, Vol. 10, Issue 2
Mixed-species plantations of Eucalyptus with nitrogen-fixing trees: A review
journal, September 2006
- Forrester, David I.; Bauhus, Jürgen; Cowie, Annette L.
- Forest Ecology and Management, Vol. 233, Issue 2-3
Ecosystem carbon dioxide fluxes after disturbance in forests of North America
journal, January 2010
- Amiro, B. D.; Barr, A. G.; Barr, J. G.
- Journal of Geophysical Research, Vol. 115
Observations and assessment of forest carbon dynamics following disturbance in North America: FOREST CARBON AFTER DISTURBANCE
journal, June 2012
- Goetz, S. J.; Bond-Lamberty, B.; Law, B. E.
- Journal of Geophysical Research: Biogeosciences, Vol. 117, Issue G2
Structural diversity promotes productivity of mixed, uneven-aged forests in southwestern Germany
journal, April 2016
- Dănescu, Adrian; Albrecht, Axel T.; Bauhus, Jürgen
- Oecologia, Vol. 182, Issue 2
Structural and physiological plasticity in response to light and nutrients in five temperate deciduous woody species of contrasting shade tolerance
journal, February 2007
- Portsmuth, A.; Niinemets, Ü.
- Functional Ecology, Vol. 21, Issue 1
Analysing effects of thinning on stand volume growth in relation to site conditions: A case study for even-aged Sitka spruce (Picea sitchensis (Bong.) Carr.)
journal, January 2009
- Skovsgaard, J. P.
- Forestry, Vol. 82, Issue 1
Mechanisms of Maintenance of Species Diversity
journal, November 2000
- Chesson, Peter
- Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, Vol. 31, Issue 1
Effects of diversity of tree species and size on forest basal area growth, recruitment, and mortality
journal, May 2007
- Liang, Jingjing; Buongiorno, Joseph; Monserud, Robert A.
- Forest Ecology and Management, Vol. 243, Issue 1
Don't let spurious accusations of pseudoreplication limit our ability to learn from natural experiments (and other messy kinds of ecological monitoring)
journal, October 2015
- Davies, G. Matt; Gray, Alan
- Ecology and Evolution, Vol. 5, Issue 22
Impact of mountain pine beetle on the net ecosystem production of lodgepole pine stands in British Columbia
journal, February 2010
- Brown, M.; Black, T. A.; Nesic, Z.
- Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, Vol. 150, Issue 2
The spatial and temporal dynamics of species interactions in mixed-species forests: From pattern to process
journal, January 2014
- Forrester, David I.
- Forest Ecology and Management, Vol. 312
Wood net primary production resilience in an unmanaged forest transitioning from early to middle succession
journal, June 2010
- Gough, Christopher M.; Vogel, Christoph S.; Hardiman, Brady
- Forest Ecology and Management, Vol. 260, Issue 1
Tree species richness promotes productivity in temperate forests through strong complementarity between species: Species richness promotes forest productivity
journal, September 2011
- Morin, Xavier; Fahse, Lorenz; Scherer-Lorenzen, Michael
- Ecology Letters, Vol. 14, Issue 12
Forest disturbance across the conterminous United States from 1985–2012: The emerging dominance of forest decline
journal, January 2016
- Cohen, Warren B.; Yang, Zhiqiang; Stehman, Stephen V.
- Forest Ecology and Management, Vol. 360
Multi-year convergence of biometric and meteorological estimates of forest carbon storage
journal, February 2008
- Gough, C. M.; Vogel, C. S.; Schmid, H. P.
- Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, Vol. 148, Issue 2
Changing disturbance regimes, ecological memory, and forest resilience
journal, September 2016
- Johnstone, Jill F.; Allen, Craig D.; Franklin, Jerry F.
- Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, Vol. 14, Issue 7
Effects of structural complexity on within-canopy light environments and leaf traits in a northern mixed deciduous forest
journal, January 2017
- Fotis, Alexander T.; Curtis, Peter S.
- Tree Physiology
Long-term trends in biomass and tree demography in northern hardwoods: An integrated field and simulation study
journal, November 2015
- Halpin, Corey R.; Lorimer, Craig Gordon
- Ecology
A Large and Persistent Carbon Sink in the World's Forests
journal, July 2011
- Pan, Y.; Birdsey, R. A.; Fang, J.
- Science, Vol. 333, Issue 6045
Net primary production of a temperate deciduous forest exhibits a threshold response to increasing disturbance severity
journal, September 2015
- Stuart-Haëntjens, Ellen J.; Curtis, Peter S.; Fahey, Robert T.
- Ecology, Vol. 96, Issue 9
Above-ground biomass is driven by mass-ratio effects and stand structural attributes in a temperate deciduous forest
journal, September 2017
- Fotis, Alexander T.; Murphy, Stephen J.; Ricart, Raleigh D.
- Journal of Ecology, Vol. 106, Issue 2
Moderate forest disturbance as a stringent test for gap and big-leaf models
journal, January 2015
- Bond-Lamberty, B.; Fisk, J. P.; Holm, J. A.
- Biogeosciences, Vol. 12, Issue 2
Carbon dynamics of a ponderosa pine plantation following a thinning treatment in the northern Sierra Nevada
journal, January 2009
- Campbell, John; Alberti, Giorgio; Martin, Jonathan
- Forest Ecology and Management, Vol. 257, Issue 2
Quantifying the spatio-temporal variability of net primary production of the understory species, Sasa senanensis, using multipoint measuring techniques
journal, November 2005
- Sakai, Toru; Akiyama, Tsuyoshi
- Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, Vol. 134, Issue 1-4
The Disturbing History of Intermediate Disturbance
journal, January 1999
- Wilkinson, David M.
- Oikos, Vol. 84, Issue 1
Carbon Storage on Landscapes with Stand-replacing Fires
journal, January 2006
- Kashian, Daniel M.; Romme, William H.; Tinker, Daniel B.
- BioScience, Vol. 56, Issue 7
Canopy Structural Changes Following Widespread Mortality of Canopy Dominant Trees
journal, July 2013
- Hardiman, Brady; Bohrer, Gil; Gough, Christopher
- Forests, Vol. 4, Issue 3
Site-adapted admixed tree species reduce drought susceptibility of mature European beech
journal, January 2016
- Metz, Jérôme; Annighöfer, Peter; Schall, Peter
- Global Change Biology, Vol. 22, Issue 2
Observations and modeling of aboveground tree carbon stocks and fluxes following a bark beetle outbreak in the western United States: CARBON CYCLING FOLLOWING BARK BEETLE OUTBREAK
journal, December 2010
- Pfeifer, Eric M.; Hicke, Jeffrey A.; Meddens, Arjan J. H.
- Global Change Biology, Vol. 17, Issue 1
Preface: Impacts of extreme climate events and disturbances on carbon dynamics
journal, January 2016
- Xiao, Jingfeng; Liu, Shuguang; Stoy, Paul C.
- Biogeosciences, Vol. 13, Issue 12
Mountain Pine Beetle Outbreaks in the Rocky Mountains: Regulators of Primary Productivity?
journal, April 1986
- Romme, William H.; Knight, Dennis H.; Yavitt, Joseph B.
- The American Naturalist, Vol. 127, Issue 4
Climate Change and Forest Disturbances
journal, January 2001
- Dale, Virginia H.; Joyce, Linda A.; Mcnulty, Steve
- BioScience, Vol. 51, Issue 9
Positive biodiversity-productivity relationship predominant in global forests
journal, October 2016
- Liang, J.; Crowther, T. W.; Picard, N.
- Science, Vol. 354, Issue 6309
Carbon cycling and storage in world forests: biome patterns related to forest age
journal, December 2004
- Pregitzer, Kurt S.; Euskirchen, Eugenie S.
- Global Change Biology, Vol. 10, Issue 12
Evaluating forest subcanopy response to moderate severity disturbance and contribution to ecosystem-level productivity and resilience
journal, September 2016
- Fahey, Robert T.; Stuart-Haëntjens, Ellen J.; Gough, Christopher M.
- Forest Ecology and Management, Vol. 376
The role of canopy structural complexity in wood net primary production of a maturing northern deciduous forest
journal, September 2011
- Hardiman, Brady S.; Bohrer, Gil; Gough, Christopher M.
- Ecology, Vol. 92, Issue 9
A portable LIDAR system for rapid determination of forest canopy structure: Portable LIDAR for canopy structure
journal, July 2004
- Parker, Geoffrey G.; Harding, David J.; Berger, Michelle L.
- Journal of Applied Ecology, Vol. 41, Issue 4
Combining richness and abundance into a single diversity index using matrix analogues of Shannon's and Simpson's indices
journal, August 2006
- Gorelick, Root
- Ecography, Vol. 29, Issue 4
Responses of Temperate Forest Productivity to Insect and Pathogen Disturbances
journal, April 2015
- Flower, Charles E.; Gonzalez-Meler, Miquel A.
- Annual Review of Plant Biology, Vol. 66, Issue 1
The legacy of harvest and fire on ecosystem carbon storage in a north temperate forest
journal, September 2007
- Gough, Christopher M.; Vogel, Christoph S.; Harrold, Katherine H.
- Global Change Biology, Vol. 13, Issue 9
Diversity and Evenness: A Unifying Notation and Its Consequences
journal, March 1973
- Hill, M. O.
- Ecology, Vol. 54, Issue 2
A synthesis of current knowledge on forests and carbon storage in the United States
journal, September 2011
- McKinley, Duncan C.; Ryan, Michael G.; Birdsey, Richard A.
- Ecological Applications, Vol. 21, Issue 6
Disturbance, complexity, and succession of net ecosystem production in North America's temperate deciduous forests
journal, June 2016
- Gough, Christopher M.; Curtis, Peter S.; Hardiman, Brady S.
- Ecosphere, Vol. 7, Issue 6
Biodiversity and ecosystem functioning: A mechanistic model
journal, May 1998
- Loreau, M.
- Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Vol. 95, Issue 10
Effects of biotic disturbances on forest carbon cycling in the United States and Canada
journal, October 2011
- Hicke, Jeffrey A.; Allen, Craig D.; Desai, Ankur R.
- Global Change Biology, Vol. 18, Issue 1
Simulating coupled carbon and nitrogen dynamics following mountain pine beetle outbreaks in the western United States
journal, January 2011
- Edburg, Steven L.; Hicke, Jeffrey A.; Lawrence, David M.
- Journal of Geophysical Research, Vol. 116, Issue G4
Impacts of the emerald ash borer (Agrilus planipennis Fairmaire) induced ash (Fraxinus spp.) mortality on forest carbon cycling and successional dynamics in the eastern United States
journal, September 2012
- Flower, Charles E.; Knight, Kathleen S.; Gonzalez-Meler, Miquel A.
- Biological Invasions, Vol. 15, Issue 4
Probabilities of small-gap capture by sugar maple saplings based on height and crown growth data from felled trees
journal, March 2005
- Cole, William G.; Lorimer, Craig G.
- Canadian Journal of Forest Research, Vol. 35, Issue 3
Forest productivity increases with evenness, species richness and trait variation: a global meta-analysis
journal, January 2012
- Zhang, Yu; Chen, Han Y. H.; Reich, Peter B.
- Journal of Ecology, Vol. 100, Issue 3
Carbon consequences of forest disturbance and recovery across the conterminous United States: FOREST DISTURBANCE AND CARBON DYNAMICS
journal, January 2012
- Williams, Christopher A.; Collatz, G. James; Masek, Jeffrey
- Global Biogeochemical Cycles, Vol. 26, Issue 1
Sustained carbon uptake and storage following moderate disturbance in a Great Lakes forest
journal, July 2013
- Gough, Christopher M.; Hardiman, Brady S.; Nave, Lucas E.
- Ecological Applications, Vol. 23, Issue 5
Maintaining high rates of carbon storage in old forests: A mechanism linking canopy structure to forest function
journal, June 2013
- Hardiman, Brady S.; Gough, Christopher M.; Halperin, Abby
- Forest Ecology and Management, Vol. 298
Effects of canopy structure and species diversity on primary production in upper Great Lakes forests
journal, August 2018
- Scheuermann, Cynthia M.; Nave, Lucas E.; Fahey, Robert T.
- Oecologia, Vol. 188, Issue 2
Positive biodiversity-productivity relationship predominant in global forests
text, January 2016
- Fischer, Markus; Ba Azy, R.; Neldner, V. J.
- American Association for the Advancement of Science
Ecosystem carbon dioxide fluxes after disturbance in forests of North America
text, January 2010
- Davis, K. J.; Clark, K. L.; Chen, J.
- American Geophysical Union
Positive biodiversity-productivity relationship predominant in global forests
text, January 2016
- Liang, J.; Crowther, T. W.; Picard, N.
- American Association for the Advancement of Science
Don't let spurious accusations of pseudoreplication limit our ability to learn from natural experiments (and other messy kinds of ecological monitoring)
journal, October 2015
- Davies, G. Matt; Gray, Alan
- Ecology and Evolution, Vol. 5, Issue 22
Biodiversity and ecosystem functioning: A mechanistic model
journal, May 1998
- Loreau, M.
- Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Vol. 95, Issue 10
Analysing effects of thinning on stand volume growth in relation to site conditions: A case study for even-aged Sitka spruce (Picea sitchensis (Bong.) Carr.)
journal, January 2009
- Skovsgaard, J. P.
- Forestry, Vol. 82, Issue 1
Structural and physiological plasticity in response to light and nutrients in five temperate deciduous woody species of contrasting shade tolerance
journal, February 2007
- Portsmuth, A.; Niinemets, Ü.
- Functional Ecology, Vol. 21, Issue 1
Carbon cycling and storage in world forests: biome patterns related to forest age
journal, December 2004
- Pregitzer, Kurt S.; Euskirchen, Eugenie S.
- Global Change Biology, Vol. 10, Issue 12
Quantifying canopy complexity and effects on productivity and resilience in late-successional hemlock–hardwood forests
journal, April 2015
- Fahey, Robert T.; Fotis, Alexander T.; Woods, Kerry D.
- Ecological Applications, Vol. 25, Issue 3
Net primary production of a temperate deciduous forest exhibits a threshold response to increasing disturbance severity
journal, September 2015
- Stuart-Haëntjens, Ellen J.; Curtis, Peter S.; Fahey, Robert T.
- Ecology, Vol. 96, Issue 9
Canopy Structural Changes Following Widespread Mortality of Canopy Dominant Trees
journal, July 2013
- Hardiman, Brady; Bohrer, Gil; Gough, Christopher
- Forests, Vol. 4, Issue 3
Works referencing / citing this record:
Understanding forest dynamics by integrating age and environmental change
journal, February 2020
- Zhu, Kai
- New Phytologist
Spatial Variation in Canopy Structure across Forest Landscapes
journal, August 2018
- Hardiman, Brady; LaRue, Elizabeth; Atkins, Jeff
- Forests, Vol. 9, Issue 8