Reexamination of a novel determination of density, temperature, and symmetry energy based on a modified Fisher model
Abstract
Excited nuclei behave like liquid droplets and undergo phase transition at finite excitation temperatures; as proposed by M.E. Fisher in 1967 in order to describe the power law behavior of the “fragment” mass distribution around the critical point for a liquidgas phase transition. In the early 1980s, the pioneering work of the Purdue group generated a novel classical droplet model based on the Fischer Model, which was the socalled Modified Fisher Model(MFM). In this article, a mistake in the formulation of the Modified Fisher Model (MFM) is addressed and corrected by reversing the sign of the mixing entropy term in the original formulation. The errors in the results of the previous MFMrelated studies, such as isotopic yield distribution, isobaric yield ratios, isoscaling, mscaling, selfconsistent, determination of density, symmetry energy and temperature, and density and temperature determination related to the IMF Freeze out, are quantitatively analyzed. It is found that the errors originating from the mistake in sign of the mixing entropy term are generally small and even have no effect in some cases.
 Authors:

 Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS), Lanzhou (China)
 Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare (INFN), Catania (Italy). Lab. Nazionali del Sud (INFNLNS)
 Inner Mongolia Univ. for Nationalities, Tongliao (China)
 Texas A & M Univ., College Station, TX (United States)
 Texas A & M Univ., College Station, TX (United States); Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare (INFN), Catania (Italy). Lab. Nazionali del Sud (INFNLNS)
 Publication Date:
 Research Org.:
 Texas A & M Univ., College Station, TX (United States)
 Sponsoring Org.:
 USDOE National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA)
 OSTI Identifier:
 1498070
 Alternate Identifier(s):
 OSTI ID: 1418075
 Grant/Contract Number:
 NA0003841; DE–FG03–93ER40773
 Resource Type:
 Accepted Manuscript
 Journal Name:
 Physical Review C
 Additional Journal Information:
 Journal Volume: 97; Journal Issue: 1; Journal ID: ISSN 24699985
 Publisher:
 American Physical Society (APS)
 Country of Publication:
 United States
 Language:
 English
 Subject:
 73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS
Citation Formats
Liu, X., Zheng, H., Lin, W., Huang, M., Yang, Y. Y., Wang, J. S., Wada, R., Bonasera, A., and Natowitz, J. B. Reexamination of a novel determination of density, temperature, and symmetry energy based on a modified Fisher model. United States: N. p., 2018.
Web. doi:10.1103/physrevc.97.014613.
Liu, X., Zheng, H., Lin, W., Huang, M., Yang, Y. Y., Wang, J. S., Wada, R., Bonasera, A., & Natowitz, J. B. Reexamination of a novel determination of density, temperature, and symmetry energy based on a modified Fisher model. United States. https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevc.97.014613
Liu, X., Zheng, H., Lin, W., Huang, M., Yang, Y. Y., Wang, J. S., Wada, R., Bonasera, A., and Natowitz, J. B. Thu .
"Reexamination of a novel determination of density, temperature, and symmetry energy based on a modified Fisher model". United States. https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevc.97.014613. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1498070.
@article{osti_1498070,
title = {Reexamination of a novel determination of density, temperature, and symmetry energy based on a modified Fisher model},
author = {Liu, X. and Zheng, H. and Lin, W. and Huang, M. and Yang, Y. Y. and Wang, J. S. and Wada, R. and Bonasera, A. and Natowitz, J. B.},
abstractNote = {Excited nuclei behave like liquid droplets and undergo phase transition at finite excitation temperatures; as proposed by M.E. Fisher in 1967 in order to describe the power law behavior of the “fragment” mass distribution around the critical point for a liquidgas phase transition. In the early 1980s, the pioneering work of the Purdue group generated a novel classical droplet model based on the Fischer Model, which was the socalled Modified Fisher Model(MFM). In this article, a mistake in the formulation of the Modified Fisher Model (MFM) is addressed and corrected by reversing the sign of the mixing entropy term in the original formulation. The errors in the results of the previous MFMrelated studies, such as isotopic yield distribution, isobaric yield ratios, isoscaling, mscaling, selfconsistent, determination of density, symmetry energy and temperature, and density and temperature determination related to the IMF Freeze out, are quantitatively analyzed. It is found that the errors originating from the mistake in sign of the mixing entropy term are generally small and even have no effect in some cases.},
doi = {10.1103/physrevc.97.014613},
journal = {Physical Review C},
number = 1,
volume = 97,
place = {United States},
year = {2018},
month = {1}
}
Web of Science
Figures / Tables:
Works referenced in this record:
Isobaric yield ratios and the symmetry energy in heavyion reactions near the Fermi energy
journal, April 2010
 Huang, M.; Chen, Z.; Kowalski, S.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 81, Issue 4
Giant quadrupole resonances in ${}^{208}$ Pb, the nuclear symmetry energy, and the neutron skin thickness
journal, March 2013
 RocaMaza, X.; Brenna, M.; Agrawal, B. K.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 87, Issue 3
Experimental reconstruction of primary hot isotopes and characteristic properties of the fragmenting source in heavyion reactions near the Fermi energy
journal, October 2014
 Lin, W.; Liu, X.; Rodrigues, M. R. D.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 90, Issue 4
Giant dipole resonance as a quantitative constraint on the symmetry energy
journal, June 2008
 Trippa, Luca; Colò, Gianluca; Vigezzi, Enrico
 Physical Review C, Vol. 77, Issue 6
Competition between fermions and bosons in nuclear matter at low densities and finite temperatures
journal, December 2016
 Mabiala, J.; Zheng, H.; Bonasera, A.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 94, Issue 6
The Symmetry Energy from the NeutronRich Nucleus Produced in the IntermediateEnergy ^{40,48} Ca and ^{58,64} Ni Projectile Fragmentation
journal, June 2012
 Ma, ChunWang; Pu, Jie; Wang, ShanShan
 Chinese Physics Letters, Vol. 29, Issue 6
Isospin dependence of ${}^{6}\mathrm{He}+p$ optical potential and the symmetry energy
journal, April 2005
 Khoa, Dao T.; Than, Hoang Sy
 Physical Review C, Vol. 71, Issue 4
Antisymmetrized molecular dynamics of wave packets with stochastic incorporation of the Vlasov equation
journal, June 1996
 Ono, Akira; Horiuchi, Hisashi
 Physical Review C, Vol. 53, Issue 6
Analysis of fragment yield ratios in the nuclear phase transition
journal, May 2011
 Tripathi, R.; Bonasera, A.; Wuenschel, S.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 83, Issue 5
Temperature determined by isobaric yield ratios in heavyion collisions
journal, November 2012
 Ma, C. W.; Pu, J.; Ma, Y. G.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 86, Issue 5
Investigation of the nuclear phase transition using the Landau freeenergy approach
journal, January 2013
 Mabiala, J.; Bonasera, A.; Zheng, H.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 87, Issue 1
Power law behavior of the isotope yield distributions in the multifragmentation regime of heavy ion reactions
journal, November 2010
 Huang, M.; Wada, R.; Chen, Z.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 82, Issue 5
Probing Temperature from Intermediate Mass Fragment by Isobaric Yield Ratio in HeavyIon Collisions
journal, December 2015
 Yu, Mian; Wei, HuiLing; Ma, ChunWang
 Communications in Theoretical Physics, Vol. 64, Issue 6
Isospin Diffusion and the Nuclear Symmetry Energy in Heavy Ion Reactions
journal, February 2004
 Tsang, M. B.; Liu, T. X.; Shi, L.
 Physical Review Letters, Vol. 92, Issue 6
Novel determination of density, temperature, and symmetry energy for nuclear multifragmentation through primary fragmentyield reconstruction
journal, February 2014
 Lin, W.; Liu, X.; Rodrigues, M. R. D.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 89, Issue 2
Temperature of intermediate mass fragments in simulated 40Ca + 40Ca reactions around the Fermi energies by AMD model
journal, August 2016
 Ma, ChunWang; Qiao, ChunYuan; Ding, TianTian
 Nuclear Science and Techniques, Vol. 27, Issue 5
The many facets of the (nonrelativistic) Nuclear Equation of State
journal, May 2014
 Giuliani, G.; Zheng, H.; Bonasera, A.
 Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics, Vol. 76
Zur Theorie der Kernmassen
journal, July 1935
 Weizs�cker, C. F. v.
 Zeitschrift f�r Physik, Vol. 96, Issue 78
Reexamination of FiniteSize Effects in Isobaric Yield Ratios Using a Statistical AbrasionAblation Model
journal, May 2013
 Ma, ChunWang; Wang, ShanShan; Wei, HuiLing
 Chinese Physics Letters, Vol. 30, Issue 5
Pairing energy of fragments produced in intermediateenergy heavyion collisions
journal, August 2016
 Ma, ChunWang; Niu, Fei; Qiao, ChunYuan
 Physical Review C, Vol. 94, Issue 2
Nuclear matter symmetry energy at $0.03\u2a7d\rho /{\rho}_{0}\u2a7d0.2$
journal, June 2012
 Wada, R.; Hagel, K.; Qin, L.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 85, Issue 6
Isocaling and the symmetry energy in the multifragmentation regime of heavyion collisions
journal, June 2010
 Chen, Z.; Kowalski, S.; Huang, M.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 81, Issue 6
Critical phenomena in hadronic matter and experimental isotopic yields in high energy protonnucleus collisions
journal, December 1982
 Minich, R. W.; Agarwal, S.; Bujak, A.
 Physics Letters B, Vol. 118, Issue 46
The description of fragmentation as a critical phenomenon in high energy Pnucleus collisions
journal, April 1984
 Hirsch, A. S.; Bujak, A.; Finn, J. E.
 Nuclear Physics A, Vol. 418
Nuclear Physics A. Stationary States of Nuclei
journal, April 1936
 Bethe, H. A.; Bacher, R. F.
 Reviews of Modern Physics, Vol. 8, Issue 2
Reconstructed primary fragments and symmetry energy, temperature and density of the fragmenting source in ${}^{64}\mathrm{Zn}+{}^{112}\mathrm{Sn}$ at $40\text{}\text{MeV}/\text{nucleon}$
journal, January 2015
 Liu, X.; Lin, W.; Wada, R.
 Nuclear Physics A, Vol. 933
Antisymmetrized molecular dynamics with quantum branching processes for collisions of heavy nuclei
journal, February 1999
 Ono, Akira
 Physical Review C, Vol. 59, Issue 2
A novel approach to isoscaling: The role of the order parameter
journal, December 2010
 Huang, M.; Chen, Z.; Kowalski, S.
 Nuclear Physics A, Vol. 847, Issue 34
Symmetry energy from neutronrich fragments in heavyion collisions, and its dependence on incident energy, and impact parameters
journal, February 2013
 Ma, ChunWang; Song, HengLi; Pu, Jie
 Chinese Physics C, Vol. 37, Issue 2
Symmetry energy and experimentally observed cold fragments in intermediate heavyion collisions
journal, April 2017
 Zhang, SuYaLaTu; Huang, MeiRong; Wada, R.
 Chinese Physics C, Vol. 41, Issue 4
Freezeout concept and dynamical transport model in intermediateenergy heavyion reactions
journal, July 2015
 Liu, X.; Lin, W.; Huang, M.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 92, Issue 1
Isobaric yield ratios in heavyion reactions, and symmetry energy of neutronrich nuclei at intermediate energies
journal, June 2011
 Ma, ChunWang; Wang, Fang; Ma, YuGang
 Physical Review C, Vol. 83, Issue 6
The theory of equilibrium critical phenomena
journal, July 1967
 Fisher, M. E.
 Reports on Progress in Physics, Vol. 30, Issue 2
Experimental determination of the symmetry energy of a low density nuclear gas
journal, January 2007
 Kowalski, S.; Natowitz, J. B.; Shlomo, S.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 75, Issue 1
Symmetry energy and the isospin dependent equation of state
journal, July 2004
 Shetty, D. V.; Yennello, S. J.; Botvina, A. S.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 70, Issue 1
Constraining the symmetry term in the nuclear equation of state at subsaturation densities and finite temperatures
journal, March 2012
 Marini, P.; Bonasera, A.; McIntosh, A.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 85, Issue 3
Symmetry energy for fragmentation in dynamical nuclear collisions
journal, October 2004
 Ono, Akira; Danielewicz, P.; Friedman, W.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 70, Issue 4
Projectile fragmentation of ${}^{40}\mathrm{Ca}$ , ${}^{48}\mathrm{Ca}$ , ${}^{58}\mathrm{Ni}$ , and ${}^{64}\mathrm{Ni}$ at 140 MeV/nucleon
journal, November 2006
 Mocko, M.; Tsang, M. B.; Andronenko, L.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 74, Issue 5
Primary isotope yields and characteristic properties of the fragmenting source in heavyion reactions near the Fermi energy
journal, July 2014
 Liu, X.; Lin, W.; Wada, R.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 90, Issue 1
Symmetry energy extracted from fragments in relativistic energy heavyion collisions induced by 124,136Xe
journal, June 2012
 Ma, ChunWang; Pu, Jie; Wei, HuiLing
 The European Physical Journal A, Vol. 48, Issue 6
Residue Coulomb Interaction Among Isobars and Its Influence in Symmetry Energy of NeutronRich Fragment
journal, September 2015
 Ma, ChunWang; Wang, ShanShan; Zhang, YanLi
 Communications in Theoretical Physics, Vol. 64, Issue 3
Erratum: Novel determination of density, temperature, and symmetry energy for nuclear multifragmentation through primary fragmentyield reconstruction [Phys. Rev. C 89 , 021601(R) (2014)]
journal, March 2017
 Lin, W.; Liu, X.; Rodrigues, M. R. D.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 95, Issue 3
Neutronskin effects in isobaric yield ratios for mirror nuclei in a statistical abrasionablation model
journal, October 2013
 Ma, ChunWang; Wei, HuiLing; Ma, YuGang
 Physical Review C, Vol. 88, Issue 4
Quantum Nature of a Nuclear Phase Transition
journal, September 2008
 Bonasera, A.; Chen, Z.; Wada, R.
 Physical Review Letters, Vol. 101, Issue 12
Density dependence of the symmetry energy and the nuclear equation of state: A dynamical and statistical model perspective
journal, August 2007
 Shetty, D. V.; Yennello, S. J.; Souliotis, G. A.
 Physical Review C, Vol. 76, Issue 2
Constraints on the Density Dependence of the Symmetry Energy
journal, March 2009
 Tsang, M. B.; Zhang, Yingxun; Danielewicz, P.
 Physical Review Letters, Vol. 102, Issue 12
The theory of equilibrium critical phenomena
journal, January 1968
 Fisher, M. E.
 Reports on Progress in Physics, Vol. 31, Issue 1
Isobaric yield ratios in heavyion reactions, and symmetry energy of neutronrich nuclei at intermediate energies
text, January 2014
 Ma, ChunWang; Wang, Fang; Ma, YuGang
 Unpublished
The Quantum Nature of a Nuclear Phase Transition
text, January 2008
 Bonasera, A.; Chen, Z.; Wada, R.
 arXiv
Critical behavior of the isotope yield distributions in the Multifragmentation Regime of Heavy Ion Reactions
text, January 2010
 Huang, M.; Wada, R.; Chen, Z.
 arXiv
Analysis of fragment yield ratios in the nuclear phase transition
text, January 2010
 Tripathi, R.; Bonasera, A.; Wuenschel, S.
 arXiv
Isobaric yield ratios in heavyion reactions, and symmetry energy of neutronrich nuclei at intermediate energies
text, January 2011
 Ma, ChunWang; Wang, Fang; Ma, YuGang
 arXiv
Reexamining the "finitesize" effects in isobaric yield ratios using a statistical abrasionablation model
text, January 2012
 Ma, C. W.; Wang, S. S.; Wei, H. L.
 arXiv
Temperature determined by isobaric yield ratio in heavyion collisions
text, January 2012
 Ma, C. W.; Pu, J.; Ma, Y. G.
 arXiv
Neutronskin effects in isobaric yield ratio for mirror nuclei in statistical abrasionablation model
text, January 2013
 Ma, Chunwang; Wei, Huiling; Ma, Yugang
 arXiv
Residue Coulomb interaction among isobars and its influence in symmetry energy of neutronrich fragment
text, January 2014
 Ma, ChunWang; Wang, ShanSha n.; Zhang, YanLi
 arXiv
Primary Isotope Yields and Characteristic Properties of the Fragmenting Source in Heavyion Reactions near the Fermi Energies
text, January 2014
 Liu, X.; Lin, W.; Wada, R.
 arXiv
Symmetry energy and the isospin dependent equation of state
text, January 2004
 Shetty, D. V.; Yennello, S. J.; Botvina, A.
 arXiv
Experimental determination of the symmetry energy of a low density nuclear gas
text, January 2006
 Kowalski, S.; Natowitz, J. B.; Shlomo, S.
 arXiv
Symmetry energy for fragmentation in dynamical nuclear collisions
text, January 2004
 Ono, Akira; Danielewicz, P.; Friedman, W. A.
 arXiv
Antisymmetrized molecular dynamics of wave packets with stochastic incorporation of Vlasov equation
text, January 1996
 Ono, Akira; Horiuchi, Hisashi
 arXiv