skip to main content
DOE PAGES title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. VIII. A Comparison to Cosmological Short-duration Gamma-Ray Bursts

Abstract

Here, we present a comprehensive comparison of the properties of the radio through X-ray counterpart of GW170817 and the properties of short-duration gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). For this effort, we utilize a sample of 36 short GRBs spanning a redshift range of $$z \approx 0.12-2.6$$ discovered over 2004-2017. We find that the counterpart to GW170817 has an isotropic-equivalent luminosity that is $$\approx 3000$$ times less than the median value of on-axis short GRB X-ray afterglows, and $$\gtrsim10^{4}$$ times less than that for detected short GRB radio afterglows. Moreover, the allowed jet energies and particle densities inferred from the radio and X-ray counterparts to GW170817 and on-axis short GRB afterglows are remarkably similar, suggesting that viewing angle effects are the dominant, and perhaps only, difference in their observed radio and X-ray behavior. From comparison to previous claimed kilonovae following short GRBs, we find that the optical and near-IR counterpart to GW170817 is comparatively under-luminous by a factor of $$\approx 3-5$$, indicating a range of kilonova luminosities and timescales. A comparison of the optical limits following short GRBs on $$\lesssim 1$$ day timescales also rules out a "blue" kilonova of comparable optical isotropic-equivalent luminosity in one previous short GRB. Finally, we investigate the host galaxy of GW170817, NGC4993, in the context of short GRB host galaxy stellar population properties. We find that NGC4993 is superlative in terms of its large luminosity, old stellar population age, and low star formation rate compared to previous short GRB hosts. Additional events within the Advanced LIGO/VIRGO volume will be crucial in delineating the properties of the host galaxies of NS-NS mergers, and connecting them to their cosmological counterparts.

Authors:
ORCiD logo [1]; ORCiD logo [2];  [2]; ORCiD logo [1]; ORCiD logo [2];  [3]; ORCiD logo [2];  [4];  [2];  [2];  [2];  [2];  [5];  [6];  [7];  [8];  [8];  [5];  [9];  [10] more »;  [6];  [11] « less
  1. Northwestern Univ., Evanston, IL (United States)
  2. Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, Cambridge, MA (United States)
  3. Ohio Univ., Athens, OH (United States)
  4. Columbia Univ., New York, NY (United States)
  5. Fermi National Accelerator Lab. (FNAL), Batavia, IL (United States)
  6. Univ. of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA (United States)
  7. Syracuse Univ., Syracuse, NY (United States)
  8. Univ. of Chicago, Chicago, IL (United States)
  9. Univ. of Chicago, Chicago, IL (United States); Enrico Fermi Institute, Chicago, IL (United States)
  10. Space Telescope Science Institute, Baltimore, MD (United States); The Johns Hopkins Univ., Baltimore, MD (United States)
  11. Fermi National Accelerator Lab. (FNAL), Batavia, IL (United States); Brandeis Univ., Waltham, MA (United States)
Publication Date:
Research Org.:
Fermi National Accelerator Lab. (FNAL), Batavia, IL (United States)
Sponsoring Org.:
USDOE Office of Science (SC), High Energy Physics (HEP) (SC-25)
OSTI Identifier:
1408214
Report Number(s):
arXiv:1710.05438; FERMILAB-PUB-17-498-AE-CD
Journal ID: ISSN 2041-8213; 1630781; TRN: US1702934
Grant/Contract Number:  
AC02-07CH11359
Resource Type:
Accepted Manuscript
Journal Name:
The Astrophysical Journal. Letters
Additional Journal Information:
Journal Volume: 848; Journal Issue: 2; Journal ID: ISSN 2041-8213
Publisher:
Institute of Physics (IOP)
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Subject:
79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS; gamma-ray burst: general; gravitational waves; stars: neutron

Citation Formats

Fong, W., Berger, E., Blanchard, P. K., Margutti, R., Cowperthwaite, P. S., Chornock, R., Alexander, K. D., Metzger, B. D., Villar, V. A., Nicholl, M., Eftekhari, T., Williams, P. K. G., Annis, J., Brout, D., Brown, D. A., Chen, H. -Y., Doctor, Z., Diehl, H. T., Holz, D. E., Rest, A., Sako, M., and Soares-Santos, M. The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. VIII. A Comparison to Cosmological Short-duration Gamma-Ray Bursts. United States: N. p., 2017. Web. doi:10.3847/2041-8213/aa9018.
Fong, W., Berger, E., Blanchard, P. K., Margutti, R., Cowperthwaite, P. S., Chornock, R., Alexander, K. D., Metzger, B. D., Villar, V. A., Nicholl, M., Eftekhari, T., Williams, P. K. G., Annis, J., Brout, D., Brown, D. A., Chen, H. -Y., Doctor, Z., Diehl, H. T., Holz, D. E., Rest, A., Sako, M., & Soares-Santos, M. The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. VIII. A Comparison to Cosmological Short-duration Gamma-Ray Bursts. United States. doi:10.3847/2041-8213/aa9018.
Fong, W., Berger, E., Blanchard, P. K., Margutti, R., Cowperthwaite, P. S., Chornock, R., Alexander, K. D., Metzger, B. D., Villar, V. A., Nicholl, M., Eftekhari, T., Williams, P. K. G., Annis, J., Brout, D., Brown, D. A., Chen, H. -Y., Doctor, Z., Diehl, H. T., Holz, D. E., Rest, A., Sako, M., and Soares-Santos, M. Mon . "The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. VIII. A Comparison to Cosmological Short-duration Gamma-Ray Bursts". United States. doi:10.3847/2041-8213/aa9018. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1408214.
@article{osti_1408214,
title = {The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. VIII. A Comparison to Cosmological Short-duration Gamma-Ray Bursts},
author = {Fong, W. and Berger, E. and Blanchard, P. K. and Margutti, R. and Cowperthwaite, P. S. and Chornock, R. and Alexander, K. D. and Metzger, B. D. and Villar, V. A. and Nicholl, M. and Eftekhari, T. and Williams, P. K. G. and Annis, J. and Brout, D. and Brown, D. A. and Chen, H. -Y. and Doctor, Z. and Diehl, H. T. and Holz, D. E. and Rest, A. and Sako, M. and Soares-Santos, M.},
abstractNote = {Here, we present a comprehensive comparison of the properties of the radio through X-ray counterpart of GW170817 and the properties of short-duration gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). For this effort, we utilize a sample of 36 short GRBs spanning a redshift range of $z \approx 0.12-2.6$ discovered over 2004-2017. We find that the counterpart to GW170817 has an isotropic-equivalent luminosity that is $\approx 3000$ times less than the median value of on-axis short GRB X-ray afterglows, and $\gtrsim10^{4}$ times less than that for detected short GRB radio afterglows. Moreover, the allowed jet energies and particle densities inferred from the radio and X-ray counterparts to GW170817 and on-axis short GRB afterglows are remarkably similar, suggesting that viewing angle effects are the dominant, and perhaps only, difference in their observed radio and X-ray behavior. From comparison to previous claimed kilonovae following short GRBs, we find that the optical and near-IR counterpart to GW170817 is comparatively under-luminous by a factor of $\approx 3-5$, indicating a range of kilonova luminosities and timescales. A comparison of the optical limits following short GRBs on $\lesssim 1$ day timescales also rules out a "blue" kilonova of comparable optical isotropic-equivalent luminosity in one previous short GRB. Finally, we investigate the host galaxy of GW170817, NGC4993, in the context of short GRB host galaxy stellar population properties. We find that NGC4993 is superlative in terms of its large luminosity, old stellar population age, and low star formation rate compared to previous short GRB hosts. Additional events within the Advanced LIGO/VIRGO volume will be crucial in delineating the properties of the host galaxies of NS-NS mergers, and connecting them to their cosmological counterparts.},
doi = {10.3847/2041-8213/aa9018},
journal = {The Astrophysical Journal. Letters},
number = 2,
volume = 848,
place = {United States},
year = {2017},
month = {10}
}

Journal Article:
Free Publicly Available Full Text
Publisher's Version of Record

Citation Metrics:
Cited by: 22 works
Citation information provided by
Web of Science

Save / Share:

Works referenced in this record:

Effect of a high Opacity on the Light Curves of Radioactively Powered Transients from Compact Object Mergers
journal, August 2013


A Study of Compact Object Mergers as Short Gamma‐Ray Burst Progenitors
journal, September 2006

  • Belczynski, Krzysztof; Perna, Rosalba; Bulik, Tomasz
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 648, Issue 2
  • DOI: 10.1086/505169

Stellar Mass‐to‐Light Ratios and the Tully‐Fisher Relation
journal, March 2001

  • Bell, Eric F.; de Jong, Roelof S.
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 550, Issue 1
  • DOI: 10.1086/319728

Short-Duration Gamma-Ray Bursts
journal, August 2014


AN r -PROCESS KILONOVA ASSOCIATED WITH THE SHORT-HARD GRB 130603B
journal, August 2013


The afterglow and elliptical host galaxy of the short γ-ray burst GRB 050724
journal, December 2005


The Afterglow and Ulirg host Galaxy of the dark Short grb 120804a
journal, February 2013


The Galaxy Luminosity Function and Luminosity Density at Redshift z = 0.1
journal, August 2003

  • Blanton, Michael R.; Hogg, David W.; Bahcall, Neta A.
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 592, Issue 2
  • DOI: 10.1086/375776

Closing in on a Short‐Hard Burst Progenitor: Constraints from Early‐Time Optical Imaging and Spectroscopy of a Possible Host Galaxy of GRB 050509b
journal, February 2006

  • Bloom, J. S.; Prochaska, J. X.; Pooley, D.
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 638, Issue 1
  • DOI: 10.1086/498107

The Swift X-Ray Telescope
journal, October 2005


Swope Supernova Survey 2017a (SSS17a), the optical counterpart to a gravitational wave source
journal, October 2017


Spectroscopy of the short-hard GRB 130603B: The host galaxy and environment of a compact object merger⋆
journal, March 2014


Nucleosynthesis, neutrino bursts and γ-rays from coalescing neutron stars
journal, July 1989

  • Eichler, David; Livio, Mario; Piran, Tsvi
  • Nature, Vol. 340, Issue 6229
  • DOI: 10.1038/340126a0

An online repository of Swift /XRT light curves of $\vec \gamma$-ray bursts
journal, April 2007


Methods and results of an automatic analysis of a complete sample of Swift -XRT observations of GRBs
journal, August 2009


Swift and NuSTAR observations of GW170817: Detection of a blue kilonova
journal, October 2017


The Locations of Short Gamma-Ray Bursts as Evidence for Compact Object Binary Progenitors
journal, September 2013


HUBBLE SPACE TELESCOPE OBSERVATIONS OF SHORT GAMMA-RAY BURST HOST GALAXIES: MORPHOLOGIES, OFFSETS, AND LOCAL ENVIRONMENTS
journal, December 2009


Demographics of the Galaxies Hosting Short-Duration Gamma-Ray Bursts
journal, May 2013


A Decade of Short-Duration Gamma-Ray Burst Broadband Afterglows: Energetics, Circumburst Densities, and jet Opening Angles
journal, December 2015


Short grb 130603b: Discovery of a jet Break in the Optical and Radio Afterglows, and a Mysterious Late-Time X-Ray Excess
journal, December 2013


THE AFTERGLOW AND EARLY-TYPE HOST GALAXY OF THE SHORT GRB 150101B AT z = 0.1343
journal, December 2016


The afterglow of GRB 050709 and the nature of the short-hard γ-ray bursts
journal, October 2005


A novel explosive process is required for the γ-ray burst GRB 060614
journal, December 2006


The Swift Gamma‐Ray Burst Mission
journal, August 2004

  • Gehrels, N.; Chincarini, G.; Giommi, P.
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 611, Issue 2
  • DOI: 10.1086/422091

A short γ-ray burst apparently associated with an elliptical galaxy at redshift z = 0.225
journal, October 2005

  • Gehrels, N.; Sarazin, C. L.; O'Brien, P. T.
  • Nature, Vol. 437, Issue 7060
  • DOI: 10.1038/nature04142

An Ordinary Short Gamma-Ray Burst with Extraordinary Implications: Fermi -GBM Detection of GRB 170817A
journal, October 2017


GRB 050509B: Constraints on Short Gamma-Ray Burst Models
journal, August 2005

  • Hjorth, J.; Sollerman, J.; Gorosabel, J.
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 630, Issue 2
  • DOI: 10.1086/491733

The optical afterglow of the short γ-ray burst GRB 050709
journal, October 2005

  • Hjorth, Jens; Watson, Darach; Fynbo, Johan P. U.
  • Nature, Vol. 437, Issue 7060
  • DOI: 10.1038/nature04174

The Macronova in GRB 050709 and the GRB-macronova connection
journal, September 2016

  • Jin, Zhi-Ping; Hotokezaka, Kenta; Li, Xiang
  • Nature Communications, Vol. 7, Issue 1
  • DOI: 10.1038/ncomms12898

The Light Curve of the Macronova Associated with the Long–Short Burst grb 060614
journal, September 2015


Kilonova light curves from the disc wind outflows of compact object mergers
journal, April 2015

  • Kasen, Daniel; Fernández, Rodrigo; Metzger, Brian D.
  • Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Vol. 450, Issue 2
  • DOI: 10.1093/mnras/stv721

Infrared Emission from Kilonovae: The Case of the Nearby Short Hard Burst GRB 160821B
journal, July 2017

  • Kasliwal, Mansi M.; Korobkin, Oleg; Lau, Ryan M.
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 843, Issue 2
  • DOI: 10.3847/2041-8213/aa799d

Limits on radioactive powered emission associated with a short-hard GRB 070724A in a star-forming galaxy: Short-hard GRB 070724A
journal, May 2010

  • Kocevski, Daniel; Thöne, Christina C.; Ramirez-Ruiz, Enrico
  • Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Vol. 404, Issue 2
  • DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2010.16327.x

GW170817: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Neutron Star Inspiral
journal, October 2017


The supernova rate per unit mass
journal, March 2005


The Rest‐Frame Optical Luminosity Functions of Galaxies at 2≤ z ≤3.5
journal, February 2007

  • Marchesini, D.; van Dokkum, P.; Quadri, R.
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 656, Issue 1
  • DOI: 10.1086/510305

The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. V. Rising X-Ray Emission from an Off-axis Jet
journal, October 2017


Kilonovae
journal, May 2017


Red or blue? A potential kilonova imprint of the delay until black hole formation following a neutron star merger
journal, May 2014

  • Metzger, Brian D.; Fernández, Rodrigo
  • Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Vol. 441, Issue 4
  • DOI: 10.1093/mnras/stu802

Electromagnetic counterparts of compact object mergers powered by the radioactive decay of r-process nuclei: Transients from compact object mergers
journal, June 2010


Gamma-ray bursts as the death throes of massive binary stars
journal, August 1992

  • Narayan, Ramesh; Paczynski, Bohdan; Piran, Tsvi
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 395
  • DOI: 10.1086/186493

Short Gamma‐Ray Bursts and Binary Mergers in Spiral and Elliptical Galaxies: Redshift Distribution and Hosts
journal, March 2008

  • O’Shaughnessy, R.; Belczynski, K.; Kalogera, V.
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 675, Issue 1
  • DOI: 10.1086/526334

Grb 080503: Implications of a Naked Short Gamma-Ray Burst Dominated by Extended Emission
journal, April 2009


The Luminous Infrared host Galaxy of Short-Duration grb 100206a
journal, October 2012


Discovery of the afterglow and host galaxy of the low-redshift short GRB 080905A★: The short GRB 080905A
journal, August 2010


The Afterglow, Energetics, and Host Galaxy of the Short‐Hard Gamma‐Ray Burst 051221a
journal, October 2006

  • Soderberg, A. M.; Berger, E.; Kasliwal, M.
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 650, Issue 1
  • DOI: 10.1086/506429

An origin in the local Universe for some short γ-ray bursts
journal, December 2005

  • Tanvir, N. R.; Chapman, R.; Levan, A. J.
  • Nature, Vol. 438, Issue 7070
  • DOI: 10.1038/nature04310

A ‘kilonova’ associated with the short-duration γ-ray burst GRB 130603B
journal, August 2013

  • Tanvir, N. R.; Levan, A. J.; Fruchter, A. S.
  • Nature, Vol. 500, Issue 7464
  • DOI: 10.1038/nature12505

An Achromatic Break in the Afterglow of the Short grb 140903a: Evidence for a Narrow jet
journal, August 2016


On the nature of the ‘hostless’ short GRBs
journal, November 2013

  • Tunnicliffe, R. L.; Levan, A. J.; Tanvir, N. R.
  • Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Vol. 437, Issue 2
  • DOI: 10.1093/mnras/stt1975

The Discovery of the Electromagnetic Counterpart of GW170817: Kilonova AT 2017gfo/DLT17ck
journal, October 2017

  • Valenti, Stefano; Sand, David, J.; Yang, Sheng
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 848, Issue 2
  • DOI: 10.3847/2041-8213/aa8edf

The Deep Evolutionary Exploratory Probe 2 Galaxy Redshift Survey: The Galaxy Luminosity Function to z  ∼ 1
journal, August 2006

  • Willmer, C. N. A.; Faber, S. M.; Koo, D. C.
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 647, Issue 2
  • DOI: 10.1086/505455

A possible macronova in the late afterglow of the long–short burst GRB 060614
journal, June 2015

  • Yang, Bin; Jin, Zhi-Ping; Li, Xiang
  • Nature Communications, Vol. 6, Issue 1
  • DOI: 10.1038/ncomms8323

Deducing the Lifetime of Short Gamma‐Ray Burst Progenitors from Host Galaxy Demography
journal, August 2007

  • Zheng, Zheng; Ramirez‐Ruiz, Enrico
  • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 665, Issue 2
  • DOI: 10.1086/519544

    Works referencing / citing this record:

    An Empirical Study of Contamination in Deep, Rapid, and Wide-field Optical Follow-up of Gravitational Wave Events
    journal, April 2018


    Jet Geometry and Rate Estimate of Coincident Gamma-Ray Burst and Gravitational-wave Observations
    journal, July 2019

    • Mogushi, Kentaro; Cavaglià, Marco; Siellez, Karelle
    • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 880, Issue 1
    • DOI: 10.3847/1538-4357/ab1f76

    An Empirical Study of Contamination in Deep, Rapid, and Wide-field Optical Follow-up of Gravitational Wave Events
    journal, April 2018


    Jet Geometry and Rate Estimate of Coincident Gamma-Ray Burst and Gravitational-wave Observations
    journal, July 2019

    • Mogushi, Kentaro; Cavaglià, Marco; Siellez, Karelle
    • The Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 880, Issue 1
    • DOI: 10.3847/1538-4357/ab1f76