Systems and methods for controlling an industrial asset in the presence of a cyber-attack
Abstract
Systems and methods are provided for the control of an industrial asset, such as a power generating asset. Accordingly, a cyber-attack model predicts a plurality of operational impacts on the industrial asset resulting from a plurality of potential cyber-attacks. The cyber-attack model also predicts a corresponding plurality of potential mitigation responses. In operation, a cyber-attack impacting at least one component of the industrial asset is detected via the cyber-attack neutralization module and a protected operational impact of the cyber-attack is identified based on the cyber-attack model. The cyber-attack neutralization module selects at least one mitigation response of the plurality of mitigation responses based on the predicted operational impact and an operating state of the industrial asset is altered based on the selected mitigation response.
- Inventors:
- Issue Date:
- Research Org.:
- General Electric Co., Schenectady, NY (United States)
- Sponsoring Org.:
- USDOE
- OSTI Identifier:
- 2293732
- Patent Number(s):
- 11790081
- Application Number:
- 17/229,934
- Assignee:
- General Electric Company (Schenectady, NY)
- DOE Contract Number:
- OE0000902
- Resource Type:
- Patent
- Resource Relation:
- Patent File Date: 04/14/2021
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
Citation Formats
D'Amato, Fernando Javier, Dokucu, Mustafa Tekin, Achanta, Hema Kumari, Singal, Kalpesh, Abbaszadeh, Masoud, Wang, Yuh-Shyang, Kvaternik, Karla, Nandi, Souransu, and Boutselis, Georgios. Systems and methods for controlling an industrial asset in the presence of a cyber-attack. United States: N. p., 2023.
Web.
D'Amato, Fernando Javier, Dokucu, Mustafa Tekin, Achanta, Hema Kumari, Singal, Kalpesh, Abbaszadeh, Masoud, Wang, Yuh-Shyang, Kvaternik, Karla, Nandi, Souransu, & Boutselis, Georgios. Systems and methods for controlling an industrial asset in the presence of a cyber-attack. United States.
D'Amato, Fernando Javier, Dokucu, Mustafa Tekin, Achanta, Hema Kumari, Singal, Kalpesh, Abbaszadeh, Masoud, Wang, Yuh-Shyang, Kvaternik, Karla, Nandi, Souransu, and Boutselis, Georgios. Tue .
"Systems and methods for controlling an industrial asset in the presence of a cyber-attack". United States. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/2293732.
@article{osti_2293732,
title = {Systems and methods for controlling an industrial asset in the presence of a cyber-attack},
author = {D'Amato, Fernando Javier and Dokucu, Mustafa Tekin and Achanta, Hema Kumari and Singal, Kalpesh and Abbaszadeh, Masoud and Wang, Yuh-Shyang and Kvaternik, Karla and Nandi, Souransu and Boutselis, Georgios},
abstractNote = {Systems and methods are provided for the control of an industrial asset, such as a power generating asset. Accordingly, a cyber-attack model predicts a plurality of operational impacts on the industrial asset resulting from a plurality of potential cyber-attacks. The cyber-attack model also predicts a corresponding plurality of potential mitigation responses. In operation, a cyber-attack impacting at least one component of the industrial asset is detected via the cyber-attack neutralization module and a protected operational impact of the cyber-attack is identified based on the cyber-attack model. The cyber-attack neutralization module selects at least one mitigation response of the plurality of mitigation responses based on the predicted operational impact and an operating state of the industrial asset is altered based on the selected mitigation response.},
doi = {},
journal = {},
number = ,
volume = ,
place = {United States},
year = {2023},
month = {10}
}
Works referenced in this record:
Intelligent Cyberphysical Intrusion Detection and Prevention Systems and Methods for Industrial Control Systems
patent-application, September 2014
- Dixit, Paritosh; Thanos, Daniel
- US Patent Application 13/801496; 20140283047
A Data-Driven Design for Fault Detection of Wind Turbines Using Random Forests and XGboost
journal, January 2018
- Zhang, Dahai; Qian, Liyang; Mao, Baijin
- IEEE Access, Vol. 6
Dynamic Concurrent Learning Method to Neutralize Cyber Attacks and Faults for Industrial Asset Monitoring Nodes
patent-application, July 2019
- Mestha, Lalit Keshav; Anubl, Olugbenga; Achanta, hema
- US Patent Application 15/986,996; 2019/0230119 Al
Industrial Control System Smart Hardware Monitoring
patent-application, December 2015
- Gendelman, Ilan
- US Patent Application 14/718192; 20150346706
System and Method for Unsupervised Anomaly Detection on Industrial Time-Series Data
patent-application, October 2017
- Harpale, Abhay; Pandey, Achalesh Kumar; Narkaj, Alexander
- US Patent Application 15/474563; 20170284896
Monitoring, detection, and surveillance system using principal component analysis with machine and sensor data
patent, May 2019
- Xiao, Wei; Silva, Jorge Manuel Gomes da; Emrani, Saba
- US Patent Document 10,303,954
Method and apparatus for detection of anomalies in integrated parameter systems
patent, June 2016
- Mihnev, Aldimir
- US Patent Document 9,379,951
Adaptive, Self-Tuning Virtual Sensing System for Cyber-Attack Neutralization
patent-application, March 2021
- Abbaszadeh, Masoud; Dokucu, Mustafa Tekin; John, Justin Varkey
- US Patent Application 16/574,493; 2021/0081270 Al
System and Method for Providing Monitoring of Industrial Equipment
patent-application, August 2014
- Craig, Jason; Pugh, William; Albarran, Richard Daniel
- US Patent Application 13/776407; 20140244192
System and Method for Logging Security Events for an Industrial Control System
patent-application, October 2013
- Chong, Justin Brandon; Socky, David Richard; Sahoo, Manas Ranjan
- US Patent Application 13/460779; 20130291115
On Cyber Attacks and Signature Based Intrusion Detection for Modbus Based Industrial Control Systems
journal, January 2014
- Gao, Wei; Morris, Thomas
- Journal of Digital Forensics, Security and Law
Apparatus and method for detecting an abnormality sign in a control system
patent-application, October 2014
- Heo, Youngjun; Sohn, Seon-Gyoung; Kang, Dong Ho
- US Patent Application 13/927794; 20140298399
System and methods for adaptive model generation for detecting intrusions in computer systems
patent, May 2007
- Honig, Andrew; Howard, Andrew; Eskin, Eleazar
- US Patent Document 7,225,343
Dynamic normalization of monitoring node data for threat detection in industrial asset control system
patent, June 2020
- Mestha, Lalit Keshav; Bushey, Cody Joe; Holzhauer, Daniel Francis
- US Patent Document 10,678,912
Automated Attack Localization and Detection
patent-application, June 2018
- Abbaszadeh, Masoud; Mestha, Lalit Keshav; Bushey, Cody
- US Patent Application 15/478425; 20180157831
Method and system for anomaly detection using a collective set of unsupervised machine-learning algorithms
patent-application, December 2007
- Lim, Keng Leng Albert
- US Patent Application 11/449533; 20070289013
Method for Quantitative Resilience Estimation of Industrial Control Systems
patent-application, May 2013
- Wei, Dong; Ji, Kun
- US Patent Application 13/703158; 20130132149
Domain Level Threat Detection for Industrial Asset Control System
patent-application, October 2017
- Mestha, Lalit Keshav; Thatcher, Jonathan Carl; Holhauer, Daniel Francis
- US Patent Application 15/137311; 20170310690
Condition Monitoring of Wind Power System With Nonparametric Regression Analysis
journal, June 2014
- Yampikulsakul, Nattavut; Byon, Eunshin; Huang, Shuai
- IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion, Vol. 29, Issue 2, p. 288-299
Relaxation‐based anomaly detection in cyber‐physical systems using ensemble kalman filter
journal, October 2019
- Karimipour, Hadis; Leung, Henry
- IET Cyber-Physical Systems: Theory & Applications, Vol. 5, Issue 1
Anomaly detection and diagnosis/prognosis method, anomaly detection and diagnosis/prognosis system, and anomaly detection and diagnosis/prognosis program
patent, November 2016
- Maeda, Shunji; Shibuya, Hisae
- US Patent Document 9,483,049
Secured Automated or Semi-Automated Systems
patent-application, November 2017
- Barkan, Mordecai
- US Patent Application 15/675611; 20170346840
Distributed Estimation and Detection of Anomalies in Control Systems
patent-application, April 2018
- Sun, Hongbo; Minot, Ariana
- US Patent Application 15/298392; 20180115561
System and method for detecting anomalies in wind turbines
patent, July 2012
- Mihok, John Joseph; Salem, Sameh Ramadan; Bhalodia, Dhaval Ramesh
- US Patent Document 8,219,356
The behavioral approach to diagnostics of cyber-physical systems
conference, September 2014
- Skormin, Victor; Dolgikh, Andrey; Birnbaum, Zachary
- 2014 IEEE AUTOTEST
Intelligent monitoring system and method for building predictive models and detecting anomalies
patent, October 2010
- Veillette, Michel; Berriah, Said; Tremblay, Gilles
- US Patent Document 7,818,276
Differential Acoustic Model Representation and Linear Transform-Based Adaptation for Efficient User Profile Update Techniques in Automatic Speech Recognition
patent-application, May 2015
- Gollan, Christian; Willett, Daniel
- US Patent Application 14/399867; 20150149174
A novel wind turbine condition monitoring method based on cloud computing
journal, May 2019
- Qian, Peng; Zhang, Dahai; Tian, Xiange
- Renewable Energy, Vol. 135
Mapping wind turbines and predicting wake effects using satellite imagery data
patent, August 2019
- Arya, Vijay; Bandyopadhyay, Sambaran; Panda, Akash Kumar
- US Patent Document 10,387,728
Systems and methods for cyber-attack detection at sample speed
patent, March 2020
- Mestha, Lalit Keshav; John, Justin Varkey; Yan, Weizhong
- US Patent Document 10,594,712
Cyber Threat Analysis Framework for the Wind Energy Based Power System
conference, November 2017
- Datta, Amarjit; Rahman, Mohammad Ashiqur
- Proceedings of the 2017 Workshop on Cyber-Physical Systems Security and PrivaCy
Efficient Localization of Transmitters Within Complex Electromagnetic Environments
patent-application, May 2016
- Baxley, Robert John; Altman, Justin Trent
- US Patent Application 14/928974; 20160127931
Ineffective network equipment identification
patent-application, May 2017
- Kallos, George
- US Patent Application 15/319970; 20170142133
Method of artificial nueral network loadflow computation for electrical power system
patent, June 2014
- Patel, Sureshchandra B.
- US Patent Document 8,756,047
System and method for logging security events for an industrial control system
patent, June 2015
- Chong, Justin Brandon; Socky, David Richard; Sahoo, Manas Ranjan
- US Patent Document 9,046,886
Method for Mitigation of Cyber Attacks on Industrial Control Systems
patent-application, February 2017
- Schneider, Omer; Giller, Nir
- US Patent Application 14/830776; 20170054751
A survey of cyber security management in industrial control systems
journal, June 2015
- Knowles, William; Prince, Daniel; Hutchison, David
- International Journal of Critical Infrastructure Protection, Vol. 9
Ensemble regression model-based anomaly detection for cyber-physical intrusion detection in smart grids
conference, October 2016
- Kosek, Anna Magdalena; Gehrke, Oliver
- 2016 IEEE Electrical Power and Energy Conference (EPEC)
Automated attack localization and detection
patent, September 2019
- Abbaszadeh, Masoud; Mestha, Lalit Keshav; Bushey, Cody Joe
- US Patent Document 10,417,415
Dynamic concurrent learning method to neutralize cyber attacks and faults for industrial asset monitoring nodes
patent, July 2020
- Mestha, Lalit Keshav; Anubi, Olugbenga; Achanta, Hema Kumari
- US Patent Document 10,728,282
Fault detection and isolation of a dual spool gas turbine engine using dynamic neural networks and multiple model approach
journal, February 2014
- Sadough Vanini, Z. N.; Khorasani, K.; Meskin, N.
- Information Sciences, Vol. 259
Adaptive fault detection in wind turbine via RF and CUSUM
journal, July 2020
- Xu, Qifa; Lu, Shixiang; Zhai, Zhongping
- IET Renewable Power Generation, Vol. 14, Issue 10
A New Hybrid Fault Detection Method for Wind Turbine Blades Using Recursive PCA and Wavelet-Based PDF
journal, February 2020
- Rezamand, Milad; Kordestani, Mojtaba; Carriveau, Rupp
- IEEE Sensors Journal, Vol. 20, Issue 4
Correction system and method for gas turbine proportional droop governor
patent-application, August 2016
- Chen, Yuhui; Sweet, Bryan Edward; Szepek, Scott William
- US Patent Application 14/612491; 20160222816
Artificial intelligence modeling for cyber-attack simulation protocols
patent, August 2022
- Donovan, Matthew P.; Nicotera, Paul; Hollister, Dahyun
- US Patent Document 11,429,713
Security System for and Method of Detecting and Responding to Cyber Attacks on Large Network Systems
patent-application, January 2008
- Gonsalves, Paul G.; Call, Catherine Dudley; Ho, Stephen
- US Patent Application 11/805403; 20080010225
Interface with Secure Intermediary Platform to Generate Data Compatible with an External System in an Oil and Gas Asset Supply Chain
patent-application, August 2017
- Finkel, Charles; Campbell, Mark; Van Ngoc Ty, Christophe
- US Patent Application 15/518923; 20170244726
System and method for developing a cyber-attack scenario
patent, July 2017
- Nguyen, Daniel; Shelton, Jason W.; Mitchell, Timothy M.
- US Patent Document 9,712,553
Discriminative feature learning for blade icing fault detection of wind turbine
journal, September 2020
- Yi, Huaikuan; Jiang, Qinchao
- Measurement Science and Technology, Vol. 31, Issue 11
Digital information infrastructure and method for security designated data and with granular data stores
patent, June 2013
- Redlich, Ron M.; Nemzow, Martin A.
- US Patent Document 8,468,244
System and Method for Maintaining the Health of a Control System
patent-application, February 2016
- T., Rvia Kumar; Banerjee, Goutam; Pai, Ramesh Brahmavar
- US Patent Application 14/448164; 20160033941
Systems and methods for secure operation of an industrial controller
patent, July 2016
- Chong, Justin Brandon; Socky, David Richard; Thakur, Pavan Kumar Singh
- US Patent Document 9,397,997
Intelligent cyberphysical intrusion detection and prevention systems and methods for industrial control systems
patent, August 2016
- Dixit, Paritosh; Thanos, Daniel
- US Patent Document 9,405,900
System and Method for Detecting a Cyber-Attack at SCADA/ICS Managed Plants
patent-application, September 2018
- Arov, Michael; Ochman, Ronen; Cohen, Moshe
- US Patent Application 15/989748; 20180276375
System and method for improved production surveillance using visual pattern recognition in oil and gas upstream
patent-application, November 2016
- Rajaram, Venkatakrishnan; Kumar, Hemant
- US Patent Application 14/794424; 20160341636
Monitoring and Preventing Remote User Automated Cyber Attachks
patent-application, February 2022
- Lewis, Patrick
- US Patent Application 16/988863; 20220046047
Challenges of Machine Learning Based Monitoring for Industrial Control System Networks
conference, March 2012
- Mantere, Matti; Uusitalo, Ilkka; Sailio, Mirko
- 2012 26th International Conference on Advanced Information Networking and Applications Workshops
Method and system for profiling network flows at a measurement point within a computer network
patent-application, March 2002
- Malan, Gerald R.; Jahanian, Farnam
- US Patent Application 09/855809; 20020032717
Prediction method of predicting a future state of a system
patent, September 2014
- Engler, Joseph J.
- US Patent Document 8,849,737
Data Driven Condition Monitoring of Wind Power Plants Using Cluster Analysis
conference, September 2015
- Li, Peng; Eickmeyer, Jens; Niggemann, Oliver
- 2015 International Conference on Cyber-Enabled Distributed Computing and Knowledge Discovery
Domain level threat detection for industrial asset control system
patent, June 2018
- Mestha, Lalit Keshav; Thatcher, Jonathan; Holzhauer, Daniel Francis
- US Patent Document 9,998,487
Tunable wireless power architectures
patent, July 2016
- Karalis, Aristeidis; Kesler, Morris P.; Hall, Katherine L.
- US Patent Document 9,384,885
An unsupervised anomaly-based detection approach for integrity attacks on SCADA systems
journal, October 2014
- Almalawi, Abdulmohsen; Yu, Xinghuo; Tari, Zahir
- Computers & Security, Vol. 46
Dynamic normalization of monitoring node data for threat detection in industrial asset control system
patent-application, May 2018
- Mestha, Lalit Keshav; Bushey, Cody Joe; Holzhauer, Daniel Francis
- US Patent Application 15/351809; 20180137277
Component Malfunction Impact Assessment
patent-application, September 2021
- Konrardy, Blake; Christensen, Scott T.; Hayward, Gregory
- US Patent Application 15/409305; 20210295439
Systems and methods for remote monitoring, security, diagnostics, and prognostics
patent, January 2016
- Evans, Scott Charles; Arthur, Richard Brownell; Bouqata, Bouchra
- US Patent Document 9,245,116
Anomaly Detection for Context-Dependent Data
patent-application, November 2016
- Bauer, Alexander; Heidtke, Nico; Niessen, Maria
- US Patent Application 14/703502; 20160328654
Integrated Condition Based Maintenance System for Wind Turbines
patent-application, January 2011
- Parthasarathy, Girija; Graber, Wendy Foslien; Brotherton, Tom
- US Patent Application 12/841301; 20110020122
Wind Turbine Fault Detection Using a Denoising Autoencoder With Temporal Information
journal, February 2018
- Jiang, Guoqian; Xie, Ping; He, Haibo
- IEEE/ASME Transactions on Mechatronics, Vol. 23, Issue 1
Asset-Based Dynamic Impact Assessment of Cyberattacks for Risk Analysis in Industrial Control Systems
journal, February 2018
- Li, Xuan; Zhou, Chunjie; Tian, Yu-Chu
- IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics, Vol. 14, Issue 2
Gas turbine and steam turbine combined cycle electric power generating plant having a coordinated and hybridized control system and an improved factory based method for making and testing combined cycle and other power plants and control systems therefor
patent, June 1984
- Martz, Lyle F.; Kiscaden, Roy W.; Uram, Robert
- US Patent Document 4,455,614
Multifactor authentication
patent, March 2015
- Bjones, Ronald John Kamiel Euphrasia; Cameron, Kim; Nadalin, Anthony Joseph
- US Patent Document 8,973,123
Connection based denial of service detection
patent, May 2012
- Dudfield, Anne Elizabeth; Poletto, Massimiliano Antonio
- US Patent Document 8,191,136
Systems and methods for secure operation of an industrial controller
patent, March 2015
- Chong, Justin Brandon; Socky, David Richard; Thakur, Pavan Kumar Singh
- US Patent Document 8,973,124
Systems and methods for improving the ranking and prioritization of attack-related events
patent, August 2020
- Aloisio, Scott; Joyce, Robert A.; Powers, Judson
- US Patent Document 10,749,890
Economic evaluation of maintenance strategies for wind turbines: a stochastic analysis
journal, September 2015
- Kerres, Bertrand; Fischer, Katharina; Madlener, Reinhard
- IET Renewable Power Generation, Vol. 9, Issue 7
Identification of False Data Injection Attacks With Considering the Impact of Wind Generation and Topology Reconfigurations
journal, July 2018
- Mohammadpourfard, Mostafa; Sami, Ashkan; Weng, Yang
- IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, Vol. 9, Issue 3
Apparatus and method for detecting abnormality sign in control system
patent, September 2015
- Heo, Youngjun; Sohn, Seon Gyoung; Kang, Dong Ho
- US Patent Document 9,130,983