Method and apparatus for constructing informative outcomes to guide multi-policy decision making
Abstract
In Multi-Policy Decision-Making (MPDM), many computationally-expensive forward simulations are performed in order to predict the performance of a set of candidate policies. In risk-aware formulations of MPDM, only the worst outcomes affect the decision making process, and efficiently finding these influential outcomes becomes the core challenge. Recently, stochastic gradient optimization algorithms, using a heuristic function, were shown to be significantly superior to random sampling. In this disclosure, it was shown that accurate gradients can be computed-even through a complex forward simulation—using approaches similar to those in dep networks. The proposed approach finds influential outcomes more reliably, and is faster than earlier methods, allowing one to evaluate more policies while simultaneously eliminating the need to design an easily-differentiable heuristic function.
- Inventors:
- Issue Date:
- Research Org.:
- Univ. of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI (United States)
- Sponsoring Org.:
- USDOE; Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA)
- OSTI Identifier:
- 1998514
- Patent Number(s):
- 11681896
- Application Number:
- 17/371,221
- Assignee:
- The Regents of the University of Michigan (Ann Arbor, MI)
- DOE Contract Number:
- D13AP00059
- Resource Type:
- Patent
- Resource Relation:
- Patent File Date: 07/09/2021
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
Citation Formats
Olson, Edwin, Mehta, Dhanvin H., and Ferrer, Gonzalo. Method and apparatus for constructing informative outcomes to guide multi-policy decision making. United States: N. p., 2023.
Web.
Olson, Edwin, Mehta, Dhanvin H., & Ferrer, Gonzalo. Method and apparatus for constructing informative outcomes to guide multi-policy decision making. United States.
Olson, Edwin, Mehta, Dhanvin H., and Ferrer, Gonzalo. Tue .
"Method and apparatus for constructing informative outcomes to guide multi-policy decision making". United States. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1998514.
@article{osti_1998514,
title = {Method and apparatus for constructing informative outcomes to guide multi-policy decision making},
author = {Olson, Edwin and Mehta, Dhanvin H. and Ferrer, Gonzalo},
abstractNote = {In Multi-Policy Decision-Making (MPDM), many computationally-expensive forward simulations are performed in order to predict the performance of a set of candidate policies. In risk-aware formulations of MPDM, only the worst outcomes affect the decision making process, and efficiently finding these influential outcomes becomes the core challenge. Recently, stochastic gradient optimization algorithms, using a heuristic function, were shown to be significantly superior to random sampling. In this disclosure, it was shown that accurate gradients can be computed-even through a complex forward simulation—using approaches similar to those in dep networks. The proposed approach finds influential outcomes more reliably, and is faster than earlier methods, allowing one to evaluate more policies while simultaneously eliminating the need to design an easily-differentiable heuristic function.},
doi = {},
journal = {},
number = ,
volume = ,
place = {United States},
year = {2023},
month = {6}
}
Works referenced in this record:
Autonomous Vehicle Operational Management Blocking Monitoring
patent-application, March 2020
- Wray, Kyle; Witwicki, Stefan; Zilberstein, Shlomo
- US Patent Application 16/473037; 20200098269
Method of Navigating a Vehicle and System Thereof
patent-application, May 2020
- Cohen, Ofir; Appelman, Dina; Degani, Arnon
- US Patent Application 16/619173; 20200159227
Field-based torque steering control
patent, April 2017
- Olson, Edwin; Galceran, Enric; Eustice, Ryan M.
- US Patent Document 9,618,938
Intervention in Operation of a Vehicle Having Autonomous Driving Capabilities
patent-application, December 2018
- Liu, Shih-Yuan; Ravichandran, Harshavardhan; Iagnemma, Karl
- US Patent Application 15/624780; 20180365908
System and method for providing driver behavior classification at intersections and validation on large naturalistic data sets
patent, September 2015
- Aoude, Georges; Desaraju, Vishnu Rajeswar; How, Jonathan P.
- US Patent Document 9,129,519
Individualized Adaptation of Driver Action Prediction Models
patent-application, February 2018
- Martinson, Eric; Olabiyi, Oluwatobi; Oguchi, Kentaro
- US Patent Application 15/362799; 20180053102
Driving Support Device
patent-application, March 2017
- Matsuoka, Katsuhiro; Morimoto, Kazuhiro
- US Patent Application 15/229166; 20170072853
Fast discovery of influential outcomes for risk-aware MPDM
conference, May 2017
- Mehta, Dhanvin; Ferrer, Gonzalo; Olson, Edwin
- 2017 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA)
Detecting sensor degradation by actively controlling an autonomous vehicle
patent, March 2016
- Ferguson, David I.; Zhu, Jingdong
- US Patent Document 9,274,525
Calibration of a Chemical Sensor in a Portable Electronic Device
patent-application, August 2014
- Mayer, Felix
- US Patent Application 14/168136; 20140244198
Kiosk Cluster
patent-application, October 2018
- Kwok, Ching Kwong
- US Patent Application 16/003135; 20180293537
Real Time Car Driving Simulator
patent-application, January 2016
- Naouri, Ygdal
- US Patent Application 14/753151; 20160005333
Intervention in Operation of a Vehicle Having Autonomous Driving Capabilities
patent-application, August 2019
- Liu, Shih-Yuan; Ravichandran, Harshavardhan; Iagnemma, Karl
- US Patent Application 16/398900; 20190258246
System and Method for Real-Time Transit Prioritization
patent-application, August 2019
- Warnick, Jonathan; Long, James
- US Patent Application 15/905815; 20190265059
Systems and Methods for a Vehicle Controller Safety Monitor
patent-application, April 2019
- Goldberg, Joshua David
- US Patent Application 15/810495; 20190106117
Vehicle Sensor Field Calibration Utilizing Other Vehicles
patent-application, April 2020
- Schwindt, Oliver; Heyl, Andreas; Gussner, Thomas
- US Patent Application 16/165075; 20200124447
Sensor Fusion Using Inertial and Image Sensors
patent-application, October 2017
- Zhao, Kaiyong; Shen, Shaojie; Lin, Yi
- US Patent Application 15/289354; 20170301111
Method and Apparatus for Constructing Informative Outcomes to Guide Multi-Policy Decision Making
patent-application, September 2018
- Olson, Edwin; Mehta, Dhanvin H.; Ferrer, Gonzalo
- US Patent Application 15/923577; 20180268281
Apparatus for Switching Driving Mode of Vehicle and Method Thereof
patent-application, July 2016
- Kim, Hyun
- US Patent Application 14/833170; 20160209840
Event-Based Connected Vehicle Control and Response Systems
patent-application, February 2019
- Kumar, Surender; Marlow, Clint J.; Gibson, Timothy W.
- US Patent Application 15/667484; 20190039545
A Survey of Motion Planning and Control Techniques for Self-Driving Urban Vehicles
journal, March 2016
- Paden, Brian; Cap, Michal; Yong, Sze Zheng
- IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Vehicles, Vol. 1, Issue 1
Online per-feature descriptor customization
patent, November 2017
- Richardson, Andrew; Olson, Edwin B.
- US Patent Document 9,811,760
Automated system and method for modeling the behavior of vehicles and other agents
patent, November 2016
- Zhu, Jingdong; Ferguson, David I.; Dolgov, Dmitri A.
- US Patent Document 9,495,874
Autonomous Vehicle Rapid Development Testbed Systems and Methods
patent-application, February 2008
- Vian, John L.; Provine, Ronald C.; Bieniawski, Stefan R.
- US Patent Application 11/459617; 20080033684
Method, Apparatus, and System for Estimating Vulnerable Road Users
patent-application, January 2020
- Stenneth, Leon; Marappan, Ram
- US Patent Application 16/036698; 20200020226
Video Tracking System and Method
patent-application, May 2004
- Sablak, Sezai; Katz, David N.; Trajkovic, Miroslav
- US Patent Application 10/306509; 20040100563
Vehicle to infrastructure based safe trajectory planning for Autonomous Intersection Management
conference, November 2013
- Wuthishuwong, Chairit; Traechtler, Ansgar
- 2013 13th International Conference on ITS Telecommunications (ITST)
Route Planning for an Autonomous Vehicle
patent-application, December 2017
- Iagnemma, Karl
- US Patent Application 15/182365; 20170356748
Cellular Communication Devices and Methods
patent-application, June 2020
- Mistry, Samir S.; Johnson, Sam; LaFountain, Philip N.
- US Patent Application 16/349146; 20200189731
Autonomous vehicle collision mitigation systems and methods
patent, August 2019
- Wood, Matthew; Leach, William M.; Poeppel, Scott C.
- US Patent Document 10,386,856
Modifying the behavior of an autonomous vehicle using context based parameter switching
patent, August 2017
- Zhu, Jingdong; Urmson, Christopher Paul; Ferguson, David I.
- US Patent Document 9,720,412
Method and Device for the Combined Simulation and Control of Remote-Controlled Vehicles
patent-application, November 2015
- Guehring, Olaf; Schmidt, Holger
- US Patent Application 14/439975; 20150316928
Methods and Systems for Automation Guidance
patent-application, March 2018
- Whitlow, Stephen
- US Patent Application 15/269089; 20180082596
Customize and legalize self-driving motor vehicles
patent, May 2020
- Huai, Xiaoning
- US Patent Document 10,642,276
Input from a Plurality of Teleoperators for Decision Making Regarding a Predetermined Driving Situation
patent-application, June 2019
- Hummelshoj, Jens Strabo
- US Patent Application 15/851890; 20190196465
Accident response using autonomous vehicle monitoring
patent, May 2017
- Konrardy, Blake; Christensen, Scott T.; Hayward, Gregory
- US Patent Document 9,646,428
Systems and Methods for Centralized Control of Autonomous Vehicles
patent-application, January 2018
- Ferren, Bran
- US Patent Application 15/643376; 20180011485
Shared vehicle obstacle data
patent, February 2020
- Lin, Michael; Kentley-Klay, Timothy David
- US Patent Document 10,558,224
Reinforcement and Model Learning for Vehicle Operation
patent-application, November 2020
- Wray, Kyle Hollins; Witwicki, Stefan; Zilberstein, Shlomo
- US Patent Application 16/757936; 20200346666
Predictive Modeling
patent-application, May 2010
- Misra, Vishwas
- US Patent Application 12/265281; 20100114554
Sensor Data Anomaly Detection System and Method for a Vehicle
patent-application, July 2020
- Lull, Joseph C.; Malhan, Rajesh
- US Patent Application 16/519583; 20200233060
Simulation Transmitter for Remote Operated Vehicles
patent-application, April 2012
- Yao-Chang, Lee; Yu-Chien, Huang
- US Patent Application 13/269083; 20120089275
Navigable path networks for autonomous vehicles
patent, April 2019
- Siegel, Hilliard Bruce; Mishra, Priyank
- US Patent Document 10,248,120
Event Data Recordation to Identify and Resolve Anomalies Associated with Control of Driverless Vehicles
patent-application, July 2019
- Penna, Mauro Della
- US Patent Application 15/872555; 20190220011
Technology for real-time detection and mitigation of remote vehicle anomalous behavior
patent, January 2020
- Fields, Brian Mark; Nepomuceno, John A.; Christensen, Scott T.
- US Patent Document 10,540,892
Flexible Support of Multi-Homing in Networks of Moving Things Including Autonomous Vehicles Based Networks
patent-application, June 2018
- Lopes, Diogo Miguel Augusto; Condeixa, Tiago Silvestre
- US Patent Application 15/603903; 20180184352
Autonomous navigation in dynamic social environments using Multi-Policy Decision Making
conference, October 2016
- Mehta, Dhanvin; Ferrer, Gonzalo; Olson, Edwin
- 2016 IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems (IROS)
Maneuver generation program and method
patent, March 2001
- O'Shea, Michael
- US Patent Document 6,199,013
System of Automatic Driving Assistance, Roadside Assistance and Vehicle-Side Assistance
patent-application, August 2019
- Li, Wenrui; Li, Yiming; Wu, Nan
- US Patent Application 16/243878; 20190236950
Optimizing Active Decision Making Using Simulated Decision Making
patent-application, September 2006
- Dalal, Mukesh; Prieditis, Armand
- US Patent Application 10/552645; 20060200333
Comparing the effect of pruning on a best path and a naïve-approach blackboard solver
journal, July 2015
- Straub, Jeremy
- International Journal of Automation and Computing, Vol. 12, Issue 5
Method and system for adaptive vehicle control in autonomous vehicles
patent, March 2020
- Singhal, Abhishek
- US Patent Document 10,586,254
Early warning and collision avoidance
patent, March 2019
- Aoude, Georges; Abufadel, Amer; Jeanbart, Karl
- US Patent Document 10,235,882
Communication Based Vehicle-Pedestrian Collision Warning System
patent-application, September 2013
- Caminiti, Lorenzo; Lovell, Jeffrey Clark; Richardson, James Joseph
- US Patent Application 13/894764; 20130253816
Controller Architecture for Monitoring Health of an Autonomous Vehicle
patent-application, February 2019
- Jiang, Shengbing; Du, Xinyu; Holland, Steven W.
- US Patent Application 15/688457; 20190066399
Method and apparatus for planning motions of robot manipulators
patent, August 1996
- Chen, Pang-Chuan; Hwang, Young-Kuk
- US Patent Document 5,544,282
Autonomous Vehicle Simulation System
patent-application, October 2016
- Wei, Jerome H.; Wang, Walter; Gevorkian, Arthur
- US Patent Application 14/695495; 20160314224
Enhanced Environment Simulator for Proxy Robot Handlers
patent-application, November 2015
- Stephens, Jr., Kenneth Dean
- US Patent Application 14/271437; 20150321337
Systems and Methods for Managing Data with Heterogeneous Multi-Paths and Multi-Networks in an Internet of Moving Things
patent-application, August 2018
- Condeixa, Tiago Silvestre; Lopes, Diogo Miguel Augusto; Magalhaes de Matos, Ricardo Jorge
- US Patent Application 15/847264; 20180220283
Device, System, and Method of Autonomous Driving and Tele-Operated Vehicles
patent-application, April 2021
- Altman, Baruch Yosef
- US Patent Application 16/981313; 20210116907
MPDM: Multipolicy decision-making in dynamic, uncertain environments for autonomous driving
conference, May 2015
- Cunningham, Alexander G.; Galceran, Enric; Eustice, Ryan M.
- 2015 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA)
Data Stream Analytics at Service Layer
patent-application, May 2019
- Singh, Sneha Aman; Li, Xu; Ly, Quang
- US Patent Application 16/096510; 20190138524
Intersection Collision Warning System
patent-application, November 2007
- King, Timothy I.; Refai, Hazem H.
- US Patent Application 11/714572; 20070276600
Vehicle Trajectory Determination
patent-application, February 2017
- Olson, Edwin; Galceran, Enric; Cunningham, Alexander G.
- US Patent Application 14/814766; 20170031361
Determining Threats Based on Information from Road-Based Devices in a Transportation-Related Context
patent-application, June 2013
- Lord, Richard T.; Lord, Robert W.; Myhrvold, Nathan P.
- US Patent Application 13/425210; 20130141576
Robot Simulation Device and Robot Simulation Program
patent-application, August 2006
- Hosokawa, Hirofumi; Fujii, Seiichi
- US Patent Application 10/550285; 20060184275
Efficient Communications Amongst Computing Nodes for Operating Autonomous Vehicles
patent-application, June 2018
- Wang, Quan; Xia, Liming; Feng, Jingchao
- US Patent Application 15/115249; 20180183873
Systems and methods for intelligently calibrating infrastructure devices using onboard sensors of an autonomous agent
patent, April 2021
- Voorheis, Tom; Goeddel, Rob; Vozar, Steve
- US Patent Document 10,969,470
Method and Device for the Combined Simulation and Control of Remote-Controlled Vehicles Using a User-Friendly Projection System
patent-application, October 2015
- Guehring, Olaf; Schmidt, Holger
- US Patent Application 14/646578; 20150302756
Vehicular Communication Network and Methods of Use and Manufacture Thereof
patent-application, September 2017
- Bai, Xue; Miucic, Radovan
- US Patent Application 15/073598; 20170268896
Towards a Driver Support System for Teleoperated Driving
conference, October 2019
- Neumeier, Stefan; Facchi, Christian
- 2019 IEEE Intelligent Transportation Systems Conference (ITSC)
Roadway Sensing Systems
patent-application, July 2014
- Stelzig, Chad; Govindarajan, Kiran; Swingen, Cory
- US Patent Application 14/208775; 20140195138
Decision Making for Autonomous Vehicle Motion Control
patent-application, March 2018
- Redding, Joshua D.; Johnson, Luke B.; Levihn, Martin
- US Patent Application 15/713326; 20180089563
Computer-Implemented System and Method for Simulating Motor Vehicle and Bicycle Traffic
patent-application, May 2002
- Faghri, Ardeshir
- US Patent Application 09/963325; 20020062207
Self-calibrating sensors and actuators for unmanned vehicles
patent, July 2018
- Gariepy, Ryan Christopher; Shehata, Kareem; Mukherjee, Prasenjit
- US Patent Document 10,012,981
5G Dynamic Slice and Network Identity Instantiation, Termination, and Access Management System and Method
patent-application, December 2018
- Shaw, Venson; Dowlatkhah, Sangar
- US Patent Application 15/623829; 20180367997
Systems and Methods for Obstacle Avoidance
patent-application, August 2007
- Allard, James; Wienhold, Kathleen A.; Norris, William Robert
- US Patent Application 11/584097; 20070193798
Persistent Aerial Reconnaissance and Communication System
patent-application, April 2020
- Anderson, Bretton E.; Bohorquez, Felipe; Filippov, Misha
- US Patent Application 16/088040; 20200122830