Systems and methods for energy cost optimization in a building system
Abstract
Methods and systems to minimize energy cost in response to time-varying energy prices are presented for a variety of different pricing scenarios. A cascaded model predictive control system is disclosed comprising an inner controller and an outer controller. The inner controller controls power use using a derivative of a temperature setpoint and the outer controller controls temperature via a power setpoint or power deferral. An optimization procedure is used to minimize a cost function within a time horizon subject to temperature constraints, equality constraints, and demand charge constraints. Equality constraints are formulated using system model information and system state information whereas demand charge constraints are formulated using system state information and pricing information. A masking procedure is used to invalidate demand charge constraints for inactive pricing periods including peak, partial-peak, off-peak, critical-peak, and real-time.
- Inventors:
- Issue Date:
- Research Org.:
- Johnson Controls Technology Company, Holland, MI (United States)
- Sponsoring Org.:
- USDOE
- OSTI Identifier:
- 1320888
- Patent Number(s):
- 9436179
- Application Number:
- 13/802,279
- Assignee:
- Johnson Controls Technology Company (Holland, MI)
- Patent Classifications (CPCs):
-
G - PHYSICS G05 - CONTROLLING G05B - CONTROL OR REGULATING SYSTEMS IN GENERAL
Y - NEW / CROSS SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES Y02 - TECHNOLOGIES OR APPLICATIONS FOR MITIGATION OR ADAPTATION AGAINST CLIMATE CHANGE Y02B - CLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION TECHNOLOGIES RELATED TO BUILDINGS, e.g. HOUSING, HOUSE APPLIANCES OR RELATED END-USER APPLICATIONS
- DOE Contract Number:
- EE0003982
- Resource Type:
- Patent
- Resource Relation:
- Patent File Date: 2013 Mar 13
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
- Subject:
- 29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY; 42 ENGINEERING
Citation Formats
Turney, Robert D., and Wenzel, Michael J. Systems and methods for energy cost optimization in a building system. United States: N. p., 2016.
Web.
Turney, Robert D., & Wenzel, Michael J. Systems and methods for energy cost optimization in a building system. United States.
Turney, Robert D., and Wenzel, Michael J. Tue .
"Systems and methods for energy cost optimization in a building system". United States. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1320888.
@article{osti_1320888,
title = {Systems and methods for energy cost optimization in a building system},
author = {Turney, Robert D. and Wenzel, Michael J.},
abstractNote = {Methods and systems to minimize energy cost in response to time-varying energy prices are presented for a variety of different pricing scenarios. A cascaded model predictive control system is disclosed comprising an inner controller and an outer controller. The inner controller controls power use using a derivative of a temperature setpoint and the outer controller controls temperature via a power setpoint or power deferral. An optimization procedure is used to minimize a cost function within a time horizon subject to temperature constraints, equality constraints, and demand charge constraints. Equality constraints are formulated using system model information and system state information whereas demand charge constraints are formulated using system state information and pricing information. A masking procedure is used to invalidate demand charge constraints for inactive pricing periods including peak, partial-peak, off-peak, critical-peak, and real-time.},
doi = {},
journal = {},
number = ,
volume = ,
place = {United States},
year = {Tue Sep 06 00:00:00 EDT 2016},
month = {Tue Sep 06 00:00:00 EDT 2016}
}
Works referenced in this record:
Dynamic matrix control method
patent, September 1982
- Prett, David M.; Ramaker, Brian L.; Cutler, Charles R.
- US Patent Document 4,349,869
Dynamic process control
patent, October 1986
- Morshedi, Abdol M.; Cutler, Charles R.; Fitzpatrick, Thomas J.
- US Patent Document 4,616,308
Receding horizon based adaptive control having means for minimizing operating costs
patent, April 1994
- MacArthur, J. Ward; Wahlstedt, David; Woessner, Michael A.
- US Patent Document 5,301,101
Model predictive control apparatus
patent, September 1994
- Iino, Yutaka; Ohya, Junko
- US Patent Document 5,347,446
Method of multivariable predictive control utilizing range control
patent, September 1994
- Lu, Zhuxin J.; MacArthur, J. Ward; Horn, Brian C.
- US Patent Document 5,351,184
Neural net based disturbance predictor for model predictive control
patent, April 1995
- Mathur, Anoop; Gopinath, Ravi S.
- US Patent Document 5,408,406
Single input single output rate optimal controller
patent, August 1995
- Jelinek, Jan
- US Patent Document 5,442,544
Model predictive control apparatus and method
patent, May 1996
- Cawlfield, David W.
- US Patent Document 5,519,605
Method of optimal controller design for multivariable predictive control utilizing range control
patent, November 1996
- Lu, Zhuxin J.
- US Patent Document 5,572,420
Systems and methods using bridge models to globally optimize a process facility
patent, April 2000
- Lu, Zhuxin J.
- US Patent Document 6,055,483
System and methods for globally optimizing a process facility
patent, September 2000
- Lu, Zhuxin J.
- US Patent Document 6,122,555
Method for on-line optimization of a plant
patent, August 2001
- Piche, Stephen; Havener, John P.; Semrad, Donald
- US Patent Document 6,278,899
Process facility control systems using an efficient prediction form and methods of operating the same
patent, February 2002
- Lu, Z. Joseph
- US Patent Document 6,347,254
Performance assessment of model predictive controllers
patent, October 2002
- Hugo, Alan
- US Patent Document 6,459,939
Model predictive controller for coordinated cross direction and machine direction control
patent, October 2004
- Backstrom, Johan U.; He, Pengling
- US Patent Document 6,807,510
System and method for enterprise modeling, optimization and control
patent, August 2005
- Plumer, Edward; Sayyar-Rodsari, Bijan; Schweiger, Carl Anthony
- US Patent Document 6,934,931
System and method of adaptive control of processes with varying dynamics
patent, May 2006
- Sayyarrodsari, Bijan; Hartman, Eric; Axelrud, Celso
- US Patent Document 7,039,475
Integrated model predictive control and optimization within a process control system
patent, May 2006
- Mehta, Ashish; Wojsznis, Peter; Wojsznis, Wilhelm K.
- US Patent Document 7,050,863
Dynamic controller for controlling a system
patent, May 2006
- Martin, Gregory D.; Boe, Eugene; Piche, Stephen
- US Patent Document 7,050,866
System and method of accelerated active set search for quadratic programming in real-time model predictive control
patent, December 2006
- Das, Indraneel
- US Patent Document 7,152,023
Method and system for using a measure of fueling rate in the air side control of an engine
patent, January 2007
- Stewart, Gregory E.
- US Patent Document 7,165,399
Square root method for computationally efficient model predictive control
patent, March 2007
- Fuller, James W.
- US Patent Document 7,197,485
Model predictive controller with life extending control
patent, April 2007
- Fuller, James W.
- US Patent Document 7,203,554
Process control system
patent, September 2007
- Gallestey, Eduardo; Stothert, Alec
- US Patent Document 7,266,416
Multiple-input/multiple-output control blocks with non-linear predictive capabilities
patent, September 2007
- Wojsznis, Wilhelm K.; Blevins, Terrence L.; Mehta, Ashish
- US Patent Document 7,272,454
Optimized energy management system
patent, September 2007
- Miller, Craig
- US Patent Document 7,274,975
Coordinated multivariable control of fuel and air in engines
patent, October 2007
- Stewart, Gregory E.; Shahed, Syed; Borrelli, Francesco
- US Patent Document 7,275,374
Real-time quadratic programming for control of dynamical systems
patent, February 2008
- Das, Indraneel; Fuller, James W.
- US Patent Document 7,328,074
Multivariable control for an engine
patent, February 2008
- Stewart, Gregory E.; Kolavennu, Soumitri; Borrelli, Francesco
- US Patent Document 7,328,577
System and method for exploiting a good starting guess for binding constraints in quadratic programming with an infeasible and inconsistent starting guess for the solution
patent, May 2008
- Das, Indraneel; Rey, Gonzalo J.
- US Patent Document 7,376,471
Integrated model predictive control and optimization within a process control system
patent, May 2008
- Wojsznis, Wilhelm K.; Blevins, Terry; Nixon, Mark J.
- US Patent Document 7,376,472
Emissions sensors for fuel control in engines
patent, June 2008
- Stewart, Gregory E.; Rhodes, Michael L.
- US Patent Document 7,389,773
SISO model predictive controller
patent, July 2008
- Rawlings, James B.; Pannocchia, Gabriele; Laachi, Nabil
- US Patent Document 7,400,933
Model predictive control apparatus
patent, August 2008
- Nishira, Hikaru; Kawabe, Taketoshi
- US Patent Document 7,418,372
Fast performance prediction of multivariable model predictive controller for paper machine cross-directional processes
patent, November 2008
- Fan, Junqiang
- US Patent Document 7,454,253
Apparatus and method for coordinating controllers to control a paper machine or other machine
patent, February 2009
- Fan, Junqiang; Backstrom, Johan U.
- US Patent Document 7,496,413
Automatic tuning method for multivariable model predictive controllers
patent, August 2009
- Fan, Junqiang; Stewart, Gregory E.
- US Patent Document 7,577,483
Method and system for using a measure of fueling rate in the air side control of an engine
patent, September 2009
- Stewart, Gregory E.
- US Patent Document 7,591,135
Training a support vector machine with process constraints
patent, October 2009
- Hartman, Eric; Schweiger, Carl Anthony; Sayyarrodsari, Bijan
- US Patent Document 7,599,897
Method and apparatus for attenuating error in dynamic and steady-state processes for prediction, control, and optimization
patent, October 2009
- Boe, Eugene; Piche, Stephen; Martin, Gregory D.
- US Patent Document 7,610,108
Automated tuning of large-scale multivariable model predictive controllers for spatially-distributed processes
patent, January 2010
- Fan, Junqiang; Stewart, Gregory E.
- US Patent Document 7,650,195
Method for optimizing the functioning of a plurality of compressor units and corresponding device
patent, March 2010
- Liepold, Helmut; Metzger, Michael
- US Patent Document 7,676,283
Dynamic model predictive control
patent, November 2010
- Attarwala, Fakhruddin T.
- US Patent Document 7,826,909
Iterative matrix processor based implementation of real-time model predictive control
patent, November 2010
- Vouzis, Panagiotis; Bleris, Leonidas; Arnold, Mark G.
- US Patent Document 7,844,352
On-line adaptive model predictive control in a process control system
patent, December 2010
- Thiele, Dirk; Wojsznis, Wilhelm K.
- US Patent Document 7,856,281
Emissions sensors for fuel control in engines
patent, February 2011
- Stewart, Gregory E.; Rhodes, Michael L.
- US Patent Document 7,878,178
Real-time global optimization of building setpoints and sequence of operation
patent, February 2011
- Sloup, Charles J.; Karnes, Daniel; Henze, Gregor P.
- US Patent Document 7,894,943
Two-stage model predictive control technique
patent, April 2011
- Cheng, Xu
- US Patent Document 7,930,045
Configurable automotive controller
patent, August 2011
- Stewart, Greg; Borrelli, Francesco; Pekar, Jaroslav
- US Patent Document 7,996,140
Methods and apparatus for model predictive control in a real time controller
patent, August 2011
- Kirchhof, Darrin Glen
- US Patent Document 8,005,575
Training a model of a non-linear process
patent, September 2011
- Sayyar-Rodsari, Bijan; Plumer, Edward; Hartman, Eric
- US Patent Document 8,019,701
Model predictive control system and method for reduction of steady state error
patent, October 2011
- Sayyar-Rodsari, Bijan
- US Patent Document 8,032,235
System and method for continuous supply chain control and optimization using stochastic calculus of variations approach
patent, October 2011
- Lu, Joseph Z.; Morningred, John Duane
- US Patent Document 8,036,758
Apparatus and method for model predictive control (MPC) of a nonlinear process
patent, October 2011
- Renfro, Jeffrey G.; Lu, Joseph Z.
- US Patent Document 8,046,089
Configurable automotive controller
patent, November 2011
- Stewart, Greg; Borrelli, Francesco; Pekar, Jaroslav
- US Patent Document 8,060,290
Decomposition of nonlinear dynamics using multiple model approach and gap metric analysis
patent, December 2011
- Gugaliya, Jinendra K.; Gudi, Ravindra; Mo, Jinyi
- US Patent Document 8,073,659
Methods and systems for the design and implementation of optimal multivariable model predictive controllers for fast-sampling constrained dynamic systems
patent, December 2011
- Pekar, Jaroslav; Borralli, Francesco; Stewart, Gregory E.
- US Patent Document 8,078,291
Method and apparatus for prediction-based wind turbine control
patent, January 2012
- Egedal, Per; Rubak, Rune; Stiesdal, Henrik
- US Patent Document 8,105,029
Engine controller
patent, February 2012
- Stewart, Gregory E.; Rhodes, Michael L.
- US Patent Document 8,109,255
Method and system for diagnostics of apparatus
patent, February 2012
- Gorinevsky, Dimitry
- US Patent Document 8,121,818
Universal model predictive controller
patent, February 2012
- Attarwala, Fakhruddin T.
- US Patent Document 8,126,575
Method and system for combining feedback and feedforward in model predictive control
patent, March 2012
- Pekar, Jaroslav; Strewart, Greg; Kihas, Dejan
- US Patent Document 8,145,329
Method and apparatus for effecting temperature difference in a respective zone
patent, May 2012
- Laskow, Paul Ira
- US Patent Document 8,180,493
Robust adaptive model predictive controller with tuning to compensate for model mismatch
patent, May 2012
- Thiele, Dirk
- US Patent Document 8,185,217
Model predictive controller with tunable integral component to compensate for model mismatch
patent, June 2012
- Thiele, Dirk
- US Patent Document 8,200,346
Remote energy management using persistent smart grid network context
patent, December 2012
- Raman, Madhusudan; Dubois, Jean F.; Chipalkatti, Renu
- US Patent Document 8,335,596
Automated demand response energy management system
patent, April 2013
- Rombouts, Jan-Willem; Gheerardyn, Jos; Mermans, Pieter-Jan
- US Patent Document 8,417,391
Energy management system and method
patent, October 2013
- Roscoe, George William; Papallo, Jr., Thomas Frederick; Rivers, Jr., Cecil
- US Patent Document 8,548,638
Power demand-supply management server and power demand-supply management system
patent, July 2014
- Tomita, Yasushi; Sato, Yasuo; Watanabe, Masahiro
- US Patent Document 8,768,527
Automated demand response energy management system
patent, September 2014
- Gheerardyn, Jos; Rombouts, Jan-Willem
- US Patent Document 8,825,219
Energy decision management system
patent, November 2014
- Harmon, Ed; Gaillard, Ted
- US Patent Document 8,886,361
Optimized Energy Management System
patent-application, November 2007
- Miller, Craig
- US Patent Application 11/837888; 20070276547
Energy Optimization Method
patent-application, May 2011
- Zhou, Zhi; de Bedout, Juan Manuel; Kern, John Michael
- US Patent Application 12/640020; 20110106327
Energy Optimization System
patent-application, May 2011
- Zhon, Zhi; de Bedout, Juan Manuel; Kern, John MIchale
- US Patent Application 12/640021; 20110106328
Building Management System with Fault Analysis
patent-application, July 2011
- Drees, Kirk H.
- US Patent Application 13/077508; 20110178977
Energy Management Systems and Methods
patent-application, September 2011
- Irving, Gary W.
- US Patent Application 12/975188; 20110231320
Systems and Methods for Detecting Changes in Energy Usage in a Building
patent-application, April 2012
- Drees, Kirk H.; Kummer, James P.; Wenzel, Michael J.
- US Patent Application 13/252092; 20120084063
Virtual Thermostat System and Method
patent-application, January 2013
- Mansfield, Carl; Park, Daniel J.; Elrod, David
- US Patent Application 13/539057; 20130013119
Integration of Commercial Building Operations with Electric System Operations and Markets
patent-application, January 2013
- Henze, Gregor P.; Cushing, Vincent J.; Corbin, Charles D.
- US Patent Application 13/404748; 20130013121
System and Method of Energy Management Control
patent-application, September 2013
- Ji, Kun; Lu, Yan; Song, Zhen
- US Patent Application 13/763870; 20130231792
A survey of industrial model predictive control technology
journal, July 2003
- Qin, S. Joe; Badgwell, Thomas A.
- Control Engineering Practice, Vol. 11, Issue 7, p. 733-764
The unscented Kalman filter for nonlinear estimation
conference, January 2000
- Wan, E. A.; Van Der Merwe, R.
- Symposium on Adaptive Systems for Signal Processing Communications and Control, Proceedings of the IEEE 2000 Adaptive Systems for Signal Processing, Communications, and Control Symposium (Cat. No.00EX373)