skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Calculation of Upper Subcritical Limits for Nuclear Criticality in a Repository

Abstract

The purpose of this document is to present the methodology to be used for development of the Subcritical Limit (SL) for post closure conditions for the Yucca Mountain repository. The SL is a value based on a set of benchmark criticality multiplier, k{sub eff} results that are outputs of the MCNP calculation method. This SL accounts for calculational biases and associated uncertainties resulting from the use of MCNP as the method of assessing k{sub eff}. The context for an SL estimate include the range of applicability (based on the set of MCNP results) and the type of SL required for the application at hand. This document will include illustrative calculations for each of three approaches. The data sets used for the example calculations are identified in Section 5.1. These represent three waste categories, and SLs for each of these sets of experiments will be computed in this document. Future MCNP data sets will be analyzed using the methods discussed here. The treatment of the biases evaluated on sets of k{sub eff} results via MCNP is statistical in nature. This document does not address additional non-statistical contributions to the bias margin, acknowledging that regulatory requirements may impose additional administrative penalties. Potentially,more » there are other biases or margins that should be accounted for when assessing criticality (k{sub eff}). Only aspects of the bias as determined using the stated assumptions and benchmark critical data sets will be included in the methods and sample calculations in this document. The set of benchmark experiments used in the validation of the computational system should be representative of the composition, configuration, and nuclear characteristics for the application at hand. In this work, a range of critical experiments will be the basis of establishing the SL for three categories of waste types that will be in the repository. The ultimate purpose of this document is to present methods that will effectively characterize the MCNP computations with respect to bias, as applicable to the repository setting. Combining varied sets of critical experiments into a single source of benchmark criticals provides wider ranges of applicability and, potentially, additional variability contribution to the treatment for the uncertainty of the bias. This will allow the estimation of the bias characteristics that will be useful in establishing the SL. If extrapolation is required, there may be need for ad lioc analyses to evaluate the bias characteristics, or at a minimum to recalculate the SLY based on the new range for the trending variable. This may also require extending the data set of critical experiments.« less

Authors:
Publication Date:
Research Org.:
Yucca Mountain Project, Las Vegas, Nevada
Sponsoring Org.:
USDOE
OSTI Identifier:
895333
Report Number(s):
B00000000-01717-0210-00027 Rev. 00
MOL.19980429.0420, DC# 26386; TRN: US0702527
DOE Contract Number:
NA
Resource Type:
Technical Report
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Subject:
12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE WASTES, AND NON-RADIOACTIVE WASTES FROM NUCLEAR FACILITIES; BENCHMARKS; CALCULATION METHODS; CLOSURES; CONFIGURATION; CRITICALITY; EXTRAPOLATION; VALIDATION; WASTES; YUCCA MOUNTAIN

Citation Formats

J.W. Pegram. Calculation of Upper Subcritical Limits for Nuclear Criticality in a Repository. United States: N. p., 1998. Web. doi:10.2172/895333.
Copy to clipboard
J.W. Pegram. Calculation of Upper Subcritical Limits for Nuclear Criticality in a Repository. United States. doi:10.2172/895333.
Copy to clipboard
J.W. Pegram. Wed . "Calculation of Upper Subcritical Limits for Nuclear Criticality in a Repository". United States. doi:10.2172/895333. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/895333.
Copy to clipboard
@article{osti_895333,
title = {Calculation of Upper Subcritical Limits for Nuclear Criticality in a Repository},
author = {J.W. Pegram},
abstractNote = {The purpose of this document is to present the methodology to be used for development of the Subcritical Limit (SL) for post closure conditions for the Yucca Mountain repository. The SL is a value based on a set of benchmark criticality multiplier, k{sub eff} results that are outputs of the MCNP calculation method. This SL accounts for calculational biases and associated uncertainties resulting from the use of MCNP as the method of assessing k{sub eff}. The context for an SL estimate include the range of applicability (based on the set of MCNP results) and the type of SL required for the application at hand. This document will include illustrative calculations for each of three approaches. The data sets used for the example calculations are identified in Section 5.1. These represent three waste categories, and SLs for each of these sets of experiments will be computed in this document. Future MCNP data sets will be analyzed using the methods discussed here. The treatment of the biases evaluated on sets of k{sub eff} results via MCNP is statistical in nature. This document does not address additional non-statistical contributions to the bias margin, acknowledging that regulatory requirements may impose additional administrative penalties. Potentially, there are other biases or margins that should be accounted for when assessing criticality (k{sub eff}). Only aspects of the bias as determined using the stated assumptions and benchmark critical data sets will be included in the methods and sample calculations in this document. The set of benchmark experiments used in the validation of the computational system should be representative of the composition, configuration, and nuclear characteristics for the application at hand. In this work, a range of critical experiments will be the basis of establishing the SL for three categories of waste types that will be in the repository. The ultimate purpose of this document is to present methods that will effectively characterize the MCNP computations with respect to bias, as applicable to the repository setting. Combining varied sets of critical experiments into a single source of benchmark criticals provides wider ranges of applicability and, potentially, additional variability contribution to the treatment for the uncertainty of the bias. This will allow the estimation of the bias characteristics that will be useful in establishing the SL. If extrapolation is required, there may be need for ad lioc analyses to evaluate the bias characteristics, or at a minimum to recalculate the SLY based on the new range for the trending variable. This may also require extending the data set of critical experiments.},
doi = {10.2172/895333},
journal = {},
number = ,
volume = ,
place = {United States},
year = {Wed Jul 29 00:00:00 EDT 1998},
month = {Wed Jul 29 00:00:00 EDT 1998}
}
Copy to clipboard
Technical Report:
View Technical Report (1.46 MB)
DOI:  10.2172/895333
Save / Share:
Export Metadata
Save to My Library
You must Sign In or Create an Account in order to save documents to your library.

  • A compilation of benchmark critical experiments was made for essentially one-dimensional systems containing plutonium. The systems consist of spheres, series of experiments with cylinders and cuboids that permit extrapolation to infinite cylinders and slabs, and large cylinders for which separability of the neutron flux into a product of spatial components is a good approximation. Data from the experiments were placed in a form readily usable as computer code input. Aqueous solutions of Pu(NO/sub 3/)/sub 4/ are treated as solutions of PuO/sub 2/ in nitric acid. The apparent molal volume of PuO/sub 2/ as a function of plutonium concentration was derivedmore » from analyses of solution density data and was incorporated in the Savannah River Laboratory computer codes along with density tables for nitric acid. The biases of three methods of calculation were established by correlation with the benchmark experiments. The oldest method involves two-group diffusion theory and has been used extensively at the Savannah River Laboratory. The other two involve S/sub n/ transport theory with, in one method, Hansen-Roach cross sections and, in the other, cross sections derived from ENDF/B-IV. Subcritical limits were calculated by all three methods. Significant differences were found among the results and between the results and limits currently in the American National Standard for Nuclear Criticality Safety in Operations with Fissionable Materials Outside Reactor (ANSI N16.1), which were calculated by yet another method, despite the normalization of all four methods to the same experimental data. The differences were studied, and a set of subcritical limits was proposed to supplement and in some cases to replace those in the ANSI Standard, which is currently being reviewed.« less

  • ; ;
    An assessment has been performed of the criticality potential associated with the disposal of spent fuel in a tuff geology above the water table. Eleven potential configurations were defined which cover a vast range of geometries and conditions from the nominal configuration at emplacement to a hypothetical configuration thousands of years after emplacement in which the structure is gone, the fuel pellets disintegrated and the borehole flooded. Of these eleven configurations, four have been evaluated at this time. The results of this evaluation indicate that even with very conservative assumptions (4.5 w/o fresh fuel), criticality is not a problem formore » the nominal configuration either dry or fully flooded. In the cases where the condition of the waste package is assumed to have severely deteriorated, over long times, calculations were performed with less conservative assumptions (depleted fuel). An assessment of these calculations indicates that criticality safety could be demonstrated if the depletion of the fissile inventory during fuel irradiation is taken into account. A detailed discussion of the calculations performed is presented in this report. Also included are a description of the configurations which were considered, the analytical methods and models used, and a discussion of additional related work which should be performed. 15 references, 11 figures, 8 tables.« less

  • The purpose of this study is to provide some basic guidance regarding the criticality safety implications associated with long term burial of highly enriched nuclear fuel in a geologic repository. Generic calculations to determine the distance required to neutronically isolate neighboring fissile regions are reported. Two specific fuels are also addressed, Fort Saint Vrain and Shippingport PWR Core-2 Seed-2 (PWR). These fuels are addressed under both dry and flooded conditions. Fort Saint Vrain fuel contains a uranium-graphite fuel matrix, is graphite moderated and has a relatively low {sup 235}U loading ({approximately}1 kg per element). PWR contains a uranium-zirconium fuel matrix,more » is water moderated, zircaloy clad and has a {sup 235}U loading of {approximately}15 kg per cluster. These two fuels are representative of many of the fuels currently stored at the Idaho Chemical Processing Plant (ICPP). The spent fuel storage system under consideration involves filling cylindrical canisters with spent nuclear fuel. These canisters are then to be placed into a geologic repository. Salt and tuff are the two most likely materials in which the canisters will be buried. Canisters will require sufficient material between them to ensure that the overall reactivity stays within acceptable limits. Fuels will also have to be shown to be critically safe under a variety of conditions. These conditions include flooding and the loss of the physical integrity of the fuel.« less

  • ;