skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Annual emissions and air-quality impacts of an urban area district-heating system: Boston case study

Abstract

A district-heating system, based on thermal energy from power plants retrofitted to operate in the cogeneration mode, is expected to improve local air quality. This possibility has been examined by comparing the emissions of five major atmospheric pollutants, i.e., particulates, sulfur oxides, carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, and nitrogen oxides, from the existing heating and electric system in the City of Boston with those from a proposed district heating system. Detailed, spatial distribution of existing heating load and fuel mix is developed to specify emissions associated with existing heating systems. Actual electric-power-plant parameters and generation for the base year are specified. Additional plant fuel consumption and emissions resulting from cogeneration operation have been estimated. Six alternative fuel-emissions-control scenarios are considered. The average annual ground-level concentrations of sulfur oxides are calculated using a modified form of the EPA's Climatological Dispersion Model. This report describes the methodology, the results and their implications, and the areas for extended investigation. The initial results confirm expectations. Average sulfur oxides concentrations at various points within and near the city drop by up to 85% in the existing fuels scenarios and by 95% in scenarios in which different fuels and more-stringent emissions controls at the plants are used. Thesemore » reductions are relative to concentrations caused by fuel combustion for heating and large commercial and industrial process uses within the city and Boston Edison Co. electric generation.« less

Authors:
; ; ;
Publication Date:
Research Org.:
Argonne National Lab., IL (USA)
OSTI Identifier:
5227005
Report Number(s):
ANL/CNSV-TM-36
DOE Contract Number:
W-31-109-ENG-38
Resource Type:
Technical Report
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Subject:
32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATION; 54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES; 29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY AND ECONOMY; AIR QUALITY; DISTRICT HEATING; ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS; MASSACHUSETTS; POLLUTION SOURCES; EMISSION; AEROSOLS; CARBON MONOXIDE; CO-GENERATION; COMPARATIVE EVALUATIONS; HEATING SYSTEMS; HYDROCARBONS; NITROGEN OXIDES; PARTICLES; SULFUR OXIDES; URBAN AREAS; CARBON COMPOUNDS; CARBON OXIDES; CHALCOGENIDES; COLLOIDS; DEUS; DISPERSIONS; ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY; HEATING; NITROGEN COMPOUNDS; NORTH AMERICA; NORTH ATLANTIC REGION; ORGANIC COMPOUNDS; OXIDES; OXYGEN COMPOUNDS; POWER GENERATION; SOLS; STEAM GENERATION; SULFUR COMPOUNDS; USA; 320603* - Energy Conservation, Consumption, & Utilization- Municipalities & Community Systems- Public Utilities- (1980-); 500200 - Environment, Atmospheric- Chemicals Monitoring & Transport- (-1989); 290800 - Energy Planning & Policy- Heat Utilization- (1980-); 290300 - Energy Planning & Policy- Environment, Health, & Safety

Citation Formats

Bernow, S.S., McAnulty, D.R., Buchsbaum, S., and Levine, E. Annual emissions and air-quality impacts of an urban area district-heating system: Boston case study. United States: N. p., 1980. Web. doi:10.2172/5227005.
Copy to clipboard
Bernow, S.S., McAnulty, D.R., Buchsbaum, S., & Levine, E. Annual emissions and air-quality impacts of an urban area district-heating system: Boston case study. United States. doi:10.2172/5227005.
Copy to clipboard
Bernow, S.S., McAnulty, D.R., Buchsbaum, S., and Levine, E. Fri . "Annual emissions and air-quality impacts of an urban area district-heating system: Boston case study". United States. doi:10.2172/5227005. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/5227005.
Copy to clipboard
@article{osti_5227005,
title = {Annual emissions and air-quality impacts of an urban area district-heating system: Boston case study},
author = {Bernow, S.S. and McAnulty, D.R. and Buchsbaum, S. and Levine, E.},
abstractNote = {A district-heating system, based on thermal energy from power plants retrofitted to operate in the cogeneration mode, is expected to improve local air quality. This possibility has been examined by comparing the emissions of five major atmospheric pollutants, i.e., particulates, sulfur oxides, carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, and nitrogen oxides, from the existing heating and electric system in the City of Boston with those from a proposed district heating system. Detailed, spatial distribution of existing heating load and fuel mix is developed to specify emissions associated with existing heating systems. Actual electric-power-plant parameters and generation for the base year are specified. Additional plant fuel consumption and emissions resulting from cogeneration operation have been estimated. Six alternative fuel-emissions-control scenarios are considered. The average annual ground-level concentrations of sulfur oxides are calculated using a modified form of the EPA's Climatological Dispersion Model. This report describes the methodology, the results and their implications, and the areas for extended investigation. The initial results confirm expectations. Average sulfur oxides concentrations at various points within and near the city drop by up to 85% in the existing fuels scenarios and by 95% in scenarios in which different fuels and more-stringent emissions controls at the plants are used. These reductions are relative to concentrations caused by fuel combustion for heating and large commercial and industrial process uses within the city and Boston Edison Co. electric generation.},
doi = {10.2172/5227005},
journal = {},
number = ,
volume = ,
place = {United States},
year = {Fri Feb 01 00:00:00 EST 1980},
month = {Fri Feb 01 00:00:00 EST 1980}
}
Copy to clipboard
Technical Report:
View Technical Report (9.78 MB)
DOI:  10.2172/5227005
Save / Share:
Export Metadata
Save to My Library
You must Sign In or Create an Account in order to save documents to your library.

  • ; ; ; ...
    A study was made to determine the potential impact of a district-heating/cogeneration system on the air quality in the Minneapolis-St. Paul metropolitan area. Annual average SO/sub 2/ concentrations in air at ground level were determined for a base year (1976) and for a future year (1987) with and without a 2600-MW(t) district-heating system. Without district heating, the SO/sub 2/ concentrations in the area are predicted to increase with time because of anticipated increased substitution of oil for curtailed natural gas. Implementation of the district-heating/cogeneration system is predicted to mitigate this increase of SO/sub 2/ concentrations significantly. Although the total emissionsmore » will be slightly higher with district heating/cogeneration because of the substitution of coal for natural gas and oil, use of tall stacks at the cogeneration plants will permit greater dispersion of the SO/sub 2/ emissions. Considerable overall energy savings, particularly in the form of natural gas and oil, will be realized with a district heating/cogeneration system.« less

  • ; ;
    The study described in this report is part of a project sponsored by the Toronto Atmospheric Fund, performed at the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, to assess the potential role of surface property modifications on energy, meteorology, and air quality in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA), Canada. Numerical models were used to establish the possible meteorological and ozone air-quality impacts of increased urban albedo and vegetative fraction, i.e., ''cool-city'' strategies that can mitigate the urban heat island (UHI), significantly reduce urban energy consumption, and improve thermal comfort, particularly during periods of hot weather in summer. Mitigation is even more important duringmore » critical heat wave periods with possible increased heat-related hospitalization and mortality. The evidence suggests that on an annual basis cool-city strategies are beneficial, and the implementation of such measures is currently being investigated in the U.S. and Canada. We simulated possible scenari os for urban heat-island mitigation in the GTA and investigated consequent meteorological changes, and also performed limited air-quality analysis to assess related impacts. The study was based on a combination of mesoscale meteorological modeling, Lagrangian (trajectory), and photochemical trajectory modeling to assess the potential meteorological and ozone air-quality impacts of cool-city strategies. As available air-quality and emissions data are incompatible with models currently in use at LBNL, our air-quality analysis was based on photochemical trajectory modeling. Because of questions as to the accuracy and appropriateness of this approach, in our opinion this aspect of the study can be improved in the future, and the air-quality results discussed in this report should be viewed as relatively qualitative. The MM5 meteorological model predicts a UHI in the order of 2 to 3 degrees C in locations of maxima, and about 1 degree C as a typical value over most of the urban area. Our si mulations suggest that cool-city strategies can typically reduce local urban air temperature by 0.5-1 degrees C; as more sporadic events, larger decreases (1.5 degrees C, 2.5-2.7 degrees C and 4-6 degrees C) were also simulated. With regard to ozone mixing ratios along the simulated trajectories, the effects of cool-city strategies appear to be on the order of 2 ppb, a typical decrease. The photochemical trajectory model (CIT) also simulates larger decreases (e.g., 4 to 8 ppb), but these are not taken as representative of the potential impacts in this report. A comparison with other simulations suggest very crudely that a decrease of this magnitude corresponds to significant ''equivalent'' decreases in both NOx and VOCs emissions in the region. Our preliminary results suggest that significant UHI control can be achieved with cool-cities strategies in the GTA and is therefore worth further study. We recommend that better input data and more accurate modeling schemes be used to carry out f uture studies in the same direction.« less

  • ;
    A site-specific study was conducted to evaluate the feasibility of a large, cogeneration/district-heating system for US cities. The MInneapolis-St. Paul area was chosen as the site for a case study of a modern hot-water district-heating system. The first phase of the work was a conceptual feasibility study for the entire metropolitan region. The effort concentrated on assessing the heat loads and heat sources that could be connected over a 20-year period. This study phase set the framework for the overall potential for district heating in the region and was the stimulus for the sceond phase, the St. Paul district-heating demonstrationmore » project. The St. P District-Heating Development Company is planning to build the first modern hot-water district-heating system in a major US city.« less

  • ; ;
    The report provides procedures for estimating the ambient air concentrations associated with emissions of particulate matter from soils handling operations at Superfund sites. Materials handling operations are necessary at any site where ex-situ treatment is performed. In addition, soils handling operations, such as excavation or grading, are frequently performed as part of site preparation. Procedures are given to evaluate the effect of the handling rate and contaminant concentration on the emission rates and on the ambient air concentrations at selected distances from the treatment area. Health-based ambient air action levels are also provided for comparison to the estimated ambient concentrations.

  • ; ; ; ...
    A central solar-heating plant with seasonal heat storage in a deep underground aquifer is designed by means of a solar-seasonal-storage-system simulation code based on the Solar Energy Research Institute (SERI) code for Solar Annual Storage Simulation (SASS). This Solar Seasonal Storage Plant is designed to supply close to 100% of the annual heating and domestic-hot-water (DHW) load of a hypothetical new community, the Fox River Valley Project, for a location in Madison, Wisconsin. Some analyses are also carried out for Boston, Massachusetts and Copenhagen, Denmark, as an indication of weather and insolation effects. Analyses are conducted for five different typesmore » of solar collectors, and for an alternate system utilizing seasonal storage in a large water tank. Predicted seasonal performance and system and storage costs are calculated. To provide some validation of the SASS results, a simulation of the solar system with seasonal storage in a large water tank is also carried out with a modified version of the Swedish Solar Seasonal Storage Code MINSUN.« less