skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: The importance of mediation

Abstract

Environmental mediation involving hazardous materials often includes a neutral, third party to assist other groups with resolving disputes or with negotiations. Most often, mediators facilitate discussion and suggest possible resolutions among parties, rather than advise as to what action must be taken to reach an agreement. There is opportunity for all sides to express grievances and frustrations as well as hearing possible solutions to resolve discrepancies. Most often, those involved with mediation attain a sense of confidence, competency, and satisfaction with the mediation process. An honest broker is an example of a third party mediator believed capable of assisting mediation in an unbiased manner. The opposing groups must be confident that an honest broker is credible and will provide his/her services to reach a satisfactory conclusion; therefore, the reputation of the mediator is crucial to the success of the mediation process.

Authors:
 [1]
  1. Environmental Mediation, Inc., Newport Beach, CA (United States)
Publication Date:
OSTI Identifier:
452005
Report Number(s):
CONF-9611118-
TRN: IM9715%%37
Resource Type:
Conference
Resource Relation:
Conference: HazMat West `96. International environmental management and technology conference and exhibition, Long Beach, CA (United States), 5-7 Nov 1996; Other Information: PBD: 1996; Related Information: Is Part Of 12. annual environmental management and technology conference west -- HazMat `96 west: Technical papers; PB: 544 p.
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Subject:
29 ENERGY PLANNING AND POLICY; NEGOTIATION; HAZARDOUS MATERIALS; REMEDIAL ACTION; ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY; ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS; ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY; LIABILITIES

Citation Formats

Nastri, W.H. The importance of mediation. United States: N. p., 1996. Web.
Nastri, W.H. The importance of mediation. United States.
Nastri, W.H. 1996. "The importance of mediation". United States. doi:.
@article{osti_452005,
title = {The importance of mediation},
author = {Nastri, W.H.},
abstractNote = {Environmental mediation involving hazardous materials often includes a neutral, third party to assist other groups with resolving disputes or with negotiations. Most often, mediators facilitate discussion and suggest possible resolutions among parties, rather than advise as to what action must be taken to reach an agreement. There is opportunity for all sides to express grievances and frustrations as well as hearing possible solutions to resolve discrepancies. Most often, those involved with mediation attain a sense of confidence, competency, and satisfaction with the mediation process. An honest broker is an example of a third party mediator believed capable of assisting mediation in an unbiased manner. The opposing groups must be confident that an honest broker is credible and will provide his/her services to reach a satisfactory conclusion; therefore, the reputation of the mediator is crucial to the success of the mediation process.},
doi = {},
journal = {},
number = ,
volume = ,
place = {United States},
year = 1996,
month =
}

Conference:
Other availability
Please see Document Availability for additional information on obtaining the full-text document. Library patrons may search WorldCat to identify libraries that hold this conference proceeding.

Save / Share:
  • Interleukin 3 (IL3) has recently been shown to be a mast cell/basophil growth factor. Based on the previous observations that IL3-dependent cells are capable of NC activity which are believed to be important in immunosurveillance, the authors attempted to define if the IL3-dependent NC cells were of basophilic origin. To approach this, the authors tested a murine IL3-dependent basophilic cell line and a rat basophilic leukemic cell line against various tumor targets in a 4h or 18h /sup 51/Cr release assay. Both basophilic cell types effectively lysed the NC target, WEHI-164, but not the NK targets, YAC-1, RLM1, RBL5. Moreover,more » triggering of the basophils by incubation at 37C with IgE-anti-IgE or IgE with specific antigen or by direct binding to anti-IgE receptor antibodies enhanced NC activity and at the same time induced the release of a soluble cytotoxic factor (CF). The CF lysed only WEHI but not YAC-1, RLM1 or RBL5 tumor cells, distinguishing it from NKCF. The release of the NCCF was dependent on the dose of the triggering agents, required extracellular Ca/sup + +/, and was detected within 15 min of triggering. It has a MW of 43,000 as determined by gel filtration. Basophils, therefore, are not only involved in inflammatory responses but also in tumor immunity, via the NC effector mechanism.« less
  • Skin tumors induced in mice by chronic ultraviolet (UV) irradiation are highly antigenic and can induce a state of transplantation immunity in syngeneic animals. In the present study, the authors compared the in vitro cytolytic activity of splenic lymphocytes from mice immunized with either regressor or progressor UV-tumors. The results of this comparison implicated tumor-specific cytolytic T (Tc) lymphocytes in rejection of regressor UV-tumors, and revealed that immunization with the progressor UV-tumor 2237 failed to elicit detectable levels of progressor tumor-specific Tc cells even as the tumors rejected. Following in vitro resensitization of spleen cells from either regressor or progressormore » tumor immune animals, the authors found NK-like lymphocytes with anti-tumor activity. As the authors had not detected cells with this activity in splenic lymphocyte preparations prior to in vitro resensitization, the authors examined lymphocytes from the local tumor environment during the course of progressor tumor rejection for this activity. This analysis revealed NK lymphocytes exhibiting significant levels of cytolytic activity against UV-tumors. These results implicate NK cells as potential effector cells in the rejection of progressor UV-tumors by immune animals, and suggests that these cells may be regulated by T lymphocytes.« less
  • There has been a search for an effective alternative for resolving disputes over environmental issues. Properly employed, and in suitable situations, environmental mediation can be such a remedy; it has proved less costly and time consuming than litigation, and has produced agreements honored by the parties to the mediation. Why has it not been employed more extensively. And what is its potential for helping to resolve disputes related to coal mining and other mineral extraction. What are some of the disadvantages, weaknesses, or failures of environmental mediation. There are a number, of course, but the most important probably are thosemore » that involve 1) representation - that is to say, who is involved in the mediation process - and 2) the matter of closure and implementation. Let's consider each of these briefly.« less
  • Examples are given of cases in which mediation has and is playing a part in the establishment of environmental policy. Benefits of mediated settlements include savings in time and expense for all parties involved, as well as the ability to accommodate a multiplicity of parties and viewpoints and to tailor a solution to the problem. A more-subtle prospect offered by the process is that in some situations a compromise will accomplish broader objectives to the problem than a total victory in adversarial proceedings would yield. (JGB)
  • In the past few years there has been a rapid growth in interest in the subject of environmental mediation and other alternative forms of environmental conflict resolution. A number of mediation centers have sprung into existence, largely with foundation support. Several disputes have been successfully mediated, although actual case histories are still limited in number. This development has taken place largely because of frustration with the more traditional forms of conflict resolution, particularly litigation, and is therefore likely to continue as court dockets lengthen. In addition to traditional mediation, several groups have conducted major policy dialogues dealing with such issuesmore » as coal and nuclear waste. Environmental mediation is nearing a turning point. It will soon be known whether it can make a major contribution to decision making and receive the recognition it must have to achieve adequate funding and case loads. The author is optimistic that mediation will play an increasing role in environmental conflict over the next few years.« less