SUFT408: On the Determination of Equivalent Squares for Rectangular Small MV Photon Fields
Abstract
Purpose: It is common practice to tabulate dosimetric data like output factors, scatter factors and detector signal correction factors for a set of square fields. In order to get the data for an arbitrary field, it is mapped to an equivalent square, having the same scatter as the field of interest. For rectangular fields both, tabulated data and empiric formula exist. We tested the applicability of such rules for very small fields. Methods: Using the MonteCarlo method (EGSnrcdoseRZ), the dose to a point in 10cm depth in water was calculated for cylindrical impinging fluence distributions. Radii were from 0.5mm to 11.5mm with 1mm thickness of the rings. Different photon energies were investigated. With these data a matrix was constructed assigning the amount of dose to the field center to each matrix element. By summing up the elements belonging to a certain field, the dose for an arbitrary point in 10cm depth could be determined. This was done for rectangles up to 21mm side length. Comparing the dose to square field results, equivalent squares could be assigned. The results were compared to using the geometrical mean and the 4Xperimeter/area rule. Results: For side length differences less than 2mm, the difference betweenmore »
 Authors:
 University of Wuerzburg, Wuerzburg (Germany)
 Publication Date:
 OSTI Identifier:
 22649004
 Resource Type:
 Journal Article
 Resource Relation:
 Journal Name: Medical Physics; Journal Volume: 43; Journal Issue: 6; Other Information: (c) 2016 American Association of Physicists in Medicine; Country of input: International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA)
 Country of Publication:
 United States
 Language:
 English
 Subject:
 60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES; 61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY; CYLINDRICAL CONFIGURATION; MATRICES; MONTE CARLO METHOD; PHOTONS; RADIATION DOSES; RADIOTHERAPY
Citation Formats
Sauer, OA, Wegener, S, and Exner, F. SUFT408: On the Determination of Equivalent Squares for Rectangular Small MV Photon Fields. United States: N. p., 2016.
Web. doi:10.1118/1.4956593.
Sauer, OA, Wegener, S, & Exner, F. SUFT408: On the Determination of Equivalent Squares for Rectangular Small MV Photon Fields. United States. doi:10.1118/1.4956593.
Sauer, OA, Wegener, S, and Exner, F. 2016.
"SUFT408: On the Determination of Equivalent Squares for Rectangular Small MV Photon Fields". United States.
doi:10.1118/1.4956593.
@article{osti_22649004,
title = {SUFT408: On the Determination of Equivalent Squares for Rectangular Small MV Photon Fields},
author = {Sauer, OA and Wegener, S and Exner, F},
abstractNote = {Purpose: It is common practice to tabulate dosimetric data like output factors, scatter factors and detector signal correction factors for a set of square fields. In order to get the data for an arbitrary field, it is mapped to an equivalent square, having the same scatter as the field of interest. For rectangular fields both, tabulated data and empiric formula exist. We tested the applicability of such rules for very small fields. Methods: Using the MonteCarlo method (EGSnrcdoseRZ), the dose to a point in 10cm depth in water was calculated for cylindrical impinging fluence distributions. Radii were from 0.5mm to 11.5mm with 1mm thickness of the rings. Different photon energies were investigated. With these data a matrix was constructed assigning the amount of dose to the field center to each matrix element. By summing up the elements belonging to a certain field, the dose for an arbitrary point in 10cm depth could be determined. This was done for rectangles up to 21mm side length. Comparing the dose to square field results, equivalent squares could be assigned. The results were compared to using the geometrical mean and the 4Xperimeter/area rule. Results: For side length differences less than 2mm, the difference between all methods was in general less than 0.2mm. For more elongated fields, relevant differences of more than 1mm and up to 3mm for the fields investigated occurred. The mean square side length calculated from both empiric formulas fitted much better, deviating hardly more than 1mm and for the very elongated fields only. Conclusion: For small rectangular photon fields, deviating only moderately from square both investigated empiric methods are sufficiently accurate. As the deviations often differ regarding their sign, using the mean improves the accuracy and the useable elongation range. For ratios larger than 2, MonteCarlo generated data are recommended. SW is funded by Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (SA481/101)},
doi = {10.1118/1.4956593},
journal = {Medical Physics},
number = 6,
volume = 43,
place = {United States},
year = 2016,
month = 6
}

In an attempt to find the most suitable method for determining the equivalent square for two commonly employed blocked field arrangements, a comparison of measured outputs was made for four different treatment machines. The machines varied by manufacturer, design, and energy. The fields in question were a midlineblocked field and a halfblocked field. The data obtained were used to streamline calculations made by technologists for the original treatment setting. It was further used to enhance the accuracy of computergenerated verification of the original setting. The authors recommend that each institution employing such fields consider obtaining similar data for their ownmore »

Sci—Fri AM: Mountain — 01: Validation of a new formulism and the related correction factors on output factor determination for small photon fields
Small field dosimetry measurements including output factors are difficult due to lack of chargedparticle equilibrium, occlusion of the radiation source, the finite size of detectors, and nonwater equivalence of detector components. With available detectors significant variations could be measured that will lead to incorrect delivered dose to patients. IAEA/AAPM have provided a framework and formulation to correct the detector response in small photon fields. Monte Carlo derived correction factors for some commonly used small field detectors are now available, however validation has not been performed prior to this study. An Exradin A16 chamber, EDGE detector and SFD detector were usedmore » 
SUC30406: Determination of Intermediate Correction Factors for Three Dosimeters in Small Composite Photon Fields Used in Robotic Radiosurgery
Purpose: To calculate using MonteCarlo the intermediate and total correction factors (CFs) for two microchambers and a plastic scintillator for composite fields delivered by the CyberKnife system. Methods: A linac model was created in BEAMnrc by matching percentage depth dose (PDD) curves and output factors (OFs) measured using an A16 microchamber with Monte Carlo calculations performed in egschamber to explicitly model detector response. Intermediate CFs were determined for the A16 and A26 microchambers and the W1 plastic scintillator in fourteen different composite fields inside a solid water phantom. Seven of these fields used a 5 mm diameter collimator; the remainingmore » 
An analytical method to calculate equivalent fields to irregular symmetric and asymmetric photon fields
Equivalent field is frequently used for central axis depthdose calculations of rectangular and irregularshaped photon beams. As most of the proposed models to calculate the equivalent square field are dosimetry based, a simple physicalbased method to calculate the equivalent square field size was used as the basis of this study. The table of the sides of the equivalent square or rectangular fields was constructed and then compared with the wellknown tables by BJR and Venselaar, et al. with the average relative error percentage of 2.5 ± 2.5% and 1.5 ± 1.5%, respectively. To evaluate the accuracy of this method, themore »