skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: SU-F-P-51: Similarity Analysis of the Linear Accelerator Machines Based On Clinical Simulation

Abstract

Purpose: To evaluate the clinical rationale for Truebeam and Trilogy Linac machines from Varian Medical System as exchangeable treatment modalities in the same radiation oncology department. Methods: Intensity Modulated Radiotherapy (IMRT) plans for different diseases were selected for this study. These disease sites included brain, head and neck, breast, lung, and prostate. The parameters selected for this study were the energy amount, Monitor Unit (MU); dose coverage of target reflected by prescription isodose volume(PIV); dose spillage described by the volume of 50% isodoseline of the prescription; and dose homogeneities represented by the maximum dose (MaxD) and the minimum dose (MinD) of target volume (TV) and critical structure (CS). Each percentage difference between the values of these parameters formed an element of a matrix, which was called Similarity Comparison Matrix(SCM). The elements of the SCM were then simplified by dimensional conversion algorithm, which was used to determine clinical similarity between two machines through a single value. Results: For the selected clinical cases in this study, the average percentage differences between Trilogy and Truebeam in MU was 0.28% with standard deviation(SD) 0.66%, PIV was 0.23% with SD 0.20%, Volume at 50% prescription dose was 0.31% with SD at 0.78%, MaxD at TVmore » is 0.26% with SD 0.35%, MinD at TV is −0.04% with SD 0.51%, MaxD in CS is −0.53% with SD 0.92%, and MinD in CS 3.31%, with SD at 2.89%. The sum, product, geometric and harmonic mean for the matrix elements were 19.0%, 0.00%, 0.19%, and 0.00%. Conclusion: A method to compare two machines in clinical level was developed and some reference values were calculated for decision-making in clinical practice, and this strategy could be expanded to different clinical applications.« less

Authors:
 [1];  [2]
  1. Associates In Medical Physics, Lanham, MD (United States)
  2. (United States)
Publication Date:
OSTI Identifier:
22626721
Resource Type:
Journal Article
Resource Relation:
Journal Name: Medical Physics; Journal Volume: 43; Journal Issue: 6; Other Information: (c) 2016 American Association of Physicists in Medicine; Country of input: International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA)
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Subject:
60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES; 61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY; ALGORITHMS; BRAIN; DECISION MAKING; DISEASES; LINEAR ACCELERATORS; LUNGS; MAMMARY GLANDS; PROSTATE; RADIATION DOSES; RADIOTHERAPY; SIMULATION

Citation Formats

Li, K, and John R Marsh Cancer Center. SU-F-P-51: Similarity Analysis of the Linear Accelerator Machines Based On Clinical Simulation. United States: N. p., 2016. Web. doi:10.1118/1.4955758.
Li, K, & John R Marsh Cancer Center. SU-F-P-51: Similarity Analysis of the Linear Accelerator Machines Based On Clinical Simulation. United States. doi:10.1118/1.4955758.
Li, K, and John R Marsh Cancer Center. 2016. "SU-F-P-51: Similarity Analysis of the Linear Accelerator Machines Based On Clinical Simulation". United States. doi:10.1118/1.4955758.
@article{osti_22626721,
title = {SU-F-P-51: Similarity Analysis of the Linear Accelerator Machines Based On Clinical Simulation},
author = {Li, K and John R Marsh Cancer Center},
abstractNote = {Purpose: To evaluate the clinical rationale for Truebeam and Trilogy Linac machines from Varian Medical System as exchangeable treatment modalities in the same radiation oncology department. Methods: Intensity Modulated Radiotherapy (IMRT) plans for different diseases were selected for this study. These disease sites included brain, head and neck, breast, lung, and prostate. The parameters selected for this study were the energy amount, Monitor Unit (MU); dose coverage of target reflected by prescription isodose volume(PIV); dose spillage described by the volume of 50% isodoseline of the prescription; and dose homogeneities represented by the maximum dose (MaxD) and the minimum dose (MinD) of target volume (TV) and critical structure (CS). Each percentage difference between the values of these parameters formed an element of a matrix, which was called Similarity Comparison Matrix(SCM). The elements of the SCM were then simplified by dimensional conversion algorithm, which was used to determine clinical similarity between two machines through a single value. Results: For the selected clinical cases in this study, the average percentage differences between Trilogy and Truebeam in MU was 0.28% with standard deviation(SD) 0.66%, PIV was 0.23% with SD 0.20%, Volume at 50% prescription dose was 0.31% with SD at 0.78%, MaxD at TV is 0.26% with SD 0.35%, MinD at TV is −0.04% with SD 0.51%, MaxD in CS is −0.53% with SD 0.92%, and MinD in CS 3.31%, with SD at 2.89%. The sum, product, geometric and harmonic mean for the matrix elements were 19.0%, 0.00%, 0.19%, and 0.00%. Conclusion: A method to compare two machines in clinical level was developed and some reference values were calculated for decision-making in clinical practice, and this strategy could be expanded to different clinical applications.},
doi = {10.1118/1.4955758},
journal = {Medical Physics},
number = 6,
volume = 43,
place = {United States},
year = 2016,
month = 6
}
  • Purpose: To report our clinical experiences with on-board imager (OBI) kV image verification for cranial stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) and radiotherapy (SRT) treatments. Methods and Materials: Between January 2007 and May 2008, 42 patients (57 lesions) were treated with SRS with head frame immobilization and 13 patients (14 lesions) were treated with SRT with face mask immobilization at our institution. No margin was added to the gross tumor for SRS patients, and a 3-mm three-dimensional margin was added to the gross tumor to create the planning target volume for SRT patients. After localizing the patient with stereotactic target positioner (TaPo), orthogonalmore » kV images using OBI were taken and fused to planning digital reconstructed radiographs. Suggested couch shifts in vertical, longitudinal, and lateral directions were recorded. kV images were also taken immediately after treatment for 21 SRS patients and on a weekly basis for 6 SRT patients to assess any intrafraction changes. Results: For SRS patients, 57 pretreatment kV images were evaluated and the suggested shifts were all within 1 mm in any direction (i.e., within the accuracy of image fusion). For SRT patients, the suggested shifts were out of the 3-mm tolerance for 31 of 309 setups. Intrafraction motions were detected in 3 SRT patients. Conclusions: kV imaging provided a useful tool for SRS or SRT setups. For SRS setup with head frame, it provides radiographic confirmation of localization using the stereotactic target positioner. For SRT with mask, a 3-mm margin is adequate and feasible for routine setup when TaPo is combined with kV imaging.« less
  • This paper deals with two stability aspects of linear systems of the form I ¨ x +B˙ x +Cx = 0 given by the triple (I;B;C). A general transformation scheme is given for a structure and Jordan form preserving transformation of the triple. We investigate how a system can be transformed by suitable choices of the transformation parameters into a new system (I;B1;C1) with a symmetrizable matrix C1. This procedure facilitates stability investigations. We also consider systems with a Hamiltonian spectrum which discloses marginal stability after a Jordan form preserving transformation.
  • A previous paper introduced the use of wave digital filters as a basic building block for power system simulation, particularly suitable for real-time applications. This paper stresses the simulation of non-linear and switching elements, emphasizing the advantages of the wave filters implementation. The digital structure is maintained even when non-linear components change their characteristics or power electronic devices switch their states. As a very important by-product, the suppression of numerical oscillations related to the trapezoidal rule is achieved in a rather simple way, with no effects on simulation results.
  • This paper, which continues the preceding works will provide further detailed discussions about both parasitic hunting-effect alleviation of transverse flux homopolar linear induction machine (TFLIM), and improvement on closed-loop transient characteristics of transverse flux homopolar linear oscillating machine (TFLOM). Novel artificial knowledge-based compensators are proposed here to solve above problems for these time-varying and highly nonlinear machine systems. It will be shown that not only this approach is easy of practical implementation, but also the involved design tasks of such compensators are applicable for other linear machine control objectives. Illustrations and verifications will be supplied to confirm the graceful featuresmore » of this intelligent strategy.« less
  • This paper will present a prototype of transverse flux homopolar linear machine system, along with a systematic and generalized 3-dimensional approach which is capable to analyze three kinds of linear machines, the transverse flux linear induction machine (TFLIM), the homopolar linear synchronous machine (HLSM), and the transverse flux linear reluctance machine (TFLRM), all in one compact mathematical model. Also, other than using the conventional steady-state geometric vector analysis or the concentrated magnetic circuit analysis in the modeling process, a novel methodology which combines the state-space technique with the statistical saliency-effect superposition method is proposed. With such detailed and generalized modelingmore » approach, the capability of analyzing the saliency effects induced by the distributed windings in practical linear machine systems will be enhanced, and the representations of all the related linear machine system equations can be manipulated in compact matrix forms. From this comprehensive theoretical approach and the experimental verifications, it is shown that a convenient and reliable mathematical basis for the associated computer-aided analysis and design studies on linear machine systems will be provided.« less