skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Consistency of multi-time Dirac equations with general interaction potentials

Abstract

In 1932, Dirac proposed a formulation in terms of multi-time wave functions as candidate for relativistic many-particle quantum mechanics. A well-known consistency condition that is necessary for existence of solutions strongly restricts the possible interaction types between the particles. It was conjectured by Petrat and Tumulka that interactions described by multiplication operators are generally excluded by this condition, and they gave a proof of this claim for potentials without spin-coupling. Under suitable assumptions on the differentiability of possible solutions, we show that there are potentials which are admissible, give an explicit example, however, show that none of them fulfills the physically desirable Poincaré invariance. We conclude that in this sense, Dirac’s multi-time formalism does not allow to model interaction by multiplication operators, and briefly point out several promising approaches to interacting models one can instead pursue.

Authors:
;  [1]
  1. Mathematisches Institut, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität Theresienstr. 39, 80333 München (Germany)
Publication Date:
OSTI Identifier:
22596651
Resource Type:
Journal Article
Resource Relation:
Journal Name: Journal of Mathematical Physics; Journal Volume: 57; Journal Issue: 7; Other Information: (c) 2016 Author(s); Country of input: International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA)
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Subject:
71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSICS; DIRAC EQUATION; MATHEMATICAL SOLUTIONS; QUANTUM MECHANICS; RELATIVISTIC RANGE; WAVE FUNCTIONS

Citation Formats

Deckert, Dirk-André, E-mail: deckert@math.lmu.de, and Nickel, Lukas, E-mail: nickel@math.lmu.de. Consistency of multi-time Dirac equations with general interaction potentials. United States: N. p., 2016. Web. doi:10.1063/1.4954947.
Deckert, Dirk-André, E-mail: deckert@math.lmu.de, & Nickel, Lukas, E-mail: nickel@math.lmu.de. Consistency of multi-time Dirac equations with general interaction potentials. United States. doi:10.1063/1.4954947.
Deckert, Dirk-André, E-mail: deckert@math.lmu.de, and Nickel, Lukas, E-mail: nickel@math.lmu.de. 2016. "Consistency of multi-time Dirac equations with general interaction potentials". United States. doi:10.1063/1.4954947.
@article{osti_22596651,
title = {Consistency of multi-time Dirac equations with general interaction potentials},
author = {Deckert, Dirk-André, E-mail: deckert@math.lmu.de and Nickel, Lukas, E-mail: nickel@math.lmu.de},
abstractNote = {In 1932, Dirac proposed a formulation in terms of multi-time wave functions as candidate for relativistic many-particle quantum mechanics. A well-known consistency condition that is necessary for existence of solutions strongly restricts the possible interaction types between the particles. It was conjectured by Petrat and Tumulka that interactions described by multiplication operators are generally excluded by this condition, and they gave a proof of this claim for potentials without spin-coupling. Under suitable assumptions on the differentiability of possible solutions, we show that there are potentials which are admissible, give an explicit example, however, show that none of them fulfills the physically desirable Poincaré invariance. We conclude that in this sense, Dirac’s multi-time formalism does not allow to model interaction by multiplication operators, and briefly point out several promising approaches to interacting models one can instead pursue.},
doi = {10.1063/1.4954947},
journal = {Journal of Mathematical Physics},
number = 7,
volume = 57,
place = {United States},
year = 2016,
month = 7
}
  • Multi-time wave functions are wave functions that have a time variable for every particle, such as ϕ(t{sub 1},x{sub 1},...,t{sub N},x{sub N}). They arise as a relativistic analog of the wave functions of quantum mechanics but can be applied also in quantum field theory. The evolution of a wave function with N time variables is governed by N Schrödinger equations, one for each time variable. These Schrödinger equations can be inconsistent with each other, i.e., they can fail to possess a joint solution for every initial condition; in fact, the N Hamiltonians need to satisfy a certain commutator condition in ordermore » to be consistent. While this condition is automatically satisfied for non-interacting particles, it is a challenge to set up consistent multi-time equations with interaction. We prove for a wide class of multi-time Schrödinger equations that the presence of interaction potentials (given by multiplication operators) leads to inconsistency. We conclude that interaction has to be implemented instead by creation and annihilation of particles, which, in fact, can be done consistently [S. Petrat and R. Tumulka, “Multi-time wave functions for quantum field theory,” Ann. Physics (to be published)]. We also prove the following result: When a cut-off length δ > 0 is introduced (in the sense that the multi-time wave function is defined only on a certain set of spacelike configurations, thereby breaking Lorentz invariance), then the multi-time Schrödinger equations with interaction potentials of range δ are consistent; however, in the desired limit δ → 0 of removing the cut-off, the resulting multi-time equations are interaction-free, which supports the conclusion expressed in the title.« less
  • Multi-time wave functions are wave functions that have a time variable for every particle, such as ϕ(t{sub 1},x{sub 1},...,t{sub N},x{sub N}). They arise as a relativistic analog of the wave functions of quantum mechanics but can be applied also in quantum field theory. The evolution of a wave function with N time variables is governed by N Schrödinger equations, one for each time variable. These Schrödinger equations can be inconsistent with each other, i.e., they can fail to possess a joint solution for every initial condition; in fact, the N Hamiltonians need to satisfy a certain commutator condition in ordermore » to be consistent. While this condition is automatically satisfied for non-interacting particles, it is a challenge to set up consistent multi-time equations with interaction. We prove for a wide class of multi-time Schrödinger equations that the presence of interaction potentials (given by multiplication operators) leads to inconsistency. We conclude that interaction has to be implemented instead by creation and annihilation of particles, which, in fact, can be done consistently [S. Petrat and R. Tumulka, “Multi-time wave functions for quantum field theory,” Ann. Physics (to be published)]. We also prove the following result: When a cut-off length δ > 0 is introduced (in the sense that the multi-time wave function is defined only on a certain set of spacelike configurations, thereby breaking Lorentz invariance), then the multi-time Schrödinger equations with interaction potentials of range δ are consistent; however, in the desired limit δ → 0 of removing the cut-off, the resulting multi-time equations are interaction-free, which supports the conclusion expressed in the title.« less
  • Two-body Dirac equations (TBDE) of Dirac's relativistic constraint dynamics have been successfully applied to obtain a covariant nonperturbative description of QED and QCD bound states. Coulomb-type potentials in these applications lead naively in other approaches to singular relativistic corrections at short distances that require the introduction of either perturbative treatments or smoothing parameters. We examine the corresponding singular structures in the effective potentials of the relativistic Schroedinger equation obtained from the Pauli reduction of the TBDE. We find that the relativistic Schroedinger equation leads in fact to well-behaved wave function solutions when the full potential and couplings of the systemmore » are taken into account. The most unusual case is the coupled triplet system with S=1 and L={l_brace}(J-1),(J+1){r_brace}. Without the inclusion of the tensor coupling, the effective S-state potential would become attractively singular. We show how including the tensor coupling is essential in order that the wave functions be well-behaved at short distances. For example, the S-state wave function becomes simply proportional to the D-state wave function and dips sharply to zero at the origin, unlike the usual S-state wave functions. Furthermore, this behavior is similar in both QED and QCD, independent of the asymptotic freedom behavior of the assumed QCD vector potential. Light- and heavy-quark meson states can be described well by using a simplified linear-plus-Coulomb-type QCD potential apportioned appropriately between world scalar and vector potentials. We use this potential to exhibit explicitly the origin of the large pi-rho splitting and effective chiral symmetry breaking. The TBDE formalism developed here may be used to study quarkonia in quark-gluon plasma environments.« less
  • In a recent Letter, we used ''two-body Dirac equations'' to make the naive quark model fully relativistic. In this paper, we apply Dirac's constraint mechanics and supersymmetry not to a string but instead to a system of two spinning particles to derive the two coupled Dirac equations that govern the quantum mechanics of two spin-1/2 particles interacting through world scalar and vector potentials. Along the way, we demonstrate that our equations are compatible, that the scalar and vector interaction structures contribute separately to compatibility when both are present, and that compatibility persists even in the presence of relative-momentum-dependent interactions. Wemore » show that extrapolation of supersymmetries associated with the ordinary single-particle Dirac equation to the interacting two-body system eliminates spin complications and reduces the compatibility problem to that of the corresponding spinless system. In addition, supersymmetry introduces physically important nonperturbative recoil effects that contribute to the correct perturbative spectrum while rendering nonsingular certain singular terms of standard semirelativistic approximations. This eliminates the need for singularity-softening parameters or finite particle sizes in phenomenological applications. In order to make clear the underlying structure of our equations, we also derive the corresponding coupled Dirac or Klein-Gordon equations that govern a system of two particles, one or neither of which has spin.« less