skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Possibilities And Influencing Parameters For The Early Detection Of Sheet Metal Failure In Press Shop Operations

Abstract

The concept of forming limit curves (FLC) is widely used in industrial practice. The required data should be delivered for typical material properties (measured on coils with properties in a range of +/- of the standard deviation from the mean production values) by the material suppliers. In particular it should be noted that its use for the validation of forming robustness providing forming limit curves for the variety of scattering in the mechanical properties is impossible. Therefore a forecast of the expected limit strains without expensive cost and time-consuming experiments is necessary. In the paper the quality of a regression analysis for determining forming limit curves based on tensile test results is presented and discussed.Owing to the specific definition of limit strains with FLCs following linear strain paths, the significance of this failure definition is limited. To consider nonlinear strain path effects, different methods are given in literature. One simple method is the concept of limit stresses. It should be noted that the determined value of the critical stress is dependent on the extrapolation of the tensile test curve. When the yield curve extrapolation is very similar to an exponential function, the definition of the critical stress value is verymore » complicated due to the low slope of the hardening function at large strains.A new method to determine general failure behavior in sheet metal forming is the common use and interpretation of three criteria: onset on material instability (comparable with FLC concept), value of critical shear fracture and the value of ductile fracture. This method seems to be particularly successful for newly developed high strength steel grades in connection with more complex strain paths for some specific material elements. Nevertheless the identification of the different failure material parameters or functions will increase and the user has to learn with the interpretation of the numerical results.« less

Authors:
; ; ;  [1]
  1. ThyssenKrupp Steel AG, Sales/Engineering - Auto Division, Kaiser-Wilhelm Strasse 100, 47166 Duisburg (Germany)
Publication Date:
OSTI Identifier:
21061788
Resource Type:
Journal Article
Resource Relation:
Journal Name: AIP Conference Proceedings; Journal Volume: 908; Journal Issue: 1; Conference: NUMIFORM 2007: 9. international conference on numerical methods in industrial forming processes, Porto (Portugal), 17-21 Jun 2007; Other Information: DOI: 10.1063/1.2740795; (c) 2007 American Institute of Physics; Country of input: International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA)
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Subject:
71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSICS; DIAGRAMS; EXTRAPOLATION; FRACTURES; HARDENING; JOINTS; MECHANICAL PROPERTIES; METALS; NONLINEAR PROBLEMS; PRESSING; REGRESSION ANALYSIS; SHEAR; SHEETS; STEELS; STRAINS; STRESSES; VALIDATION

Citation Formats

Gerlach, Joerg, Kessler, Lutz, Paul, Udo, and Roesen, Hartwig. Possibilities And Influencing Parameters For The Early Detection Of Sheet Metal Failure In Press Shop Operations. United States: N. p., 2007. Web. doi:10.1063/1.2740795.
Gerlach, Joerg, Kessler, Lutz, Paul, Udo, & Roesen, Hartwig. Possibilities And Influencing Parameters For The Early Detection Of Sheet Metal Failure In Press Shop Operations. United States. doi:10.1063/1.2740795.
Gerlach, Joerg, Kessler, Lutz, Paul, Udo, and Roesen, Hartwig. Thu . "Possibilities And Influencing Parameters For The Early Detection Of Sheet Metal Failure In Press Shop Operations". United States. doi:10.1063/1.2740795.
@article{osti_21061788,
title = {Possibilities And Influencing Parameters For The Early Detection Of Sheet Metal Failure In Press Shop Operations},
author = {Gerlach, Joerg and Kessler, Lutz and Paul, Udo and Roesen, Hartwig},
abstractNote = {The concept of forming limit curves (FLC) is widely used in industrial practice. The required data should be delivered for typical material properties (measured on coils with properties in a range of +/- of the standard deviation from the mean production values) by the material suppliers. In particular it should be noted that its use for the validation of forming robustness providing forming limit curves for the variety of scattering in the mechanical properties is impossible. Therefore a forecast of the expected limit strains without expensive cost and time-consuming experiments is necessary. In the paper the quality of a regression analysis for determining forming limit curves based on tensile test results is presented and discussed.Owing to the specific definition of limit strains with FLCs following linear strain paths, the significance of this failure definition is limited. To consider nonlinear strain path effects, different methods are given in literature. One simple method is the concept of limit stresses. It should be noted that the determined value of the critical stress is dependent on the extrapolation of the tensile test curve. When the yield curve extrapolation is very similar to an exponential function, the definition of the critical stress value is very complicated due to the low slope of the hardening function at large strains.A new method to determine general failure behavior in sheet metal forming is the common use and interpretation of three criteria: onset on material instability (comparable with FLC concept), value of critical shear fracture and the value of ductile fracture. This method seems to be particularly successful for newly developed high strength steel grades in connection with more complex strain paths for some specific material elements. Nevertheless the identification of the different failure material parameters or functions will increase and the user has to learn with the interpretation of the numerical results.},
doi = {10.1063/1.2740795},
journal = {AIP Conference Proceedings},
number = 1,
volume = 908,
place = {United States},
year = {Thu May 17 00:00:00 EDT 2007},
month = {Thu May 17 00:00:00 EDT 2007}
}
  • A processing technique for the fabrication of layered metal-intermetallic composites is presented, in which a self-propagating, high-temperature synthesis reaction (SHS) was initiated at the interface between dissimilar elemental metal foils. The resultant composite microstructure consisted of a fully dense, well-bonded metal-intermetallic layered composite. In this United States Bureau of Mines study, metal (Fe, Ni, or Ti) foils were reacted with Al foils to produce metal-metal aluminide layered composites. Tensile tests conducted at room temperature revealed that composites could be designed to behave in a high-strength and high-toughness manner by altering the thicknesses of the starting elemental foils. Failure characteristics revealedmore » that the processes that govern ductile vs brittle behavior of the composites occur early in the fracture.« less
  • Sheet metal stamping processes have been widely implemented in many industries due to its repeatability and productivity. In general, the simulations for a sheet metal forming process involve nonlinearity, complex material behavior and tool-material interaction. Instabilities in terms of tearing and wrinkling are major concerns in many sheet metal stamping processes. In this work, a sheet metal stamping process of a mild steel for a wheelhouse used in automobile industry is studied by using an explicit nonlinear finite element code and incorporating failure analysis (tearing and wrinkling) and design under uncertainty. Margins of tearing and wrinkling are quantitatively defined viamore » stress-based criteria for system-level design. The forming process utilizes drawbeads instead of using the blank holder force to restrain the blank. The main parameters of interest in this work are friction conditions, drawbead configurations, sheet metal properties, and numerical errors. A robust design model is created to conduct a probabilistic design, which is made possible for this complex engineering process via an efficient uncertainty propagation technique. The method called the weighted three-point-based method estimates the statistical characteristics (mean and variance) of the responses of interest (margins of failures), and provide a systematic approach in designing a sheet metal forming process under the framework of design under uncertainty.« less
  • Two analytical approaches are detailed for the determination of Forming Limit Diagrams (F.L.D.) and compared with experimental results. The first one is the 'Enhanced Modified Maximum Force Criterion EMMFC' and the second one is the 'Through-Thickness Shear Instability Criterion TTSIC'. The criteria are both written in an intrinsic analytical form and are applicable to linear and non-linear given strain paths as it occurs in any FEM codes for sheet-metal forming simulation. Finally, the two methods are complementary depending on the nature of failure and the predicted curves are in reasonable agreement with the trend of experimental results for a widemore » range of materials.« less
  • A correct prediction of a possible sheet metal failure is essential to sheet metal forming simulations. The use of the conventional forming limit curve (FLC) is the standard approach on industrial level for this problem. The FLC concept is limited to the case of linear strain paths, however. The initial FLC is no longer valid in the case of nonlinear strain paths. The algorithm Crach allows for a transient prediction of the forming limit for localized necking in the case of arbitrary strain paths. For high strength steels and aluminium sheets there is also a risk of fracture without priormore » localized necking. This paper presents a fracture model that accounts for ductile fracture (caused by void nucleation, void growth and void coalescence) and shear fracture (caused by shear band localization). For both types of fracture, stress state parameters are introduced which can be applied for the plane stress state and for the general 3D stress state. The fracture limits are defined by the equivalent plastic strain at fracture as a function of the stress state parameter based on different experiments with nearly constant stress state parameter. These fracture limit curves are a basis for an integral damage accumulation in the sheet metal forming simulation for arbitrary nonlinear strain paths. The model Crach for the prediction of localized necking and the two fracture models for ductile and shear fracture are combined in the comprehensive failure model CrachFEM. CrachFEM can be linked via a user material model MF GenYld to different explicit FEM codes.« less