skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Why the ninth circuit court's decision on contracts signed during the western markets crisis is a call for FERC to enhance its oversight of market competitiveness

Abstract

Current complaints about problems in the nascent wholesale energy markets should not allow buyers to escape their contractual obligations. It would throw out the baby with the bathwater if the December 2006 decisions provide an excuse for buyers to renege on contractual commitments because today's energy markets are imperfect. (author)

Authors:
; ;
Publication Date:
OSTI Identifier:
20864966
Resource Type:
Journal Article
Resource Relation:
Journal Name: Electricity Journal; Journal Volume: 20; Journal Issue: 2; Other Information: Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Subject:
29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY AND ECONOMY; MARKET; CONTRACTS; MARKETERS; US FERC; COMPETITION; ENFORCEMENT; LEGAL ASPECTS

Citation Formats

Schotland, Sara D., Bidstrup, W. Richard, and Morrissey, Jennifer A. Why the ninth circuit court's decision on contracts signed during the western markets crisis is a call for FERC to enhance its oversight of market competitiveness. United States: N. p., 2007. Web. doi:10.1016/J.TEJ.2007.01.004.
Schotland, Sara D., Bidstrup, W. Richard, & Morrissey, Jennifer A. Why the ninth circuit court's decision on contracts signed during the western markets crisis is a call for FERC to enhance its oversight of market competitiveness. United States. doi:10.1016/J.TEJ.2007.01.004.
Schotland, Sara D., Bidstrup, W. Richard, and Morrissey, Jennifer A. 2007. "Why the ninth circuit court's decision on contracts signed during the western markets crisis is a call for FERC to enhance its oversight of market competitiveness". United States. doi:10.1016/J.TEJ.2007.01.004.
@article{osti_20864966,
title = {Why the ninth circuit court's decision on contracts signed during the western markets crisis is a call for FERC to enhance its oversight of market competitiveness},
author = {Schotland, Sara D. and Bidstrup, W. Richard and Morrissey, Jennifer A.},
abstractNote = {Current complaints about problems in the nascent wholesale energy markets should not allow buyers to escape their contractual obligations. It would throw out the baby with the bathwater if the December 2006 decisions provide an excuse for buyers to renege on contractual commitments because today's energy markets are imperfect. (author)},
doi = {10.1016/J.TEJ.2007.01.004},
journal = {Electricity Journal},
number = 2,
volume = 20,
place = {United States},
year = 2007,
month = 3
}
  • Auctioned biddable contracts, which offer the right to schedule or bid generation into the market, allow for the creation of multiple players while leaving operational control of generation assets in the hands of incumbent firms. The auction process can be designed to facilitate the rent transfer objectives of stranded cost/benefit recovery.
  • In 1994, the U.S. Supreme Court held that ash generated by waste-to-energy (WTE) facilities was not exempt from Subtitle C hazardous waste management regulations under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). As a result of City of Chicago v. Environmental Defense Fund, Inc., WTE installations are required to test their combustion ash and determine whether it is hazardous. The WTE industry and the municipalities utilizing WTE technologies initially feared that if significant amounts of their ash tested hazardous, the costs and liabilities associated with RCRA Subtitle C hazardous waste management requirements would pose a serious threat to the continuedmore » viability of the WTE concept. In this article, the author presents a review of the WTE industry in the five years following the decision, and finds that the specter of the decline of WTE has not materialized.« less
  • A recent decision of the US Supreme Court, upholding a moratorium imposed by the state of California against new construction of nuclear plants until certain conditions are met, is being hailed by critics of nuclear power as a devastating defeat for the nuclear and electric-utility industries, one which will severely cripple, if not eliminate altogether, the further development of nuclear power in the US. The authors disagree with this characterization of the decision and believe that its impact is limited in scope and there are some positive aspects with respect to the decision. Furthermore, the recently enacted Nuclear Waste Policymore » Act at the federal level would seem to satisfy state requirements for the availability of nuclear waste disposal. The future of nuclear power will depend more on its relative economics than on this court decision. Accordingly, Congress should act expeditiously and approve licensing-reform legislation so as to allow nuclear power to compete equitably with other energy sources.« less
  • On March 29, 1995, in its open meeting, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) announced proposed rules under which every public utility would have to unbundle its services (Docket RM95-8-000). Part of the proposal included using a set formula to determine firm transmission rates for use in each utility`s initial rate filing. The FERC also opened a separate proceeding to develop an industry-wide standard for electronic bulletin boards, which will provide information on whether utilities can accommodate a proposed transmission request (Docket RM95-9-000). The author believes that the FERC`s effort on formula-based rates and electronic bulletin boards is misdirected. Formula-basedmore » rates are ill suited for mandatory firm transmission rates, since formula-based rates generally do not acknowledge the operating conditions that will occur during service performance. These conditions can be devastating to the utility and reduce the reliability of the network. The FERC`s effort on formula-based rates in Docket RM95-8-000 would be better directed toward automated real time pricing of unscheduled flows of electricity, and the electronic bulletin boards being studied in Docket RM95-9-000 could be used to report the real time prices being paid at various locations around a utility system.« less
  • Technological advances in power generation and a world-wide increase in the demand for electrical power may offer US companies opportunities in the export markets. In the US alone, the industry is forecasting a need for at least 140000 Mw of new generating capacity in the next ten years and more than six times that much world-wide. Along with fossil fuel plants, independent power producers are building additional hydropower units and are planning at least eight large pumped storage generating projects. While coal remains the dominant fuel in the US, gas-fired combustion turbine plants claim the largest market share. The cleanmore » coal project, however, is expected to boost the use of the fuel, both here and abroad, when integrated gasification turbine units and fluidized bed combustion become commercially available.« less