skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Degree of entanglement as a physically ill-posed problem: The case of entanglement with vacuum

Abstract

We analyze an example of a photon in a superposition of different modes, and ask what is the degree of their entanglement with a vacuum. The problem turns out to be ill-posed since we do not know which representation of the algebra of canonical commutation relations (CCR) to choose for the field quantization. Once we make a choice, we can solve the question of entanglement unambiguously. So the difficulty is not with mathematics, but with physics of the problem. In order to make the discussion explicit we analyze from this perspective a popular argument based on a photon leaving a beam splitter and interacting with two two-level atoms. We first solve the problem algebraically in the Heisenberg picture, without any assumption about the form of representation of CCR. Then we take the {infinity}-representation and show in two ways that in two-mode states the modes are maximally entangled with the vacuum, but single-mode states are not entangled. Next we repeat the analysis in terms of the representation of CCR taken from Berezin's book and show that two-mode states do not involve the mode-vacuum entanglement. Finally, we switch to a family of reducible representations of CCR recently investigated in the context ofmore » field quantization, and show that the entanglement with the vacuum is present even for single-mode states. Still, the degree of entanglement here is difficult to estimate, mainly because there are N+2 subsystems, with N unspecified and large.« less

Authors:
;  [1]
  1. Katedra Fizyki Teoretycznej i Metod Matematycznych, Politechnika Gdanska, 80-952 Gdansk (Poland)
Publication Date:
OSTI Identifier:
20787071
Resource Type:
Journal Article
Resource Relation:
Journal Name: Physical Review. A; Journal Volume: 73; Journal Issue: 4; Other Information: DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevA.73.042111; (c) 2006 The American Physical Society; Country of input: International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA)
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Subject:
74 ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS; ALGEBRA; ATOMS; BEAM SPLITTING; COMMUTATION RELATIONS; ENERGY LEVELS; GROUP THEORY; HEISENBERG PICTURE; OPTICS; PHOTONS; QUANTIZATION; QUANTUM ENTANGLEMENT; QUANTUM MECHANICS; SWITCHES

Citation Formats

Pawlowski, Marcin, and Czachor, Marek. Degree of entanglement as a physically ill-posed problem: The case of entanglement with vacuum. United States: N. p., 2006. Web. doi:10.1103/PHYSREVA.73.0.
Pawlowski, Marcin, & Czachor, Marek. Degree of entanglement as a physically ill-posed problem: The case of entanglement with vacuum. United States. doi:10.1103/PHYSREVA.73.0.
Pawlowski, Marcin, and Czachor, Marek. Sat . "Degree of entanglement as a physically ill-posed problem: The case of entanglement with vacuum". United States. doi:10.1103/PHYSREVA.73.0.
@article{osti_20787071,
title = {Degree of entanglement as a physically ill-posed problem: The case of entanglement with vacuum},
author = {Pawlowski, Marcin and Czachor, Marek},
abstractNote = {We analyze an example of a photon in a superposition of different modes, and ask what is the degree of their entanglement with a vacuum. The problem turns out to be ill-posed since we do not know which representation of the algebra of canonical commutation relations (CCR) to choose for the field quantization. Once we make a choice, we can solve the question of entanglement unambiguously. So the difficulty is not with mathematics, but with physics of the problem. In order to make the discussion explicit we analyze from this perspective a popular argument based on a photon leaving a beam splitter and interacting with two two-level atoms. We first solve the problem algebraically in the Heisenberg picture, without any assumption about the form of representation of CCR. Then we take the {infinity}-representation and show in two ways that in two-mode states the modes are maximally entangled with the vacuum, but single-mode states are not entangled. Next we repeat the analysis in terms of the representation of CCR taken from Berezin's book and show that two-mode states do not involve the mode-vacuum entanglement. Finally, we switch to a family of reducible representations of CCR recently investigated in the context of field quantization, and show that the entanglement with the vacuum is present even for single-mode states. Still, the degree of entanglement here is difficult to estimate, mainly because there are N+2 subsystems, with N unspecified and large.},
doi = {10.1103/PHYSREVA.73.0},
journal = {Physical Review. A},
number = 4,
volume = 73,
place = {United States},
year = {Sat Apr 15 00:00:00 EDT 2006},
month = {Sat Apr 15 00:00:00 EDT 2006}
}
  • A time-domain data continuation problem for a second order hyperbolic equation in a three-dimensional inhomogeneous half-space, which is a common problem in time-domain layer-stripping, is considered. Two different approaches, namely the local continuation approach and the wave-splitting approach, are used to propagate the surface data (the Dirichlet and Neumann data) to the data at deeper planes. The local continuation approach requires a regularization in order to obtain a stable numerical result. The wave-splitting approach uses larger transverse spatial domain of dependence, and gives reasonably stable results even without any additional smoothing process. {copyright} {ital 1996 American Institute of Physics.}
  • We demonstrate a practical possibility of loss compensation in measured photocounting statistics in the presence of dark counts and background radiation noise. It is shown that satisfactory results are obtained even in the case of low detection efficiency and large experimental errors.
  • Purpose: Combination of serial tumor imaging with radiobiological modeling can provide more accurate information on the nature of treatment response and what underlies resistance. The purpose of this article is to improve the algorithms related to imaging-based radiobilogical modeling of tumor response. Methods: Serial imaging of tumor response to radiation therapy represents a sum of tumor cell sensitivity, tumor growth rates, and the rate of cell loss which are not separated explicitly. Accurate treatment response assessment would require separation of these radiobiological determinants of treatment response because they define tumor control probability. We show that the problem of reconstruction ofmore » radiobiological parameters from serial imaging data can be considered as inverse ill-posed problem described by the Fredholm integral equation of the first kind because it is governed by a sum of several exponential processes. Therefore, the parameter reconstruction can be solved using regularization methods. Results: To study the reconstruction problem, we used a set of serial CT imaging data for the head and neck cancer and a two-level cell population model of tumor response which separates the entire tumor cell population in two subpopulations of viable and lethally damage cells. The reconstruction was done using a least squared objective function and a simulated annealing algorithm. Using in vitro data for radiobiological parameters as reference data, we shown that the reconstructed values of cell surviving fractions and potential doubling time exhibit non-physical fluctuations if no stabilization algorithms are applied. The variational regularization allowed us to obtain statistical distribution for cell surviving fractions and cell number doubling times comparable to in vitro data. Conclusion: Our results indicate that using variational regularization can increase the number of free parameters in the model and open the way to development of more advanced algorithms which take into account tumor heterogeneity, for example, related to hypoxia.« less
  • Here, this work explores the effect of the ill-posed problem on uncertainty quantification for motion estimation using digital image correlation (DIC) (Sutton et al. 2009). We develop a correction factor for standard uncertainty estimates based on the cosine of the angle between the true motion and the image gradients, in an integral sense over a subregion of the image. This correction factor accounts for variability in the DIC solution previously unaccounted for when considering only image noise, interpolation bias, contrast, and the software settings such as subset size and spacing.
  • Very large matrices with rapidly decaying singular values commonly arise in the numerical solution of ill-posed problems. The singular value decomposition (SVD) is a basic tool for both the analysis and computation of solutions to such problems. In most applications, it suffices to obtain a partial SVD consisting of only the largest singular values and their corresponding singular vectors. In this paper, two separate approaches -- one based on subspace iteration and the other based on the Lanczos method -- are considered for the efficient iterative computation of partial SVDs. In the context of ill-posed problems, an analytical and numericalmore » comparison of these two methods is made and the role of the regularization operator in convergence acceleration is explored.« less