skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. I. Discovery of the Optical Counterpart Using the Dark Energy Camera

Journal Article · · The Astrophysical Journal. Letters (Online)
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; more »; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; « less

Here, we present the Dark Energy Camera (DECam) discovery of the optical counterpart of the first binary neutron star merger detected through gravitational-wave emission, GW170817. Our observations commenced 10.5 hr post-merger, as soon as the localization region became accessible from Chile. We imaged 70 deg2 in the i and z bands, covering 93% of the initial integrated localization probability, to a depth necessary to identify likely optical counterparts (e.g., a kilonova). At 11.4 hr post-merger we detected a bright optical transient located $$10\buildrel{\prime\prime}\over{.} 6$$ from the nucleus of NGC 4993 at redshift z = 0.0098, consistent (for $${H}_{0}=70$$ km s–1 Mpc–1) with the distance of 40 ± 8 Mpc reported by the LIGO Scientific Collaboration and the Virgo Collaboration (LVC). At detection the transient had magnitudes of $i=17.3$ and $z=17.4$, and thus an absolute magnitude of $${M}_{i}=-15.7$$, in the luminosity range expected for a kilonova. We identified 1500 potential transient candidates. Applying simple selection criteria aimed at rejecting background events such as supernovae, we find the transient associated with NGC 4993 as the only remaining plausible counterpart, and reject chance coincidence at the 99.5% confidence level. We therefore conclude that the optical counterpart we have identified near NGC 4993 is associated with GW170817. This discovery ushers in the era of multi-messenger astronomy with gravitational waves and demonstrates the power of DECam to identify the optical counterparts of gravitational-wave sources.

Research Organization:
SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory (SLAC), Menlo Park, CA (United States); Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL), Los Alamos, NM (United States); Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (FNAL), Batavia, IL (United States); Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL), Berkeley, CA (United States); Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), Oak Ridge, TN (United States); The Ohio State Univ., Columbus, OH (United States)
Sponsoring Organization:
USDOE Office of Science (SC), High Energy Physics (HEP); USDOE Office of Science (SC), Advanced Scientific Computing Research (ASCR); USDOE National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA)
Contributing Organization:
The Dark Energy Survey and The Dark Energy Camera GW-EM Collaboration
Grant/Contract Number:
AC02-76SF00515; AC02-07CH11359; AC02-05CH11231; AC05-00OR22725; AC52-06NA25396; SC0011726
OSTI ID:
1408100
Alternate ID(s):
OSTI ID: 1418148; OSTI ID: 1421834; OSTI ID: 1422481; OSTI ID: 1422966; OSTI ID: 1602503
Report Number(s):
FERMILAB-PUB-17-454-AE-CD-PPD; arXiv:1710.05459; LA-UR-17-29523; TRN: US1702930
Journal Information:
The Astrophysical Journal. Letters (Online), Vol. 848, Issue 2; ISSN 2041-8213
Publisher:
Institute of Physics (IOP)Copyright Statement
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Citation Metrics:
Cited by: 321 works
Citation information provided by
Web of Science

References (43)

GW151226: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a 22-Solar-Mass Binary Black Hole Coalescence journal June 2016
Localization and Broadband Follow-Up of the Gravitational-Wave Transient Gw150914 journal July 2016
Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger journal February 2016
GW170817: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Neutron Star Inspiral journal October 2017
LIGO: the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory journal June 2009
Advanced Virgo: a second-generation interferometric gravitational wave detector journal December 2014
A dark Energy Camera Search for Missing Supergiants in the lmc After the Advanced ligo Gravitational-Wave Event Gw150914 journal May 2016
Binary neutron star mergers: a review of Einstein’s richest laboratory journal July 2017
Effect of a high Opacity on the Light Curves of Radioactively Powered Transients from Compact Object Mergers journal August 2013
Short-Duration Gamma-Ray Bursts journal August 2014
The detection efficiency of on-axis short gamma-ray burst optical afterglows triggered by aLIGO/Virgo journal October 2014
A Decam Search for an Optical Counterpart to the ligo Gravitational-Wave Event Gw151226 journal July 2016
Short GRB and binary black hole standard sirens as a probe of dark energy journal September 2006
The Dark Energy Survey: more than dark energy – an overview journal March 2016
A Measurement of the Rate of Type Ia Supernovae at Redshift z ≈ 0.1 from the First Season of the SDSS‐II Supernova Survey journal July 2008
Nucleosynthesis, neutrino bursts and γ-rays from coalescing neutron stars journal July 1989
Imfit: a Fast, Flexible new Program for Astronomical Image Fitting journal January 2015
The dark Energy Camera journal October 2015
A Decade of Short-Duration Gamma-Ray Burst Broadband Afterglows: Energetics, Circumburst Densities, and jet Opening Angles journal December 2015
Automated Transient Identification in the dark Energy Survey journal August 2015
Using Gravitational‐Wave Standard Sirens journal August 2005
The Difference Imaging Pipeline for the Transient Search in the dark Energy Survey journal November 2015
Low-Γ jets from Compact Stellar Mergers: Candidate Electromagnetic Counterparts to Gravitational wave Sources journal September 2016
Transient Events from Neutron Star Mergers journal November 1998
What is the most Promising Electromagnetic Counterpart of a Neutron star Binary Merger? journal January 2012
Electromagnetic counterparts of compact object mergers powered by the radioactive decay of r-process nuclei: Transients from compact object mergers journal June 2010
Short-hard gamma-ray bursts journal April 2007
Detectable radio flares following gravitational waves from mergers of binary neutron stars journal September 2011
Exploring Short Gamma-Ray Bursts as Gravitational-Wave Standard Sirens journal November 2010
The multimessenger picture of compact object encounters: binary mergers versus dynamical collisions journal February 2013
Determining the Hubble constant from gravitational wave observations journal September 1986
A dark Energy Camera Search for an Optical Counterpart to the First Advanced ligo Gravitational wave Event Gw150914 journal May 2016
The rate of core Collapse Supernovae to Redshift 2.5 from the Candels and Clash Supernova Surveys journal November 2015
Synthetic Off-Axis Light Curves for Low-Energy Gamma-Ray Bursts journal May 2011
A gravitational-wave standard siren measurement of the Hubble constant.
  • Collaboration, LIGO Scientific; Collaboration,, 1m2h; Collaboration, Dark Energy Camera GW-EM
  • Apollo - University of Cambridge Repository https://doi.org/10.17863/cam.31821
text January 2017
A Measurement of the Rate of type-Ia Supernovae at Redshift $z\approx$ 0.1 from the First Season of the SDSS-II Supernova Survey text January 2008
Synthetic off-axis light curves for low energy gamma-ray bursts text January 2011
The detection efficiency of on-axis short gamma ray burst optical afterglows triggered by aLIGO/Virgo text January 2014
Automated Transient Identification in the Dark Energy Survey text January 2015
The Rate of Core Collapse Supernovae to Redshift 2.5 From The CANDELS and CLASH Supernova Surveys text January 2015
The Dark Energy Survey: more than dark energy - an overview text January 2016
A DECam Search for an Optical Counterpart to the LIGO Gravitational Wave Event GW151226 text January 2016
Transient Events from Neutron Star Mergers text January 1998

Cited By (151)

Prospects for observing and localizing gravitational-wave transients with Advanced LIGO, Advanced Virgo and KAGRA journal April 2018
Cosmology with Gravitational Waves in DES and LSST journal October 2017
Optical emission from a kilonova following a gravitational-wave-detected neutron-star merger journal October 2017
The optical afterglow of the short gamma-ray burst associated with GW170817 journal July 2018
A two per cent Hubble constant measurement from standard sirens within five years journal October 2018
Measuring cosmic distances with standard sirens journal December 2018
Numerical relativity of compact binaries in the 21st century journal November 2018
Does the Hubble constant tension call for new physics? journal September 2018
Prospects of the local Hubble parameter measurement using gravitational waves from double neutron stars journal January 2018
The progenitors of compact-object binaries: impact of metallicity, common envelope and natal kicks journal July 2018
Progenitors of gravitational wave mergers: binary evolution with the stellar grid-based code ComBinE journal August 2018
Late-time evolution of afterglows from off-axis neutron star mergers journal August 2018
Long-lived remnants from binary neutron star mergers journal September 2018
The host galaxies of double compact objects merging in the local Universe journal October 2018
The impact of electron-capture supernovae on merging double neutron stars journal October 2018
Host galaxies of merging compact objects: mass, star formation rate, metallicity, and colours journal May 2019
Jet structure in the afterglow phase for gamma-ray bursts with a precessing jet journal June 2019
Detectability of neutron star merger afterglows journal July 2019
Probing the extragalactic fast transient sky at minute time-scales with DECam journal December 2019
Implications of the search for optical counterparts during the first six months of the Advanced LIGO’s and Advanced Virgo’s third observing run: possible limits on the ejecta mass and binary properties journal December 2019
Imprints of r-process heating on fall-back accretion: distinguishing black hole–neutron star from double neutron star mergers journal March 2019
Subaru Hyper Suprime-Cam Survey for an optical counterpart of GW170817‡ journal February 2018
Are fast radio bursts the most likely electromagnetic counterpart of neutron star mergers resulting in prompt collapse? journal August 2019
GW170817 --the first observed neutron star merger and its kilonova: Implications for the astrophysical site of the r-process journal November 2019
Binary Neutron Star (BNS) Merger: What We Learned from Relativistic Ejecta of GW/GRB 170817A journal July 2019
A Magnetar Origin for the Kilonova Ejecta in GW170817 journal March 2018
An Empirical Study of Contamination in Deep, Rapid, and Wide-field Optical Follow-up of Gravitational Wave Events journal April 2018
Shock Acceleration of Electrons and Synchrotron Emission from the Dynamical Ejecta of Neutron Star Mergers journal May 2018
Three-dimensional GRMHD Simulations of Neutrino-cooled Accretion Disks from Neutron Star Mergers journal May 2018
Mass Ejection from the Remnant of a Binary Neutron Star Merger: Viscous-radiation Hydrodynamics Study journal June 2018
Coincident Detection Significance in Multimessenger Astronomy journal June 2018
Numerical Simulations of the Jet Dynamics and Synchrotron Radiation of Binary Neutron Star Merger Event GW170817/GRB 170817A journal August 2018
On GW170817 and the Galactic Binary Neutron Star Population journal October 2018
Jet Dynamics in Compact Object Mergers: GW170817 Likely Had a Successful Jet journal October 2018
Low-frequency View of GW170817/GRB 170817A with the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope journal October 2018
From γ to Radio: The Electromagnetic Counterpart of GW170817 journal October 2018
Scattered Short Gamma-Ray Bursts as Electromagnetic Counterparts to Gravitational Waves and Implications of GW170817 and GRB 170817A journal October 2018
Optimized Radio Follow-up of Binary Neutron-star Mergers journal November 2018
First Cosmology Results Using Type Ia Supernovae from the Dark Energy Survey: Photometric Pipeline and Light-curve Data Release journal March 2019
Radioactive Heating and Late Time Kilonova Light Curves journal May 2019
Optical Follow-up of Gravitational-wave Events during the Second Advanced LIGO/VIRGO Observing Run with the DLT40 Survey journal April 2019
Late-time Kilonova Light Curves and Implications to GW170817 journal June 2019
Impact of Pulsar and Fallback Sources on Multifrequency Kilonova Models journal July 2019
Double Neutron Star Mergers from Hierarchical Triple-star Systems journal September 2019
Extended Calculations of Energy Levels and Transition Rates of Nd ii-iv Ions for Application to Neutron Star Mergers journal February 2019
ν bhlight : Radiation GRMHD for Neutrino-driven Accretion Flows journal April 2019
INTEGRAL Detection of the First Prompt Gamma-Ray Signal Coincident with the Gravitational-wave Event GW170817 journal October 2017
The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. III. Optical and UV Spectra of a Blue Kilonova from Fast Polar Ejecta journal October 2017
The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. VII. Properties of the Host Galaxy and Constraints on the Merger Timescale journal October 2017
The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. VI. Radio Constraints on a Relativistic Jet and Predictions for Late-time Emission from the Kilonova Ejecta journal October 2017
The Combined Ultraviolet, Optical, and Near-infrared Light Curves of the Kilonova Associated with the Binary Neutron Star Merger GW170817: Unified Data Set, Analytic Models, and Physical Implications journal December 2017
Improved Constraints on H 0 from a Combined Analysis of Gravitational-wave and Electromagnetic Emission from GW170817 journal December 2017
GW170817: Joint Constraint on the Neutron Star Equation of State from Multimessenger Observations journal January 2018
Brightening X-Ray Emission from GW170817/GRB 170817A: Further Evidence for an Outflow journal January 2018
A Precise Distance to the Host Galaxy of the Binary Neutron Star Merger GW170817 Using Surface Brightness Fluctuations journal February 2018
The Binary Neutron Star Event LIGO/Virgo GW170817 160 Days after Merger: Synchrotron Emission across the Electromagnetic Spectrum journal March 2018
Continued Brightening of the Afterglow of GW170817/GRB 170817A as Being Due to a Delayed Energy Injection journal May 2018
Observational Implications of Lowering the LIGO-Virgo Alert Threshold journal July 2018
Radio Sky Maps of the GRB 170817A Afterglow from Simulations journal September 2018
A Strong Jet Signature in the Late-time Light Curve of GW170817 journal November 2018
A Standard Siren Measurement of the Hubble Constant from GW170817 without the Electromagnetic Counterpart journal January 2019
Implications from GW170817 for Δ-isobar Admixed Hypernuclear Compact Stars journal April 2019
Measuring the Delay Time Distribution of Binary Neutron Stars. I. Through Scaling Relations of the Host Galaxies of Gravitational-wave Events journal June 2019
Follow-up of the Neutron Star Bearing Gravitational-wave Candidate Events S190425z and S190426c with MMT and SOAR journal July 2019
GROWTH on S190426c: Real-time Search for a Counterpart to the Probable Neutron Star–Black Hole Merger using an Automated Difference Imaging Pipeline for DECam journal August 2019
GROWTH on S190510g: DECam Observation Planning and Follow-up of a Distant Binary Neutron Star Merger Candidate journal August 2019
Binary Black Hole Population Properties Inferred from the First and Second Observing Runs of Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo journal September 2019
The Optical Afterglow of GW170817: An Off-axis Structured Jet and Deep Constraints on a Globular Cluster Origin journal September 2019
Upscattered Cocoon Emission in Short Gamma-Ray Bursts as High-energy Gamma-Ray Counterparts to Gravitational Waves journal December 2019
Kilonovae journal December 2019
The X-shooter GRB afterglow legacy sample (XS-GRB) journal March 2019
Neutron star pulse profile observations as extreme gravity probes journal August 2019
A Strategy for LSST to Unveil a Population of Kilonovae without Gravitational-wave Triggers journal May 2019
RAPID: Early Classification of Explosive Transients Using Deep Learning journal September 2019
Rapidly evolving transients in the Dark Energy Survey journal August 2018
Implications of the radio and X-ray emission that followed GW170817 journal April 2018
Merging black holes in young star clusters journal May 2019
Observable features of GW170817 kilonova afterglow journal June 2019
The host galaxies of double compact objects across cosmic time journal September 2019
Illuminating gravitational waves: A concordant picture of photons from a neutron star merger journal October 2017
On the Progenitor of Binary Neutron Star Merger GW170817 other January 2017
Prospects for observing and localizing gravitational-wave transients with Advanced LIGO, Advanced Virgo and KAGRA text January 2020
Background-limited Imaging in the Near Infrared with Warm InGaAs Sensors: Applications for Time-domain Astronomy journal January 2019
A Long-lived Remnant Neutron Star after GW170817 Inferred from Its Associated Kilonova journal July 2018
Super-knee Cosmic Rays from Galactic Neutron Star Merger Remnants journal October 2018
Kilonova Emission from Black Hole–Neutron Star Mergers: Observational Signatures of Anisotropic Mass Ejection journal October 2018
Finding the Remnants of the Milky Way's Last Neutron Star Mergers journal July 2019
Jet–Cocoon Outflows from Neutron Star Mergers: Structure, Light Curves, and Fundamental Physics journal August 2019
A Pulsar Wind Nebula Embedded in the Kilonova AT 2017gfo Associated with GW170817/GRB 170817A journal October 2019
LIGO/Virgo Sources from Merging Black Holes in Ultradwarf Galaxies journal February 2020
Estimating the Contribution of Dynamical Ejecta in the Kilonova Associated with GW170817 journal December 2017
A Turnover in the Radio Light Curve of GW170817 journal May 2018
Spitzer Space Telescope Infrared Observations of the Binary Neutron Star Merger GW170817 journal July 2018
A Search for Optical Emission from Binary Black Hole Merger GW170814 with the Dark Energy Camera journal March 2019
Searches after Gravitational Waves Using ARizona Observatories (SAGUARO): System Overview and First Results from Advanced LIGO/Virgo’s Third Observing Run journal August 2019
The Reliability of the Low-latency Estimation of Binary Neutron Star Chirp Mass journal October 2019
On the Possibility of GW190425 Being a Black Hole–Neutron Star Binary Merger journal February 2020
An interacting dark sector and the implications of the first gravitational-wave standard siren detection on current constraints journal May 2019
Serendipitous discoveries of kilonovae in the LSST main survey: maximizing detections of sub-threshold gravitational wave events journal February 2019
Is the Macronova in GW170817 Powered by the Central Engine? journal July 2018
Binary Neutron Star Mergers: Mass Ejection, Electromagnetic Counterparts, and Nucleosynthesis journal December 2018
LSST Target-of-opportunity Observations of Gravitational-wave Events: Essential and Efficient journal March 2019
On the Progenitor of Binary Neutron Star Merger GW170817 journal December 2017
Fading of the X-Ray Afterglow of Neutron Star Merger GW170817/GRB 170817A at 260 Days journal July 2018
Observations of GW170817 by DESGW and the DECam GW-EM Collaboration journal October 2017
The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. II. UV, Optical, and Near-infrared Light Curves and Comparison to Kilonova Models journal October 2017
The Rapid Reddening and Featureless Optical Spectra of the Optical Counterpart of GW170817, AT 2017gfo, during the First Four Days journal October 2017
Estimating the contribution of dynamical ejecta in the kilonova associated with GW170817 text January 2017
Models and Simulations for the Photometric LSST Astronomical Time Series Classification Challenge (PLAsTiCC) journal July 2019
Prospects for observing and localizing gravitational-wave transients with Advanced LIGO, Advanced Virgo and KAGRA other January 2020
A gravitational-wave standard siren measurement of the Hubble constant.
  • Collaboration, LIGO Scientific; Collaboration,, 1m2h; Collaboration, Dark Energy Camera GW-EM
  • Apollo - University of Cambridge Repository https://doi.org/10.17863/cam.31821
text January 2017
RAPID: Early Classification of Explosive Transients Using Deep Learning text January 2019
The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. IV. Detection of Near-infrared Signatures of r -process Nucleosynthesis with Gemini-South journal October 2017
The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. III. Optical and UV Spectra of a Blue Kilonova from Fast Polar Ejecta text January 2017
An Empirical Study of Contamination in Deep, Rapid, and Wide-Field Optical Follow-Up of Gravitational Wave Events text January 2017
Illuminating Gravitational Waves: A Concordant Picture of Photons from a Neutron Star Merger text January 2017
INTEGRAL Detection of the First Prompt Gamma-Ray Signal Coincident with the Gravitational Wave Event GW170817 text January 2017
The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. IV. Detection of Near-infrared Signatures of r-process Nucleosynthesis with Gemini-South text January 2017
The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. VII. Properties of the Host Galaxy and Constraints on the Merger Timescale text January 2017
On the Progenitor of Binary Neutron Star Merger GW170817 text January 2017
The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. II. UV, Optical, and Near-IR Light Curves and Comparison to Kilonova Models text January 2017
Optical emission from a kilonova following a gravitational-wave-detected neutron-star merger text January 2017
Improved constraints on H0 from a combined analysis of gravitational-wave and electromagnetic emission from GW170817 text January 2017
A long-lived remnant neutron star after GW170817 inferred from its associated kilonova text January 2017
Mass Ejection from the Remnant of a Binary Neutron Star Merger: Viscous-Radiation Hydrodynamics Study text January 2017
A magnetar origin for the kilonova ejecta in GW170817 text January 2018
Progenitors of gravitational wave mergers: Binary evolution with the stellar grid-based code ComBinE text January 2018
Continued Brightening of the Afterglow of GW170817/GRB 170817A as due to a Delayed Energy Injection text January 2018
Rapidly evolving transients in the Dark Energy Survey text January 2018
Long-lived Remnants from Binary Neutron Star Mergers text January 2018
Shock acceleration of electrons and synchrotron emission from the dynamical ejecta of neutron star mergers text January 2018
Fading of the X-ray Afterglow of Neutron Star Merger GW170817/GRB170817A at 260 days text January 2018
Spitzer Space Telescope Infrared Observations of the Binary Neutron Star Merger GW170817 text January 2018
The progenitors of compact-object binaries: impact of metallicity, common envelope and natal kicks text January 2018
A standard siren measurement of the Hubble constant from GW170817 without the electromagnetic counterpart text January 2018
Distinguishing the nature of comparable-mass neutron star binary systems with multimessenger observations: GW170817 case study text January 2018
Numerical Relativity of Compact Binaries in the 21st Century text January 2018
Binary Neutron Star Mergers: Mass Ejection, Electromagnetic Counterparts and Nucleosynthesis text January 2018
First Cosmology Results Using Type Ia Supernovae From the Dark Energy Survey: Photometric Pipeline and Light Curve Data Release text January 2018
Serendipitous Discoveries of Kilonovae in the LSST Main Survey: Maximising Detections of Sub-Threshold Gravitational Wave Events text January 2018
GW170817$-$the first observed neutron star merger and its kilonova: implications for the astrophysical site of the r-process text January 2019
Extended calculations of energy levels and transition rates of Nd II-IV ions for application to neutron star mergers text January 2019
RAPID: Early Classification of Explosive Transients using Deep Learning text January 2019
Impact of Pulsar and Fallback Sources on Multifrequency Kilonova Models text January 2019
Measuring the delay time distribution of binary neutron stars. I. Through Scaling Relations of the Host Galaxies of Gravitational Wave Events text January 2019
Jet Structure in the Afterglow Phase for Gamma-ray Bursts with a Precessing Jet text January 2019
Full Transport Model of GW170817-Like Disk Produces a Blue Kilonova text January 2019
The host galaxies of double compact objects across cosmic time text January 2019
Searches After Gravitational-waves Using ARizona Observatories (SAGUARO): System Overview and First Results from Advanced LIGO/Virgo's Third Observing Run text January 2019
The Optical Afterglow of GW170817: An Off-axis Structured Jet and Deep Constraints on a Globular Cluster Origin text January 2019
On the possibility of GW190425 being a black hole--neutron star binary merger text January 2020