A Comparison of Monte Carlo and Deterministic Solvers for keff and Sensitivity Calculations
Abstract
Verification and validation of our solutions for calculating the neutron reactivity for nuclear materials is a key issue to address for many applications, including criticality safety, research reactors, power reactors, and nuclear security. Neutronics codes solve variations of the Boltzmann transport equation. The two main variants are Monte Carlo versus deterministic solutions, e.g. the MCNP [1] versus PARTISN [2] codes, respectively. There have been many studies over the decades that examined the accuracy of such solvers and the general conclusion is that when the problems are wellposed, either solver can produce accurate results. However, the devil is always in the details. The current study examines the issue of selfshielding and the stress it puts on deterministic solvers. Most Monte Carlo neutronics codes use continuousenergy descriptions of the neutron interaction data that are not subject to this effect. The issue of selfshielding occurs because of the discretisation of data used by the deterministic solutions. Multigroup data used in these solvers are the average cross section and scattering parameters over an energy range. Resonances in cross sections can occur that change the likelihood of interaction by one to three orders of magnitude over a small energy range. Selfshielding is the numerical effectmore »
 Authors:
 Los Alamos National Lab. (LANL), Los Alamos, NM (United States)
 Publication Date:
 Research Org.:
 Los Alamos National Lab. (LANL), Los Alamos, NM (United States)
 Sponsoring Org.:
 USDOE National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA), Office of Defense Programs (DP) (NA10)
 OSTI Identifier:
 1412920
 Report Number(s):
 LAUR1731177
 DOE Contract Number:
 AC5206NA25396
 Resource Type:
 Technical Report
 Country of Publication:
 United States
 Language:
 English
 Subject:
 73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS; Deterministic; Monte Carlo; comparison
Citation Formats
Haeck, Wim, Parsons, Donald Kent, White, Morgan Curtis, Saller, Thomas, and Favorite, Jeffrey A. A Comparison of Monte Carlo and Deterministic Solvers for keff and Sensitivity Calculations. United States: N. p., 2017.
Web. doi:10.2172/1412920.
Haeck, Wim, Parsons, Donald Kent, White, Morgan Curtis, Saller, Thomas, & Favorite, Jeffrey A. A Comparison of Monte Carlo and Deterministic Solvers for keff and Sensitivity Calculations. United States. doi:10.2172/1412920.
Haeck, Wim, Parsons, Donald Kent, White, Morgan Curtis, Saller, Thomas, and Favorite, Jeffrey A. Tue .
"A Comparison of Monte Carlo and Deterministic Solvers for keff and Sensitivity Calculations". United States.
doi:10.2172/1412920. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1412920.
@article{osti_1412920,
title = {A Comparison of Monte Carlo and Deterministic Solvers for keff and Sensitivity Calculations},
author = {Haeck, Wim and Parsons, Donald Kent and White, Morgan Curtis and Saller, Thomas and Favorite, Jeffrey A.},
abstractNote = {Verification and validation of our solutions for calculating the neutron reactivity for nuclear materials is a key issue to address for many applications, including criticality safety, research reactors, power reactors, and nuclear security. Neutronics codes solve variations of the Boltzmann transport equation. The two main variants are Monte Carlo versus deterministic solutions, e.g. the MCNP [1] versus PARTISN [2] codes, respectively. There have been many studies over the decades that examined the accuracy of such solvers and the general conclusion is that when the problems are wellposed, either solver can produce accurate results. However, the devil is always in the details. The current study examines the issue of selfshielding and the stress it puts on deterministic solvers. Most Monte Carlo neutronics codes use continuousenergy descriptions of the neutron interaction data that are not subject to this effect. The issue of selfshielding occurs because of the discretisation of data used by the deterministic solutions. Multigroup data used in these solvers are the average cross section and scattering parameters over an energy range. Resonances in cross sections can occur that change the likelihood of interaction by one to three orders of magnitude over a small energy range. Selfshielding is the numerical effect that the average cross section in groups with strong resonances can be strongly affected as neutrons within that material are preferentially absorbed or scattered out of the resonance energies. This affects both the average cross section and the scattering matrix.},
doi = {10.2172/1412920},
journal = {},
number = ,
volume = ,
place = {United States},
year = {Tue Dec 12 00:00:00 EST 2017},
month = {Tue Dec 12 00:00:00 EST 2017}
}

If you have ever given up on a nuclear criticality calculation and terminated it because it took so long to converge, you might find this thesis of interest. The author develops three methods for improving the fission source convergence in nuclear criticality calculations for physical systems with high dominance ratios for which convergence is slow. The Fission Matrix Acceleration Method and the Fission Diffusion Synthetic Acceleration (FDSA) Method are acceleration methods that speed fission source convergence for both Monte Carlo and deterministic methods. The third method is a hybrid Monte Carlo method that also converges for difficult problems where themore »

Hybrid Monte CarloDeterministic Methods for Nuclear ReactorRelated Criticality Calculations
The overall goal of this project is to develop, implement, and test new Hybrid Monte Carlodeterministic (or simply Hybrid) methods for the more efficient and more accurate calculation of nuclear engineering criticality problems. These new methods will make use of two (philosophically and practically) very different techniques  the Monte Carlo technique, and the deterministic technique  which have been developed completely independently during the past 50 years. The concept of this proposal is to merge these two approaches and develop fundamentally new computational techniques that enhance the strengths of the individual Monte Carlo and deterministic approaches, while minimizing theirmore » 