skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Recommended Guidelines for NERC CIP Compliance for Synchrophasor Systems

Abstract

Compliance with the NERC requirements for Critical Infrastructure Protection (CIP) for synchrophasor systems in the Version 5 paradigm seems to be a matter of some uncertainty for those in the synchrophasor user community. This report aims to provide clarification and guidance in the form of case studies based on methods seen in the industry

Authors:
 [1];  [1];  [1]
  1. Pacific Northwest National Lab. (PNNL), Richland, WA (United States)
Publication Date:
Research Org.:
Pacific Northwest National Lab. (PNNL), Richland, WA (United States)
Sponsoring Org.:
USDOE Office of Electricity Delivery and Energy Reliability (OE)
OSTI Identifier:
1411938
Report Number(s):
PNNL-27062
TE1101000
DOE Contract Number:
AC05-76RL01830
Resource Type:
Technical Report
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Subject:
97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING; synchrophasors

Citation Formats

Mix, Scott R., Kirkham, Harold, and Silverstein, Alison. Recommended Guidelines for NERC CIP Compliance for Synchrophasor Systems. United States: N. p., 2017. Web. doi:10.2172/1411938.
Mix, Scott R., Kirkham, Harold, & Silverstein, Alison. Recommended Guidelines for NERC CIP Compliance for Synchrophasor Systems. United States. doi:10.2172/1411938.
Mix, Scott R., Kirkham, Harold, and Silverstein, Alison. Tue . "Recommended Guidelines for NERC CIP Compliance for Synchrophasor Systems". United States. doi:10.2172/1411938. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1411938.
@article{osti_1411938,
title = {Recommended Guidelines for NERC CIP Compliance for Synchrophasor Systems},
author = {Mix, Scott R. and Kirkham, Harold and Silverstein, Alison},
abstractNote = {Compliance with the NERC requirements for Critical Infrastructure Protection (CIP) for synchrophasor systems in the Version 5 paradigm seems to be a matter of some uncertainty for those in the synchrophasor user community. This report aims to provide clarification and guidance in the form of case studies based on methods seen in the industry},
doi = {10.2172/1411938},
journal = {},
number = ,
volume = ,
place = {United States},
year = {Tue Nov 14 00:00:00 EST 2017},
month = {Tue Nov 14 00:00:00 EST 2017}
}

Technical Report:

Save / Share:
  • This document presents the test plan for testing reciprocating IC engines at natural gas transmission facilities. The testing effort consists of a combination of two industry funded research programs: (1) The Pipeline Research Committee (PRC)/Gas Research Institute (GRI) co-funded program entitled {open_quotes}Development of EMP Guidelines for IC Engine Parameter Monitoring Systems{close_quotes} managed by SECOR International Incorporated; and (2) The Gas Research Institute sponsored program entitled {open_quotes}Measurement of Air Toxics in Engine Exhaust{close_quotes} managed by Radian Corporation. Although these programs have different objectives, as detailed following, the programs share the need for rigorously conducted field testing of IC engines; often referredmore » to as engine {open_quotes}mapping{close_quotes}. Additionally, these programs compete for limited and qualified resources, hence the need and decision to cooperate in the field testing phase of each program.« less
  • The Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990 will require owners and operators of major sources emitting certain pollutants subject to enforceability and applicability thresholds to provide monitoring to demonstrate compliance with the applicable emissions limitations or standards. In response to these impending, if or if not uncertain, monitoring requirements, the PRC International (PRCI) and Gas Research Institute (GRI) co-funded a program entitled {open_quotes}Development of Enhanced Monitoring Protocol Guidelines for IC Engine Parameter Based Compliance Monitoring Systems{close_quotes} to provide the natural gas pipeline industry with technically credible documentation and guidelines that support the application of cost-effective compliance monitoring approaches, including Parametermore » Based Compliance Monitoring (PBCM), for IC reciprocating engines for which this is the final report. The program focused on the fundamental building blocks of a sufficient compliance monitoring plan including: control strategies, quality assurance/maintenance practices, engine parameter monitoring and an understanding of the relationship between engine emissions and those engine parameters. In support of the guideline development described above, the test team, consisting of members of Enginuity, AETC and ASSET, performed extensive field testing on seven different typical pipeline engines (two and four stroke cycle) collecting engine parameter and emissions data for a total of approximately 250 unique operating conditions. Third parties contributed an equal amount of data resulting in one of the most comprehensive data bases of engine parameters and emissions in the industry.« less
  • The US Environmental Protection Agency is providing background information that supports the use of Metro Machine Corporation`s (MMC) compliant all position enclosure (CAPE) plus air management system and regenerative thermal oxidizer (RTO) (CAPE + RTO System) as an alternative means of limiting the emissions of volatile organic hazardous air pollutants per volume of applied solids (nonvolatiles). This document also explains how the authors arrived at the operating, recordkeeping, and reporting conditions that MMC must meet for approval. The add-on control system they used consists of a pollution capture unit operation (CAPE) plus air management system and a destruction unit operationmore » (RTO). When operated according to the specified procedures, it will control emissions to a level no greater than that from using coatings which comply with the limits in Table 2 of 40 CFR Part 63, Subpart II.« less
  • The objective of this project was to demonstrate functionality and performance of a Direct Non-iterative State Estimator (DNSE) integrated with NYPA’s Energy Management System (EMS) and with enhanced Real Time Dynamics Monitoring System (RTDMS) synchrophasor platform from Electric Power Group (EPG). DNSE is designed to overcome a major obstacle to operational use of Synchro-Phasor Management Systems (SPMS) by providing to synchrophasor management systems (SPMS) applications a consistent and a complete synchrophasor data foundation in the same way that a traditional EMS State Estimator (SE) provides to EMS applications. Specifically, DNSE is designed to use synchrophasor measurements collected by a centralmore » PDC, Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) measurements, and Energy Management System (EMS) network model, to obtain the complete state of the utility’s operating model at rates that are close to the synchrophasor data rates. In this way, the system is comprehensive in that it does not only cover the part of the network that is “visible” via synchrophasors, but also the part that is only “visible” through the SCADA measurements. Visualization needs associated with the use of DNSE results are fulfilled through suitably enhanced Real Time Dynamics Monitoring System (RTDMS), with the enhancements implemented by EPG. This project had the following goals in mind: To advance the deployment of commercial grade DNSE software application that relies on synchrophasor and SCADA data ; Apply DNSE at other utilities, to address a generic and fundamental need for “clean” operational data for synchrophasor applications; Provide means for “live” estimated data access by control system operators; Enhance potential for situational awareness through full system operational model coverage; Sub-second execution rate of the Direct Non-iterative State Estimator, eventually at a near-phasor data rate execution speed, i.e. < 0.1 sec. Anticipated benefits from this projects are: Enhanced reliability and improvements in the economic efficiency of bulk power system planning and operations; Providing “clean” data to other synchrophasor applications; Enhancement of situational awareness by providing the full operational model updated at near synchrophasor rate; A production-grade software tool that incorporate synchrophasor and SCADA data; Provides a basis for development of next generation monitoring and control applications, based on both SCADA and PMU data. Quanta Technology (QT) team worked in collaboration with Electric Power Group (EPG) whose team has enhanced its commercial Real Time Dynamics Monitoring System (RTDMS) to accommodate the requirements posed by DNSE application. EPG also provided its ePDC and Model-less Data Conditioning (PDVC) software for integration with DNSE+. QT developed the system requirements for DNSE; developed system architecture and defined interfaces between internal DNSE components. The core DNSE algorithm with all surrounding interfaces was named DNSE+. Since the DNSE development was done in a simulated system environment, QT used its PMU simulator that was enhanced during this project for development and factory acceptance testing (FAT). SCADA data in this stage was simulated by commercial PSS/e software. The output of DNSE are estimates of System states in C37.118-2 format, sent to RTDMS for further processing and display. As the number of these states is large, it was necessary to expand the C37.111-2 standard to accommodate large data sets. This enhancement was implemented in RTDMS. The demonstration of pre-production DNSE technology was done at NYPA using streaming field data from NYPA PMUs and from its RTUs through their SCADA system. NYPA provided ICCP interface as well as Common Information Model (CIM). The relevance of the DNSE+ application is that it provides state estimation of the power system based on hybrid set of data, consisting of both available PMU data and SCADA measurements. As this is a direct, non-iterative method of calculation of the system states, if does not suffer from convergence issues which is potential problem for conventional state estimators. Also, it can take any available PMU measurements, so it does not need to have a high percentage of PMU coverage needed in the case of Linear State Estimator. As the DNSE calculates synchrophasors of the system states (both phase and absolute value) as sub-second rate, this application can provide a basis for development of next generation of applications based both on SCADA and PMU data.« less
  • The study provides recommendations on methods and procedures for use in the premining assessment of surface coal mine overburden. Topics addressed include: overburden drilling and sampling, parameters for predicting quality impact, laboratory methods for analyzing overburden, and procedures for greenhouse testing of overburden. The study is the second phase of a two-part program.