skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Comment on “Boson Peak in Deeply Cooled Confined Water: A Possible Way to Explore the Existence of the Liquid-to-Liquid Transition in Water”

Abstract

In their Letter, Wang et al. report on an inelastic neutron scattering (INS) experiment where they describe the pressure evolution of a low energy (E ~ 6 meV) excitation, emerging in confined protonated water only below 230 K at an exchanged momentum Q=2.0 Å -1. Also, water confinement was used to overcome the unavoidable crystallization occurring below ~250 K in bulk water. The authors report that a similar finding was also obtained in both bulk (numerical simulations) and confined water at ambient pressure. They refer to this low temperature excitation as a boson peak (BP), and relate its occurrence to the Widom line, concluding that the observed pressure behavior of the BP reveals the signature of the high-density liquid (HDL) to the low-density liquid (LDL) transition proposed, though severely questioned, for bulk water. Lastly, we believe these claims to be unconvincing for the following reasons.

Authors:
 [1];  [2]
  1. Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche Istituto Officina dei Materiali, Operative Group in Grenoble (OGG) c/o Institut Laue Langevin (France)
  2. Centre for Life Nano Science IIT at Sapienza Istituto Italiano di Tecnologia, Roma (Italy)
Publication Date:
Research Org.:
Oak Ridge National Lab. (ORNL), Oak Ridge, TN (United States). Spallation Neutron Source (SNS)
Sponsoring Org.:
USDOE Office of Science (SC)
OSTI Identifier:
1356955
DOE Contract Number:  
AC05-00OR22725
Resource Type:
Journal Article
Journal Name:
Physical Review Letters
Additional Journal Information:
Journal Volume: 115; Journal Issue: 14; Journal ID: ISSN 0031-9007
Publisher:
American Physical Society (APS)
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
English
Subject:
71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSICS; 37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY

Citation Formats

Formisano, F., and De Panfilis, S. Comment on “Boson Peak in Deeply Cooled Confined Water: A Possible Way to Explore the Existence of the Liquid-to-Liquid Transition in Water”. United States: N. p., 2015. Web. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.115.149801.
Formisano, F., & De Panfilis, S. Comment on “Boson Peak in Deeply Cooled Confined Water: A Possible Way to Explore the Existence of the Liquid-to-Liquid Transition in Water”. United States. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.115.149801.
Formisano, F., and De Panfilis, S. Wed . "Comment on “Boson Peak in Deeply Cooled Confined Water: A Possible Way to Explore the Existence of the Liquid-to-Liquid Transition in Water”". United States. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.115.149801.
@article{osti_1356955,
title = {Comment on “Boson Peak in Deeply Cooled Confined Water: A Possible Way to Explore the Existence of the Liquid-to-Liquid Transition in Water”},
author = {Formisano, F. and De Panfilis, S.},
abstractNote = {In their Letter, Wang et al. report on an inelastic neutron scattering (INS) experiment where they describe the pressure evolution of a low energy (E ~ 6 meV) excitation, emerging in confined protonated water only below 230 K at an exchanged momentum Q=2.0 Å-1. Also, water confinement was used to overcome the unavoidable crystallization occurring below ~250 K in bulk water. The authors report that a similar finding was also obtained in both bulk (numerical simulations) and confined water at ambient pressure. They refer to this low temperature excitation as a boson peak (BP), and relate its occurrence to the Widom line, concluding that the observed pressure behavior of the BP reveals the signature of the high-density liquid (HDL) to the low-density liquid (LDL) transition proposed, though severely questioned, for bulk water. Lastly, we believe these claims to be unconvincing for the following reasons.},
doi = {10.1103/PhysRevLett.115.149801},
journal = {Physical Review Letters},
issn = {0031-9007},
number = 14,
volume = 115,
place = {United States},
year = {2015},
month = {9}
}

Works referenced in this record:

Vibrational dynamics and phonon dispersion of polycrystalline ice XII and of high-density amorphous ice
journal, March 2008


Observation of collective excitations in heavy water in the 108 cm−1 momentum range
journal, March 1978

  • Bosi, P.; Dupré, F.; Menzingee, F.
  • Lettere al Nuovo Cimento, Vol. 21, Issue 12
  • DOI: 10.1007/BF02763195

Spectroscopic and transport properties of water: Model calculations and the interpretation of experimental results
journal, June 1982


Density profile of water confined in cylindrical pores in MCM-41 silica
journal, January 2012


Connecting the Water Phase Diagram to the Metastable Domain: High-Pressure Studies in the Supercooled Regime
journal, October 2014

  • Fanetti, Samuele; Pagliai, Marco; Citroni, Margherita
  • The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters, Vol. 5, Issue 21
  • DOI: 10.1021/jz501971h

Mixing of Longitudinal and Transverse Dynamics in Liquid Water
journal, September 1997


High-resolution neutron scattering measurement of the dynamic structure factor of heavy water
journal, September 2000


Water dynamics in a lithium chloride aqueous solution probed by Brillouin neutron and x-ray scattering
journal, January 2012


Vibrational dynamics of amorphous ice structures studied by high-resolution neutron spectroscopy
journal, August 2008


Phase behaviour of metastable water
journal, November 1992

  • Poole, Peter H.; Sciortino, Francesco; Essmann, Ulrich
  • Nature, Vol. 360, Issue 6402
  • DOI: 10.1038/360324a0

A comparative study on bulk and nanoconfined water by time-resolved optical Kerr effect spectroscopy
journal, January 2013

  • Taschin, Andrea; Bartolini, Paolo; Marcelli, Agnese
  • Faraday Discussions, Vol. 167
  • DOI: 10.1039/c3fd00060e

Propagation of sound in water. A molecular-dynamics study
journal, July 1974


Escaping the no man's land: Recent experiments on metastable liquid water
journal, January 2015


Reply to Soper: Density measurement of confined water with neutron scattering
journal, November 2011

  • Zhang, Y.; Faraone, A.; Kamitakahara, W. A.
  • Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Vol. 108, Issue 47
  • DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1113408108

Sulla forma della banda Raman dell’acqua. I
journal, November 1932


High-frequency longitudinal and transverse dynamics in water
journal, January 2005


Density minimum in supercooled confined water
journal, November 2011


Transverse dynamics of water across the melting point: A parallel neutron and x-ray inelastic scattering study
journal, May 2012


Boson Peak in Deeply Cooled Confined Water: A Possible Way to Explore the Existence of the Liquid-to-Liquid Transition in Water
journal, June 2014


Collective excitations in liquid water at low frequency and large wave vector
journal, November 1991

  • Sastry, Srikanth; Sciortino, Francesco; Stanley, H. Eugene
  • The Journal of Chemical Physics, Vol. 95, Issue 10
  • DOI: 10.1063/1.461354

Transition from Normal to Fast Sound in Liquid Water
journal, July 1996


Single-particle dynamics of water molecules in confined space
journal, May 1995

  • Bellissent-Funel, M. -C.; Chen, S. H.; Zanotti, J. -M.
  • Physical Review E, Vol. 51, Issue 5
  • DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.51.4558

Equivalence of the Boson Peak in Glasses to the Transverse Acoustic van Hove Singularity in Crystals
journal, May 2011


Low‐frequency Raman spectrum of supercooled water
journal, December 1983

  • Krishnamurthy, S.; Bansil, R.; Wiafe‐Akenten, J.
  • The Journal of Chemical Physics, Vol. 79, Issue 12
  • DOI: 10.1063/1.445756

Viscoelastic behavior of water in the terahertz-frequency range: An inelastic x-ray scattering study
journal, November 1999


Low-Frequency Raman Scattering from Water at High Pressures and High Temperatures
journal, January 1996

  • Walrafen, G. E.; Chu, Y. C.; Piermarini, G. J.
  • The Journal of Physical Chemistry, Vol. 100, Issue 24
  • DOI: 10.1021/jp960140o