skip to main content
OSTI.GOV title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information

Title: Analysis of drought impacts on electricity production in the Western and Texas interconnections of the United States.

Abstract

Electricity generation relies heavily on water resources and their availability. To examine the interdependence of energy and water in the electricity context, the impacts of a severe drought to assess the risk posed by drought to electricity generation within the western and Texas interconnections has been examined. The historical drought patterns in the western United States were analyzed, and the risk posed by drought to electricity generation within the region was evaluated. The results of this effort will be used to develop scenarios for medium- and long-term transmission modeling and planning efforts by the Western Electricity Coordination Council (WECC) and the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT). The study was performed in response to a request developed by the Western Governors Association in conjunction with the transmission modeling teams at the participating interconnections. It is part of a U.S. Department of Energy-sponsored, national laboratory-led research effort to develop tools related to the interdependency of energy and water as part of a larger interconnection-wide transmission planning project funded under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act. This study accomplished three main objectives. It provided a thorough literature review of recent studies of drought and the potential implications for electricity generation. It analyzedmore » historical drought patterns in the western United States and used the results to develop three design drought scenarios. Finally, it quantified the risk to electricity generation for each of eight basins for each of the three drought scenarios and considered the implications for transmission planning. Literature on drought impacts on electricity generation describes a number of examples where hydroelectric generation capacity has been limited because of drought but only a few examples of impact on thermoelectric generation. In all documented cases, shortfalls of generation were met by purchasing power from the market, albeit at higher prices. However, sufficient excess generation and transmission must be available for this strategy to work. Although power purchase was the most commonly discussed drought mitigation strategy, a total of 12 response strategies were identified in the literature, falling into four main categories: electricity supply, electricity demand response, alternative water supplies, and water demand response. Three hydrological drought scenarios were developed based on a literature review and historical data analysis. The literature review helped to identify key drought parameters and data on drought frequency and severity. Historical hydrological drought data were analyzed for the western United States to identify potential drought correlations and estimate drought parameters. The first scenario was a West-wide drought occurring in 1977; it represented a severe drought in five of the eight basins in the study area. A second drought scenario was artificially defined by selecting the conditions from the 10th-percentile drought year for each individual basin; this drought was defined in this way to allow more consistent analysis of risk to electricity generation in each basin. The final scenario was based upon the current low-flow hydro modeling scenario defined by WECC, which uses conditions from the year 2001. These scenarios were then used to quantify the risk to electricity generation in each basin. The risk calculations represent a first-order estimate of the maximum amount of electricity generation that might be lost from both hydroelectric and thermoelectric sources under a worst-case scenario. Even with the conservative methodology used, the majority of basins showed a limited amount of risk under most scenarios. The level of risk in these basins is likely to be amenable to mitigation by known strategies, combined with existing reserve generation and transmission capacity. However, the risks to the Pacific Northwest and Texas Basins require further study. The Pacific Northwest is vulnerable because of its heavy reliance on hydroelectric generation. Texas, conversely, is vulnerable because of its heavy dependence on thermoelectric generation, which relies on surface water for cooling, along with the fact that this basin seems to experience more severe drought events on average. Further modeling analysis will be performed in conjunction with the modeling teams at the participating interconnections (WECC and ERCOT) to explore the transmission implications of the drought scenarios in more detail. Given the first-order nature of this analysis, more detailed study of the potential impacts of drought on electricity generation is recommended. Future analyses should attempt to model the potential impacts of drought at the power-plant level, including potential mitigation strategies; include the effects of drought duration; understand the impacts of climate change; and consider economic impacts.« less

Authors:
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;  [1];  [2];  [2];  [2]
+ Show Author Affiliations
  1. (Environmental Science Division)
  2. (
Publication Date:
Research Org.:
Argonne National Lab. (ANL), Argonne, IL (United States)
Sponsoring Org.:
TD; OE
OSTI Identifier:
1035461
Report Number(s):
ANL/EVS/R-11/14
TRN: US201205%%116
DOE Contract Number:
DE-AC02-06CH11357
Resource Type:
Technical Report
Country of Publication:
United States
Language:
ENGLISH
Subject:
54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES; 32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATION; 29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY AND ECONOMY; AVAILABILITY; CAPACITY; DATA ANALYSIS; DESIGN; DROUGHTS; ECONOMIC IMPACT; ELECTRIC RELIABILITY COUNCILS; ELECTRICITY; MARKET; MITIGATION; PLANNING; PRICES; PRODUCTION; SIMULATION; SURFACE WATERS; WATER REQUIREMENTS; WATER RESOURCES

Citation Formats

Harto, C. B., Yan, Y. E., Demissie, Y. K., Elcock, D., Tidwell, V. C., Hallett, K., Macknick, J., Wigmosta, M. S., Tesfa, T. K., Sandia National Laboratory), National Renewable Energy Laboratory), and Pacific Northwest National Laboratory). Analysis of drought impacts on electricity production in the Western and Texas interconnections of the United States.. United States: N. p., 2012. Web. doi:10.2172/1035461.
Copy to clipboard
Harto, C. B., Yan, Y. E., Demissie, Y. K., Elcock, D., Tidwell, V. C., Hallett, K., Macknick, J., Wigmosta, M. S., Tesfa, T. K., Sandia National Laboratory), National Renewable Energy Laboratory), & Pacific Northwest National Laboratory). Analysis of drought impacts on electricity production in the Western and Texas interconnections of the United States.. United States. doi:10.2172/1035461.
Copy to clipboard
Harto, C. B., Yan, Y. E., Demissie, Y. K., Elcock, D., Tidwell, V. C., Hallett, K., Macknick, J., Wigmosta, M. S., Tesfa, T. K., Sandia National Laboratory), National Renewable Energy Laboratory), and Pacific Northwest National Laboratory). Thu . "Analysis of drought impacts on electricity production in the Western and Texas interconnections of the United States.". United States. doi:10.2172/1035461. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1035461.
Copy to clipboard
@article{osti_1035461,
title = {Analysis of drought impacts on electricity production in the Western and Texas interconnections of the United States.},
author = {Harto, C. B. and Yan, Y. E. and Demissie, Y. K. and Elcock, D. and Tidwell, V. C. and Hallett, K. and Macknick, J. and Wigmosta, M. S. and Tesfa, T. K. and Sandia National Laboratory) and National Renewable Energy Laboratory) and Pacific Northwest National Laboratory)},
abstractNote = {Electricity generation relies heavily on water resources and their availability. To examine the interdependence of energy and water in the electricity context, the impacts of a severe drought to assess the risk posed by drought to electricity generation within the western and Texas interconnections has been examined. The historical drought patterns in the western United States were analyzed, and the risk posed by drought to electricity generation within the region was evaluated. The results of this effort will be used to develop scenarios for medium- and long-term transmission modeling and planning efforts by the Western Electricity Coordination Council (WECC) and the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT). The study was performed in response to a request developed by the Western Governors Association in conjunction with the transmission modeling teams at the participating interconnections. It is part of a U.S. Department of Energy-sponsored, national laboratory-led research effort to develop tools related to the interdependency of energy and water as part of a larger interconnection-wide transmission planning project funded under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act. This study accomplished three main objectives. It provided a thorough literature review of recent studies of drought and the potential implications for electricity generation. It analyzed historical drought patterns in the western United States and used the results to develop three design drought scenarios. Finally, it quantified the risk to electricity generation for each of eight basins for each of the three drought scenarios and considered the implications for transmission planning. Literature on drought impacts on electricity generation describes a number of examples where hydroelectric generation capacity has been limited because of drought but only a few examples of impact on thermoelectric generation. In all documented cases, shortfalls of generation were met by purchasing power from the market, albeit at higher prices. However, sufficient excess generation and transmission must be available for this strategy to work. Although power purchase was the most commonly discussed drought mitigation strategy, a total of 12 response strategies were identified in the literature, falling into four main categories: electricity supply, electricity demand response, alternative water supplies, and water demand response. Three hydrological drought scenarios were developed based on a literature review and historical data analysis. The literature review helped to identify key drought parameters and data on drought frequency and severity. Historical hydrological drought data were analyzed for the western United States to identify potential drought correlations and estimate drought parameters. The first scenario was a West-wide drought occurring in 1977; it represented a severe drought in five of the eight basins in the study area. A second drought scenario was artificially defined by selecting the conditions from the 10th-percentile drought year for each individual basin; this drought was defined in this way to allow more consistent analysis of risk to electricity generation in each basin. The final scenario was based upon the current low-flow hydro modeling scenario defined by WECC, which uses conditions from the year 2001. These scenarios were then used to quantify the risk to electricity generation in each basin. The risk calculations represent a first-order estimate of the maximum amount of electricity generation that might be lost from both hydroelectric and thermoelectric sources under a worst-case scenario. Even with the conservative methodology used, the majority of basins showed a limited amount of risk under most scenarios. The level of risk in these basins is likely to be amenable to mitigation by known strategies, combined with existing reserve generation and transmission capacity. However, the risks to the Pacific Northwest and Texas Basins require further study. The Pacific Northwest is vulnerable because of its heavy reliance on hydroelectric generation. Texas, conversely, is vulnerable because of its heavy dependence on thermoelectric generation, which relies on surface water for cooling, along with the fact that this basin seems to experience more severe drought events on average. Further modeling analysis will be performed in conjunction with the modeling teams at the participating interconnections (WECC and ERCOT) to explore the transmission implications of the drought scenarios in more detail. Given the first-order nature of this analysis, more detailed study of the potential impacts of drought on electricity generation is recommended. Future analyses should attempt to model the potential impacts of drought at the power-plant level, including potential mitigation strategies; include the effects of drought duration; understand the impacts of climate change; and consider economic impacts.},
doi = {10.2172/1035461},
journal = {},
number = ,
volume = ,
place = {United States},
year = {Thu Feb 09 00:00:00 EST 2012},
month = {Thu Feb 09 00:00:00 EST 2012}
}
Copy to clipboard
Technical Report:
View Technical Report
DOI:  10.2172/1035461
Save / Share:
Export Metadata
Save to My Library
You must Sign In or Create an Account in order to save documents to your library.

  • Passage of the California Nuclear Power Plant Initiative (Land Use, Nuclear Power Liability, and Safeguard Act), could require the step-wise shutdown of nuclear power plants in California over the next ten years. If nuclear power plants were to be phased out, the consequences during the next few decades will depend upon the choice of fuels and technologies that would be substituted into the California electricity supply system. One of the direct consequences may result from the loss of the present investments in nuclear facilities and with certain local employment and business changes. Shifts in major energy sources for the futuremore » will affect every segment of society, the economy, and the environment. This study confines itself to an analysis of the direct costs and the resulting pollutants associated with various energy choices for California. To help estimate the consequences of phasing out nuclear energy in California, three choices of fuels and technologies for supplying electricity to California were examined. The first choice assumes a continuation of present plans with no new restrictions placed on the use and construction of nuclear power plants. The second choice phases out nuclear power plants in California within ten years (plant outputs are reduced 40 percent after one year and maintained at this level for five years and are further reduced by ten percent per year thereafter). The third choice also phases out nuclear energy in California, but emphasizes oil instead of coal substitution. (MCW)« less

  • This report examines the projected electrical demand and power supply situation in the West generally, and in the states of Washington, Oregon, Idaho, and California particularly, for the summer of 1977. Drought conditions have decreased the ability of some hydroelectric plants to produce electric energy in the amount necessary for utilities to maintain uninterrupted supply to all consumers. The magnitude of the problems expected to arise and what may be done to ameliorate the difficulties are indicated.

  • The projected electrical demand and supply situation in the West are examined, with particular emphasis on the Pacific Northwest situation during the winter of 1977. While the projected shortage of energy is small, continued lack of precipitation and failure to pursue conservation measures could result in a more critical situation. An interim report published on March 31, placed emphasis on the California situation; this report updates that evaluation and presents new information based on the Pacific Northwest's winter electricity outlook. Drought conditions have decreased the ability of some hydroelectric plants to produce sufficient electric energy necessary to maintain power supplymore » to interruptible customers and, potentially, to firm customers. The largest coordinating group of electric utilities in the drought area is the Northwest Power Pool (NWPP), which is part of an interconnected network of power plants and transmission facilities within the Western Systems Coordinating Council (WSCC), a voluntary association of utilities serving all or part of 14 states, and a portion of Canada. In the U.S. portion of NWPP, where 66.3% of the projected winter energy will be from hydroelectric facilities, the proportion of hydroelectric to thermal generation is much higher than in the other WSCC areas. It is unlikely that existing water shortfalls can be replenished, although increased precipitation may alleviate problems in some areas. The reduced water supplies have created the prospect of inadequate hydroelectric generation and the need for other measures to respond to regional electricity demands. These conditions are reviewed and the results are summarized, focusing on the period of October, 1977 through March, 1978.« less

  • This report examines the projected electrical demand and supply situation in the West, with particular emphasis on the Pacific Northwest situation during the winter of 1977. While the projected shortage of energy is small, continued lack of precipitation and failure to pursue conservation measures could result in a more critical situation. An interim report was published on March 31, 1977, placing greater emphasis on the California situation since California is a summer-peaking state. The present report updates that evaluation and presents new information based on the Pacific Northwest's winter electricity outlook.

  • This report examines the projected electrical demand and power supply situation in the West generally, and in the states of Washington, Oregon, Idaho and California particularly, mainly for the summer of 1977. The reduced water supplies caused by drought conditions have created the prospect of inadequate hydroelectric supplies and the need for other measures to respond to regional electricity demands. These conditions are reviewed and the results summarized.