The role of data in the EIS process: Evidence from the BLM wilderness review
- Univ. of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI (United States)
Various propositions have been offered about the role of the environmental impact statement (EIS) in agency decision making. These include statements that agencies are (1) using the information collected in the EIS to make rational decisions; (2) justifying decisions made a priori; (3) using the EIS to gain support or consensus for projects; or (4) simply fulfilling a legal mandate, with the EIS having no substantive impact on decisions. Previous studies regarding the role of EIS data have focused on the quality of the data in the EIS and whether or not the data are related to decisions. The role of site-specific information in the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) wilderness EIS process is analyzed and the results are used to reflect on the impact of the EIS in agency decision making. These results are compared with an earlier analysis of the Forest Service's Second Roadless Area Review and Evaluation (RARE II). The results of the statistical analyses of three sets of BLM wilderness EISs indicate that although some of the site-specific information about resource potential is statistically related to agency wilderness recommendations, the vast majority of the information is not. In addition, in some cases, the information was related to wilderness recommendations in a counterintuitive direction. Overall, of the 190 measures of resource potential found in these documents, only 17 (9%) were statistically related to BLM recommendations in an intuitive direction. The fact that most of the information in these EISs is not statistically related to decisions lends support to the proposition that the agency was primarily fulfilling the legally mandated procedure of the National Environmental Policy Act in producing these EISs, rather than achieving the spirit of the law. Results from the analysis of the Forest Service's RARE II wilderness review are similar.
- OSTI ID:
- 6000291
- Journal Information:
- Environmental Impact Assessment Review; (United States), Vol. 13:2; ISSN 0195-9255
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
Similar Records
National Forest Management Act of the 1976: a critical look at two trees in the NFMA forest
Wilderness designation of Bureau of Land Management lands and impacts on the availability of energy resources
Related Subjects
POLICY AND ECONOMY
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS
DATA ANALYSIS
NATURE RESERVES
RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
US NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT
IMPLEMENTATION
DECISION MAKING
LAND USE
PLANNING
RECOMMENDATIONS
DOCUMENT TYPES
LAWS
MANAGEMENT
RESOURCES
290300* - Energy Planning & Policy- Environment
Health
& Safety