Development of a mechanistic thermal aging model for Grade 91
- Argonne National Lab. (ANL), Argonne, IL (United States)
This report provides a summary on understanding and predicting the effects of long-term thermal aging on microstructure and tensile properties of G91 to corroborate the ASME Code rules in strength reduction due to elevated temperature service. The research is to support the design and long-term operation of G91 structural components in sodium-cooled fast reactors (SFRs). The report is a Level 2 deliverable in FY18 (M2NT-18AN050502061), under the Work Package NT-18AN05050206, “G91 Code Extension Testing” performed by the Argonne National Laboratory (ANL), as part of the Advanced Materials Development Program for Fast Reactors. The thermal aging study of G91 involves three types of thermally-aged specimens: (1) specimens machined from two heats of G91, G91-H1 and H30176 that have been tested for the Advanced Materials Development Programs in the past years. These specimens were aged at 550, 600, and 650°C for times up to ~64,000 h; (2) specimens fabricated from the heads of the archived crept specimens (13 in total) of six heats of G91, H5349, H30394, H30383, H10148, H30176. These specimens were aged at 427 - 538°C and for times up to 132,647 h; (3) specimens made from a tube removed from the Kingston coal-fired power plant after exposure for 155,000 h at 550°C. These three sets of specimens provide a comprehensive data set for understanding and predicting the effect of long-term thermal aging on microstructure and tensile properties of G91. Microstructural analysis of the thermally-aged G91 revealed that thermal aging causes significant microstructural changes: (1) the tempered martensite formed during tempering is unstable, and suffers significant recovery during aging, manifested by an increase in subgrain width, a decrease in subgrain length, and a decrease in subgrain aspect ratio (i.e. subgrains become more equiaxed) as the aging temperature and time increase. The subgrain recovery is facilitated by the reduction of dislocation density within subgrains; (2) M23C6 carbides in the as-received G91 are distributed along grain and subgrain boundaries and play an important role as pinning obstacles against subgrain coarsening. M23C6 carbides coarsen during aging, and the coarsening of M23C6 carbides reduces the pinning force on the boundaries; (3) MX carbonitrides in the as-received G91 are distributed uniformly within subgrains, providing the precipitation hardening effect. They coarsen with increasing aging temperature and time, but the coarsening rate is low; (3) a new phase, the Laves phase intermetallic forms during aging. The formation of the Laves phase removes the Mo solutes from the matrix, reducing the solid solution strengthening effect. The Laves phase particles grow rapidly once they are nucleated, and they precipitate primarily along boundaries. They may have a pinning effect on boundaries, but should provide little to the alloy strength. The evolution of each microstructural constituent during thermal aging can be well described by individual microstructural models. The estimated activation energy for MX coarsening was 175 kJ/mol, equivalent to the activation energy for boundary and core diffusion in a-Fe, while the estimated activation energy for subgrain coarsening was significantly lower, ~96 kJ/mol. Thermal aging of G91 results in the reduction in the yield stress and the ultimate tensile strength but has an insignificant effect on the uniform and total elongations. The reduction in tensile strength is more pronounced as the aging temperature and time increases. The in situ tensile tests with high-energy X-rays revealed that sub-boundary strengthening plays a dominant role, and the strengthening role of M23C6 particles may be accounted for by subgrian boundary hardening, and three strengthening mechanisms can be superimposed to describe the tensile strength of G91: subgrain boundary hardening, MX precipitation hardening, and Mo solid solution strengthening. A microstructure – strength model was establ
- Research Organization:
- Argonne National Lab. (ANL), Argonne, IL (United States)
- Sponsoring Organization:
- USDOE Office of Nuclear Energy (NE), Nuclear Reactor Technologies (NE-7). Advanced Reactor Technologies (ART)
- DOE Contract Number:
- AC02-06CH11357
- OSTI ID:
- 1485132
- Report Number(s):
- ANL-ART-150; 148865; TRN: US1902706
- Country of Publication:
- United States
- Language:
- English
Similar Records
Characterization of Alloy 709 Commercial Heats
Comparison of the effects of long-term thermal aging and HFIR irradiation on the microstructural evolution of 9Cr-1MoVNb steel